9 ms·
California Senate Passes Bill Requiring Passive Speed Limiters
- mdp2021 2y agoTaking for granted that cars should have a GPS system installed, and that drivers can always accept that...
- 7e 2y agoThe driver will own the GPS system, no? How is this different from owning a smartphone?
- mdp2021 2y ago> How is this different In that GPS subsystems I want off are off.
- MadnessASAP 2y agoWire cutters are the universal off button.
- greenavocado 2y agoIf they start checking for it you can use a dummy load on the antenna port
- alexey-salmin 2y agoWait until it becomes illegal
- mdp2021 2y agoWe have a problem with third subsystems in the car checking that all security subsystem be present in order to start normal march (as opposed to "degraded mode" or just "off"). I have seen vehicles which worked with some security subsystems disconnected, and others that refused to work properly. Plus, you have the issue of the method: "Welcome to your wedding: this is your wife, and this the complimentary gimp (should you want to dispose it, you have the onus)". Plus: have you considered how much the complementary gimps (etc.) that come with the car inflate its price?
- spdustin 2y agoAlso a universal guilty verdict if you try to beat the ticket.
- paraselene_ 2y agoYou can't update/upgrade your onboard car infotainment/ECU like a smartphone. I'd assume the onboard map data going stale FAST. You get to choose which smartphone to use, and when to upgrade them. The lifecycle of a car is A LOT longer than its onbaord infotainment. I see no mandated free of charge on data updating, nor mandated support timeframe.
- bbkane 2y agoYou can change a smartphone a lot easier than an integrated GPS system
- bell-cot 2y ago> In the text of SB 961 that system is described as: “An integrated vehicle system that uses, at minimum, the GPS location of the vehicle compared with a database of posted speed limits, to determine the speed limit, and utilizes a brief, one-time visual and audio signal to alert the driver each time they exceed the speed limit by more than 10 miles per hour.” No mention of how much the manufacturer is allowed to charge you every month, for access to "your" car's proprietary GPS->Speed Limit database.
- tacticalturtle 2y agoIt’s also not uncommon to see out of date speed limits on Google/Apple maps. I can only imagine some future manufacturer’s database would be even more out of sync.
- schreiaj 2y agoThe number of times I've looked at the speed limit my car thinks it is supposed to be and seen 80 on what is effectively a residential road... Or that the highway near my house that the car seems to think is 35. Barring also adding some sort of managed database owned by the state I don't see this being remotely viable.
- DavidPeiffer 2y agoMany cars use vision systems to identify the current speed limit, eliminating the need for a database.
- ryandrake 2y agoCar manufacturers forget about their cars infotainment systems as soon as they sell them. I just drove home on a road yesterday that was totally missing from my Toyota's built-in map. Even if they offer a map update, it's probably already out of date and they probably charge for it. I'm sure the speed limit data is going to be equally fresh and easy to update.
- D13Fd 2y ago
- thepasswordis 2y agoI don’t like this but I also don’t know the alternatives. People drag race right in front of my house all night long on the weekends. It’s absurdly dangerous. We are on the edge of a residential neighborhood (so our house faces the main road), and a few blocks from a police station. The police do nothing. I don’t think I’ve seen somebody “pulled over” in my city in like a decade. A few days ago I say a guy pull into the oncoming traffic lanes and hit the top of 3rd gear to cut in front of a line of cars at a stop light. Just absolutely insane, deranged behavior and I see it every single day. Edit: I was mistaken and thought this limited speed. Apparently this is actually useless.
- gizmo686 2y agoI don't think this will help with that. From the text of the bill, the only requirement is that the system alerts the driver when they are more than 10mph over the limit. The system us not required to limit the vehicle speed, nor is it required to report the infraction to the authorities.
- ryandrake 2y agoSo it's just another annoying fuse to pull. Along with OnStar and the cell modem.
- thepasswordis 2y agoAh, my mistake. I had been reading about this and read “passive speed limiter” as something that…limits the speed. This sounds absolutely and completely useless.
- rnrn 2y ago> The police do nothing. > I don’t think I’ve seen somebody “pulled over” in my city in like a decade Seems like there’s a pretty straightforward alternative here - have law enforcement enforce the law.
