11 ms·
The Prophet Who Failed
- ggddv 2y ago[flagged]
- thsksbd 2y agoBecause we were explicitly told to be discerning. "For many will come in My name, saying, ‘I am the Christ,’ and will deceive many. " Mt 24-5 "Beware of false prophets, who come to you in sheep’s clothing, but inwardly they are ravenous wolves. 16 You will know them by their fruits." Mt 7-15
- RRWagner 2y agoan accusation can be a confession
- block_dagger 2y agoHow do you know the source of these quotes are authentic and true?
- kaonwarb 2y agoI don't think that matters to the observation being commented on, which is of the nature of "if one believes in X, it's surprising to me they won't also believe in Y."
- thsksbd 2y agoWho is Jesus? A vague reference in Josephus? A vague reference in the Talmud? If I don't believe in the Gospels there's not much Jesus left to believe in, is there?
- freshpretzels 2y agoThere is! There are extra-biblical mentions and deductions. But note that the value of the Bible is that it is already a great collection of varying sources on the matter conveniently pre-packaged into a single volume for all who wish to determine those details. Someone did the heavy lift of identifying the highest quality sources and putting them together in one compendium for all to eat and drink from its rich retellings.
- freshpretzels 2y agoThe only way to have trust in such a message is to experience truth in it. The Gospel gives an open invitation for all to read its claims and promises…and to put them to the test. However, be warned that an adventure awaits. Should you read the words and believe them with the smallest faith you can muster, the real-world consequences are stunning and vast and earth-shaking and beautiful. The journey with God is an adventure indeed.
- empath75 2y ago>The only way to have trust in such a message is to experience truth in it. You've basically just abandoned any kind of logical or grounded epistemology and replaced it with believing in whatever "feels right". Which, you know, you do you, but it just sort of abandons any pursuit of some underlying reality that we share. There's nothing really to discuss there and you could be talking about a belief that the moon is made of cheese, that the earth is flat, or that we should all follow Satan or anything else that "feels right" to whoever. It's funny that all the early church fathers and theologians made efforts to persuade people that the bible was true through logic and reason and evidence, but that was abandoned by the Church over time, as first people were forced to join the church on pain of death and damnation, and then later as any kind of logical or evidential argument for religion became untenable, people fell back on "well, you just have to choose to believe it if it feels good." Faith in the early church was not an argument for the existence of god, but was _predicated_ on the existence of God, a Christian was supposed to have faith that God, who you already believed in, had the world's best interests in mind. It was never meant to substitute for understanding the world through reason.
- freshpretzels 2y agoNothing I said excludes logic or evidence, or advocates believing in whatever “feels” right. I clearly said it’s about truth, and truth has to be determined with logic and evidence and first-order experience.
- amazingman 2y agoBut then why not be so discerning in one more context? OP's point still applies here IMO.
- MontagFTB 2y agoWho is to say Christians didn’t use their discernment to conclude that Jesus is who he claimed and did what was said of him?
- amazingman 2y agoAnyone paying even casual attention to the epistemology of Christians.
- bigstrat2003 2y agoI'll certainly admit lots of Christians have bad epistemology, because frankly lots of people do in general. But there are also lots of people who have thought about this very seriously, contrary to your claim.
- amazingman 2y agoI'm sure there are. But if they ended up confirming belief in a magic carpenter born of a virgin, then we're back to bad epistemology.
- freshpretzels 2y agoNot all contexts are equally valid or equally believable. Some of them disqualify themselves pretty quickly.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kirse 2y agoWhat happened to Jesus' disciples? >> https://i.redd.it/uvkz50fs3tn61.jpg https://i.redd.it/uvkz50fs3tn61.jpg
- hatenberg 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- empath75 2y agoI hope the reason nobody has responded to this yet is that they're giving this wonderful article the attention it deserves. I have a lot of thoughts about it, and this is one of the cases where I wish comment sections here weren't so ephemeral and stayed up long enough to be worth spending more time on it. All of us are facing a personal apocalypse. We all build an entire universe in our minds based on what our senses take in and that world is going to evaporate when you die, and the rest of the world will continue on just fine without us. For a lot of people, it feels better, for some reason, to think that we are so important that the rest of the universe will also cease to exist when we die. Aside from dreams of the world ending, another way to sort of assuage that dread that we all carry around with the knowledge of our own mortality is to lean into the intuitive belief that we are somehow non-physical entities that are merely contained in these physical bodies temporarily, and that some day we'll be released and go back into our true form. These two ideas often go together, but don't always. The neo-platonists, for example, believed in eternal non-physical bodies ascending to some kind of divinity after death, but didn't really have an 'end-of-the-world' prophecy. A lot of people reading an essay about this will think about this as an object lesson in gullibility and people failing to use reason, but there are a lot of so-called "rationalists" on this very website who themselves believe in a version of this -- that the world is soon going to face a technological apocalypse of some kind -- maybe it's a super-powerful AI escaping, or climate doom, or nuclear war, or whatever, and at the same time believing that they themselves will find a way to escape death, from mind-uploading, or life extension or something similar. Transumanism, extropianism, "effective altruism", a lot of those modern techno-utopian philosophies are just millenarian doomsday cults with a "scientific" technological gloss. I don't think there's anything especially "wrong" about the religion this essay is about. It's no crazier than Christianity was, which was also a religion built around a prophet whose apocalypse didn't arrive and who died unexpectedly. They had to build an (at times beautiful, at times ridiculous) tower of philosophical abstractions to retroactively make any of it make sense to them. On a completely unrelated tangent: If you read https://www.reddit.com/r/Superstonk/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Superstonk/ the subreddit for die hard Gamestop "investors", there's a lot of similarity between the way they talk about the "mother of all short squeezes" and the way the doomsday cults talk about the end of the world. There's a religious fervor to it that's sort of based around the idea that the modern economy is a house of cards and will completely collapse because of people shorting a retail video game store.
