3 ms·
> Oh. And what are these universal "human values?" That is the core problem of AI X-risk, and has been studied in this context for at least 2-3 decades. If we
by TeMPOraL 2y ago
> Oh. And what are these universal "human values?"
That is the core problem of AI X-risk, and has been studied in this context for at least 2-3 decades. If we knew the answer, we would know how to make a perfectly aligned AGI.
- llm_trw 2y agoAn AGI aligned to Germany in 1938 is not much better to one not aligned at all.
- TeMPOraL 2y agoThat wouldn't have been aligned to generalized human values even back in 1938.
- pixl97 2y agoI mean, that is why a key point of fascism is dehumanizing entire classes of people so you don't have to consider their values at all. If AI/AGI even becomes moderately successful soon we'll quickly see companies remove neo-luddites from their list of general human values so their security bots can beat unemployed hungry factory workers to death when they attempt to picket in front of the company offices.
- lstodd 2y agoThe key point of fascism is not "dehumanizing", "classes" or "people". Those are just side effects or by-products, whatever you like. The key point is "forget yourself, devote all you were to the state".
- llm_trw 2y agoWhenever I hear someone speaking of generalized human values all I hear is "My values" or else. Lest we forget that the largest genocide of the 20th century was done by communists for universal brotherhood in China. If we'd picked Hitler AI as our overlord we would have fewer deaths than if we picked Mao AI (and possibly Stalin AI). In short: anyone in favor of human universalism is the last person you want to put in charge of AGI alignment.
- MostlyStable 2y ago>If we knew the answer, we would know how to make a perfectly aligned AGI. Actually no, we wouldn't. The problem, at the moment, is even more basic than "what values should we align an AGI with". Currently, the problem is "how do we robustly align an AI with any set of values." We currently do not know how to do this. You could hand OpenAI a universal set of safe values inscribed on stone tablets from god, and they wouldn't know what to do with them. To state it another way, people like to talk about paperclip maximizers. But here's the thing: if we wanted, to we couldn't purposefully make such a maximizer. Right now, AI values are emergent. We can sort-of-kind-of steer them in some general directions, but we don't know how to give them rules that they will robustly follow in all situations, including out-of-context. Look at how easy it is to jailbreak current models into giving you instructions on how to build a bomb. All current AI companies would prefer if their products would never do this, and yet they have been unable to ensure it. They need to solve that problem before they can solve the next one.
- TeMPOraL 2y ago> Currently, the problem is "how do we robustly align an AI with any set of values." That's a fair point, and you're absolutely right. > They need to solve that problem before they can solve the next one. Agreed. That, and they need to do it before they build an AGI. Unfortunately, from X-risk perspective, the two are almost the same problem. The space of alignments that lead to prosperous, happy humanity is a very, very tiny area in the larger space of possible value systems an AI could have. Whether we align AI to something outside this area (failing the "what values should we align an AGI to" problem), or the AI drifts outside of it over time (chancing the "what values" problem, but failing the "how do we robustly align" one), the end result is the same.
- MostlyStable 2y agoYes, I agree that both problems need to be solved. But I think it's still worth focusing on where we actually are. Lots of people believe that they have a set of safe values to align an AI to (Musk thinks "curiosity" will work, another commenter in this thread suggested "don't kill humans"), and so those people will think that the alignment problem is trivial: "Just align the AI to these simple, obviously correct principles". But the truth is that it doesn't even matter whether or not they are correct (my personal opinion is that they are not), because we don't know how to align an AI to whatever their preferred values are. It makes it more obvious to more people how hard the problem is.
- anon373839 2y ago> we would know how to make a perfectly aligned AGI Fortunately then, no one has any idea how to make AGI or whether AGI is even a coherent concept.