9 ms·
Young women fall out of love with dating apps
- belter 2y agohttps://archive.is/IqpWD https://archive.is/IqpWD
- wpasc 2y agothank you beltalowda
- belter 2y agoIm ta nating
- gautamcgoel 2y agoSometimes HN warms my heart.
- m_a_g 2y agoI think this applies to all genders. I don't know a single person who is happy using these apps. However, I'm curious about what other HNers think, especially women.
- exe34 2y agoI use it as a placebo to quieten down that part of my brain that would otherwise stop me from working. I wouldn't want to meet the sort of people who would want to meet me from these apps.
- ushakov 2y agoI was talking to my friend today about dating apps being a softporn addiction
- godelski 2y ago(Male) One thing that really changed my thinking of these apps was asking myself a simple question: "could I find my best friend through an app like this?" Once I realized this, I was able to quit them and make that quit actually stick. Instead of being in the cycle of uninstall, be lonely, get back on, frustrated, a few lackluster dates, maybe get laid, feel more frustrated, quit, rinse, lather, repeat. I met my current partner through a friend (who also set me up with my previous partner, which did NOT end well). This is the woman I intend to marry and both her and I knew we had something different pretty quickly. I don't think this would have happened if we met on an app weirdly enough. But I think if you're in a relationship, try to set up your friends. Truth is, a lot of them want it (get their permission first obviously). It's still a roll of the dice, but the odds are better. It's kinda like the same reason you prefer to hire someone through a recommendation from a current employee or someone you know/trust. There's more signal. But also, these types of setups can be softer and more natural, allowing you to get your feet wet knowing the person. And let's also be honest, sometimes you got to meet someone a few times and dating apps lead to a lot of first dates and very few second dates because you get the idea that if you're not a perfect fit (might be an off day for either of you) that there's plenty more people to choose from.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- xenospn 2y ago(male) I use them to get laid. In a big city (Los Angeles) they work quite well. No expectations of a relationship.
- guilhas 2y agoI have seen successful cases. People in their 30s coming out of a long relation, with a not very social job/life, have some difficulty finding a new partner if not online Of course, there are many different apps, more casual, more serious, some bots all around... you need the right app for the job But my impression was a lot of people alone lookig for a serious someone, and not many opportunities to meet new people
- pseudalopex 2y ago> I think this applies to all genders. I don't know a single person who is happy using these apps. The article was not about who is happy really. It was about who is not using the apps.
- axegon_ 2y agoI can't share personal experiences since I've always hated the idea of dating apps/sites with a passion. Social media in general but that's a different story. But a lot of people around me have and I have discussed it with many of them. There are a few not-so-obvious shortcomings in dating apps: From a business perspective, they make a ton of sense. And I'm sure the people behind them have made thousands of experiments while developing them but I feel like(just like anyone I've spoken to), they never managed to simulate what would happen at scale and most importantly they can't fully simulate human behavior. At large, us men are very used to hearing "no" from a very early age. Which has one of two effects: those that excel in some areas are more likely to keep trying even when they fail. Those who seem to be on the back foot in most areas become the outcasts but strangely it looks as if that yields some results for them in the dating apps. But there is a group in the middle that are the real losers in this(and likely the vast majority). For women it's kind of different: they are the more likely ones to say "no" to a man, even if they feel some attraction - "there's always another one". Which is not to say that I don't know instances where this philosophy has massively backfired but what can you do. The truth is, dating apps are very appealing to those with low self-esteem and bad social skills: at a glance they provide some form of protection, which is unfortunately not true. Dating apps, just like real dating is a numbers game and all they do is digitalize social anxiety and insecurities. If anything, they probably make it worse: people can hide to a degree things that they are insecure about: height, high pitched voice or whatever. But sooner or later that has to materialize and the blow often is much bigger than having to go through it out of the gate. Here's a real life example with a former colleague of mine: finding a partner was his sole purpose in life. Really nice guy, very educated, great sense of humor but, as I said in the previous paragraph, kinda short and a really squeaky voice. The good news is that he made it and is now married and has a son. Great. But he spent ungodly amount of time on dating apps and spent thousands of bucks on them-like literally in the 5-digit realm. Kudos for being this persistent - I honestly don't think I know anyone that has gone through as much effort as he has - the process spanned over a period of 5 years. The truth is he was actively being exploited by dating apps and while he was aware of it, he saw it as his only chance. Personally I did not understand his urge and not because I had a partner or a family - I still don't in my dead-center mid 30's: my philosophy on that topic is literally "meh, whatever". But seeing this guy struggle so much, it honestly was heart breaking. On the other end of the scale, I know women that scroll through tinder endlessly, nope-ing out of everyone they see and the second they tap yes on someone they are are even vaguely interested in, it's an instant match. It kind of looks like playing age of empires with the ac cobra cheat always on: it is fun the first three or four times but it gets boring fast. But remember when I said that women are not used to hearing "no"? Well I was having a coffee with her a while back and she said that at some point she really wanted to ask me out. I laughed and asked her why she didn't: "You are a very strange breed: most men will say yes instantly because it's an easy shortcut. You are not most and you wouldn't even bat an eyelash while telling me to take a hike in my face. That thought was absolutely terrifying". Those wouldn't have been my words of choice but she definitely had the right idea. But the fact that a woman that has a magnitude of good qualities and is way more attractive than I am is terrified of getting rejected speaks volumes. In reality men have to go through a lot of effort to get any results at all with dating apps. Women... Well they simply need to be on them.
