4 ms·
Mortgages Stuck Around 7% Force Rapid Rethink of American Dream
- Analemma_ 2y agoTotal rubbish. 7% was the floor for 30-year mortgages from 1970 to the mid-2000's[0], and people were buying houses just fine. This is a submarine story trying to use the heartstring-pulling framing of "the American dream is dead!" to try and coax policymakers into any course of action other than the "build. more. friggin. housing." which is the only actual way out of this. [0]: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MORTGAGE30US https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MORTGAGE30US
- AzzieElbab 2y agoRight, but house prices have moved much faster than earnings, and if house prices fall, people will lose the savings embedded in those houses.
- tbatchelli 2y agoAnd others might be able to buy a house for the first time. The issue with houses being the main form of families to acquire wealth is that newcomers to the market have it much much harder to enter participate in it as time goes on and house values increase. So people losing some "paper" savings is a price to pay so other people can also own. But in reality, when homeowners struggle and sell their homes is mostly large real-estate funds that buy them. So it's possible that homes losing their value means owners lose savings but newcomers still can't enter the home ownership virtuous cycle.
- nly 2y agoThe principle paid down on those repayment mortgage came from homeowner income and was diverted away from other savings and investments. Punishing millions of people who just sought housing security because, for reasons beyond their control, the Fed decided to cut rates after the GFC and keep them low for 15 years is just not tenable. Fortunately, in the UK at least, it looks like (nominal) house prices will remain stagnant until real earnings catch up with rates. A better all round solution.
- credit_guy 2y agoThe vast majority of the homeowners would not lose their principal. They would lose some of their paper profits.
- nly 2y agoAt the sort of correction you're talking of you're talking about millions of people going in to negative equity. In the US market this may be tolerable because you have full-term mortgages, so people can just stay put even if they're pushed in to negative equity. In the UK it's death. Here mortgages typically last for 2-5 years. Homeowners would be pushed in to negative equity and be unable to remortgage.
- AzzieElbab 2y agoCanada is similar to the UK. I don't see any way out other than productivity-driven growth and building more housing. Both seem extremely unlikely
- chii 2y ago> So it's possible that homes losing their value means owners lose savings but newcomers still can't enter the home ownership virtuous cycle. if a house is cheap, but is still valuable (as new owners _want_ to buy because it's worth it while it's cheap), then this means it's a mis-pricing. And mis-pricing means that any investing entity will want to buy as well. In aggregate, this _should_ push the price back to the correct equilibrium. Therefore, housing being expensive today is a reflection of how many people value it high. It might also indicate that the reason it was cheap before was a mispricing, and those who got in early was merely lucky.
- fred_is_fred 2y agoI’d argue that there’s so many buyers waiting in the wings (not even counting hedge funds and Blackrock), that there’s an effective floor on home prices. 5% down swing will mean more buyers and in that kind of market a 20% drop just isn’t happening.
- hattmall 2y agoYeah but homes were priced based on that historical trend. Now the high interest rates are pushing up against a decade plus of very low interest rates. There are willing sellers that can't actually sell because even with significant equity in their existing home a new purchase would result in a much higher payment. There are too many people locked in at low rates.
- demondemidi 2y agoPrecisely! I can’t sell because I cannot afford to buy if I moved. I’m lucky to have a house but I’m stuck in it for at least another decade or two.
- cableshaft 2y agoYep, we're pretty much stuck. Not really complaining, at least I have a home bought at a much lower price and rate compared to homes now, so my mortgage payment is quite affordable, but I really wish we had followed through with moving when we were looking at homes just before the rates started jacking up. We waited a bit and it quickly got to the point where our mortgage payment would double if we sold and bought an equivalent home to what we have today (and we'd ideally want to upgrade a bit, we bought this intending it to be an affordable starter home).
- cherryteastain 2y agoMedian house price to median household income ratio was a lot lower back in the 70s. Data for the UK (similar in all developed economies): https://www.schroders.com/en-gb/uk/individual/insights/what-174-years-of-data-tell-us-about-house-price-affordability-in-the-uk/ https://www.schroders.com/en-gb/uk/individual/insights/what-... 4-6x from the 70s to the 90s, now 9x and growing rapidly.
