6 ms·
> RCTs are fine but the obsession with them is overwrought and counterproductive. My own drum to beat on this is regarding clinical trials for fatal diagnoses l
by Aurornis 2y ago
> RCTs are fine but the obsession with them is overwrought and counterproductive. My own drum to beat on this is regarding clinical trials for fatal diagnoses like cancer:
RCTs for mental health conditions are a completely different situation. The short-term placebo response rate for cancers is not high (obviously) though the influence of unblinded trial operators making subjective analyses can be a problem.
Many mental health conditions, on the other hand, have unbelievably high placebo response rates over the duration of a short trial. The magnitude of the placebo response is almost hard to believe in certain studies.
The placebo effect can be a problem for approving new drugs as some times the placebo group improved so much that there isn’t much room left for the active drug to improve beyond that. This is a problem of study design and rating systems that is difficult to solve.
Unfortunately, some study operators use this fact to their advantage by omitting placebo group. Without a placebo group, it’s not obvious that the drug is actually doing anything better than placebo, of course.
- BurningFrog 2y ago> * Many mental health conditions, on the other hand, have unbelievably high placebo response rates over the duration of a short trial* Probably how faith healing works.
- vitiral 2y agoIf someone could explain how "the placebo effect" is not just "scientifically proven faith healing" I'd love to hear it.
- otherme123 2y agoPlacebos doesn't heal. They just seem to relief some symptoms typically self reported, like pain, but the underlying cause is still there.
- Xymist 2y agoThe tricky thing about that (which isn't false, per se) in the context of mental health is that "relieve some self reported symptoms" can actually be sufficient treatment. As with many sorts of pain, if the patient feels better, _they are better_ in a meaningful sense. Whether it's "real" is sort of beside the point, especially if the problem is that they are (for example) too miserable to do normal life things that would stop them being miserable and the placebo is sufficient for them to feel as if perhaps they could.
- lukas099 2y agoAlso, relief of emotional discomfort can help the patient adopt more behaviors that are associated with positive changes in mental health, such as exercise and pursuing social engagements.
- Uehreka 2y agoNot necessarily. The placebo effect is the kind of thing where you might have trouble at first telling if your symptoms are improving or if you’re just having a “good day” or an “easy week”, and that confusion can even last a month or two during which you’re over-observing your internal state and feeling hopeful that “maybe this is what getting better feels like”. But in the long term you often figure it out. I had a placebo effect recently when switching ADHD medication to get around the shortages. For a couple months I thought there was a chance my new meds might actually be better, they definitely felt different (and still do). But six months in it’s clear to me that I’m struggling with productivity more than I was before I switched (though less than when I was off meds). I’m just one guy, but I’d guess this is why doctors don’t just prescribe placebos all the time as actual therapies (well, that and they’d lose credibility which would then destroy any remaining placebo effect).
- QuantumGood 2y agoWarts are overall very responsive to placebos. My M.D. father, family practice in the army, later a pathologist, would do what he had learned from other doctors: Put some dye in toothpaste, put it on the wart(s), bandage it, talk about what a miracle cure it was etc. He said it worked the few times he tried it.
- Modified3019 2y agoFYI, food dyes are not inherently inert, and are capable of having antifungal, antiviral, and/or antioxidant effects. Quick examples: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10068-011-0002-0 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10068-011-0002-0 https://www.purdue.edu/newsroom/releases/2020/Q3/new-approach-to-airborne-disinfection-uses-food-coloring-dyes.html https://www.purdue.edu/newsroom/releases/2020/Q3/new-approac... The pigments fungi produce are so essential to their survival, they can’t defend against pathogens when they are gene edited to stop producing them. Toothpaste is also far from an inactive substance, there are definitely plausible mechanisms at play with the toothpaste and dye mix that could help suppress/resolve a wart. It would be worth a study, though I’m not sure what one would use to try and achieve a truly inert placebo for comparison without first figuring out what doesn’t work.
- sugarkjube 2y agoNothing to do with placebo, it's the covering that did the trick, not the talk about miracle cure. (I discovered this myself when I was a kid, any proper airtight cover is likely to get rid of it, YMMV)
- collyw 2y agoStress negatively affects the outcome of patients, why couldn't the opposite be true?
- TrevorJ 2y agoMental health conditions are typically defined by a collection of symptoms though, aren't they? I am not suggesting there is no underlying cause, but our ability to detect and quantify that cause is lacking, so defining disorders based on a collection of symptoms is what we are mostly left with in many cases.
- tsimionescu 2y agoIt varies a lot. For many conditions, like cancers, the placebo effect is basically random noise (cancers sometimes just reduce or go away on their own, regardless of treatment or even of the appearance of treatment ; we don't know the natural rate of this, because it's unethical to not treat people who you know have cancer). In addition, in non-blind trials, there is a "placebo effect" that amounts to mistakes or lies by those involved in the research in favor of a positive outcome. This is not a real effect in patients at all, just an artifact in the reported data. Then, for conditions linked to our psyche, including pure psychological conditions but also things like pain, blood pressure, heart rate, nausea, and some others - the placebo effect is more real, but usually temporary. Some people who have been living in some amount of despair at their condition experience a positive surge of hope once treatment starts, and they can ignore the pain, or feel some push to get out of their depression, or calm their anxiety which was exacerbating, say, the high blood pressure etc. This effect almost always tapers off if the treatment is not doing anything more fundamental. Coupled with the fact that we don't understand how psychological disorders work at the chemical level at all, especially in relation to the conscious mind and interventions on that (e.g. therapy, but also various religious practices), this means it's very hard to account for this without a double-blind RCT.