- CoastalCoder 2y ago> Seems like there’s a pretty straightforward alternative here - have law enforcement enforce the law. As a law-and-order kind of person, this my first reaction as well. But it seems so obvious, I have to wonder: what's at work that prevents this solution from being enacted? I.e., are there factors I'm not aware of that make it logistically and/or politically difficult?
- RhysU 2y agoAnyone want to annex California? It's clearly becoming more trouble than it's worth.
- mdp2021 2y ago(I actually laughed out loud) We'll get many large backgardens ("for investment only - currently inhabited"), as the same proposal was made in the UK in 2021 (if I remember well. Cannot search for the article right now). Edit: ok, etiquette obliged. I am checking. The results are much worse than I understood... (This is so unnerving I typed 'understool', and there could be many slips in that.) > The EU ruled on 6 July 2022 that all new cars manufactured in Europe must be fitted with speed limiters as of July 2024 https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/new-car-speed-limiters-driving-laws-uk-b2157426.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/new-car-spee...
- elicksaur 2y agofyi annex means the opposite of how I think you are using it. e.g. “The city annexed part of the outlying county to increase its property tax base. It now has to provide services to that area.”
- alexey-salmin 2y ago
- Cheer2171 2y agoGood. I don't understand why speedometers go up to 130 mph. I don't know why Americans feel they have a God-given right to break the speed limit. If you aren't going 10-20 mph over the speed limit, you're not following the flow of traffic. I will be going the posted speed limit of 65 mph (and not in the far-left "fast lane") and have had so many insane aggressive drivers tailgate me and road rage. The de facto speed limit is always higher than the posted one. If they update the posted limit to match what is followed and enforced, then the de facto speed limit will increase. Laws that are on the books but rarely enforced is a recipe for abuse. It is unjust that I, as an immigrant to this country who can be deported if I commit crimes, have to violate the posted law in order to keep up with the flow of traffic. Edit: Actually, it looks like this just informs the driver that they are going over the speed limit. Not good. It needs to physically restrict the speed of the car.
- hooo 2y agoIs this satire? 10mph and over is usually with the flow of traffic. Many speed limits are artificially low and that’s why traffic flows faster.
- zdw 2y agotraffic flows faster because the roads widths and other affordances are designed for high speed, even on low speed roads. If you want people to go slower, make the roads/lanes narrower.
- Cheer2171 2y agoI am 100% serious. It is unjust that I, as an immigrant to this country who can be deported if I commit crimes, have to violate the posted law in order to keep up with the flow of traffic.
- quantified 2y agoI know quite a few people, and I was once one myself, who simply keep to the limit. You can assert your right to drive only the speed limit, you have that.
- austin-cheney 2y agoHorrible. Texas used to follow this belief too, that exceed speed was the primary cause of traffic accidents and so must be heavily enforced, but then reversed direction with positive results. The bad logic is as follows: Speed in excess of posted limits increases the probability of a traffic related accident. This is affirming the consequent in combination with an appeal to probability. The reality is that there are typically a multitude of variables responsible for traffic accidents, and so isolating and then blaming one of those variables in isolation results in a belief system that ignores evidence. The primary cause of most traffic accidents is driver inattention irrespective of their speed. A driver who is not paying sufficient attention and driving with excess speed is more dangerous still, but the primary factor there is still not the speed. Now instead of heavily enforcing speed limits aggressively everywhere, often as a money making venture for local municipalities, Texas police instead focus on more import aspects of criminal law and community service. Reckless driving is still just as heavily enforced however.
- mslate 2y agoI was with you until your assertion that enforcement is the answer. Copying Texas on traffic engineering is not a serious take: https://ftp.txdot.gov/pub/txdot-info/trf/trafficsafety/engineering/comparative-analysis.pdf https://ftp.txdot.gov/pub/txdot-info/trf/trafficsafety/engin...
- austin-cheney 2y agoThat is the opposite of what I said.
- droopyEyelids 2y agoIt seems like you’d want to address every one of the variables. If thats true wouldnt addressing an easy one of them be a way to start?
- quantified 2y agoTreating the most impactful ones is usually the best. The safest speed is zero, create that limit and no more accidents ever.
- spdustin 2y agoThree things missing so far from the discourse: 1. It all but eliminates plausible deniability for those fighting speeding tickets. 2. New drivers will certainly benefit from the additional alert, as they often have no idea they’re speeding. 3. The federal government has been moving in this direction for a while. It’s coming.
