5 ms·
It's time to take phones away from students
- tgv 2y agoThey should be taken away from minors in general. No smart phone before 18. Ideally, nobody should ever have a smart phone. The best time to implement any strategy for limiting smart phone use was 8 to 10 years ago, when the addictive effects were obvious. The second best time is right now.
- squigz 2y agoNobody should have a smartphone? I know a lot of very interesting takes come up when the smartphones/kids debate comes up, but this comment certainly takes the cake.
- nuccy 2y ago/s I wonder how close we are with phones to what was back in 50-80s with smoking [1]. Maybe in 100 years, people will look back at early/mid 21th century and call it "like the Wild West". 1. https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm4843a2.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm4843a2.htm
- gambiting 2y agoI mean the article says right at the start that until 90s(!!!!) it was legal for kids to smoke in school and in fact some people have been advocating for keeping it legal. Madness.
- camtarn 2y agoFor those of us who live in places where 'students' usually means people at university or college, this article is about schoolchildren.
- deadbabe 2y agoSometimes I think about how wild it must have been that there was a time when people simply didn’t have smartphones. Just people going out into the world not knowing anything except what they carry in their brain and what is immediately around them.
- kayodelycaon 2y agoI’m not even 40 and I remember growing up without internet access, much less a cell phone. I had to walk to a library to use their computers.
- selykg 2y agoYup, I miss those days. I had computers from an early age, but being connected all the time has had a negative impact on me personally. I've started really paying attention and doing the "Digital Declutter" that Cal Newport talks about in his book Digital Minimalism. I have very very few notifications pop up on my phone now and I'm experimenting more with leaving it at home when I go somewhere. Trying to add a bigger disconnection between me and my phone.
- mentos 2y agoThanks Steve
- kelseyfrog 2y agoThere was certainly a lot more conversations/debate around verifiable, but inaccessible, knowledge. You would ask a friend or family member something like, "what's the second longest river," and have a discussion about it if no one knew for certain or of two people had differing opinions. Now we simply look it up which means we don't have those conversations. I feel that on a whole it's made us less comfortable with situations where one person thinks A and another thinks B that's spilled from verifiable knowledge to scenarios where personal opinions differ. Probably something something culture wars. It also meant that if you told someone you were meeting them at a certain place and time that not showing up was a huge waste of their time and a larger social no-no. Nowadays people cancel at the last moment because you can be sure your message will be received.
- deadbabe 2y agoI feel like this is exactly the same feeling when you ask a question on the internet somewhere and people just tell you to go google it. Like okay sorry I even fuckin asked!!
- some-guy 2y agoI don't live in Silicon Valley anymore but I found it _extremely_ ironic that in my experience, it's the parents that work in tech that are more likely to limit technology usage for their children. (Full disclosure: I'm part of this demographic)
- jimbob45 2y agoSomeone on here recently pointed out that a FitBit-style watch where the kid can still be tracked-by-location and maybe receive pager-style notifications is a decent compromise to giving your kid a whole smartphone. That way you still get to limit technology but still reap the benefits of being able to track your kid and also ping them to contact you if you can't get a hold of them.
- patrickmay 2y agoThis is me. I'm also the most technical person in my family and the only one with an analog watch.
- tnel77 2y agoI feel like being fully immersed in tech makes it that much more obvious. My children barely watch TV and we plan on waiting for smart phones until as late as possible. They’ll have a flip phone once they need to call for pickups from sports and such.
- jjav 2y agoI wouldn't call it ironic though, when you know how the sausage is made and how toxic it is, it is a logical outcome. In my child's elementary school (in Silicon Valley) there were no kids with cellphones at any grade level. The school didn't outright prohibit them (although they were discouraged), but all parents had agreement that it was an evil best postponed and cellphones have no place in elementary school. (Not coincidentally, every family had at least one, if not two, parents in tech.)
- et-al 2y agoIf anyone watched The Social Dilemma (2020), they interviewed a number of managers responsible for this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Social_Dilemma#Interviewees https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Social_Dilemma#Interviewee... And of course the managers are repentant now with a few million in the bank.
- zknill 2y agoI'm confused why most of the discussion about these issues is based on blocking the means of access to the content rather than making those hosting the content responsible for it. Here we're talking about banning smartphones, rather than making the social media companies responsible for their various harms. There's an idiom of 'internalise the externalities', which basically means making the party responsible for a cost bear the cost themselves. It's a useful way of making a market efficient and self-regulate, by making something that costs society also cost the producer. This kind of narrative seems to be pervasive. For example; we aren't asking the biggest polluters to bear the cost of their pollution (e.g. airlines having to reduce carbon in the atmosphere in line with the amount they produce). We didn't ask the tobacco companies to bear the cost of the public health impact they create. Instead of blocking or banning the means of access (smartphones), we should be 'internalising the externalities' and making the social media companies bear a cost inline with the negative social cost they create.
