10 ms·
Small modular reactors: Still too expensive, too slow, and too risky [pdf]
- hi-v-rocknroll 2y agoAfter reading S. Levy's retrospective book on GE NE and ALWRs, SMRs were delayed for decades but came too little, too late. There's essentially no general purpose point for them given the costs of PV and onshore wind have become cheaper to deploy. This is good for everyone so long as politic including techno-"religious" preferences doesn't subsidize coal, oil, gas, or even nuclear when there are cleaner and cheaper solutions today.
- gravitywave 2y agoIt's worth keeping in mind that 'low cost' PV comes from China (which makes 80% of the global supply of PV cells) which is run predominantly on coal (60% of their electrical energy) and China continues to build a GW coal plant approximately weekly, and incidentally, a new GW nuclear plant about monthly.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoThe coal plants China are building are peaker plants run at a fairly low duty cycle, most of their new power comes from solar. IOW they're building solar+coal instead of solar+batteries.
- mnau 2y agoNumber of coal plants is irrelevant. It's a misinformation. What matters is how much coal they do burn. Their coal plants have capacity factor under 50%. Chinese consumption of coal is roughly as ~10 years ago (82EJ vs 88EJ). That is what matters. Coal plants are going to balance the grid, just like in Germany.
- p1mrx 2y ago> the costs of PV and onshore wind have become cheaper to deploy What about the additional cost of storage/transmission to make those sources available 24/7? Perhaps you've done that analysis and they're still cheaper, but I would automatically reject any argument that excludes storage/transmission.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bobthepanda 2y agonuclear has an opposite but related storage problem to solar and pv; whereas it's hard to reliably predict and line up solar and wind power, it is also generally hard to spin nuclear up and down quickly according to peak power demand as well. one of the first uses of pumped hydro was to store excess power at nuclear stations. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludington_Pumped_Storage_Power_Plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludington_Pumped_Storage_Power... transmission is also an issue at nuclear stations, because no one wants to live near one, and they generate so much power you would probably need additional transmission capacity wherever one was sited anyways.
- pfdietz 2y agoNuclear still loses to PV/wind even with those considerations. And it loses massively if you project those (especially PV) down their historical experience curves. Seriously; do you really think the experts pushing PV/wind have not thought of this? It's been very well addressed.
- p1mrx 2y agoThe experts pushing PV/wind generally expect fossil methane to remain on the grid, or significant upgrades to long-distance transmission.
- pfdietz 2y agoOr substitution of e-fuels for the last residual gas use on the grid. https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/9837910 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/9837910
- jes5199 2y agoI've seen that analysis - depending on how you model it, solar+wind+batteries is often still cheaper, plus batteries are solar are getting cheaper every year, while nuclear isn't (historically it's been getting slightly more expensive over time). So if it takes a decade to get a nuclear plant approved, even if it's competitive today, it probably won't be in 2034
- TheDudeMan 2y ago"Too Expensive, Too Slow, and Too Risky" Because they are still too big. They must be very small. Fuel efficiency is less important than creating economies of scale in manufacturing.
- lven 2y agonot when it's more expensive than diesel. Must find the balance.
- TheDudeMan 2y agoNuclear fuel is about 20x cheaper than diesel (per unit energy). https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/840500 https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/840500 (page 6, table VII)
- Arnt 2y agoCan a nuclear reactor be small enough that it doesn't need an expensive fence with 24/7 guards, and an expensive evaluation of the site for disaster risk? I sort of suspect the answer to be no, but would like to hear arguments for yes.
- littlestymaar 2y ago> doesn't need an expensive fence with 24/7 guards You means, like most industrial plants anyway or even college campuses? An “expensive fence” and 24/7 security guard are still ridiculously cheap compared to the price of the thing itself.
- worik 2y ago> like most industrial plants anyway or even college campuses? Nuclear power stations are an extreme, not typical, example
- littlestymaar 2y agoThis is in fact purely a political decision: a nuclear power plant is in reality less prone to being attacked than a virology lab, and the consequences are way less severe [1], then why should we expect the former to have much more stringent security rules? [1] unless you leave the nuclear reactor unattended in the hands of terrorists for days, they won't be able to extract any nuclear material (which would be the worse case scenario and only one comparable to terrorist stealing a vial of Ebola or Smallpox)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- morninglight 2y agoYes, it might be a hard sell. https://i.pinimg.com/originals/1b/52/bc/1b52bcb5c6d5488cd25650a7fa36e0c7.gif https://i.pinimg.com/originals/1b/52/bc/1b52bcb5c6d5488cd256...
- littlestymaar 2y agoIt's interesting to see a paper talking about how SMR are seemingly unfeasible in reasonable time when we already have plenty of small nuclear reactors being built somewhat in series: nuclear submarine and aircraft carrier engines.
- throwanem 2y agoIt's hard to imagine commercial SMRs being built to the same standard as marine propulsion reactors, or receiving the same level of investment in ongoing maintenance.
- littlestymaar 2y agoAnd yet that's exactly what NavalGroup and EDF are working on: https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/NUWARD_(r%C3%A9acteur) https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/NUWARD_(r%C3%A9acteur) Of course it's not going to be the same “standards” though, because the safety authority is much more rigorous when dealing with civil nuclear their your own soil than for nuclear submarines. (and keep in mind that we're talking about French companies here, and France will need to replace 58 reactors in the next 30 years, so there will a huge need for mass production)
- pfdietz 2y agoIt should be noted that military naval reactors are still more expensive than propelling ships with liquid hydrocarbons. This is why most of the ships in the US Navy are not nuclear.