- j_walter 2y agoHouse square footage was also lower back then though... https://www.newser.com/story/225645/average-size-of-us-homes-decade-by-decade.html https://www.newser.com/story/225645/average-size-of-us-homes...
- black_13 2y ago[dead]
- chao- 2y agoWhen I first realized that media discourse trivializes "The American Dream" as owning a house, I was in my early teens. In school we had just read a few essays from the 1920's and 1930's debating whether the American Dream was dead. I was very confused. Maybe the American Dream was dead in 1925. Maybe it was dead by 2005. Maybe it wasn't dead at all, or maybe it never existed to begin with! Real, illusion, dead, alive. Whatever it is, it sure as shit means something more than owning a single-family house. I wish the media discourse would stop abusing the term.
- metadat 2y ago"Owning a house" is really about achieving personal security living in a society, where if you maintain resources, your land generally won't be taken away randomly (there are rare exceptions, like government appropriation for projects). I still agree with you. Stop abusing the terms.
- brianwawok 2y agoTho in fact on a fixed income even if you 100% own your home, it’s possible property taxes can get high enough to have your home taken away.
- metadat 2y agoI've not ever heard of this happening to somebody in the United States, I suspect it's uncommon. In most states property taxes are somewhat fixed at the time of acquisition.
- thenipper 2y agoI’ve known folks in NH this has happened too. One of the only real taxes NH has is a property tax so it keeps going up. Folks who’ve owned their place forever suddenly can’t afford it. Most of them are old so they’re on fixed incomes or they’re woodchucks who do odd jobs/labor to get by. Just for comparison: I live just outside of Boston. My property taxes for my house are roughly the same as my parents in NH. Even though my house is worth 5x as much.
- ndgold 2y agoI’m curious what the full ownership proportion looks like in the US. About a quarter? Feels high to me. https://www.forbes.com/sites/johnwake/2023/03/31/us-has-3rd-lowest-percentage-of-households-that-own-their-homes-without-mortgages/?sh=43ef5df83124 https://www.forbes.com/sites/johnwake/2023/03/31/us-has-3rd-...
- yazzku 2y agoThat's an interesting statistic. The prospect of being "house poor" isn't particularly enticing to the younger generations either. And your bank actually owns the place until you've paid the last cent anyway. Couple that with the general precarity of the job market, and you probably won't be putting that down payment even if you technically could.
- chii 2y ago> your bank actually owns the place until you've paid the last cent anyway. your bank "owns" the place, but you gain the economic and utilitarian benefits of the place (after all, you get to live in it, or rent it out and receive income). It's not exactly the same as the bank owning it.
- sharadov 2y agoIn most places across the world homeownership is a dream. Housing prices are many times the household income. Despite calling it a dream, in America, historically home ownership for the middle class was a given. America has just caught up to the rest of the world.
- ramblenode 2y ago> In most places across the world homeownership is a dream. AFAIK this is more a phenomenon of Western urban areas than the world in general. Even in very poor countries home ownership is normal (and for men it can be a de facto requirement for getting married).
- 11101010001100 2y agoSure if you count inheriting a house....which is what is happening here in the west.
- jimberlage 2y agoIn 1981, the average 30 year fixed rate mortgage carried a rate of ~18%. https://www.rocketmortgage.com/learn/historical-mortgage-rates-30-year-fixed#:~:text=3.11%25%20for%202020.-,What%20were%20the%20highest%20mortgage%20rates%20in%20history%3F,highest%20annual%20average%20at%2016.63%25 https://www.rocketmortgage.com/learn/historical-mortgage-rat....
- alephnerd 2y agoHouse prices were also much lower back then, but that only proves (what I assume is) your point - we can't view the past with rose tinted glasses. The American Dream was always aspirational and took grit and effort and was never attainable for 15-30% of the country due to their skin color or ethnic origins until precedent against redlining took hold by the 1980s. IMO, I'm fine with us keeping high interest rates if it forces a rebalancing of prices long term. It's not like low interest rates would help affordability anyhow, as it's only us white collar workers in high paying fields like Tech, Finance, etc that have the dry powder to execute on purchases.
