5 ms·
The government is making it more difficult to track private aircraft travel
- ryandrake 2y ago> The U.S. yet yet to pass even a basic internet-era privacy law Nitpick, but even the first sentence in the article is nonsense. Doesn’t anyone proofread anymore? Let alone read even the first sentence before publishing?
- the_duke 2y agoAt least that way you know it's not written by an LLM...
- NoMoreNicksLeft 2y agoIf I wanted to give my AI headline-writer software typos, I bet there's a simple algorithm for that. Letter missing, letter doubling, transposition, and nearby-qwerty keys. Of course, you'd need a separate algo for brain farts (their/there/they're and whatnot), but I think I could make something for that too. The sad truth is that it's not worth it to anyone to go to the trouble just to spare us the insult to our intelligence.
- pc86 2y agoJust ask the LLM to slip in one common typo or swap in an incorrect homophone, no need for a "separate algo" for what is just a single instruction.
- TeMPOraL 2y agoYou could probably just tell the LLM to make random spelling and grammar mistakes in its output, as if it was a news writer in a hurry.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 2y agoBecause they do so well at randomness?
- TeMPOraL 2y agoThey do, yes.
- gamepsys 2y ago> Doesn’t anyone proofread anymore? If the headline got you to click than the article has completed it's job. The other 500 words are just to make you not feel scammed.
- jjtheblunt 2y agoits :)
- madeofpalk 2y agoYou're saying you've never ever made a typo in anything you've published? It's almost universally agreed that you can proof read all you want, but has soon as you hit publish you'll spot at least one mistake.
- dylan604 2y agoEven HN gives you a two hour grace period to edit the contents of your post.
- pyvpx 2y agowhich federal privacy law were you thinking of?
- JohnMakin 2y agoCan you name one federal law passed in the last 20 years regarding online privacy? I work in this space and genuinely cannot think of one, but would glad to be corrected. Edit: misunderstood the comment I was replying to, haven't had coffee yet
- rocqua 2y agoThere's a double word (yet) in the quote.
- dylan604 2y agoThe fact that you feel like you have to point this out just shows how you're missing the point that nobody cares. Yes, it is a silly mistake to make, but it doesn't negate the intent of the sentence. Harping on it just as a take down comment on a post is just immature. If this was a post or even just a thread on the lack of editorial process with in today's online media, then we could nitpick the use (or not) of the Oxford comma, the emdash vs endash vs hyphon vs ellipses vs parantheticals. We could even pontificate on the grammar like the selected sentence structure, use of single long sentence as an entire paragraph, the use of capitalization of all the letters or just the first letter in an acronym for a name like Nasa vs NASA. Alas, that's not what this is, so there's a saying that comes to mind about time and place or even picking your battles.
- atonse 2y agoAgreed, but then again, you see a stupid sentence like this later in the article: > Jack Sweeney, the jet tracking student who made Elon Musk cry like a baby – and realize, wait, I'm not really sure this is any kind of legitimate news source. I'll wait for a more accurate article without all the editorializing.
- tengbretson 2y agoGreat! Maybe this will cause a decrease in the total number of people getting harassed by jerks on the internet.
- Phiwise_ 2y agoInteresting that people seem to not like your comment. Isn't harassment and doxxing against the rules around here? What's the principle that disagrees with this statement that doesn't also apply to everything else on site?
- giraffe_lady 2y agoThe rule is against doxxing and harassment here. That doesn't mean we can't support or advocate for their use elsewhere. Not that I am trying to do that per se. But just pointing out that HN doesn't & can't really demand ideological commitment to not using specific conflict tactics broadly.
- Phiwise_ 2y agoYou've misunderstood me, in a way that doesn't make sense as unintentional. Of course I'm not commenting on the rules of HN. Why would I comment in support of a user who just restates those rules then?
- giraffe_lady 2y agoSorry I misunderstood you. It really was not intentional. People state the rules of HN all the time, I really thought that was all you were doing.