- vitiral 2y agoThe problem as I see it is that all medicine is fundamentally trying to find effective scaffolding on the human body, triggering it's own ability to heal. A surgeon can't repair a corpse. What causes the body to heal itself more effectively? I would think this is brutally difficult to study, since it's all subjective.
- Zababa 2y agoI think part of medicine is that, but part of medicine is trying to keep you alive despite your body. Or maybe what I'm arguing here is the "body healing itself". But for example, if you have autoimmune disease, or allergies, you want the body to slow down and take it easy because it's harming itself.
- 2y ago
- llamaimperative 2y agoIt is but it’s a very finicky treatment.
- ziddoap 2y agoFaith healing has heavy religious tones. Yet not everyone who responds positively to a placebo is religious. So, it feels sort of weird to call the placebo effect some form of faith healing.
- paulsef 2y ago[dead]
- protonfish 2y agoI guess it depends on how you define religion. I think that we can have faith in anything - science, your doctor, etc. that could work in a similar fashion to religious faith.
- burnished 2y agoThis is specious. Religion is clearly centered around the spiritual and physical beliefs about the world and the practices of a specific group. Trusting your doctor is usually more along the lines of an educated guess due to the necessity to act without perfect information.
- vitiral 2y agoThat was the point of the question. Wouldn't you say "placebo" has heavy intellectualizing overtones?
- Zababa 2y agoI think part of it is regression to the mean. Like, your body heals itself naturally from many things. Say you get a cold. For most people at some point it'll heal. If you have a group of people with the cold, and try to determine how effective vitamin C or zinc or COLDKILLER777 is, you can't just give it to them and say "look, they're healed", because they would heal naturally. You have to prove that they feel less symptoms or heal faster than people in the same circumstances that don't receive the same molecule. I also remember some similar stuff for back pain and surgeries. In that context people were seeking treatment when their back issues peaked, and the question was, when you take the cohort of people that had back surgery and the cohort of people that didn't, did the back surgery make a difference? Because some people healed naturally. I don't know if this is true in that specific context, but to take a more pedestrian one, I've had lots of small cuts, burns and things like that during my life, and they all healed.
- somenameforme 2y agoThe placebo effect controls for all of these factors, and is entirely real. It's the reason placebo control groups exist in the first place. If the placebo effect was just statistical noise, then you could greatly simplify trials by just taking a random group of people as the control, and do away entirely with trying to hide from both patient and technician who is taking the drug - because it wouldn't matter at all. You can see the opposite effect with the less well known nocebos [1]. People can experience objectively measurable side effects (such as bloating) that are in no way associated with a treatment, but that a patient believes to be a side effect. It can even be fatal. The article references aboriginals who will 'curse' one another resulting in the victim rapidly dying, because he believes so strongly that he is going to die! A similar thing in contemporary medicine has been observed with those who receive a fatal prognosis of cancer with them ending up dying long before there is any way the cancer could have killed them. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nocebo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nocebo
- djtango 2y agoIsn't that amazing? That we can help people extraneously without having to administer chemicals which have a nonlocalised effect on our bodies. There's still so much to learn I recently heard that new fathers see a reduction in testosterone. How does having a baby chemically alter a man!? What's the stimulus and mechanism for that...
- whythre 2y agoPheromones from the pregnant mother seem like a good candidate for the reason behind Low T…
- datavirtue 2y agoMy vote as well. Proximity and "stickiness" to the mother. Likely not a thing if the father moves on to the next region/town after sireing a child. I think back to the isolated humans encountered by the British when working on their rocket programs. Basically groups of women that men moved between, impregnating. Move into a group, kill a child or two and/or fight other males, impregnate someone and move on. I overlay this behavior whenever I try to figure people out.
- edmundsauto 2y agoAs a recent father: low sleep.
- djtango 2y agoI can't really refute this but I suspect based on the body of research on this study, the drop must be a lot more than just sleep deprivation. There are plenty of men who work long hours and have poor sleep but I don't believe the drop in T is as remarkable as that post partum How about the science behind how a baby's crying stimulates milk production.
- llamaimperative 2y agoAgain cognitive. These are only challenging you because you’re assuming cognition cannot affect hormones/chemical systems but we know otherwise.
- collyw 2y agoThe placebo effect is as powerful as many prescription drugs. It amazes me that scientists generally dismiss it rather than actually study it intensely. It's well known that stress can negatively affect your physiology, so I see no reason not to think that the opposite could be true.
- darepublic 2y agoHence why magical thinking can be useful sometimes (or at least that's what I tell myself wishfully)
- bigyikes 2y agoCan you say more? Does “magical thinking” mean religion, or something else? I’m actually curious.
- darepublic 2y agoCan mean believing things will be OK, or events will somehow spare you, whatever the reason. Whether it's because of religious conviction, you've grown a lucky beard, had a happy dream the night before, etc. Even while being somewhat conscious of the irrationality of such beliefs they sometimes can be of help I feel. Also when music inspires / motivates you I feel like it stirs up a similar effects to a strong magical belief.
- burnished 2y ago'Everything happens for a reason' is a pretty common example of magical thinking that you might be more familiar with. Basically when someone favors a magical principal over cause and effect when describing the world. I don't think it would make sense to say religion in general is magical thinking, a lot of religion can be moral or legal precepts or an explanation of the world that is rooted largely in cause and effect. There is clearly some magical thinking at play when you get into specifics but personally I'm not sure where we would say it enters play: is the belief in a final tallying magical thinking when it is justified by the belief that there exists an entity capable and willing? Not sure.
- poincaredisk 2y agoHilariously, this works even if the patient is aware of the placebo effect. I'm on antidepressants (first time in my life) since two weeks ago. I feel MUCH better already. But the drug I'm taking starts working at least 4 weeks after therapy starts. There was not a single trial where it performed better than placebo during a shorter timeframe. And yet I feel better.