- personomas 2y ago"Elizabeth Prophet regarded American society as existing in a state of decay, comparing it to the last days of the Roman Empire." [0] She's definitely right about that one ^. A very slow decay, most visibly seen by its gradual fall of GDP and world influence. This is also paralleled by increasing social welfare over the years, which the church also rejected: "Elizabeth preached against socialism in all forms, seeing it as part of the global elite conspiracy's plot to control all facets of society. She instead emphasised a philosophy of individualism. Palmer and Abravanel characterised the Church's viewpoint as a 'conservative Republican stance'." [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Church_Universal_and_Triumphant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Church_Universal_and_Triumphan...
- personomas 2y agoNow on the other hand Trump has gone insane and is completely misleading the Republican party, but this a completely different matter...
- krapp 2y agoTrump only normalized beliefs already gaining ground within alt-right, neoconservative and fringe Evangelical ideology. His politics were just boilerplate Fox News/AM radio fare. Blame the Republican party for preferring to embrace and try to weaponize their lunatic fringe, and blame the other side rather than clean their own house.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- foogazi 2y agoWhat’s with this obsession with the Roman Empire ? This the British talk this way in the 18th century ?
- personomas 2y ago[dead]
- 2y ago
- tasty_freeze 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- api 2y agoThis cult and its predecessor, the I AM, are cornerstones of American fascism. It’s a deep dive worth doing. I AM toward its end even perpetuated stories remarkably similar to Qanon, in the 1930s. A fun fact too: General Nathan Flynn recited a very strange prayer at one of his gatherings. Turns out it’s a prayer from the Church Universal and Triumphant, this woman’s fascist cult. So there may be surviving ideological links today, or Flynn may be in a cult himself, or maybe whoever wrote it for him is. https://x.com/PiperK/status/1445663165186904065 https://x.com/PiperK/status/1445663165186904065 A lot of this stuff goes even further back to William Dudley Pelley and the Silver Shirts, an American fascist movement. Pelley and Edna Ballard, one of the founders of I AM, were associated. Wouldn’t be the first time cults tried to use rich or powerful followers to gain money or power for themselves. Look into Scientology.
- selimthegrim 2y agoMichael Flynn?
- api 2y agoYes. My mistake. I’m surprised people are low key defending these groups, even people on the right. This isn’t conservatism. It’s totalitarianism backed by new age woo. I guess I shouldn’t be that surprised. Totalitarianism is back in fashion lately. Feels like we want to LARP the early 20th century.
- lolinder 2y ago> even people on the right. Since I'm assuming that I'm one target of this as the only person to contradict you in this subthread, I just want to be clear: I'm not on the right. As far as the conservatives in my (very red) state are concerned I'm a flaming liberal. As for how I'd describe myself, I'm basically in the "we desperately need to reverse the trend of everyone assuming that anyone who disagrees with them is evil" camp, which is why I strongly object to casual comparisons to fascism. Using that word or the word "cult" to label someone immediately frees you from any obligation to engage with them as a person, and I'm not okay with that tendency from either wing of modern politics.
- Borrible 2y ago"The Sounds of American Doomsday Cults Vol. 14" sounds like a great CIA PsyOp piece.