- backtoyoujim 2y agoThe speed limit was about gas consumption in a supply crisis. And it should be still about energy consumption.
- TulliusCicero 2y agoWhat? Do you just not care about safety at all or something?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- CalRobert 2y agoNot much but it’s a start. Unfortunately the US treats every street and road like it’s a country road when it comes to speed limits, with a lot of deaths as a result. Great video on this at https://youtu.be/bglWCuCMSWc?si=AseOYw8Lo7DKw0or https://youtu.be/bglWCuCMSWc?si=AseOYw8Lo7DKw0or
- andrewaylett 2y agoMy UK 2017 Ford has technology that achieves this functionality, albeit not switched on by default and therefore also not unable to be deactivated by the user. It's fine, I guess? The car has a camera that records speed limit signs as it passes, and shows the last speed it saw on the dashboard. I'm not sure if it's the camera or the built-in maps that allow it to distinguish between single carriageway and dual carriageway roads, which have different limits for the same signage, but it's pretty good at it. It does have GPS, but it doesn't seem to use it for limits in general driving -- that probably means it's insufficient for this law. One may set visible or audible announcements, or even update the cruise control limited, based on the current detected limit. The downside of using a camera, though, is that as good as it is at picking up the right limits (and it is good!) it struggles with advance warning signs and also with some junctions on corners where the limit changes if you turn off. On the other hand, if the audible reminder sounds when your speed goes above the limit then the obvious thing to do is to hit 85mph then not slow down and it won't bother you again :).
- rnrn 2y agoCalifornia government seems to be afflicted with a disorder in which they pass laws and add regulations to pretend to address problems without doing any of the basic things to improve governance and improve infrastructure that would obviously actually help address the problems. (e.g. enforce speed limits and distracted driving laws where they matter, not just on freeways) It’s the same thing with the new income-based adjustments to electricity rates, which “helps reduce the burden of utility payments” without doing anything to address the fact that California has the among the highest cost of electricity anywhere. I don’t think the legislators think about this or care, because look! they are “addressing the problems”. Will adding a require speeding bell in cars reduce car-related fatalities? Or just cause people to learn how to shut off or ignore the government-mandated bell?
- mulderc 2y agoWe do we allow cars to be sold that can go over the speed limit by such extreme amount? It seems like we have the technology to have cars automatically limit their speeds to the speed limit of the street they are on.
- whatindaheck 2y ago[dead]
- instagib 2y agoPassive limiter: a gps based speed detection for a “brief one-time” audible & visual warning if speed greater than 10mph over the highest posted “limit” by 2029 50% then adoption 100% in 2032.
- exabrial 2y agoCalifornia politics are already a meme. I just wish they would stay in California.
- harmmonica 2y agoTangential to this bill, wonder if anyone has predictions on how driving a car yourself vs taking a robotaxi (e.g.,Waymo) will play out over time (assuming autonomy doesn't get derailed due to risks in the tech or crippling regulation). I ride Waymo a bit these days and it's still surprising when the car comes to a complete stop at stop signs. I'm actually delighted by it and I say that as a fan of driving (and, candidly, speeding when I do) though certainly not on traffic-choked roads and freeways. If I could vote tomorrow, though, and everyone would drive as "thoughtfully" as a Waymo, I'd vote for it. That said, I can't see any politician in a red state like Texas, or even in many blue states, telling folks they have to give up driving themselves. Is it a foregone conclusion that if the tech does in fact survive this break-in period, that governments will stop people from driving? Will it have to be a hybrid forever in the name of "freedom"? A lot of ink has been spilt about this already on HN and elsewhere, of course, but always interested in the HN crowd's current view on this.
- alexey-salmin 2y agoI do worry about mandatory self-driving cars: e.g. if the government declares a curfew they won't go anywhere. However I do agree that self-driving would reduce mortality a lot, the question is whether the price is too high. This is in fact an interesting dilemma, not the trolley problem.
- harmmonica 2y agoGood point. So maybe the answer is some sort of quid pro quo. You're forcing me to give up driving myself? I'm forcing you, the government (through voting; cue laughter from the cynical gallery), to restrict what you're able to do to self-driving cars (need a warrant to force-stop, no en-masse disabling, etc.). I say that with a US-centric viewpoint, of course, because there's zero chance countless countries around the world be sensitive to their citizens' objections (questionable in the US as well of course, but not out of the question).