3 ms·
Modern AAA game development is suffering a chronic mismanagement problem. Like fimmaking. Poor creative vision, not communicated clearly to those executing it;
by pjc50 2y ago
Modern AAA game development is suffering a chronic mismanagement problem. Like fimmaking. Poor creative vision, not communicated clearly to those executing it; endless rewrites and rework; lack of originality; poor treatment of staff leading to poor morale; and churning away in the background, the culture war.
Technically the only interesting challenge is "how do we get off Unity?"
- chii 2y ago> a chronic mismanagement problem. Like fimmaking. the mismanagement stems from the fact that it is costing too much from the onset, and "management" wants to ensure that the investment makes a good enough return to justify the high cost. Therefore, they dictate all of the risks have to be removed - such as not going for a risky new brand, but make a sequel. They want realistic graphics because it's more commercially viable - going for a different or uncommon aesthetic means taking risks. I would argue all of the problems in AAA development stems from this fact. it is also why indie games can be so cheap yet so successful. Not because indies are better (tho they are- at least more passionate if nothing else), but because indies are capable of taking risks to push the edge and make something new and untested. It's the same as films - creative endeavours cannot have their risks managed away. It is inherent, and there's a large chance of failure even if the team has done their best.
- kevindamm 2y agoThe risk aversion in product is not a new phenomenon, though. Bigger producers have been following that track since at least the 90s. Adherence to brand, and even more so to basic game genres and mechanics, has been an issue complained about by devs at any big enough studio for decades. What changed, I think, is all of the development studios being bought up by large producers. But, then again, I see steam as being a great counterforce on this, and the ease of releasing on web or mobile has been a boon for indie devs too. So maybe that hasn't changed that much. The technology has advanced to where you can spend blockbuster budgets and get nearly film-quality results (not nearly possible in the cartridge and CD days). Meanwhile the price per AAA title has stayed relatively fixed at 50-60 USD for that same range of time, so production houses have had to try being appealing to ever-larger audiences. Fortunately, many people continue playing these games into their 30s and 40s so the market grows on its own too. I'm trying to say you're right about the risk aversion being a big part of the industry's problems but that's been an issue for a while, it has gotten terribly enhanced with the growth of the industry. Now I wonder which is worse.. extracting money one quarter a time with punishingly difficult timing tests, or extracting money via cosmetics that have no actual game impact but are marketed very compellingly.
- the_snooze 2y ago>it is also why indie games can be so cheap yet so successful. Not because indies are better (tho they are- at least more passionate if nothing else), but because indies are capable of taking risks to push the edge and make something new and untested. The cheapness also means indies simply get more "shots on goal." The barrier to entry is relatively low, so failing is lower-stakes. You have way more indies trying (and mostly failing), which means you have a greater raw number of hits. That's compared to a big company only having a handful of big-budget games in development.
- josephg 2y agoThis also creates a better environment for learning the craft. You learn more about how to create good games by launching 3 small indie games in 3 years than 1 large game. Especially when you’re a small cog in that large game project.
- 587846 2y agoThis certainly seems to be true, at least for one modern example, according to a recent post that linked to a YouTube video whose creator evidently has insider information about the 'failure' of Kerbal Space Program 2 (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40485788 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40485788).
- chris37879 2y agoAs someone in an otherwise healthy position at my job, fuck yes, I want to get away from Unity, but there's just no better option for the platforms we're targeting and how quickly we want to ship things. Something about the devil you know, ya know?
- lkirkwood 2y agoWhat are your thoughts on Godot? If you were equally experienced and invested in that would things be different?
- strix_varius 2y agoAs someone who's worked quite a bit with both, no. I have hopes for Godot but in terms of actually shipping commercially-viable games, it's not even in the same league as Unity. This comes from many things, but some of the big ones are: * Ability to do first-party console ports * 3D rendering fidelity and speed * Asset store quality & quantity * Robustness & stability - they both have tons of bugs but with Unity there is almost always a way around the bug, due to the decades of commercial games that paved the path before you. For one quick example, Godot's physics engine is well-known to be poor, both in terms of performance and in terms of accuracy/stability. It has tons of bugs, tunneling, jittering, etc. Both the 2D and 3D physics engines in Godot are currently slated to be ripped out & replaced with external ones of higher quality (Box2D and Jolt). But currently, that hasn't happened, so one of the foundational parts of most games - physics - is guaranteed to be broken to some degree in a Godot game.
- peterashford 2y agoBut Jolt is pretty much a drop-in replacement right now, no?
- strix_varius 2y agoFor a hack, sure. For something you're doing seriously, not so much. Replacing the 3d engine with Jolt is on the official roadmap. If it were really a drop in replacement today, that would have already shipped.
- pjmlp 2y agoGetting off Unity, or Unreal, is the same as asking "how do we get off Office?". Before their ascension there were already plenty to middleware to chose from, Ogre3D, SFML, SDL, Gamemaker, RenderWare, jMonkeyEngine,... They aren't used as much, even the free ones, because of supported languages, tooling, asset store, platform owners support, and everything else that keeps them relevant in the industry despite their flaws.