6 ms·
At some point, suspension of disbelief is the expected behavior of the reader. Nobody would want to read a fantasy about dwarfs, hobbits, elves, and dragons if
by dylan604 2y ago
At some point, suspension of disbelief is the expected behavior of the reader. Nobody would want to read a fantasy about dwarfs, hobbits, elves, and dragons if they first had to get through a complete history of the financial systems within the fantasy world. Most people can't make it through all of the language system within the tomes that Tolkien did include.
Expecting all of the details to work in a FANTASY story is just ludicrous. This is why a lot of people that are not fans shy away from fans having these types of conversations.
- hosh 2y agoOn the other hand, Tolkien spent his time creating realistic languages and lore to go with that, above and beyond many fantasy writers. On the gripping hand, having read through various histories, it's nuts how often historians get things mixed up or wrong, or obsolete with emerging evidence. Our histories, even evidence-based, tells a story of our past, and no narrative can fully describe what happened.
- ben_w 2y ago> On the gripping hand, having read through various histories, it's nuts how often historians get things mixed up or wrong, or obsolete with emerging evidence. Our histories, even evidence-based, tells a story of our past, and no narrative can fully describe what happened. Indeed; the similarity of "history" and "story" is no mere coincidence, they share a root. And in German, both are the same word: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Geschicht https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Geschicht
- jltsiren 2y agoTolkien himself had a different point of view. In his opinion, if suspension of disbelief becomes necessary, it's a sign that the writer has failed. He preferred "secondary belief" instead. The idea was that the reader should remain immersed in the fictional world, confident that the world works consistently according to its internal logic. That the logic is there, even if the reader doesn't know it, and that the writer doesn't break it for their own convenience.
- WalterBright 2y agoI lost all interest in Harry Potter when he was hanging outside a window, helpless. Then, his buddy appears with a flying car to rescue him. I'm not interested in such lazy writing.
- dylan604 2y agoThat's like complaining that Harry was stuck but magic happened to get him out of a situation. That's kind of like the entire point of the series
- WalterBright 2y agoMaking up random arbitrary things whenever needed to get out of a fix is just bad storytelling. One of the great things about LOTR is the ring is ascribed various powers, and then the consequences of that play out. The rules within its world are consistent. HP has no consistency. Probably why I also prefer hard scifi - it must follow the known rules of physics, or at least have plausible extensions. I liked GoT a lot as it was driven by human decisions and foibles. But it slowly devolved into convenient magic absurdities, like resurrecting dead people, and I lost interest.
- dylan604 2y ago> Probably why I also prefer hard scifi - it must follow the known rules of physics, or at least have plausible extensions. Well, if you're going to put in plausible extensions instead of following the rules then "i'm not interested in such lazy writing" as you stated. In any fictional story telling, there's going to be some creative licensing involved to tell the story. Hell, even in biopics and "based on true" there's a lot of creative license just to make the story interesting. Following the rules of known physics just limits the imagination to make for bland stories. > I liked GoT a lot as it was driven by human decisions and foibles. But it slowly devolved into convenient magic absurdities, like resurrecting dead people, and I lost interest. From the very off of the show, the resurrecting dead people was involved in the story. If it wasn't, "the night is dark and full of terrors" and "winter is coming" would be pointless. Just because the dead coming back was timed to happen with the story is just part of it. I mean, next, you'll tell me that Zombieland or Shaun of the Dead were pointless since they were resurrected dead people too. I think you've moved into the comic book guy territory of "worst book/movie/comic ever" type of meme
- WalterBright 2y agoIn the Hobbit movie, Smaug's gold hoard was so vast that if it actually went into circulation, gold would be cheaper than iron. The citizens would be making roof tiles and plumbing out of it. (Although iron ore is plentiful, it is expensive to refine and smelt.) Even the relatively few Spanish gold ships hauling gold to the Old World resulted in massive inflation, not wealth.
- complaintdept 2y ago>Although iron ore is plentiful, it is expensive to refine and smelt Might explain why the land around the Lonely Mountain was unforested*. This is what happened in ancient Greece -- deforestation largely due to charcoal production for smelting iron. Topsoil got eroded and it still hasn't recovered today. Prior to metallurgy, Greece was densely forested, and must have had some biggish trees, judging by the construction of temples etc. * IIRC. Also a fire breathing dragon taking up residence probably didn't help.
- astrange 2y ago> Nobody would want to read a fantasy about dwarfs, hobbits, elves, and dragons if they first had to get through a complete history of the financial systems within the fantasy world. Japanese fantasy works on a system where you look at whatever novel is currently popular, copy every surface/world detail from it, then add exactly one thing you wanted it to be all along and just talk about all the time. It's basically done for SEO reasons, but it means you can save all the setup time if every story is in the same medieval isekai that vaguely feels like Dragon Quest. So yes, there are stories that are just about forex speculation with elves or whatever. Spice and Wolf is one. I feel like Western writers also used to do this, but the difference is they'd copy D&D and instead make the story about the super complex magic system they made up, and frankly I don't want to hear about your magic system.
- dylan604 2y agoIsn't that fanfic?
- astrange 2y agoNo, it's not fanfic. It's not set in another continuity, it's just their own fantasy worlds are even less unique than ours. They have fanfic too of course.
- Jensson 2y ago> it's just their own fantasy worlds are even less unique than ours They do have many more fantasy worlds though, not being as unique means they have room for many many more and better ones. I do feel western authors focuses too much on being different so often they make things bad just to not be like the others.
- dylan604 2y agoDo copyright rules exist differently in Japan than the US? Can you imagine if I created a movie that occurs within the accepted Star Wars universe so that my protagonist was from a planet called Tatooine who had a sister that was a princess? I would be sued into oblivion.