- spondylosaurus 2y agoI agree that higher interest is a worthwhile trade-off if actual prices come down, but to your last point, don't low interest rates benefit some marginal buyers by (1) lowering the monthly payment and (2) making it more appealing to put minimum down? Granted, even minimum down is out of reach for too many people, but I feel like "if only we could afford the down payment, we could definitely afford the mortgage..." is a relatively common lament. And sometimes those lamenters don't realize you can/should put down 5% instead of 5-20%, circumstances permitting.
- ben_jones 2y ago> it's only us white collar workers in high paying fields like Tech, Finance, etc that have the dry powder to execute on purchases With inflation, layoffs, and lack of union representation, I suspect software engineering median salaries outside major hubs to stagnate rapidly.
- oceanplexian 2y ago
- throwaway22032 2y agoThere are too many factors which artificially make housing less liquid IMO. In the UK we have stamp duty which means that if I sell and rebuy the exact same house next door I would lose tens of thousands in taxes, on top of all of the (unavoidable) costs like surveys, estate agents etc. In both the US and UK if you can't port your mortgage to a new home then you take a gigantic financial hit to move into the same house next door because your rates go from e.g. 2% to 6% overnight, doubling your mortgage payments. We should definitely build more, but stuff like this also needs to be addressed, no-one is going to downsize if they end up losing most of the money.
- jschveibinz 2y agoJust an idea: The use of ground rent in new developments is one way to reduce cost to home buyers in higher mortgage rate environments. In this way, the homeowner can still develop equity in the property while the ownership and expense of the land by the developer or investor can covered over time by the ground rent eventually resulting in a ROI for the developer or investor. There could be fair ways to allow homeowners to purchase the land at some point, similar to a car lease, when their financial situation allows. Another way to think of this is fractional ownership: land + dwelling.
- DataDive 2y agoHonestly, I never understood why a mortgage would even exist at, say, 3% interest ... Why would anyone loan out trillions of dollars at 3% (that also includes the risk of default). The same money in an index fund produces 7% over the long term Even at a 7% rate mortgages appear to be be less liquid, more risky, and will underperform the market. Mortgages exist probably only because the govt backs them (aka, taxpayers are on the hook) and allows banks to keep charging bogus paper filing fees on top of it. Banks offer mortgages to charge a 1K "origination" fee ... or whatever it is called.
- nine_zeros 2y agoThere are enormous funds such as pension, state, family funds that require some percentage of assets to be held in fixed income. When the government bond returned only 1%, 3% mortgage fixed income seemed glorious.
- itake 2y agoThere are many investments that need guaranteed payouts every month (like pension funds). Mortgages are very valuable. Checkout this post about mortgages for more details: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40403221 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40403221
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- chii 2y ago> Why would anyone loan out trillions ... The same money in an index fund produces 7% over the long term the originator of these mortgage loans want a consistent income from the interest payments, even if it's lower than buying equities. These equities that earn a theoretical 7% is only good in the long run, such as 10-20 years. It might not return anything in particular years, or negative returns in others. If you needed a fixed income stream (eg., an insurance, or an annuities provider like pension funds), you will not want to bet it all on equities. Mortgages, which are collateralized, means you have a buffer for losses if the defaults do happen.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoIt’s hard to compare with houses 30 years ago when, per square area, they are more technologically valuable, much larger per occupant, and the demographics surrounding the houses has completely changed.
- PM_me_your_math 2y ago[dead]
- ein0p 2y agoThey’re on their way up, way higher than 7%. If we’re headed into stagflation, which it looks like we are, they’ll probably be above 17% we had last time because back then we didn’t have $35T in debt, did not pay $1.7T in interest (which is what it’ll be next year) and did not add $2.5T in debt per year.
- chii 2y ago> above 17% we had last time but last time the world didnt have the new sources of oil that exists today, and the technology level back then was also lower - leading to lower productivity. Long term interest is related to growth, and higher interest is indicative of growth.
- ein0p 2y agoHigh interest is related to high prime rate. High prime rate is related to reduced demand for US debt, which it must issue because it can’t pay its bills. You offer debt with a higher rate of return to sweeten the pot or go bankrupt.