- thriftwy 2y ago[flagged]
- office_drone 2y agoWhile that would be nice, this writing excerpt from ~2000 years ago suggests that it's deeply ingrained in people: Why do you see the speck that is in your brother's eye, but do not notice the log that is in your own eye? Or how can you say to your brother, ‘Let me take the speck out of your eye,’ when there is the log in your own eye? You hypocrite, first take the log out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to take the speck out of your brother's eye.
- sandworm101 2y agoLol, once upon a time Dick Cheney used to disappear from travel logs by doing the opposite: traveling first class commercial like a "normal" person. He didn't even claim the costs as expenses so as to avoid any publicly-accessible records of his travel. A relative of mine ran into him, and his security detail, on a small aircraft flying out of Hartford.
- dylan604 2y ago"Folks over at Bluesky dug into the specific language of the reauthorization bill and found it was inserted by Republican Rep. Bruce Westerman of Arkansas." It's always funny (both haha and sad) to me which sacrificial lamb the parties convince to push something like this forward. It signals so much about their intent. If they wanted lots of coverage, they would pick a much more recognized person within the party as a champion to push something forward. For stuff they want to sneak in, they pick someone much more obscure. This protects the more recognized from catching any blow back. This poor guy is probably barely known in his home state, so he's probably using it as a "happy just to be mentioned" type of coverage.
- alephnerd 2y agoRep. Westerman is fairly senior. He's the Chair of the House Committee on Natural Resources - the Committee that gives authorization for mining, drilling, and land use. He is also holding Tom Cotton's former House Seat, a former Majority leader of the Arkansas State House (the first Republican one in Arkansas since the 19th century), and will most likely replace Senator Boozman when he retires. Aka, he's upper level in the hierarchy of the House GOP. Most likely, Walmart leadership (Bentonville is in Westerman's constituency) lobbied for this as private flight data is often used in competitive intel.
- dylan604 2y agoMike Johnson is the Speaker of the House, but before the chaos that put him in that spot, who here would have known his name and/or been able to pick him out of a line up. I bet there are people in his home state that wouldn't be able to do that too. Even if they are a "senior" member, which I'm only familiar with being used to reference senators, I know that I don't know every single representative from my state. There's too many of them, and the ones I do know that aren't my rep are probably because of some asshattery they were in the news from doing. It's not like senators where there's only two of them.
- selimthegrim 2y agoEven among representatives from north Louisiana that I had heard of (I live in the southern part) I hadn't heard of him.
- balderdash 2y agoI mean a) this is the right thing to do. b) it’s pathetic that this can be accomplished yet cell location tracking and and ALPRS data has not been addressed
- ghaff 2y agoThe objection should really be not that this was passed--and, yes, the people involved could probably layer on some LLCs if they wanted to obfuscate as I assume corporations tend to. But that there is really a ton of personal data available to the obsessive, especially if they're willing to spend a few dollars.
- AlexandrB 2y ago> it’s pathetic I think the word you're looking for is "corrupt". The interests of people who can afford private jets are obviously taking precedence over the interests of the rest of us.
- SpicyLemonZest 2y ago> The U.S. yet yet to pass even a basic internet-era privacy law — or regulate data brokers. And while there’s a lot of misdirection and pretense to the contrary, the primary reason is (1) because the U.S. government is too corrupt; and (2) because the U.S. government really enjoys being able to purchase massive amounts of sensitive citizen data from data brokers without having to get a pesky warrant. No, this is false. There exists, today, a bipartisan proposal for a basic Internet-era privacy law called the American Privacy Rights Act. As Techdirt has covered in the past, advocacy groups like the EFF don't think it should be passed as is, but it's advancing along in the process and may well end up being passed after some amendments. (Of course, while this information is critical to anyone who cares about internet privacy in the US, it would have made the article less effective as ragebait. Which is why the author didn't include it.) https://energycommerce.house.gov/posts/committee-chairs-rodgers-cantwell-unveil-historic-draft-comprehensive-data-privacy-legislation https://energycommerce.house.gov/posts/committee-chairs-rodg... https://www.techdirt.com/2024/04/23/any-privacy-law-is-going-to-require-some-compromise-is-apra-the-right-set-of-tradeoffs/ https://www.techdirt.com/2024/04/23/any-privacy-law-is-going... https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2024/04/americans-deserve-more-current-american-privacy-rights-act https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2024/04/americans-deserve-more...
