3 ms·
What devices do people use to limit inrush current? You can make a current limiter with a few transistors, but I'm guessing there must be better integrated solu
by amelius 2y ago
What devices do people use to limit inrush current? You can make a current limiter with a few transistors, but I'm guessing there must be better integrated solutions (e.g. with temperature protection, etc.)
- mcshicks 2y agoYou can use inductors. Some USB cables have a choke on them. But basically the problem is when a large amount of circuitry all powers up at one when you plug in. So everything connected directly to USB 5v with a lot of large capacitors to filter the power. If you really need that then you can self power and avoid the problem.
- amelius 2y agoI'm looking more for a solution that acts as a constant current source, but where the voltage never exceeds the input voltage.
- tomooot 2y agoAMC7135 might work: it's a linear LDO fixed current regulator designed for driving LEDs, which internally is basically an N-channel MOSFET which holds it's gate voltage in the linear region and actively adjusts it to provide constant current.
- amelius 2y agoThank you for the suggestion, but it seems that the device has no over-temperature protection.
- ssl-3 2y agoIf the answer to excessive in-rush current (due to capacitance) is to add series inductance, then: Isn't the more-efficient answer simply less capacitance?
- mcshicks 2y agoI think the correct answer really depends upon what you are trying to do. Sometimes where board space and cost are not an issue people use a combination of larger and smaller bypass caps to reduce switching noise. I don't think there is a one size fits all solution because people power many different types of things from USB. It's more just a caution about USB power in general. Most people know the 500mA current limit, but in-rush compliance is something you don't really see in functional testing because typically you can get away with a violation and the board will still work.
- dragontamer 2y agoI only saw this topic recently. Sorry for replying 2 days after everyone else has left... ------------ I like the pMOS constant-slew rate trick myself. A number of voltage-regulators have soft-start ramp-up already built in. But if your project doesn't have one, you can build it out of pMOS pretty easily. With just a resistor + capacitor on the pMOS (serving as negative feedback, to slow down the start), you can arbitrarily slow-down inrush current to whatever values you wish. https://www.ti.com/lit/an/slva156/slva156.pdf?ts=1717622495138 https://www.ti.com/lit/an/slva156/slva156.pdf?ts=17176224951... Constant-slew rate voltage control vs a capacitive load effectively creates current-controlled startup functionality. So its "good enough" for most people's purposes (assuming capacitive loads are what's causing you to be worried). So its a bit of an A-problem vs B-problem here. I'm giving you a slew-rate controlled soft start circuit when you asked for current control. But... its probably what you want? > but I'm guessing there must be better integrated solutions (e.g. with temperature protection, etc.) I believe the "proper" solutions are called a "load switch", of which there are a huge variety of integrated chips and MOSFETs with load-switch (constant slew rate + temperature control) solutions available. EDIT: Something like this: https://www.nxp.com/products/power-management/smart-switches-and-drivers/high-side-switches/12-v-multipurpose-low-rdson-extreme-switch:MC12XS2 https://www.nxp.com/products/power-management/smart-switches... Things get rather complicated as you edge into "proper" solutions. I'm just a hobbyist though, so I don't have much experience with these "proper" designs. EDIT2: Maybe that NXP Load switch is a bit "too full featured" for most projects. This TI one I found seems to be more mainstream and simple. TPS22950CQDDCRQ1 (https://www.ti.com/product/TPS22950-Q1 https://www.ti.com/product/TPS22950-Q1)