5 ms·
JetBrains releases RustRover IDE for Rust development
- euW3EeBe 2y agoThe VSCode extension for Rust is quite good too, probably the best IDE like support for any language I've tried. I'm more excited for JetBrains Fleet than another standalone IDE at this point.
- banish-m4 2y agoI gave up on JetBrains because most of their language plugins are broken most of the time. VSCode plugins have a much larger user base and tend to work, and I don't need 9 different products. It's similar to what happened to Atom. The main downside of VSCode is Electron leaks memory like crazy and will use north of 150 GiB of RAM.
- gertop 2y agoI'm going to make a wild guess that you use macosx and that 150GiB isn't usage but addressed space. Macs are notorious for returning nonsense memory figures with some applications.
- banish-m4 2y agoNo, it was using 90+ GiB of swap. There is a difference between virtual address space and RSS.
- euW3EeBe 2y agoThat's a crazy amount of memory usage, it might be an extension doing it? VSCode has a process explorer tool you can access under `Help>Open Process Explorer`.
- banish-m4 2y agoYep. I should've last time but I will if/when it goes mad next time. I hadn't quit the process in about 2 weeks.
- kaba0 2y agoThat has not been my experience at all. VSCode is mostly just a code editor with plugins, while Intellij is a full-blown IDE.
- banish-m4 2y agoIncorrect and hairsplitting. It's a full IDE when you configure and use it properly. Meta uses a lightly-modified fork of it internally as their private IDE for internal use.
- landonxjames 2y agoI like rust-analyzer in VSCode, but I've found that it does seem to struggle with large projects that have multiple nested Cargo workspaces. IntelliJ with the Rust plugin has handled that (admittedly niche) case better so far. I still prefer VSCode though so I just open each workspace in an individual window and it works more or less as expected.
- juliusgeo 2y agoI’ve been using the pre-release version for a bit because I am a big fan of PyCharm. I found it very good besides the profiling interface. The “jump to source” option never works for some reason. Overall, though, provides a great experience.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- armchairhacker 2y agoShould probably link to the official announcement: https://blog.jetbrains.com/rust/2024/05/21/rustrover-is-released-and-includes-a-free-non-commercial-option/ https://blog.jetbrains.com/rust/2024/05/21/rustrover-is-rele.... Notably, there's a "free for non-commercial use" license that grants access to the entire RustRover IDE. There's also controversy because JetBrains removed JavaScript/TypeScript support from RustRover right before this release, admittedly because they want to keep these features gated behind a paid subscription in IntelliJ. That wouldn't normally be an issue, except the IntelliJ Rust plugin is deprecated and doesn't have the support that RustRover does; so there's currently no single IDE that fully supports Rust + web projects, even though JetBrains could easily make one, and even though people would be willing to pay for it. The end of the blog mentions "IntelliJ IDEA Ultimate will include support for the Rust plugin for free" so hopefully they are addressing this; if they re-package Rust support into into IntelliJ but only as a paid plugin I think that would make most people happy.
- calderwoodra 2y agoAre you mixing .rs and .js(x)/.ts(x) files in the same project? Jetbrains doesn't support multiple languages in any version of their IDE well AFAIK. I daily drive PyCharm and Webstorm in parallel.
- brainless 2y agoI think they are rethinking this in their new project, Fleet. But VS Code is so good at this that it sets a very high bar.
- MeImCounting 2y agoPrivacy concerns mean Ill not be using VS Code any time soon. JetBrains gets my business for that reason alone
- mlinhares 2y agoIt does, IntelliJ ultimate has multiple language support for quite a while now.
- brainless 2y agoI have been using RustRover on Arch Linux as my daily IDE for a few months but then I switched to Zed when they landed their Linux support. RustRover is definitely more feature complete but one of my wishes is to start following the development of a large Rust project as a I use it daily. Zed, or Lapce, or Helix or similar editors fit that very well along with being very usable. Still, I would highly recommend RustRover (or PyCharm which I have used a lot over the years).
- swlkr 2y agoI'm the same way, it's one of the reasons I use helix, even for non rust dev
- ilovecaching 2y agoReminder that neovim is completely free, you can modify the editor using Lua, it has a renaissance of new awesome plugins, LSP support for the official Rust LSP server, and as a system developer you can run it on a target device or quickly switch between a serial console and your editor using tmux. Plus, you can easily add new LLM integrations or wrap tools in about a half an hour of hacking. My neovim setup is easily 10x more productive than RustRover.
- gertop 2y agoReminder that RustRover is also free (for non commercial use) and doesn't require the user to read adv entire manual before they can use it.
- leoh 2y agoThis. But also just pay for your tools if you can. It’s the kind/empathetic thing to do, honors the hard work of others, and helps elevate the craft.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- __MatrixMan__ 2y ago10x is quite a claim. Anyhow helix is nice for most of the reasons that neovim is, and also because you spend more time coding and less time fiddling with your setup.
- eviks 2y ago"Most" by range, not by value, since plugins is the biggest reason, and they don't exist in helix
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoWell yes, but that's the point. I think it's analogous to zsh/fish, either you think that customizing is fun and you want to spend time doing it, or you want a nice set of features enabled by default and a minimal config footprint. Can't have both.