- JacobThreeThree 2y ago>Here we're talking about banning smartphones The topic is about banning smartphones for students during school, not in general. Even if social media was the best thing for your health since sliced bread, it's not appropriate for learning in a school setting.
- aeturnum 2y agoI agree with you in the long term, but like the joke about solving something with regular expressions: now you have two problems. This is an argument for an intervention to reduce a certain harm in a certain way now. We should also, independently, pursue restitution. The article brings up smoking and that seems like a good model to me. We both restricted where smoking could occur and also went after cigarette companies - both efforts were worthwhile on their own and also were generally complimentary.
- squigz 2y agoIn your opinion, what would this look like? What would, say, Facebook be responsible for doing?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- CodeWriter23 2y agoSo, cancel all the one-to-one laptop programs as well, seeing the primary culprit tagged is social media, which is totally accessible from laptops.
- jacobgkau 2y agoTo be fair, one-to-one laptops located on a school's domain can have social media websites blocked at the network level and the client level. Phones usually come with data plans, which means not even a filter on the WiFi would prevent students from accessing blocked websites, even while they're physically in the school. The article does mention this.
- maximamas 2y agoBanning phones is a waste of time, the children will find a way. We need to embrace phones and teach responsible use along with holding content providers accountable. A war on phones will be as effective as the war on drugs.
- talldatethrow 2y agoMaking things illegal and not accepted works decently well. There wasn't a drug vending machine at my school, even though a few rogue students were probably buying and selling drugs at my highschool. Thus I was less likely to do drugs. Very few handguns are in students backpacks, because we don't accept it. If we didn't accept cell phones, we'd have a lot fewer kids suffering from them.
- khalladay 2y agoThis is about banning phones during class or school hours. Even though the war on drugs may have failed the general populace, the prohibition of drugs at schools has been largely successful in preventing drug use from taking place in classrooms and on school property. (the same with smoking bans at schools) This is the same.
- eesmith 2y agoWhich was the argument against prohibiting smoking at school: > John Tolton, then chairman of the Metro Toronto School Board, was having none of it. Tolton doubted whether schools even had the right to ban smoking, and if they did, “it will merely drive smoking underground.” (He was also unconvinced of the dangers of second-hand smoke.) There were other concerns, including the belief that bans would drive smokers off school property, inciting conflicts with neighbours and exacerbating absenteeism. Some parents gave their kids permission to smoke, so (the thinking went) better to offer them a regulated space in which to do so. Why won't the war on phones be as effective as the war on tobacco?
- jacobgkau 2y ago> Why won't the war on phones be as effective as the war on tobacco? I also just pointed the same thing out to the parent commenter, but to play devil's advocate: it won't be as effective because phones have a variety of legitimate use cases (communicating with family & coworkers being among them) that mean people will end up wanting/needing to use them later in life anyway, and will potentially want or need to use them (or learn how to use them) while they're still students. Tobacco/nicotine drugs serve no functional or productive purpose the way phones do.
- flerchin 2y agoIt's definitely worth a discussion. Owning a smartphone is practically mandatory in modern society, and kids are more online than anyone. I've held the line at 14 before first smartphone, and it's been challenging. I just picked up my 11yo from a GT test where he was expected to phone me after he was done. He used his mother's phone for that. In the US, there's also all the murders to consider. My wife absolutely panics at the idea of not being able to contact the kids, and no amount of reasoning can reassure her. She is not alone in this sentiment. My niece also almost succeeded at suicide, and her parents blame social media. This is specifically what we're trying to address with this article.
- hypeatei 2y ago> My wife absolutely panics at the idea of not being able to contact the kids I've never understood this reasoning but I don't have kids. How is a child being able to contact their parents going to help in active shooter situation?
- flerchin 2y agoYou can't reason someone out of a position they didn't reason themselves into. It's an exceedingly common sentiment among parents.
- rahimnathwani 2y agoThe parents might be willing to attempt a rescue when the police are not.
- mrguyorama 2y agoThis notably did not work in Uvalde, where parents were threatened and even restrained to prevent them from doing the Cop's jobs.
- flerchin 2y agoThis is not true. Some parents did save some kids. https://www.texasstandard.org/stories/uvalde-tx-shooting-anniversary-angeli-rose-gomez/ https://www.texasstandard.org/stories/uvalde-tx-shooting-ann...
- iamleppert 2y agoThe manufactures of these devices need to be held liable for the creation and distribution of a harmful product. If it can be shown the phones have an effect on a student's mental health, the executives at these companies and the companies themselves should be made to pay for any damages caused.