- SuaveSteve 2y agoThey are great for loose women who need sex for validation.
- jmclnx 2y agoI can see this and surprised it did not happen ages ago. I am sure women are being bombarded with date request to the point they will get burnout. Never mind the men who are faking their profile.
- jimbob45 2y agoI don’t intend to ever use a dating app but even I feel an aversion to wanting to use one if there’s even a chance I could be talking to a bot. Even worse if you’re a man and you suspect the girl is just looking for free food.
- thefaux 2y agoI think there is a brewing backlash to algorithms intruding too much into the human domain. These apps have likely peaked though I don't know what will replace them.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- walterbell 2y ago> Match Group, which has more than 40 dating brands including Tinder and Hinge, and Bumble, which also owns Badoo and Fruitz Consolidated oligopoly seeking creative inspiration. Reward offered.
- janice1999 2y agoWow, the list of apps they own is long: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Match_Group https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Match_Group Also, if memory serves, the first thing Match did after acquiring OkCupid was take down some of their blog posts, including "Why You Should Never Pay for Online Dating".
- candiddevmike 2y agoWhere's the DoJ when you need them?
- walterbell 2y agoDeclining population is not good for national security. Cities can discourage human-hostile architecture in public meeting places, e.g. prevent Standbucks without tables and chairs. Algo transparency reform for human bloodline management.
- walterbell 2y agoVeggie People Meet!
- belter 2y agoThey don't own the market leader...LinkedIn
- tonfreed 2y agoIt's a shame, met my wife on OkCupid
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gwervc 2y agoWomen are the big winner of dating apps: thousands upon thousands of men at disposal without to have to put any effort into finding a partner. That rose their standards like nothing before and caused (at least in my country) a culture shift against starting conversations IRL. On the other hand, it's harder than ever for random guys (like me) to pick the interest of Western women even IRL, to the point I'm not trying anymore. Despite women being clear winners and most men clear losers of dating apps, notice how the title of the article is only about women supposed suffering. In a way it's a good metaphor of the dating market: women always demanding more and men just have to suffer and shut the fuck up.
- ramesh31 2y ago>men just have to suffer and shut the fuck up. Welcome to being a man.
- jelliclesfarm 2y agoMaybe consider that women are picky and the mediocre fruits get unpicked.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- M95D 2y agoMaybe consider that mediocre women (yes, there is such a thing!) will have to lower their standards or grow old alone. Apps won't reveal to them this predicament they're in.
- paulddraper 2y agoWinners only in the short-term sense. Short-term validation, but have uncommitted relationships, which arguably harms women most.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 2y agoA more charitable read is that women are the product that these apps are selling, and men are the paying customers who want access to this gated marketplace. It's reminiscent of how clubs will let women in for free, because without them the spendy men, willing to impress the ladies with bottomless overpriced champagne, will not bother coming inc, and the club ends up making no money.
- dvt 2y agoI wrote a blog post about this a few years ago that goes viral every now and then[1]. The issue is that these companies have been forcing an asymmetrical market (surprise surprise, that's how they make money); the irony being that marriage/dating markets have been historically seen as some of the most efficient markets around. In fact, economists study these as "ideal markets." There's also a lot of pushback against the hookup culture that has become prevalent in the past decade (facilitated primarily by the apps), and of course Covid has made social groups much more rigid. As a single guy in my 30s, going out to a bar and meeting random people (even guys, let alone women) seems much harder than it was just 3-4 years ago. Dating apps are also extremely superficial where to have a modicum of success these days you essentially need to do a photo shoot. Women hate them because of weirdos and bad dates, men hate them because of atrocious m:f ratios, and frankly, I hope they go away. They've probably done more harm to our society than good. [1] https://dvt.name/2020/02/24/rfc-lets-disrupt-dating-apps/ https://dvt.name/2020/02/24/rfc-lets-disrupt-dating-apps/
- helpfulclippy 2y agoFew things have ever made me feel as horrible about myself as trying to meet women on dating apps.
