6 ms·
Toyota raided as safety testing scandal grows
- monero-xmr 2y agoI was light on money but blessed with practicality, so I bought a used Corolla with over 200k miles and I drove it to over 350k miles. And I sold it for not that much less than I paid for it (if you exclude inflation). No scandal is going to change the lived experience. Toyota produces cars that last forever with the smallest amount of issues. I owned a Chevy for a brief amount of time and it was the worst car I ever had, the entire thing felt like it was held together with cheap glue. I've owned many Toyotas and their quality is exceptional.
- readthenotes1 2y agoAnd the Toyota owners who are told that they were not breaking properly when the car accelerated and crashed are also going to have their "lived experience"
- j-bos 2y agoThis is a useful story to remember.
- dv_dt 2y agoI think about Toyota being ranked as the works car company lobbying against taking action against climatee change. https://electrek.co/2024/05/14/toyota-once-again-ranked-as-worst-automaker-on-climate-lobbying-globally/ https://electrek.co/2024/05/14/toyota-once-again-ranked-as-w...
- alternatex 2y agoThat's just a report on EV-fication of car companies. Looks like that's the biggest factor in whether a car company is considered to be taking action against climate change. I can assure you that Ford and GM couldn't give less of a damn about it and are only above Toyota because they want a piece of that sweet high EV price pie.
- djd20 2y agoWorth noting Toyota was building hybrid cars long before anyone else - drastically cutting emissions before it was cool....
- dazc 2y agoThis also demonstrates how a legacy reputation, built over a period of decades, can be also thrown away in a period of weeks. VW quality deteriorated incrementally over the years but it was the emissions cheating scandal that became the wake-up moment.
- progbits 2y ago> The raids come a day after Toyota chairman Akio Toyoda apologised to customers and car enthusiasts. He bowed deeply and held the position for a few seconds, which is customary in Japan when companies apologise for wrongdoing. Slightly better than just "taking full responsibility" in an email written by PR team. But where's the sword?
- christkv 2y ago[flagged]
- Staple_Diet 2y agoAh yes, all those Western Christians who were caught commiting fraud and felt actual contrition, like SBF, Holmes, Wall St circa...always, Enron... I won't deny the bowing is all theatre but as you say, the only regrets any of these shits have is getting caught, regardless of culture.
- Dalewyn 2y ago>But where's the sword? Considering this is the second round of controversy stemming from an earlier round last year, and the LDP and Kishida administration are facing an almost certain wipe out in the next general election, I suspect the book thrown will be heavy and sharp.
- latentsea 2y agoMy favorite time seeing this was when they raised the price of Garigari-kun from 70 yen to 80 yen then bowed deeply to apologize for making snacks less affordable for children.
- progbits 2y agoYes, that was a very classy move. I think it bears no resemblance to what is going on here.
- Dalewyn 2y agoNote that this scandal practically encompasses the entire Japanese car industry at this point and probably a bit more. This latest round involves five companies: Toyota, Mazda, Honda, Suzuki, and Yamaha. An earlier round involved Daihatsu, Subaru, and I think Mitsubishi if I'm remembering correctly. When traditional car makers are potentially facing existential crises, this really should not have happened and in Japan no less.
- makeitdouble 2y agoWas Subaru ropped in it as well ? Otherwise Mitsubishi is the poster child of car scandals, so including them in the list is a sure bet.
- freetime2 2y agoSubaru was affected by the Daihatsu scandal because they sell a couple models that Daihatsu produces under the Subaru brand. The Daihatsu Tanto, for example, is also sold by Subaru as the Chiffon. As far as I know Subaru didn’t do anything wrong.
- DiabloD3 2y agoThis seems to be a continuation of the whole Daihatsu bullshit storm, and doesn't effect us Americans, and from what I can tell, doesn't effect domestic Japanese models either. From the article: "Japanese carmakers Honda, Mazda and Suzuki are also due to be inspected by the authorities over the same issue."; those are all major Daihatsu customers pre-Toyota acquisition. Toyota is essentially being forced to fall on a sword they acquired and no actual corporate wrongdoing (by American standards) seem to have occurred by Toyota executives; all the fault seems to lie entirely at Daihatsu's feet. Sucks, because a lot of people are going to shy away from what is probably the best car brand in the US, and the only major car company left manufacturing US market cars in the US. (Why do I specifically phrase it that way? The Big 3 sell most of their US-made cars in Europe with the only actually notable exception being some members of the F150 series; almost all of the Toyota cars sold in the NA market are US and Canadian made.)
- nottorp 2y agoI kinda liked the Yaris Cross (from the outside, haven't even considered a test drive yet). Anyone can summarize what was so wrong with it that they stopped manufacturing for now?
- padthai 2y agoI have one, everything seems fine but I have not crashed it yet.
- Dalewyn 2y ago>and from what I can tell, doesn't effect domestic Japanese models either. This controversy is literally Japanese car makers falsifying test data to obtain government certification for models sold in Japan. I won't blame the US DoT if they feel like also taking a magnifying glass.