- Loggias 2y ago[dead]
- worik 2y agoI am really taken about the framing of the industrial risk, the risk of mistakes in design and implementation, as the "Boeing Problem" We know how finantialisation of Boeing created its problems, that is well documented. If a SMR industry develops how can we mitigate those risks? Boeing crashed two aeroplanes before it would even consider a problem existed. Then we saw the rot Boeing were, we thought, the best of the best. How do we stop the same thing in a nuclear programme?
- olau 2y agoThat's not actually what the paper says. It just says that when you have one design, when you find a design flaw, it affects all the instances. Due to the safety regulations, you then need to shut them all down until you've either fixed the problem or determined that's OK to restart. It's the risk of the monoculture. And it then lists some examples from existing nuclear plants. So it's not a new problem.
- orson2077 2y ago(Background: I am an engineer that has spent most of their career in energy - fossil fuels, nuclear and renewables - the whole shebang. I care deeply about climate change, and recognise the non-negotiable need of humanity for ever-increasing amounts of energy.) Take it from me - I would absolutely love renewables to displace all other forms of energy. However, from an engineering point of view, I know this is simply not feasible without some strong developments in energy storage and distribution. With today's technology, nuclear is the only real threat to the hegemony of fossil fuels, and the only practical hope of reaching climate goals (let alone long-term energy security goals). I think the fossil fuel industry knows this, and so frame their anti-nuclear rhetoric as a renewables-vs-nuclear debate, backing renewables. If I wore a tinfoil hat, I would say that a lot of the support for renewables (and hostility towards nuclear) was encouraged/stoked/funded by the fossil fuel lobby. There's an interesting blog that catalogues cases where the fossil fuel industry has scratched on nuclear. If you're interested, I'll link it below. https://atomicinsights.com/smoking-gun/ https://atomicinsights.com/smoking-gun/ As for SMRs specifically, I think they have a lot of legs. Reactors that can be assembled (and serviced) in factories would go a long way to lowering the overall cost of the reactors (even accounting for the reduced energy-cost density of the individual reactors). Questions welcome. I created an account just to give my two cents on a field to which I have dedicated my career.
- julkali 2y agoHow would you then argue against the points listed in the article?
- orson2077 2y agoRegarding their main points: - Too expensive. Nuclear power plants usually operate for 40-80 years, making their ROI after the 20 year mark (greatly varies). The report's choice of "10-15 years" for a return on investment is suspicious, as it corresponds more to the life of PVs and wind turbines. - Too slow. The first instances of a new design always take longer than the mass production instances. It's madness to compare prospective factory-manufacturable reactors to the behemouth reactors we are used to today. (Also, from memory, I think Japan once made one of those behemoth reactors in 22 months... delays are often not for technical reasons). - Too risky. Without storage and/or distribution solutions, renewables will inevitably depend on fossil fuels; this applies both to service economies and manufacturing economies. The difference is that nuclear captures is externalities, unlike fossil fuels. - A bad fit. I actually agree with this one in some cases. For example, Australia has abundant land and great weather; they could probably get by with pure renewables. However, countries like Germany (which has so-so weather and some heavy industry) would be hard-pressed to do the same. They could achieve 100% renewables by giving up certain industries, but I don't think that's reasonable to ask. - The Boeing Problem Boeing's fall from grace has everything to do with perverse incentives and regulatory failure. If the public is crucifying them for dodgy planes, I imagine they'd do even worse for making dodgy reactors. Regulation is a must for nuclear, and never has anyone serious thought otherwise.
- cyberax 2y agoSMRs never made any sense. They have all the same issue as "large" PWRs but they don't have the advantage of scale. Classic PWRs are big, but they produce a lot. SMRs end up requiring exactly the same infrastructure as large-scale reactors, but they produce only a fraction of power. The largest PWRs will produce 1.6GW, but SMRs are designed for <100MW. So you need around 20 SMRs to replace _one_ large PWR. The math just doesn't work out.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoNow do it with economies of scale and transmission losses.
- cyberax 2y agoTransmission losses are single-digit percentages. Economy of scale can lower the price a bit, but not by an order of magnitude.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Economy of scale can lower the price a bit, but not by an order of magnitude Based on what? Orders of magnitude are the norm in manufacturing. We’re seeing it in batteries right now.
- cyberax 2y agoBased on the amount of labor and specialized equipment. And don't forget, SMRs need to be at least 2 orders of magnitude cheaper for your hare-brained idea of "dispoasable reactors" to work.
- RobLach 2y agoPoint of note that David A. Schlissel is the goto anti-nuclear guy for the natural gas industry.
- rqtwteye 2y agoWhen I look at the Ukraine situation I get very nervous thinking about having a large number of nuclear reactors spread out over a country. They would be perfect bombing targets and could contaminate wide areas.
- hocuspocus 2y agoYet Ukraine plans on building more plants, in the West of the country.
- _ph_ 2y agoCan you refer me to any project you are speaking about? I consider it possible that they were planning new nuclear stations before the war, but since the war and the constant nuclear thread by the russians, I would be very surprised if there are larger projects planned.
- hocuspocus 2y agohttps://www.reuters.com/business/energy/ukraine-start-building-4-new-nuclear-reactors-this-year-minister-2024-01-25/ https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/ukraine-start-buildi...