- ooterness 2y agoA "law" has been finalized, passed by both halves of Congress, and ratified. A "bill" is an incomplete proposal at any stage of this process. There is a catchy song [1] to help everyone remember this. A bill is the same as a pull request that has not yet been merged. So the statement, "The U.S. [has] yet to pass even a basic internet-era privacy law..." is correct. In other words: The American Privacy Rights Act is just a bill, yes it's only a bill, and it's sitting there on Capitol Hill... [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tyeJ55o3El0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tyeJ55o3El0
- SpicyLemonZest 2y agoThe first part of the sentence is right - what's not correct is to blame it on corruption or dysfunction, as though nobody's working on it.
- say_it_as_it_is 2y agoThis is a toxic post by someone peeved about not being to stalk people of affluence. There are other ways to address emissions attributed to private jets, such as taxes, while respecting people's privacy.
- giraffe_lady 2y ago"People of affluence" what does this mean?
- tbrownaw 2y agoIt's recently (last few years?) become popular in some crowds to replace "_____ people" with "people of _____". It's based on the theory that the former implies an inherent trait while the latter implies a current status. (It's also of course become popular in other crowds to mock this construction by using it in ways that its original proponents would presumably object to.)
- nvy 2y agoConsidering tech billionaires got rich by destroying our privacy, why do only they deserve a law protecting their privacy?
- busterarm 2y agoThe same way children and women get special laws related to crimes that disproportionately affect them... How do you tell me you have no empathy for people higher up the status latter than you without telling me you have no empathy for people higher up the status ladder than you?
- AlexandrB 2y agoI think it's foolish to have empathy for people that have no empathy for me. I don't want to be tracked. A lot of very wealthy people have made their career (and fortune) off of tracking me against my will. Why would I care about their desire not to be tracked now?
- MostlyStable 2y agoI'm not sure I buy the comparison to Internet privacy. The comparison to cell phone tracking elsewhere in the comments is better. It's bad enough that the government has relatively trivial access to cellphone tracking data, but if it was publicly available, that would be pretty disastrous on a lot of fronts. Yes, this is a law that only protects rich people, but it's also a problem that only affects rich people, and I'm pretty comfortable saying that it is a problem. As long as not too much money or effort is being diverted to this (and therefore away from the hundreds of more important problems), I just really can't get that worked up over it.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> I'm pretty comfortable saying that it is a problem. On what evidence?
- MostlyStable 2y agoThe fact that I think it's wrong for the public to be able to trivially track anyone? I think the capacity is a bad thing. I also think it would be bad as I stated if the public could trivially track poor people. I thought I made that pretty clear in my comment. I don't understand what it is you're asking evidence for. It's clearly a thing that can be done, this the existence is this bill. And I'm making an argument that morally that is wrong. You're free to disagree with my moral judgment, and I'm sure many people do, but it's not really a thing that requires evidence.
- n4r9 2y agoWhat do you think are the negative consequences of private flight data being publicly available?
- cess11 2y ago"The fact that I think it's wrong for the public to be able to trivially track anyone?" It's not "anyone", it's people with a lot of social and economic power, that through their means of transportation does a lot more damage to society and our habitat than most people that get sentenced for a crime in the courts. If it gets public that you smoked some weed or did some oxy without a physician signing off on it then it should obviously be public that you are rich, and that you refuse to mingle with the plebs and instead fart out tons and tons of carbon dioxide.
