3 ms·
The UK's 12% is fairly typical, and a similar percentage funds (mostly better) systems in many Western European countries. Singapore has an excellent system co
by graemep 2y ago
The UK's 12% is fairly typical, and a similar percentage funds (mostly better) systems in many Western European countries.
Singapore has an excellent system costing about half the proportion of GDP.
- bumby 2y agoJust to add to the nuance, you're comparing a country with 6MM people to one with 370MM people. What dynamics do you think that difference of scale has on the overall healthcare outcome?
- graemep 2y agoand with counrties in between. I very much doubt there are either large economies or diseconomies of scale in healthcare. Certainly no indication of it in spend western Europe I can see. The UK has IMO created diseconomies of scale by having a monolithic system.
- bumby 2y agoI think there is some evidence of economies of scale. For example, Medicare can negotiate for better prices due to sheer number of patients covered.
- graemep 2y agoBetter prices on what proportion of costs? Would it outweigh the diseconomies of scale seen in the NHS? It is pretty clear that the less centralised systems in other western European countries are more efficient, nor can I see any evidence that smaller western European countries face consistently higher costs than larger ones.
- bumby 2y agoWhat are you seeing as the drivers of those diseconomies of scale? That might help me better answer the question. Again, though, I think it’s an error to treat each country as if it’s interchangeable. In other words, we need to understand the systemic causes of those costs to understand the impact as it relates to other nations. In the above example with Medicare, the cause is due to negotiating power through volume. So it’s pretty clear that scale matters there.
- nradov 2y agoThe UK does some things well but they are behind the USA (and other developed countries) in cancer survival rates. https://www.theguardian.com/society/2024/jan/11/uk-cancer-survival-rates-developed-world-report https://www.theguardian.com/society/2024/jan/11/uk-cancer-su... Singapore has an authoritarian police state which prevents many of the chronic substance abuse problems that drive a significant fraction of US healthcare spending. I don't think Americans would be willing to accept that trade-off. Singapore is also nearly 100% urban which makes care delivery much more efficient. The US healthcare system is a mess and needs reform. But we can't just copy other countries. We don't want to lose the best parts of our system or stifle innovation in (expensive) new drugs and medical devices.
- bumby 2y agoAn interesting aspect of cancer survivability is the jump in cancer rates in the US right around age 65. The implication is people aren't being seen until they qualify for Medicare, pointing to preventative healthcare access problems.