- OutOfHere 2y agoThis is due to the nature of the apps that maximize revenue generation over customer success. The apps can otherwise trivially be structure with throttles to ensure that almost everyone is getting matched, not to excess, also that only active users are matched, but this would greatly hinder revenue generation. The revenue exists in exploiting the male wallet with shiny things and false promises. If empirical communism buys you mass murder, empirical capitalism buys you rampant monopolization and relentless exploitation. Perhaps we need something like a non-profit donation-driven Signal Foundation but for free dating. It would use concepts from distributed systems, namely backpressure, throttling, and rate-limiting to ensure that almost everyone can feel a winner.
- latchkey 2y agoSuccess would be to stop using the app. Which is exactly what they don't want you to do.
- TulliusCicero 2y agoThat's true if the aim is a long-term monogamous relationship for users, which is obviously true for a lot of users, but these days not all of them.
- haliskerbas 2y agoExactly this. A great example is apps like Coffee Meets Bagel which sometimes tout themselves as the "solution" but then have a separate section of "select" candidates that you have to pay to talk to. So basically if you have a desirable profile (in this case it's basically if you're hot because that's the primary part of a profile), they monetize you without your knowledge or permission and charge the other side to initiate conversation.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 2y agoSame with Hinge, the additional attractiveness of the paid-only profiles is noticeable.
- 2y ago
- saberience 2y agoI’m not sure why this is phrased in such a way as to imply that men are fine with how the “dating app scene” operates and women are the ones being hurt by it. As a man who has used all the modern dating apps and who knows many other men who have also used them, I think I can say without hesitating that the experience almost universally sucks. As a man, even if you’re on the better looking side, with a good job etc, the numbers look something like: swipe right on 150 women, of that 150 you might get 10-12 matches. Of those matches, 3 will probably write you a single message. Of those three, one will go on a date with you. And there’s a fair chance when you go on the date, the person doesn’t look at all like their pictures. (This has happened to me twice) In one of the apps I used, Hinge, I have about 203 matches. I.e. the woman chose me and I chose her. Out of 203, I ended up going on five dates. Of that 203, 50 of them never responded to a first message. So, while I agree the experience isn’t nice for women, it’s equally soul crushing as a man. It seems more like a game where people are trying to “collect” matches like they’re Pokémon, and getting more matches fills some strange sort of immature psychological need. The whole thing deconstructs the fairly beautiful idea of falling in love or meeting someone wonderful and levels it down to some base and insidious numbers game, while also creating a sort of “dating picture” arms-race of filters, choreographed pictures, etc to ensure you stick out in a world where image becomes everything. We talk about how “objectifying” others is bad… well, dating apps are practically training us to objectify others and treat them as fungible entities to treat our loneliness and low self esteem. The whole thing is depressing, what’s worse though is that since most of the western world is less social, alone more often, has no “third space”, etc this dating app world has become many people’s only option for finding a meaningful relationship. Ok, time to swipe through another hundred women…
- dondraper36 2y agoThat echoes my experience as well. Also, I have noticed that at least for me Tinder has been very strange in that it keeps showing the same profiles every day, most of which are fake anyway. It became so absurd that even IRL it's much easier to meet someone and start a conversation than on the app that was literally created to simplify that.
- CuriouslyC 2y agoTry to find social spaces for things that are deeply meaningful to you and be outgoing. I met my wife at a shamanic ritual meetup, and the character of the relationship is on a whole different level than what I'd experienced from online dating. YMMV, but I was _very_ successful at online dating so I feel like I have a decent sample to generalize from.
- aprilthird2021 2y agoThe truth is young women have fallen out of love with dating and "hookups" in general. Many stats show that the younger generations have less friends, have less sex, etc. They value a life partner or romantic partner more for the stability and less for the "thrill" because living with a permanently online record of their lives and the viciousness of the entire Internet being able to "cancel" you for things you said or did years ago has made everyone a bit less thrill-seeking, a bit less adventurous, etc. And that doesn't really vibe with dating apps that encourage meeting someone you don't know, your friends don't know, for what's probably going to be a short term relationship. I think it's a bit of a pendulum effect. We went really hard into hookup culture in the 2000s (just check out all the American Pie type movies back then that would never be made today). Now people are swinging back more to wanting stable relationships that benefit on paper rather than in our hearts and all.
