4 ms·
I'd rather see efforts to make mass transit more attractive and encourage its use in a POSITIVE way, rather than using a stick of clogging the roads and punishi
by duxup 2y ago
I'd rather see efforts to make mass transit more attractive and encourage its use in a POSITIVE way, rather than using a stick of clogging the roads and punishing people into using mass transit. Win the market, don't just quash what you don't like.
I can imagine this easily being responded to negatively in the end and the political response is to give in and the pendulum swings wildly in the other direction.
In the end these are policy decisions that can change and I can imagine this backfiring long term in some ways.
- seadan83 2y agoThe Colorado example is about no longer giving out carrots rather than using any type of stick. Tolls and higher taxes would be examples of sticks. > clogging the roads The roads already be clogged and adding more lanes is not likely to unclog them. Single occupancy vehicles at the end of the day are not a solution for moving hundreds of thousands of people around - there's an intrinsic scaling problem that can't be solved by building infinite roads. It's kinda like trying to get high speed internet by adding more & more 56k modems.
- mdorazio 2y agoHow do you propose doing that, though? Mass transit almost everywhere runs at a significant loss already and if we're talking buses then there's a significant driver shortage. In the US the distances and routes required outside of dense urban centers also pretty much necessitate a huge increase in transit time compared to driving, making the whole thing a bad value for people who can afford a car.
- ocschwar 2y ago> How do you propose doing that, though? Thankfully, Massachusetts has shown how to do that. The governor has to make a public statement that he will not allow any more eminent domain takings for highways on his watch (and issue executive orders to that effect.) After that, the people complaining about traffic have to come up with their own ideas, and if road widening (with eminent domain confiscations) are off the table, even the most car-headed idiot out there has no choice but start talking about transit.
- hnburnsy 2y ago>After that, the people complaining about traffic have to come up with their own ideas, and if road widening (with eminent domain confiscations) are off the table, even the most car-headed idiot out there has no choice but start talking about transit. They always have the option to leave the state due to a perceived reduction in QOL. >Massachusetts is hemorrhaging people. In fact, it’s seeing the highest outmigration numbers in the last 30 years, according to a new report from the Massachusetts Taxpayers Foundation. A net 110,000 people moved out of the Bay State over roughly the first two years of the pandemic within the United States, most of them between the ages of 26 and 35. >The question is: why? Rent is certainly a factor. Boston has the second-highest median rent in the country after New York City. Traffic congestion and the many woes of the MBTA have also dominated headlines. >https://www.wgbh.org/news/local/2023-05-30/massachusetts-residents-are-leaving-the-state-why-and-where-are-they-going https://www.wgbh.org/news/local/2023-05-30/massachusetts-res...
- ocschwar 2y agoYes, people have the option of leaving. That option is so unattractive that even gainfully employed and employable people will sleep rough rather than leave. Our biggest challenge in MA is building enough housing capacity so people can park their heads somewhere safe every night. Since geometry brooks no compromise, it's nice that none, absolutely none of our existing building stock can be torn down for highways. It's also nice that our inner ring cities have abolished parking requirements, which makes it easier to build more housing.
- tonynator 2y ago[flagged]
- ksplicer 2y agoYou're making the assumption that roads pay for themselves, but that isn't true at all either. Across the US cities are going bankrupt because they can't maintain roads and other infrastructure. California has a gas tax that pays 80% of road maintenance, the rest of which is often paid from local city taxes that drivers and non-drivers alike pay. Many cities are falling behind in road maintenance though, the true impact of which won't be felt for ~20 years. A hidden cost of car infrastructure is also that the low density increases the costs of other infrastructure maintenance, such as sewage, gas, and power. Good mass transit is ultimately cheaper for everyone.
- anon291 2y ago> Mass transit almost everywhere runs at a significant loss already All infrastructure runs at a loss? Do roads generate revenue
- duxup 2y agoAsk the locals, try some sort of ideas? I'm not sure if you're saying that it can't be improved or what. It doesn't change my point, this policy easily could swing the other way if it is perceived by voters as just a stick swung at them.
- itishappy 2y ago> Ask the locals, try some sort of ideas? That's what the article is about... > Mr. Tafoya was working for the City Council when he heard about the plan to expand the highway just blocks from where his mother still lived. “I-70 radicalized me,” he said. He quit his job and helped organize a statewide coalition of activists and community members who tried to stop the Interstate 70 expansion with lawsuits and protests. In the end, Interstate 70 was expanded. But the fight served as a warning to leaders like Ms. Lew that future highway construction would face spirited opposition.
- Drakim 2y agoPersonally I feel it's fine for them to operate at a loss, it's a public service, akin to the fire department or library. The amount of good it does society to get cars off the road is staggering. The lack of bus drivers simply comes down to an unwillingness to pay more. It's the exact same problem with teachers, where the wage is extremely low but they would rather just have a shortage rather than paying more.
- wongarsu 2y agoCrucially, the road network also operates at a loss
- akira2501 2y agoIn the first level analysis. Once you realize the sheer amount of commerce and business that is enabled by roads you see that they pay for themselves several times over.
- thriftwy 2y agoOnce you realize the sheer amount of commerce and business that is enabled by a decent metro system you see that they pay for itself several times over. That's even easier to measure because these gains are localized.