- rethab 2y agoI like the jetbrains products a lot and have been using IntelliJ as my main IDE for years. What I don’t like is their pricing with regards to multiple products. I use IntelliJ 95% of the time and pay for it. Sometimes, I’m writing some Python or C and would like to have a decent IDE as well, but then I immediately need to purchase the „all products pack“. I wish there was a cheaper option for occasional use of other IDEs. Right now I use the PyCharm community edition, but this feels a bit silly :) Hopefully Fleet will solve this.
- jatins 2y agois Fleet still being developed? I had a feeling it was dead given that Jetbrains has been pretty mum about it since the announcement couple years ago
- modernerd 2y agoThey’re still building it. There was a new version 3 days ago. https://blog.jetbrains.com/fleet/2024/05/fleet-1-35-is-out-introducing-ai-powered-multi-line-code-completion-for-python-and-kotlin-windows-arm-support-wildcards-multiple-ui-improvements/ https://blog.jetbrains.com/fleet/2024/05/fleet-1-35-is-out-i...
- vbezhenar 2y agoYou can use Python plugin for Idea. It's essentially the same as PyCharm, at least theoretically. No way to use C or C#, though. Those languages are outliers for some reason.
- justinclift 2y ago> then I immediately need to purchase the „all products pack“. Most languages are available in IntelliJ via Plugins rather than needing to download the separate language specific product.
- leoh 2y agoI’m baffled by this. Many folks spend thousands on hardware. JetBrains makes such exceptional tools, I don’t understand how a few hundred bucks for the complete product pack is unreasonable (with understandable exceptions for folks with limited income). This stuff isn’t free, it surprises me when fellow engineers are averse towards paying for great software that helps us build software.
- vishnugupta 2y agoHa, what coincidence. I installed the EAP (Early Access Program) edition only last week as I've been learning Rust.
- sli 2y agoI can't justify the cost currently but I'm really going to miss the RustRover EAP. Lovely editor.
- pkulak 2y agoI’m locked in to JetBrains for JVM stuff, but the language server is so good, using Neovim is an absolute pleasure for Rust.
- veber-alex 2y agoFYI the free version of RustRover has forced telemetry that cannot be disabled. "It’s also important to note that if you’re using a non-commercial license, you cannot opt out of the collection of anonymous usage statistics. This is similar to our Early Access Program (where statistics is opt-out) and in compliance with our Privacy Policy"
- leoh 2y ago/etc/hosts
- ysleepy 2y agoI don't think that can be GDPR compliant, personal data cannot be used as a form of or alternative to payment afaik.
- igor_akhmetov 2y agoIt's not personal, it's anonymous.
- ysleepy 2y agoI assume the telemetry data contains some sort of installation identifier and without hard evidence I will assume the IP address as well.
- anastasiak2512 2y agoAll our stat collection in the products is fully compliant with GDPR, it doesn't send any personal information and it's not possible to link to the specific user from it.
- ysleepy 2y agoFor the record, can you confirm that the telementry does not contain any sort of installation or system ID and the telemetry endpoint never at any point records the IP address? A lot of companies claim gdpr compliance while blatantly disregarding it. I think forcing telemetry on free users, after the AI debacle and recently having moved the headquarters out of moscow for trust reasons, leaves a bad taste.
- sureglymop 2y agoIt's alright. Good to have this option but I'd stick with neovim. Nothing really beats treesitter + LSP + completion + formatting and still being in vim. Just the other day I wrote a treesitter query to format and highlight JavaScript within HTML within a string in rust. And all it took was a few lines of lua and 10 minutes.
- leoh 2y ago> it’s alright Are you kidding me? Even with nixos, the loe for nvim if you want to get anywhere near parity with RustRover or any other Jetbrains product ime is formidable if not impossible. Unless I can do stuff like automatically generate all arms for match statements, refactor across files, debugger support, have ease of setup (among other things), I simply cannot accept this nvim/treesitter supremacy nonsense. Can it do all that? I mean easily? With consistent keybindings between languages I don’t have to reconfigure for each language? Without installing like 20 plugins?
- sureglymop 2y agoYes. Yes you can do all that with neovim (with under 20 plugins). Can you do it easily? If you're starting from 0 then no, probably not. Look, I am not knocking this IDE. I use these products too for certain tasks. Maybe my comparison wasn't fair because setting up neovim is basically programming lua and it is usually heavily personalized/individualized. What I really meant is, so far I don't see a killer feature yet that would get me to move from either neovim or also other editors with rust-analyzer to this.
- geggo98 2y agoIf you have the time, could you please post the list of plugins you are using?
- astkaasa 2y agorust r over, brilliant name
- timka 2y agoI think JetBrains is a virus. My folks can't do anything w/o it. They tend to just use what works out of the box and don't want to learn standard open source tools. No wonder after so man years they still suck at command line. Their IDE still can't do basic things like direnv and nix shell [1]. And when I rant about them being merging master into their feature branches instead of rebasing they say it doesn't matter since JetBrains paints such merges in gray. https://github.com/Fapiko/intellij-better-direnv/issues/27 https://github.com/Fapiko/intellij-better-direnv/issues/27