6 ms·
New head of one of the world’s oldest universities organized a citation cartel
- airstrike 2y agoUniversity of Salamanca
- strikelaserclaw 2y agothe salamanca family
- xqcgrek2 2y agoThis is a common practice is almost every research group or collaboration.
- imadierich 2y agoyea.... does it make it "good" though
- ninjin 2y agoI have plenty of nasty things to say about academia. But after about 15 years in artificial intelligence, more than 80 publications, and having worked with and interacted with 15 or so research groups, I have never seen this practice. It is possible that I have been lucky (sample size of one, too), but it is also possible that this horrible unethical behaviour is less common than in "almost every research group or collaboration". If someone have numbers with solid empirical backing, I would be happy to see them.
- ProjectArcturis 2y agoNo it's not. It's common to cite relevant papers from your collaborators (you are working on the same topic, after all). But it's an aberration to create a semi-formal system where you force your underlings to cite your papers in completely different fields.
- miloignis 2y agoMight as well through in my anacdata that I've never seen this in any of the groups I am familiar with during my time as a PhD student.
- rc_mob 2y agoHoly hell that guy is corrupt. The article did not comment on why the University hired him anyyand has not fired him yet. I'm very curious about that.
- wrycoder 2y ago[flagged]
- progbits 2y agoCan someone please explain how this is tolerated? Why is the guy not a laughing stock but a rector? I could understand if it was some clever hidden cartel where people sneak in extra references that seem plausible, spread out over many people and articles. But to juts have cite only this guys garbage papers? Also the citation / H-index metric clearly need improvements. It should be trivial to do clique detection and downrank such citations.
- j7ake 2y agoHe’s a rector because he has a high H index. Nobody cares how you get to such an index unless you commit fraud. I think technically creating citing cartels is not breaking any research rules. Unethical but within the rules.
- progbits 2y agoBut why would the university want a guy like that as their rector? It tarnishes the name of the school.
- chucksmash 2y ago> Corchado won the elections on May 7, after taking advantage of the strange surprise resignation of the previous rector, and presenting himself as the only candidate. He received the support of 6.5% of the 33,000 university members who were called to vote, with half of the faculty voting blank as a sign of protest. Ran unopposed, elected on 6.5% of the vote.
- rightbyte 2y agoOh dear. They really need to change the rules such that losing against blank would postpone the appointment, or something.
- Almondsetat 2y agoHow to blank votes count as protest in an election where there isn't a threshold? Protesting would mean getting some random guy to also run and make him win
- blantonl 2y agoIt’s funny, I think a lot of us who didn’t come through high-level academia or post-graduate education activities have this perspective that those in higher education are amazing figures, above reproach, who do amazing works in society. As I’ve gotten older, and had more of an opportunity to interact with these players, and read articles such as these, I now have the perspective that a lot of these folks are monsters and are some of the craziest, narcissistic, abusive people on the face of the earth. They run fiefdoms and hold power over money and prestige and those under them and because they are brilliant people, they have the ability to damage so many more people around them as they do their work.
- Bluestein 2y ago> are monsters and are some of the craziest, narcissistic, abusive people on the face of the earth With what might be, I am sure, obvious exceptions, I have reached the personal conclusion that academia, universities, colleges, are cespits of the absolute worst, most treachearous, most cunning worst that human nature has to offer. Far from being a meritocracy, scum "floats" to the top in these environments.- I am really curious how this fact ties into the - recently discussed here - lack of value that people more and more perceive in college degrees.-
- ProjectArcturis 2y agoI've spent 15 years in academia and 10 in industry. Academia isn't worse on a per capita basis. Leaders' flaws are rawer, mainly because hardly anyone gets leadership training. And they often have more severe consequences, especially for grad students who are put in a subordinate, dependent position for an extended period of time. But IME you're at least equally likely to find psychopaths at the top of businesses.
- tristor 2y agoYou’re right. Plenty of research has shown C-suite execs tend to have psychopathic tendencies. The thing about academia, though, is that there is no escape. Not only is this behavior everywhere in the academy, economics dictates with very few exceptions you are stuck in the system and have to become part of it just to subsist and participate in research. Meanwhile in the business world it’s relatively a simple matter to quit and work elsewhere when you end up with a psycho boss, and if you’re clever it is relatively simple to be compensated in a way that makes it possible to split away and start your own business or otherwise attain a significant level of control over your own livelihood and career goals. As the saying goes, “the only way to win is not to play” when it comes to academia. Unfortunately that just further concentrates the worst characteristics. As someone who escaped academia it isn’t lost on me that academics almost universally love communism, a system that rigidly enforces equality such that it’s impossible to excel and break away from the system. One of the wonderful things about business is you can earn enough to eventually step away.