- pessimizer 2y agoIt's a great record, and the chanting is impressive. The same people also put out a single for Aum Shinrikyo which was terrible (although the "A"[*] documentary and it's sequel are fascinating if you want to know what happened after their prophecy failed.) You can also hear the Church Universal and Triumphant on Negativland's Escape From Noise as "Michael Jackson," giving a lecture about the evils of pop music (also on Sounds of American Doomsday Cults.) [*] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_(1998_Japanese_film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_(1998_Japanese_film)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- drewcoo 2y agoIf that interests you, you might enjoy the weekly radio show Music of Mind Control on WFMU. Show's archives here: https://www.wfmu.org/playlists/MW https://www.wfmu.org/playlists/MW
- paulpauper 2y agoAre Harpers and The New Yorker in a battle to see who can write the longest article. It was easy to start a bullshit religion in the mid 20th century. No google/yelp, a huge population of credulous people before the post-90s cynicism set in, post-war prosperity and discretionary income, Cold War paranoia and the public's receptiveness to doomsday messaging, a willingness of public to trust authority figures or anyone who claimed to be one.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- smallerfish 2y agoEnjoyable article. Reminded me of the experience of keeping the faith in a startup after it's become clear that it's going nowhere - there's the pragmatic need to keep earning, of course, but also an unwillingness to overturn the social framework of your life, and perhaps a stubborn refusal to upset your strong conviction that you were on the bus to destination success. I met an ex-JW the other day who has become convinced that he is an extra-terrestrial volunteer, sent to earth in order to help stabilize human society, and that he's able to remotely converse with anybody through the aid of his physical paraphenalia. He was interesting to talk with; 100% convinced that his belief system was real; IANAP, but I wouldn't immediately lump him into any major DSM-5 category. I guess certain minds seek non-mainstream belief systems as a way of distinguishing themselves from the norm, or accounting for a deep feeling of being different, or not fitting in. Perhaps this too is somewhat endemic in the startup crowd; why work for a big firm when you have special capabilities, and can blaze your own trail?
- pessimizer 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gumby 2y ago> Reminded me of the experience of keeping the faith in a startup after it's become clear that it's going nowhere Ouch. So on-point.
- Simon_O_Rourke 2y agoHa! I'll raise you the woman I know who thinks Michael Jackson was the John the Baptist to Donald Trump's Christ! There's wrong, and then there's so-wrong-it-should-be-a-musical!
- calciphus 2y agoI've known more than a few ex-religious of varying types who in young adulthood have to find an explanation for why: - they are not at all who the faiths they were raised by said they should be - they know there's not actually anything wrong with themselves (or others like them), despite what their faith taught them Squaring these two deeply personal realizations is challenging. People take many paths. Your interaction is an outlier, but by no means the most extreme I've encountered.
- GlibMonkeyDeath 2y agoThis brings back memories of the 1980s. The Church Universal and Triumphant had posters plastered all over college campuses about their retreats. As I recall, according to the posters at said retreats one could "quaff potions created by Merlin" - yes, THAT Merlin from Arthurian legend. The posters also, incongruously, had this androgynous-looking image prominently displayed: https://store.summitlighthouse.org/images/thumbs/0000144_poster-saint-germain-sindelar~1403.jpeg https://store.summitlighthouse.org/images/thumbs/0000144_pos... I thought up until very recently that this was supposed to be an image of Elizabeth Clare Prophet (whose name I thought also was surely made-up), and always wondered why this woman had a mustache :)
- etc-hosts 2y agoSt Germaine !
- conradolandia 2y agoThat's the teosophic portrait of St. Germain
- RajT88 2y agoI am always amused by these doomsday cults predicting the end of the world. As long has there been human writing, people have been saying the end is nigh. Nobody has ever been right!
- WarOnPrivacy 2y ago> As long has there been human writing, people have been saying the end is nigh. Nobody has ever been right! You aren't wrong. I've been a Christian of some stripe, my whole life. Even general Armageddon predictions (soon!) are really dumb and I wish we would stop them. Besides being wrong, they're either a pointless distraction or they're counterproductive. Counterproductive because fear sucks as a long term motivator. Faiths have examples and our job as adherents is to strive to embody the example. That's it. The rest of the guff might be supportive if applied correctly. Mostly, we don't do that.
- kromem 2y agoYet
- wudangmonk 2y ago[flagged]
- nyokodo 2y ago> they fail to even register the bigger cults now called religions “They” don’t need to because there’s always some atheist in the comment section to make bigoted generalizations and make wild claims that are demonstrably nonsense, such as… > I truely believe that humanity has a greater chance of being destroyed by one of these death cults than anything else out there. Yes, because the explicitly atheist regimes that are right now and for the last 70+ years been arming themselves to the teeth with world destroying nuclear arsenals and adopting belligerent stances against the other nuclear powers are way down the list of probable harbingers of doomsday.
- FabHK 2y agoGiven that most prophets failed in one way or the other (in their prophecies, for example), the title is not very indicative of any one person.
- greentxt 2y agoSort of trashy and shallow, but a good writer makes themselves a part of the work, rather than posturing as purely objective. Ok style wise I guess. Interesingly, avoiding chocolate when pregnant is really good advice given, as has been posted here numerous times iinm, most commercially profuced chocolate contains lead and cadmium at toxic levels. Sometimes false prophets hit upon truth. Anyway, I suppose all of this is very reassuring to catholics. Not sure the author could see the bigger picture though. Seemed a bit petty and small minded with scattered humble brags like growing out of her little kierkegaard phase. Lol
- johnea 2y agotl;dr