- DiabloD3 2y agoDomestic Japanese cars currently sold, from what I can tell, do not use engines produced by Daihatsu. They seem to have moved entirely away from them about a decade ago. Where Toyota still uses them are export models and models made domestically in Indonesia, Philippines, Thailand, and Vietnam. Under Japanese law, Toyota is guilty because Japanese plants made engines that do not comply with Japanese laws, but the engines are not to be used in Japan. Japanese corporate culture is very different than America's, and they consider this a form of wrongdoing. Although Toyota has been a long term investor in Daihatsu (starting in 1967 and crossing the 50% threshold in 1998; they were approached by Daihatsu's lenders and the Japanese government to help strengthen the post-war car industry to make this investment), they remained an independent company until 2016. All of Daihatsu's apparent crimes all point to being pre-2016.
- ecmascript 2y agoI bought a new car by Toyota yesterday, sucks to read this now even if my car probably isn't affected. :(
- freetime2 2y agoLast week two proxy advisory firms, Glass Lewis and Institutional Shareholder Services, recommended against re-electing Akio Toyoda as chairman. [1] I’m not sure what percentage of shares they control, but seems there is a chance he will be ousted or step down after all of the scandals at Daihatsu and now Toyota - much of which occurred when he was president and CEO at Toyota. [1] https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/proxy-firm-glass-lewis-recommends-vote-against-toyota-chairman-2024-05-28/ https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/proxy-...
- SebFender 2y agoHa! There you go - a concrete impact. But what about employees that supported this situation?
- Havoc 2y ago> rivals Honda, Mazda and Suzuki also admitting to submitting faulty data. So regulators respond only when it is pretty much an open secret among industry insiders much like the emissions scandal.
- A_D_E_P_T 2y agoThe fascinating thing is that regulators responded at all. Think about it. Automobile manufacturing is Japan's last halo industry -- the crown jewel of their declining economy. The past few years have not been easy, as they're up against increasingly stiff competition from China (going exponential) and rising US protectionism, and they're not well positioned for a global pivot to electric vehicles. This is pretty much the worst possible time for a scandal -- and to me it's surprising that Japanese regulators are allowed to pursue and publicize these raids and sanctions in the teeth of their own national interest.
- lupusreal 2y agoThey're well positioned if that global pivot to EV flops and populist politicians undo all the "EVs mandatory by 20XX" laws. This seems to be what they're betting on.
- eru 2y agoThe problem for that scenario is that running your cars with electricity seems to be getting cheaper relative to ICE? Even without demand from electric cars, battery technology will keep improving (perhaps slightly slower) because of all the demand from mobile computing gadgets. Aren't batteries the main cost disadvantage of electric cars compared to ICE? So even without misguided mandates, electric cars might be here to stay. (I explicitly call the mandates misguided, because the Right Way is to tax what you don't like, eg carbon emissions, and let people figure out by themselves how they want to solve it. Electric cars might be one way. Or moving closer to work, so you only have to drive half as much might be another way to react; and is just as good in terms of emisions as getting a car that's twice as efficient.)
- jimnotgym 2y ago...same old story. It will keep happening until the penalty outweighs the benefits. Make a law that if corporate wrongdoing gives a director a financial benefit, then if caught the director has to return that money to the company. No deals with shareholders, you have to return your bonus. Fines and sanctions can come afterwards. Then see if they are so keen... what do we think of that?
- cherioo 2y agoPrivatize the gain, corporatize the losses! I don’t think that is anymore disincentive at the individual level. What’s lacking is high enough fine at corporate level so the corporate will more sufficiently monitor itself. Right now there’s little incentive not to cheat, much like the fight club ford quote.
- resource_waste 2y agoI don't really understand how executives get away with big compensation. Shareholders/Owners should be getting the returns. I understand you need smart people with vision, but I imagine you could go to the executive board of any nearly company and get someone for 500k/yr and they will have similar odds of success.
- SebFender 2y agoefin corporations - It's sad when you see so many cheat regulations and then ask for forgiveness. There should be a concrete impact when similar manipulations are found. From batteries to car's performance...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Draiken 2y agoCorporation breaks the law to increase profits, gets caught, makes a PR stunt "apologizing" and gets off with a slap on the wrist. Where have I read that before? Oh, everywhere. This will never change while profits are the sole reason companies exist. No amount of regulation will stop corruption and/or incompetence from the regulator's side. It also won't change the fact that regulators directly or indirectly have incentives to turn a blind eye, so huge corporations can, you guessed it: keep profiting. People die because of these kinds of shenanigans, but nobody seems to f*** care as long as profits continue to roll in. I know I'll now never buy a Toyota, not that it matters at all to their bottom line.
- mywacaday 2y agoBut what do you buy, this is an old list but I don't think any manufacturer is clean, https://www.thestreet.com/investing/stocks/10-of-the-biggest-automotive-scandals-ever-13297513 https://www.thestreet.com/investing/stocks/10-of-the-biggest...
- Draiken 2y agoThat's another big issue. Everyone loves to repeat "vote with your wallet" but what do you do when it's all bad? I don't know. It's not feasible for many to not own a car and even if it was, the few that "vote with their wallet" suffer while companies could not care less about individuals. It only matters if enough people do it, which actually affects their bottom line. Once again we're f*** by monopolies. It's an oligopoly where all options are bad in different ways and we have no recourse. It's not like we can build our own cars or new companies will actually get into the market. Even if they do, they'll start with the same shady practices because, well, the numbers must go up! Personally I don't see a solution within our current society.
- loongloong 2y agoWhat are the car platforms/skateboards that are affected? Does it matter? I would assume the platform provides a big part of the rigidity, etc. aspects that matter in collision/safety tests. If so, the other models that use the same platforms will also be affected? (not a car industry person) Thanks!