- 331c8c71 2y agoLess friends and sex could be simply the result of face-to-face communication being steadily replaced with virtual substitutes (and the resulting relative denormalization of face-to-face communication).
- keyshapegeo99 2y agoOr it's simply because young people spend ever-increasing periods of time living in cramped shared accommodation or with their parents, due to the dysfunctional rental market in most Western Anglosphere countries. This certainly isn't conducive to sex, and often makes it difficult or impossible to host friends (meaning that people often choose to meet at venues such as restaurants instead, a situation which often necessitates more infrequent catch-ups due to the expenses involved).
- aprilthird2021 2y agoIndian people live like this and have lived like this for centuries and they have the same problems (less space, more expensive, more living at home), but they don't have the loneliness and less sex problem.
- guilhas 2y agoThis seems more like a natural adjustment since the end of lockdowns and remote learning. Younger people don't need them because of the return of student social/night life
- deskr 2y agoI understood from a friend that you get more/better matches (as a man) if you pay? The men I know that are attractive (can attract a woman with relatively little effort) are not likely to be spending money on online dating. Ergo, women are seeing a lot less of 'attractive men' in online dating?
- bradlys 2y agoWomen’s sexuality also doesn’t really line up with how dating apps work. Almost every dating app out there now is based around Grindr’s original formula. Show a few photos and about three sentences of text. It’s completely catered to men’s sexuality. For men, personality is important but if you aren’t physically attractive - there’s almost nothing that will move that. The same cannot be said for women - as most women find most men physically unattractive (often including their own partners). Most of the women I know who didn’t meet their partner from a dating app usually say they wouldn’t match with their partner if they had seen their profile online. For women, in person interactions are incredibly important for determining overall sexual value. This is why many women will meet very physically attractive men in real life but then find the men very off putting in some way or another - leading them to feel disenchanted with the process. Online dating is inherently a male gays oriented game as it has been developed over the last decade.
- janandonly 2y agoI am deeply worried about both more people reaching pensioner age and stopping to work and younger people waiting longer to settle and start families. And then even dating apps are failing us. > More than one-in-10 had received threats of physical harm. Who are these buffoons? Do you really think a lady will respond to your request for a date if you threaten her!? > Gen Z and women These two groups, younger people and women are the hardest to reach. I guess gen Z will be the first truly alone generation.
- cykros 2y agoDating apps seemed like they got about a decade that anyone took them seriously at all. Maybe 15 years if I'm being generous. Before that, we went out and met people in meat space. Often at bars, because as bad as that was, it still beat the dating apps of the day. I think at this point people are getting paralyzed by an overabundance of choice in many cases, and the illusion of the possibility of infinite pickiness (coupled with the ability to pick out flaws before you ever encounter redeeming qualities in a person). When you look at human history, for most of it, marriages were arranged. Then for the last few centuries, they were arrived at by "love" (aka, raging hormonal passions, and the occasional chemically altered decision making). Now, people are making this match making thing about finding the perfect person. May as well make it about finding a martian for how successful that's likely to be, by anyone who bothers to take a second to look at it. Humans are messy. Two humans are messier than one. Relationships aren't about perfectly compatible people, they're about learning to work together despite the fact that you're going to have reason to clash on a regular, if not constant basis. And if that prospect is too exhausting, then yea, people should expect to be alone more. If THAT prospect is unacceptable, perhaps consider rebalancing your life to make room for basic human intimacy. There's no such thing as mustering 150% of your available resources.
- Ajay-p 2y agoI think apps over time reduced dating and courtship to very short interactions. It may also have something to do with less places young people can go to interact with each other, but maybe that swipe left or right has permeated to our in-person interactions. My parents met at a roller skating rink. I don't think those exist anymore.
