6 ms·
'Operation Endgame' Hits Malware Delivery Platforms
- gracebekcy 2y ago[flagged]
- duxup 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ck45 2y agoLink to press release: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40521055 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40521055
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- warkdarrior 2y ago[flagged]
- eutropia 2y agoArresting malware distributors and seizing their domains threatens the free internet? Doesn't allowing near-infinite amounts of scams, fraud, and other abuse threaten the free internet far more than arresting bad actors?
- mint2 2y agoLike seriously, that was like saying that arresting the purveyors of contaminated, tainted meat is harming the food supply. It’s an argument that seems to be intentionally reversed in order to destroy logical debate.
- ASalazarMX 2y agoCould it be that the original commenter is saying state and corporate spying gets justified with these kind of succesful and positive operations, and this gives states the goodwill to push for deeper surveillance, which is then used unethically? Think how the world changed after the PATRIOT (lol) act, and how many terrorists have been actually detained in exchange for such invasive measures on the general public. I'd bet the most benefited from all these years of mass surveillance have been advertisers, not law enforcement.
- mullingitover 2y ago> Could it be that the original commenter is saying state and corporate spying gets justified with these kind of succesful and positive operations, and this gives states the goodwill to push for deeper surveillance, which is then used unethically? I think so, but this is backwards. State and corporate spying gets justified by the scammers and fraudsters, not by whether or not the takedown operations are successful. If scammers and fraudsters weren't doing wildly unpopular things like taking health care systems hostage with ransomware, etc, we'd all have a lot more ammo to tell the cops to respect our privacy.
- clwg 2y agoI've worked on several high-profile botnet takedowns that have resulted in arrests. There is a very fine line and a slippery slope that you absolutely need to stay on the right side of, or things can become very invasive and unethical[0]. Online scams, fraud, and malware have been around since the '80s, and we've survived. Additionally, a huge industry has been built around it, employing many people and generating massive amounts of wealth compared to the direct costs of these activities. Just compare the cost of ransomware to the "cost of cybercrime"[1][2] which is mostly revenue for the cybersecurity industry, and there is a magnitude of difference. [0] https://www.vice.com/en/article/qj454d/private-intelligence-location-data-xmode-hyas https://www.vice.com/en/article/qj454d/private-intelligence-... [1] https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/ransomware-payments-reached-record-11-billion-in-2023/ https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/ransomware-pa... [2] https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2024/01/cybersecurity-cybercrime-system-safety/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2024/01/cybersecurity-cybercr...
- moritzwarhier 2y agoYou consider total ransomware payments the "cost of ransomware"? And the revenue of the cybersecurity industry the "cost of cybercrime"? You seem competent, me I don't know much about practical cybersecurity. But the combined cost of companies or medical facilities being infected by ransomware surely is not covered by the total ransom payments, right? Sorry if I'n grossly misunderstanding your take, but I struggle to make sense of it. I see however your point about surveillance. And also, affected companies and institutions + the software companies, consultants etc they work with should carry a certain responsibility in some cases. For example, a social engineering breach with one employee who had normal privileges shouldn't allow to easily propagate over the whole network etc
- clwg 2y agoThe true cost of any of this is very hard to quantify. There are reputational costs (though you generally want to buy the dip after a hack), national security concerns, intellectual property theft, etc. So, it is a weak argument in that regard, but that's only because there's not a lot of good data to even form a solid opinion on. Sorry if my comment seemed a bit ambiguous. Personally, I have seen during incident response many organizations drop seven figures on EDR, IDS/IPS, and a bunch of widgets while ignoring or refusing to do simple things like network segmentation and configuration/patch management, and it's because they've been sold silver bullets by their vendors, so I also hold a bit of contempt for the industry as well.
