3 ms·
> If you abolish property rights, your two options are state slavery or anarchy where the strong take whatever they can. I'm pretty sure they're talking about
by Dylan16807 2y ago
> If you abolish property rights, your two options are state slavery or anarchy where the strong take whatever they can.
I'm pretty sure they're talking about real property. Land and improvements. Not the strong taking away everything you have.
And there are reasonable ways to manage land and housing other than private ownership. There's also the option of limiting it to personal use.
- s1artibartfast 2y ago>I'm pretty sure they're talking about real property. Land and improvements. Not the strong taking away everything you have. An individual has to be very careful not to create any real property value or improvements, otherwise it will be taken from you. Conceptually there are lots of solutions to managing this problem. Historically, they rely on a state institution that goes around stripping people of what they create, forcing people to create things they don't own. Communism almost always devolves into totalitarianism for this reason.
- Dylan16807 2y ago> An individual has to be very careful not to create any real property value or improvements, otherwise it will be taken from you. This is the experience of the vast majority of renters. It's not too bad. And something like "you can own X amount of house" doesn't require going anywhere near communism.
- s1artibartfast 2y ago>This is the experience of the vast majority of renters. It's not too bad. I think it is terrible. I like to be productive and crate value. Absolutely miserable without it. I hated being a renter for this reason. >And something like "you can own X amount of house" doesn't require going anywhere near communism. There are so many better ways to solve this problem than putting a cap on value creation.
- Dylan16807 2y ago> I like to be productive and crate value. You can create value in the 99% of the world that isn't attached to your house. Also a more conservative set of rules, like the limits I was talking about, would still let you own a house and upgrade it a lot in a way that you fully own. > There are so many better ways to solve this problem than putting a cap on value creation. Does "value creation" here specifically mean adding more living space? Only a very tiny fraction of homeowner construction projects would be an issue. And if you want to do something like build a third house on your property, a rule like that would say "go ahead, but then you have to sell it when you're done". You can create tons of value and profit from it, you just can't own three houses.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoLets assume this rule is only about living spaces, and not other assets and infrastructure. I like building and improving houses. I have one in the bay area I work to improve. I have built a mountain home in the Sierra Nevada, and am working on a desert home in Nevada. These take nothing away from anyone. They were empty land surrounded by more empty parcels before I did something with them. There is no shortage of land and nothing is stopping someone else from doing the same. When I die, they will probably be sold off, and there will be more options. until then, nobody is worse off. I have thought about renting them out, which is still better than if they never existed. Who am I hurting, and why should I be forced to sell? If there was a law I couldnt own three houses, I simply wouldnt build them.
- Dylan16807 2y agoThere could be an exception for houses in the middle of nowhere. But also in economic terms, if that house is in a zero-demand area and won't be on the market for decades, then it would be better if you don't build it, and instead either spend that money elsewhere or invest it.
- s1artibartfast 2y ago