- haunter 2y agoTokyo metropolitan government has a dating system for single people. It's also very strict and you need vetting (ID card, certificate that you are not married etc). Honestly I think it's a very good system and probably something that more and more countries will copy. https://www.futari-story.metro.tokyo.lg.jp/ https://www.futari-story.metro.tokyo.lg.jp/ And there are detailed dating tips too if you don't want to register https://www.futari-story.metro.tokyo.lg.jp/futari_start/ https://www.futari-story.metro.tokyo.lg.jp/futari_start/
- 4gotunameagain 2y agoI would be very careful in copying Japan for anything dating / relationship / procreation related. Of course relationship rates and birth rates might not have a very strict correlation (which they probably do), but Japanese society is so very different from western societies that unintended consequences could prove.. fun
- jey 2y agoIt's no wonder; these apps aren't delivering on the actual value proposition of dating apps: finding great matches. Instead they trap people on the platform "swiping" endlessly, where a right swipe doesn't even mean real interest. How would a dating app work if it actually worked in the user's favor? It would focus on finding great mutual matches that are personalized to exactly who you are and what you're looking for. But this is a tricky problem because there's two competing criteria: 1) we want to give each user the ability to express their personal preferences and match with the people they're most excited about, but also 2) we need to prevent spam and encourage compatible matches, otherwise some people will get inundated while others will be left shouting into the void with no reply. This is something I've been obsessed with figuring out, and it turns out there's an elegant solution drawing on mechanism design (a subfield of game theory), combined with cutting-edge preference learning algorithms that are able to learn your personal tastes with high accuracy. My cofounders and I are currently building a new app called Rarebird based on these insights. We're currently looking for a Creative Director (Lead Designer) and an ML R&D Engineer. See more details here, including a deck and technical overview: https://docs.google.com/document/d/e/2PACX-1vRfo082XRQWUfIwQibk03vW6i7tF5ySW_gYqyaDCA-b8JovhOrUeDB37VLNFQQ1YbRqrFWcYpidIheC/pub https://docs.google.com/document/d/e/2PACX-1vRfo082XRQWUfIwQ... Really, there should only be one dating app if it actually worked. What has stronger network effects than a dating app? The only reason we see such fragmentation is because the current apps don't actually deliver better matches as the population increases, instead what users experience is congestion as there's more and more irrelevant potential matches on the platform. Which is why most new apps just try to carve out a niche segment of the population, e.g. based on religion, ethnicity, or a special interest. But an ideal app would understand you holistically and find the best matches for you as a complex and multidimensional person, without forcing you to collapse yourself into one particular niche as the determining factor.
- mike_hearn 2y agoIs it really an algorithms problem? Surely that idea has been well explored over the last 20 years. OkCupid was big into the idea of algorithmically matching people based on their personality and it got crushed by Tinder, same as all the others. The problem with dating sites is not insufficiently smart machine learning. It's more like human nature when faced with a large homogenous pool of candidates, combined with the shift to smartphones as the primary way young people interact with online services (significantly restricts how many words people can be expected to produce and therefore how much data you can get for ML). OkCupid explained the problems on their blog many years ago: 1. Men aren't that picky and are willing to make a lot of effort to find a mate. They would like a nice girl who will take care of them and not be too crazy. Ideally a pretty one younger than them, but most men will settle for plain and same age or older if they have to. This lack of pickiness combined with willingness to make an effort manifests in simply swiping right on / messaging every single woman ("spam" as you put it). They are also pretty fair judges of women's attractiveness: the ratings they give are normally distributed. 2. Women become extremely picky. Tinder is/was notorious for women putting minimum heights in their profile, some also like to specify minimum salaries, specific kinds of jobs, very specific age ranges (invariably older than themselves) and so on. You don't see men do this! They also become unwilling to put in even small amounts of effort. Tinder expects only a few sentences about yourself in a profile but many women don't even write that much. Why would they, they feel like they can pick men from a menu without needing to write a personal essay. Unfortunately, women's ratings of men aren't even close to normally distributed, as they rate most men as being far less attractive than average. There are only a relatively small number of 6ft5 35-40 year old men earning 250k+ a year with a great sense of humor, the problem is women don't seem to reflect that reality in the distribution of attention they're willing to give. Only a tiny sliver of men are considered as being worth replying to, these men get all the female attention and can then sleep around as much as they want, leaving lots of heartbroken ladies in their wake. Your description of Rarebird makes it sound like the service assumes men and women are pretty much the same and a good dating service would just use AI to make everything better. OkCupid tried that and although it had its fans, once Tinder came out it became something of a ghost town. There's simply no way to satisfy women's expressed preferences no matter how fancy your ML gets. It's a social problem, not a technical one. (I am so glad to be married and out of that scene...)
- juancn 2y agoIt's like bars having ladies nights, or discos charging only males. Human mating is female selection driven, if there are no females, there's no business.
- erich_money1 2y ago[flagged]
- erich_money1 2y ago[flagged]
- deterministic 2y agoIf you hate dating apps I highly recommend speed dating instead. I met the love of my life on my very first speed dating event. And previously had zero luck online dating.