- shagie 2y agoSmartphones are not harmful to everyone (unless you're also going to claim that smartphones are dangerous to you and as an adult you are not responsible for your actions when buying one). Apple nor Samsung nor Google sells iPhones to minors - they are not able to get a contract for phone service. These devices are sold to adults and it is the adults that give the devices to children.
- bigstrat2003 2y agoYeah, unfortunately kids having smartphones is very often a case of parental negligence. Just like some parents would buy little Jimmy GTA without even bothering to think about whether that's appropriate, some parents will get their young child a pipe to the worst parts of the Internet without thought.
- seoulmetro 2y agoIt's not negligent to allow your kid to be free on the internet nor is it negligent to let them play games not meant for their age group. It's negligent to let those affect the social behaviour of the kid by themselves. Most kids get lessons by their parents and freedom to do what they want.
- seoulmetro 2y agoForks are dangerous too, should we sue IKEA whenever a child hurts someone with a fork?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 2y agoFor what it's worth, this is an article about banning phones for students inside school facilities in Canada, and not a broadside about kids and technology writ large. Kids will still bring phones to schools that ban them, the same way they smoked in the boy's room, but it's hard to argue that phone usage in schools that ban them won't drop precipitously. My kids both just barely missed this era of parenting (I think the boy may have had a phone in his last year of high school), and honestly I have a hard time getting worked up about this stuff. Maybe it matters, maybe it doesn't, but if our school district decided tomorrow "absolutely no phones, if we see them we confiscate them", I'd shrug and say "sure, give it a shot".
- rsolva 2y agoThis has already been done recently in (at least) Norway an the Netherlands. No phones in class. My SO is a teacher and she reports less distraction in class, although it is still early days.
- jasonpeacock 2y agoRelatedly, not providing kids with cell phones to start with isn't as bad as it first sounds - even the kids recognize the benefit of being without: https://www.thecut.com/article/phones-teens-screentime-restrictions-jonathan-haidt.html https://www.thecut.com/article/phones-teens-screentime-restr...
- PeterCorless 2y agoThe issue is one of judicious allowance of smartphones — teaching students about time management and their phone use. A phone is not a "cigarette" in the sense that it is not universally and simply a cause of harm. I can use a web browser or a smart phone to look up information for my job, or to educate myself on physics regarding communications and distances to Voyager 1 and 2. Or I could use my smartphone to browse TikTok videos or to post political rants. Even then, if I watch TikTok I might be watching a solar observations, learning about coronal mass ejections (CMEs) and solar flares from Professor Nixy, or I could just be watching the lastest dances. If I were on Twitter/X, I could be learning about breaking current events and world politics for my social studies classes, or I could be listening to the rants of some idiotic get-rich-quick dudebro. You could have a graphing calculator on your phone. A skymap for astronomy. Programming tools. Or... you could just fill it with games. The tool isn't the issue. It's the judiciousness of the mind using the tool. There is a time of day to do my work, and a time of day to have fun. We, as a society, as parents, as educators, are continuously failing students in terms of educating them on time and attention management, on effective learning and research techniques, and on properly using the once-supercomputer-level tools and technology they have in their hands every day. Having spent time in the classroom teaching math, I believe it would be better to have smartphone use tied to attention span ("Okay, for this part of the class, all cellphones need to be put away..."), outcomes ("You did great on the quiz. Feel free to browse the web as a reward."), and so on. Showing a student how to use a graphing calculator is awesome because it lets them finally understand equations. Seeing them plotted out. It's not just x's, coefficients and exponents. It's shapes and patterns. This is entirely dependent on the school, the teacher, the grade and the class. Yes, I know the difficulty of teaching young men and women when cell phones are right there in front of them. High school you can hope to appeal to their better nature. Elementary school? Yikes. I don't think that's doable. Maybe with some better elementary level individuals. The kids minds are often just not equipped at that age to be able to discipline themselves. You'd have to have clear "all phones away" protocols. Maybe allow them to have it at recess and lunch. That sort of thing. To my mind there needs to be a tiered approach. Different schools, different grades, different classes should have different protocols. I'd hate to be the middle school woodworking teacher who saw kids lose fingers because they weren't paying attention to a safety lesson then started haphazardly using a table saw. Unless, of course, the teacher made them all watch a safety video on the table saw, and then take a quiz to prove they were paying attention. Also, my fear: prohibition generally doesn't work. This "ban the phone" thing sounds swell and great until the first time a school is sued, perhaps because of some emergency issue where the parents could not get ahold of their kids urgently.
- ppetty 2y ago… as I read each paragraph, an icon for for 3 social media sites follows me while I scroll. There might be a few entities to blame, but something seems off when a situation is implied to be dire and related to social networks ... and by the way please share this.
- jszymborski 2y agoIt's important to note that the author and the magazines editor are not in control of this. However, I do take the point that authors have a choice as to where their work appears.