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago[dupe] Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40444795 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40444795
- renewiltord 2y agoPrivacy guys win another battle. Good for them, I suppose. Bit by bit, public information is protected.
- jMyles 2y agoI'm surprised to see agreement, even just in principle, with this amendment. If you think this is OK, are you just against ADS-B altogether? I have serious qualms about someone flying a 23,500lb hunk of metal, laden with volatile and explosive fuel, over my community without needing to publicly report telemetry and flight plan details in plaintext. First it was the cops, and now rich people. Allowing certain privileged groups to keep this information between them and the state seems likely to lead to outcomes where they can behave poorly and then be able to lie or "get their story straight" before being honest with the public. Which makes incidents more likely altogether. I think that accountability in aviation is very healthy for a technologically advanced society, and these moves seem like a step backward.
- NovemberWhiskey 2y ago>I have serious qualms about someone flying a 23,500lb hunk of metal, laden with volatile and explosive fuel, over my community without needing to publicly report telemetry and flight plan details in plaintext. But none of that requires a fixed identifier linked to the publicly-accessible airframe registry, right?
- schmookeeg 2y agoWhat are your thoughts on the 80,000lb semi trucks, laden with (admittedly less) volatile and explosive fuel, driving through your community without needing to publicly report telemetry and routing details?
- jMyles 2y agoWell, semi trucks are required to have license plates, and if they are for commercial purposes, the information on the licensee can be obtained easily. It wouldn't bother me if they were required to transmit this information via radio, though of course for ground vehicles one can simply visually look at the plate number (something impossible to do for an erratically flying aircraft, at least without a killer zoom lens and tripod). And then, for DOT hazmat licensing, which is perhaps more comparable to a private jet in terms of risk, the registration requirements are quite stringent, and including prominent display of DOT hazmat labels, as well as licensing information which is of course public. It seems to me that private jets just became far more opaque than semi trucks, relative to their transport mode.
- durandal1 2y agoSo we're saying that the reason jets should be able to be tracked by anyone, in real time, is so we can enable targeted moral shaming? Everyone, regardless of wealth or mode of transportation should have the right to not be publicly real-time tracked. Let's find more constructive ways to solve our larger scale societal problems than to fall back on mob rule.
- dosplatos 2y ago> Everyone, regardless of wealth or mode of transportation should have the right to not be publicly real-time tracked. I think that's the point. There are data brokers selling information right now on everyone's whereabouts, travel patterns, shopping behavior, and many other data points. This happens essentially any time you interact with electronics that can send and receive data. Going about data privacy legislation in this way is ridiculous. It's like if you had a clogged toilet in your house, you just continued to let it flood because you can build a ramp over the water to get to your private jet and take a dump in that toilet instead.
- frankbreetz 2y agoI think the outrage stems from wealthy people having their issue fixed by congress in a timely fashion, when regular people feel like they cannot catch a break. Housing, Inflation, Healthcare, are all a mess but this problem gets fixed right away.
- daft_pink 2y agoI think if all your data broker data was logged and tracked on twitter it would be a congressional priority. Wealthy people use youtube and tiktok too.
- nojvek 2y agoWhen you're rich, you can skirt laws by paying cops, courts and lawyers as cost of business. When you're super rich, you have lunch with politicians and they change the laws for you.
- WarOnPrivacy 2y agoThe Original Posting here linked to a TechDirt analysis piece; that piece is meaningfully different from the current PopSci link. The entirety of the PoPSci article begins and ends with the Protect-Jet-Owners'-Privacy law. The TechDirt article uses that law to refresh public attention about US Gov's disinterest in protecting the privacy of all Americans - which is a massively larger and much more important issue. https://www.techdirt.com/2024/05/29/the-u-s-finally-passes-an-internet-privacy-law-for-rich-jet-owners/ https://www.techdirt.com/2024/05/29/the-u-s-finally-passes-a...
- thrill 2y agoPoor jet owners too.