- akira2501 2y agoRight. So let's have both! You can't replace the capabilities of roads with metro and you can't replace the convenience of a metro with roads. Specifically, though, viewing roads or metro as a "loss leader" is probably an inappropriate analysis.
- prmoustache 2y agoActually, it has been shown that removing cars increase commerce.
- burutthrow1234 2y agoIn TFA, they're literally taking roads and turning them into housing near transit hubs? This policy goes hand in hand with densifying housing.
- wongarsu 2y agoIdeally you would have to change how zoning and planning works to create denser more integrated neighborhoods that can be efficiently used with public transit. If that's too difficult the next best compromise is a park-and-ride scheme. Put a couple stations with huge parking lots in strategic locations between suburbs, and offer good rail or subway connections to work places and shopping destinations. That doesn't enable anyone to get rid of their car, but it gives people a faster alternative to the most congested roads
- strken 2y agoHang on, this isn't taking anything away from drivers at all - the roads aren't suddenly going away or falling into ruin, they're just not getting enlarged. It's not much of a stick and nor is it a punishment, any more than building a road without bike lanes is a punishment for cyclists.
- someguydave 2y agoIt is punishment if you are intentionally engineering the roads to cost people more time using them.
- turnsout 2y agoBut induced demand shows that traffic will only increase… more lanes means you're waiting more.
- someguydave 2y agoThat’s because people are waiting too long on other roads! There is a point where traffic will not increase as all the demand has been sated.
- ksplicer 2y agoThis would only be true if additional lanes were built on top of each other instead of next to each other. As lanes are widened though they just keep pushing things apart and making other types of transit less pleasant, which will then create demand that wasn't there before (because people now need to be on roads longer to get where they want to go). There is a maximum density that cars can support that is LOWER than most cities are built up at.
- CalRobert 2y agoBut it will increase. People move farther away ("this commute used to be bad but now there's another lane so I can live in a bigger house further out!"), businesses build "enough" parking so things are spread farther apart, and all of this increases the miles driven, thereby increasing traffic.
- nullindividual 2y agoPeople are driven by the cattle prod. If the government wants to reduce something, it needs to be more painful to acquire or use, i.e. sin taxes. It's worked on cigarettes, alcohol, soda, etc. to varying degrees. The government would likely have a very big uphill battle to out-market the automobile industry given a large segment of the population distrusts or dislikes the government. I ultimately agree with the approach they're taking. It isn't going to be accomplished by building additional lanes and subsequently asking people to pretty-please take transit. It does need to be weighed against the practicality of transportation to/from where your transit riders need to go. Given the vast majority of Western states are sparsely populated, transit dollars can only go so far.
- kloop 2y ago> The government would likely have a very big uphill battle to out-market the automobile industry given a large segment of the population distrusts or dislikes the government. It seems weird that the response to "a democratic government, which derives its legitimacy from the consent of the governed, has lost the confidence of large swaths of the electorate" is to give that institution more direct social control. That seems like the opposite of what a sane system would do.
- someguydave 2y agoHurting people to teach them your morality certainly has some interesting historical analogies
- baq 2y agoeveryone's morality is different, one would hope the government optimizes for something else, like you paying more to slowly kill yourself because it costs the government money when you stop paying taxes early and use your social security net instead of working
- nullindividual 2y agoThis is not an argument worth having as it can be extended to any law written, up to and including laws against murder.
- itishappy 2y ago> I'd rather see efforts to make mass transit more attractive and encourage its use in a POSITIVE way Where do you think the money is going? > Within a year of the rule’s adoption in 2021, Colorado’s Department of Transportation, or CDOT, had canceled two major highway expansions, including Interstate 25, and shifted $100 million to transit projects. In 2022, a regional planning body in Denver reallocated $900 million from highway expansions to so-called multimodal projects, including faster buses and better bike lanes.
- nradov 2y agoIn order to make mass transit more attractive we will have to do something about the other riders. A lot of people that I know in the SF Bay Area simply don't feel safe on buses and light rail (although Caltrain seems to be fine). Our failures in housing and mental health public policy have turned mass transit into ersatz homeless shelters. Plus there are plenty of regular antisocial assholes playing loud music, yelling, littering, sometimes begging. Rules are not enforced. Punishing drivers isn't a solution. We need comprehensive solutions that make regular people feel welcome on public transit. Otherwise those people won't support public transit funding.
- lotsofpulp 2y ago>I'd rather see efforts to make mass transit more attractive and encourage its use in a POSITIVE way, rather than using a stick of clogging the roads and punishing people into using mass transit. Win the market, don't just quash what you don't like. Impossible. Mass transit, walking, and non motorized bicycling do not mesh with individual motorized traffic. It’s just physics. The classic individualist vs collectivist dilemma that nature presents. You have to sacrifice one for the other. As proof, simply look at all the best places for mass transit. Individual car usage is painful in all of them. The more painful using a car is, the better the public transit can be.
- the_snooze 2y agoYeah, cars are a tragedy of the commons. They're great if you're the only person on the road: you can get to anywhere you want on your own schedule. But then everyone rationally chooses to drive, which makes it a pretty crummy way to get around. Not to mention all the externalities and inefficiencies involved.