- BillTthree 2y agoAre we following the rule of law here? We are talking about arresting bad actors, built on the fundamental principal of due process. There are rules to follow. If the department of justice wants to bring criminal charges against individuals or corporations, should the first step be 'sieze all assets'? When is the doj allowed to sieze assets, if we think its a scumbag foreigner but what if its an upstanding american tax paying LLC? Should your business be subject to immediate takedowns while the doj investigates and attempts to prosecute you? Has anyone been convicted of anything? We are siezing control of personally owned assets under the presumption the responsible parties will be found guilty. That seems like a slippery slope.
- randomlurking 2y agoWhy are you assuming that rules weren’t followed? Is there any reason to suspect this? I’m not the greatest fan of the police by far, but it’s not like this (seizing assets without prior conviction) is a novel or anything but standard procedure happening in the frame of clearly defined rules. Should a murderer run free up to his conviction, even when there’s strong evidence of his crimes? Shouldn’t the police seize assets of drug cartels at the moment they can instead of years later when everybody is convicted?
- pluto_modadic 2y agoMonitor the transactions, collect evidence, get warrants, seize things, collect evidence, get arrest warrants, etc. if someone is dumb enough to register with a real name, the amount of time needed to coordinate it can be reduced. like with the 911S5 botnet, they got evidence over the years to build a case to arrest them. if it's a large group of people, it may take time or a turncoat to slowly gain evidence on the other parties. seizure of assets in those countries required the police and courts in those countries to have probable cause that yeah it was definitely related to the crime and necessitated seizure in a coordinated fashion. This is similar to the coordinated quiet takeover of a darkweb market, or the coordinated spooky takedown of another, to scare criminals onto the bugged one.
- pwillia7 2y agodepends on your definition of free
- swayvil 2y agoA free internet allows a degree of lawlessness.
- Cody-99 2y agoHow tight is the "noose of the surveillance state" when it takes them years to stop groups like this? For example, the smokeloader malware mentioned in the post has been around since at least 2011 [1] [1] https://attack.mitre.org/software/S0226/ https://attack.mitre.org/software/S0226/
- immibis 2y agoThey've been focusing on other, more important things, like protests about the police murdering people[0][1]. [0] https://www.euractiv.com/section/digital/news/macron-mulls-social-media-shutdowns-to-contain-civil-disorder/ https://www.euractiv.com/section/digital/news/macron-mulls-s... [1] https://www.voaafrica.com/a/macron-decried-for-social-media-cutoff-comment/7167853.html https://www.voaafrica.com/a/macron-decried-for-social-media-...
- k8sToGo 2y agoFree internet isn’t the Wild West.
- unnouinceput 2y ago4 people and 100 servers? that's all? that's a drop in a bucket, won't event make a dent in the black market of ransomware.
- Cody-99 2y ago>In addition, Europol released information on eight fugitives suspected of involvement in dropper services and who are wanted by Germany 4 people in the initial arrests. They already have arrest warrants for at least another 8. It seems they have arrested someone who provided a lot of infrastructure so it wouldn't surprise me if they were able to roll that into more arrests in the near future. >“It has been discovered through the investigations so far that one of the main suspects has earned at least EUR 69 million in cryptocurrency by renting out criminal infrastructure sites to deploy ransomware,”
- ASalazarMX 2y agoForget numbers, think Marvel's Endgame, envision cop superheroes from all over the world converging on the supervillain to enact justice and save civilization! I swear law enforcement and the military choose the cringest name codes, not much better than names kids would pick.
- b112 2y agoGovernment types do everything by committee and meeting, all responsibility for decisions is shared, everyone must agree. Thus nothing risky, edgy or creative makes it out of such meetings.
- red-iron-pine 2y agolol what? have you seen what comes out of the corporate world lately?
- nozzlegear 2y ago> I swear law enforcement and the military choose the cringest name codes, not much better than names kids would pick. I have it on good authority that the people in law enforcement and the military — and indeed all humans in general — were in fact kids at one point. Maybe we all just like cool sounding codenames, even if some keyboard jockeys on a forum will call it “cringe”.