- YWall39 2y agoAsked a Spanish professor of computer science, and he said the system is so corrupt that nobody cares. Everybody knows about this guy, and nobody cares.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- cess11 2y agoHere's a short article with some more links about this person: https://forbetterscience.com/2024/05/03/schneider-shorts-3-05-2024-no-data-came-from-a-paper-mill/#corchado https://forbetterscience.com/2024/05/03/schneider-shorts-3-0... Citation- and papermills are quite common and can be quite lucrative. Elsevier, Springer and the others don't really have anything to gain from stopping it.
- recursivedoubts 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- moltar 2y agoSEO backlinks IRL
- rc_kas 2y agoThe problem with building any system is that someone will always abuse it eventually.
- perihelions 2y agoThis guy's antics were featured on Retraction Watch back in 2022 [0]. All of this apparently happened in plain sight—as illustrated by this (farcical, single-candidate) faculty vote getting 50% blank ballots–protest votes. Everyone there knew. "How can we design algorithms to detect..." is the wrong question in response to this scandal—it's completely in the wrong category. IMHO! These citation cliques are unsubtle and basically trivial to detect. It's the professional work culture of research universities that's the hard, unsolved problem. [0] https://retractionwatch.com/2022/03/25/how-critics-say-a-computer-scientist-in-spain-artificially-boosted-his-google-scholar-metrics/ https://retractionwatch.com/2022/03/25/how-critics-say-a-com... ("How critics say a computer scientist in Spain artificially boosted his Google Scholar metrics")
- MrBuddyCasino 2y ago[flagged]
- leereeves 2y agoThe world is far more complex today, and many more professions require an advanced education. The vast expansion of academia has drawbacks, but it was necessary.
- cmrdporcupine 2y agoIndeed, and just in population terms the scale isn't even comparable anymore. Consider the 1920s, 1930s etc when academia produced famous luminaries like e.g. Bertrand Russell or Tolkien or Wittgenstein or Gödel or Whitehead or Heidegger or etc. etc. etc. The population of the world was 1/4 of what it is now -- but even more so the world of academia was closed to probably 99% of that world population ... if you lived outside Europe or North America ... forget it. If you were a woman? Nope. Not from a northern European ethnic background? Not upper class? Also forget it. So in reality the pool of possible candidates was very small who could rise up through this "meritocracy." It was a very defined small fish tank. Easy to look into the tank and see the biggest fishes.
- j45 2y agoThis feels a little like named social media influencers. I wonder if things like LLM's and/or knowledge graphs could research what the rest can't.
- cbg0 2y agoThese guys were stupid enough to put it in writing, but this happens in lots of places where you either get quid pro quo citations or just get put on an article as an author even though you contributed nothing. Unless folks start getting hit with jail time for this stuff, it's unlikely to change.
- jl2718 2y agoIs there a reasonable case to be made for excluding citations entirely? They seem frivolous and arbitrary, and most of the genuine ones are discovered by search, so maybe we could publish without citations, and let the search be automated. The more useful element of a paper is the unique claims that it makes, and these probably should be denoted explicitly.
- alpinisme 2y agoOne large motivation for looking at citations is as a proxy for the importance or value of your claims. More productive research claims will beget more productive research, whereas trivial or dead end or uninteresting claims will just float off into the archival void. So if you want to exclude citations you need another way to measure importance quickly and impersonally across entire fields in more or less real time.
- syngrog66 2y agoIf you observe Hacker News long enough its easy to deduce there are upvote cartels (rings) operating. If a particular submitted link has the good fortune to be put onto the screens of the folks of one of these external rings it will reliably get the 100s of upvotes needed, and fast enough, for HN's algorithms to decide it merits being promoted to the HN front page. Once there its pure gravy in terms of eyeball flow and yet more upvotes. I've certainly given up on ever hoping a link I favor makes it to the HN front page organically without relying on shady upvote eing tactics. HN has reached a point where the upvote cartels, in effect, rule. Its cheating. A form of corruption. A dark pattern. I've considered resorting to using it myself, but have not (so far?) out of ethical disgust.
- Der_Einzige 2y agoI’ve strongly considered writing scripts for other “HN dissenters” who want to show their displeasure by automatically mass upvoting all downvoted posts and automatically undeading posts. If even a tiny fraction of the N-gate former reader base used it, cyber subversives could serious muck up this place until dang and PG start to notice.
- BirAdam 2y agoAs humans, we often acknowledge our species’ failings in adhering to rigor and planned systems. Humans typically acknowledge that most lawyers and politicians are corrupt, and we often even admit this is due to various incentives that exist and push people in corrupt directions… yet, humans seem surprised or scandalized when this occurs in science, academia, medicine, religion, sports, or engineering. We are all just humans. In this case, the dude optimized for a metric that would elevate his own status. Is it wrong? Yeah. Should he be in charge of anything? No. Is he unique? No.
