2 ms·
That might be true, but has basically no bearing on the ban vs tax debate at all. I don't think anyone made an argument one way or another _how_ lead is bad: a
by eru 2y ago
That might be true, but has basically no bearing on the ban vs tax debate at all.
I don't think anyone made an argument one way or another _how_ lead is bad: all the arguments so far works just as well whether lead is 'poisonous' or bad for the brain in some special way.
You are right that private planes are mostly used by rich people. But that's not true of all products that contain lead, or processes that emit lead into the environment. (For example, there's lead in some batteries and there's lead in some solders. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead#Applications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead#Applications for more.)
The harm of lead is finite, and thus a finite tax would be a reasonable way to deal with it.
- orwin 2y agoWould you be OK to tax killing people instead of banning it?
- eru 2y agoIn practice, we already tax/fine companies for killing people. So I'll bite the bullet, and say: yes, of course. Ideally, a large part of that tax would go towards (the estate of) the victims. That's more productive than locking people up: that's just a straight up loss for society. We also already tax stochastically-killing people; or in some cases, we don't even tax it and just allow dangerous activities. Eg we allow people to drive cars and we allow people to run coal-fired power plants. Going from a small percentage chance to a larger percentage chance (nothing is certain) is not a qualitative difference, only a quantitative one.