- mmsc 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- endgame 2y agoStrange, I wasn't informed.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mrbluecoat 2y agobest laugh in a while - well played
- IndianScamOps 2y ago[dead]
- PoignardAzur 2y ago> “These nascent psyops include efforts to erode the limited trust the criminals have in each other, driving subtle wedges between fragile hacker egos, and sending offenders personalized messages showing they’re being watched,” Burgess wrote. Is the "Think about your next move" messaging that intimidating to hackers, especially those living in non-US-aligned countries? I suspect this flood of weirdly cyberpunk imagery (seriously, mugshots with a Matrix background?) is more of an artistic choice to flatter the egos of the task force's agents than a strategic move. White hat hackers probably like pretending they're in a spy movie as much as black hats do.
- lyu07282 2y agoI just imagine the mentality (and skills) of a cyber security expert who decides to work within the German bureaucracy, it explains a lot
- atomicnumber3 2y agoAn NSA or DOD guy doing digital forensics and cybercrime type stuff came to one of my college classes to teach a lesson or two. He mentioned that he would love if we came to work with him, but also people he talks to at colleges almost never do because even median pay at a generic private sector corp is better than the government wages for that work. So yes, people working in the majority of cybercrime shops are people who either couldn't hack it at a generic boring C# corpo job, or are specifically more interested in being a white hat than getting paid lots of crinkled, sweat-dampened VC money.
- lyu07282 2y agoIt's not even just the money, I had a brief experience working within german bureaucracy and i couldn't imagine a more soul sucking, conservative and uninspiring environment. You definitely have to be a certain type of person for that environment, the unpleasant type imho.
- hunter-gatherer 2y agoEh. It is more complicated than that. I started out in DIA and a lot of government employees in the "hacker space" are indeed underpaid compared to their civilian counterparts. The way the sausage is really made though is through contracting, and these folks are paid. Bottom line is that if you want to do cyberspace stuff for uncle sam and want to be paid the you shouldn't be going to any careers/*.gov website. Look instead for generic "Network Operations Engineer" type postings that are in Herndon, Bethesda, Baltimore, Annapolis Junction, Fort Meade, and so on. There are some perks to being a government employee, but you end up in the government framework for pay and what not, which sucks. if I recall correctly the folks at CIA (AFD I believe???) had some sort of system set up where they hired government employees as a POCO billet or something so they could bring talent in at a reasonable pay scale, and then they'd do some political maneuvering to rotate people around so everyone was getting paid. DIA was a charlie foxtrot in that arena and probably still is, so I'd avoid them. The FBI has a pretty good team in quantico, though I'm guessing again that most of the are really just Booz employees.
- OliverJones 2y agoLooks like some web designers in law enforcement are having some fun making fun of the cybercreeps.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pelasaco 2y agoI didn't get why all wanted hackers have german flag under their names if all of them are coming from Ukraine. Are they germans or wanted in Germany?
- koolala 2y agoBe careful cause they can pin cybercrime on anyone for any reason and there are no cyberlawyers besides AI 1000% smarter than them.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> included a countdown timer that was eventually replaced with the personal details of LockBit’s alleged leader Assuming these folks are somewhere lawless, I assume this is meant to let third parties take matters into their own hands?
- darkclouds 2y ago[dead]
- upwardbound 2y agoIf folks are interested in this kind of story (law enforcement vs cybercriminals), one of the best examples is the book Crack99: https://icdt.osu.edu/crack99-takedown-100-million-chinese-software-pirate https://icdt.osu.edu/crack99-takedown-100-million-chinese-so... https://www.amazon.com/CRACK99-Takedown-Million-Chinese-Software/dp/0393354334 https://www.amazon.com/CRACK99-Takedown-Million-Chinese-Soft...
- red-iron-pine 2y agosounds kinda like The Cuckoo's Egg, circa 2017. got my attention though, will check it out