- rendall 2y agoAre we finding it surprising because academia has changed, becoming more corrupt? Or was it always corrupt, but only now coming to light with more awareness? In any case, this is unsustainable. Our civilization relies on academe to help understand and navigate our world.
- pas 2y agoit was always corrupt, and we got here despite that corruption academia ought not to be confused with scientific and technological progress (it's enough to look at academia's roots, it did not start with pure meritocratic institutions to put it mildly.)
- carlosjobim 2y agoMost humans are of a much higher level than those who get involved in academia. We should be surprised if an admirable person has a history of academia, because any involvement is a taint on the soul.
- snird 2y agoUniversities everywhere become corrupt, as performance doesn't matter for the staff to be paid. The only thing that matters is political power, both for the hosting country subsidies as well as outside donations (Qatar massive donation that made Harvard president claim that a call to murder all Jews is ok is a great example). I have no idea how to fix this at this point. I just know that trust in academic institutions is very, very low. And justifiably so.
- timkam 2y ago> performance doesn't matter for the staff to be paid. That's not the case for the people who are in the key phase of establishing themselves as academics and who are generally not on permanent contracts. And for tenured staff, performance decides access to resources that may be as mundane as one's own research time. Conversely, the problem is a mix of extremely shallow performance metrics and a paper-pusher system in which most people get bogged down by bureaucracy by the time they get tenure (or even earlier). This means that very few people have the peace of mind that allows them to focus on high-risk fundamental research. In European AI and CS, I would claim that the ones who manage to maintain focus essentially do this in their free time and get little reward for this; the alternative, i.e., building a strong franchise, is more rewarding in terms of performance metrics.
- rokizero 2y agois it me or is his google scholar page gone? i'm wondering if it's been removed by google or he removed it himself in an effort to remove 'evidence' This used to link to his profile: https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=j7syrnkAAAAJ&hl=en https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=j7syrnkAAAAJ&hl=en
- rendall 2y agoIt seems to have been removed some time in the last year: https://web.archive.org/web/20230701000000*/https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=j7syrnkAAAAJ&hl=en https://web.archive.org/web/20230701000000*/https://scholar....
- rokizero 2y agogood find, thanks! in case anyone's curious, these were his numbers as of may 2023 All Since 2018 Citations 44715 22788 h-index 117 72 i10-index 725 461 (once more amazed how incredible useful archive.org is)
- timkam 2y agoThe Corchado issue is merely an extreme "black and white" case, whereas the overall problem is more nuanced. E.g., there is no clear line between an implicit citation cartel and a group of thought-leaders in a small community. And once you are a thought-leader in a small community, it's much easier to gain broader visibility, to obtain funding, and to influence behind-the-scenes decision making. In a way, Corchado is relatively harmless because everybody knows he is a clown. He does not have much to say in the European AI community. The real issues are in the grey areas (and the people thriving in them) that affect and taint everyone.
- rulalala 2y agoGrey area? Entire disciplines and research areas (theoretical macroeconomics, string theory, ...) could be so.
- elorant 2y agoSo basically that's an offline backlink scheme.
- LeroyRaz 2y agoI feel he was just unusually stupid enough to explicitly put in writing what many academics subtly and implicitly do. People cite their friends, others in the field (with an implicit quid pro quo), etc... even if the research cited has only a tenuous connection to the current paper. The whole practice of citations is very strange. Many times, I have seen researchers search for works to cite at the time of writing! The top Google result gets cited, without the person having even read the paper before, as all they were looking for was a cite for a pretty generic claim (e.g., machine learning has been applied to health care). I'm not sure that such citations are even bad practice as statements should be evidenced by cites. But as a result, a paper getting cited (e.g., the top ranked Google search for ML and Cancer) doesn't actually mean that the cited paper truly means anything, is credible, or a meaningful scientific contribution.
- readthenotes1 2y agoNo one else was willing to run against him. Another win for democracy!
- robotelvis 2y agoThis kind of “political citation” happens even without intentional fraud. When I was in grad school it was common knowledge that if you wanted to get papers accepted you needed to cite the people on the program committee and the likely reviewers - even if you didn’t think their work was particularly relevant to what you were doing. Not as extreme as an explicit clique telling people they have to do it, but some of the distortions are similar - senior people are senior because they are widely cited, but you have to cite them because they are senior people.
- 1oooqooq 2y agotwelve wrongs don't make a right. even including reviewers as authors would automatically remove them from being reviewer.... why do you feel the need to normalize some dumb thing you were subjected to in the past?
- lilian90 2y ago[dead]
- nobodyandproud 2y agoCrude? Yes, but the fault isn’t with Professor Juan Manuel Corchado. If the most important metric is publishing and impact, measured via citation count, then the failure is institutional.
- rulalala 2y agoUniversities are rigged by internal politics. In this case the guy will be hit by external politics later than sooner, but this will set little precedent for exemplary behaviour.
- o999 2y agoNo surprise