5 ms·
I have similar sentimental memories of ICQ. One highlight was being able to connect to it from my phone for the first time; first on my first smartphone (Symbi
by lxgr 2y ago
I have similar sentimental memories of ICQ.
One highlight was being able to connect to it from my phone for the first time; first on my first smartphone (Symbian), then from my "non-smart" Sony Ericsson that succeeded it, via some Java Jabber client and a Jabber-to-ICQ bridge! (Unfortunately nobody else that I knew had it on their phones, so I could only reach people in front of their PCs at home.)
On the other hand, it is and always has been unencrypted (not counting the OTR OTT encryption layer I've been using on it with the few friends that were also on Pidgin or Adium :), didn't support offline messages or even being logged in on more than one client, and was entirely proprietary (not sure if it was part of the "chat wars" [1] too).
Ultimately, the only constant in life is change. Instant messaging is alive and well on other platforms and networks today, let's remember ICQ fondly and be happy that we have so many good alternatives :)
[1] https://www.nplusonemag.com/issue-19/essays/chat-wars/ https://www.nplusonemag.com/issue-19/essays/chat-wars/
- semi 2y ago>(not sure if it was part of the "chat wars" [1] too). Kind of in that they were a good enough competitor that AOL bought them and AOL definitely continued to fight. I don't think they ever publicly integrated them but they did merge the back ends enough that for a while you could just login to AIM with an ICQ UID, and impress all your friends with your cool numeric aim account
- jmbwell 2y agoBeing reachable only from a PC at home… man. Now that I miss. The whole lifestyle of having a clear distinction between being at the computer and not. Status messages for a time when “away” was a state of being you ever were. Coming back to see whether your crush had messaged you. Simpler times for sure. Before we even had “wi-fi!”
- 101008 2y agoI started writing an essay about this topic. I am one of those nostalgics by the old internet. I thought it was the aesthetic (geocities, etc), but after giving it a lot of thought, that wasn't. It was that your life (all of us) was "offline by default". We lived offline and then we connect to the internet for a few minutes, hours, whatever. But you lived your life offline. We attended concerts, took photos, recorded videos, and then we took our time to share them online (maybe that same night, maybe the next days). You went online to discuss something that happened in real life. Now it's the reverse. We live "online by default". Everything happens online, all we do is first online or at least at the same time. We attend a concert? We publish pictures and videos almost instantly (some people even do a live stream from the concert!). Something happens in politics? People discuss it as it happens on Twitter, Facebook, etc. Going to the computer to connect to surf the web may sound silly, but that was the difference. Internet was inside a device you had to use. Now internet is happening around you all the time (and if you miss it for a few days, ouch!)
- hoyd 2y agoIs the essay somewhere online?
- 101008 2y agoNo, sorry, I never wrote it.
- lxgr 2y agoThe Internet being an opt-in thing that you'd consciously connect to at a set our of the day, not something that would reach out to you and notify you about all kinds of things at random times, was definitely a different feeling. Back then, it felt like a parallel world; now it's more like an overlay on this one.
- ComodoHacker 2y agoI guess AI is the next thing that's still opt-in now, will be opt-out tomorrow and then no-escape. It would be interesting to read a nostalgic thread from 2070...
- Karrot_Kream 2y agoThat's life isn't it? Mailing addresses, electricity, car-based transportation in the US, technologies and cultural institutions change and create worlds dependent on them to function. There was probably a time when the very idea that you stayed up after the sun set was seen as a silly modern affliction and indeed for most of human prehistory humans did not have access to artificial lighting. Now there are people, like me, who consider themselves as night owls.
- XorNot 2y agoThis is one of those things where I just don't understand what world people are living in, but it's always written in this bizarre passive voice where someone is just "the victim" of installing the Facebook app on their phone. What is your experience of your phone and why are you so passive about it? You're getting unwanted notifications but, then, what, don't uninstall the app? Don't mute the app? Don't click "sign out"?
- rkagerer 2y agoI love how you could set different Away statuses for distinct individuals / groups.
- andrewinardeer 2y agoDad picking up the phone while I was connected to my ISP via the 14.4kb modulater/demodulator and ruining my chat session. What a monster.
- Aeolun 2y ago> Being reachable only from a PC at home… You’d be reachable anywhere in the house, as the landline could start ringing with friends asking to play.
- philsnow 2y ago> Coming back to see whether your crush had messaged you. Reminds me of personal experience of course but also the "Less Than Three" video [0], which in turn reminds me of the GUNSHIP Art3mis & Parzival music video [1]. I'll probably never watch the Ready Player One movie again, but I'll likely watch the GUNSHIP video another 100x. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uQu71l1WQ3g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uQu71l1WQ3g [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WQaH3lh-CA4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WQaH3lh-CA4
- fullspectrumdev 2y agoI remember around 2007 or so a mobile provider here offered these “feature phones”, I think made by Huawei, that had zero rated MSN, Skype, and a couple of other services. Went from “only available when at the PC” to “always online” overnight. Got even funnier when someone worked out you could abuse the phone as a rather slow, but free, internet connection due to how poorly implemented the zero rating was done on those services :)
- toast0 2y ago> didn't support offline messages ICQ did support offline messages, from the beginning afaik, too. I had a 6-digit uin (485358 or something similar), until it got banned for running a bot (whoops). To the sibling reply, I think AIM and ICQ did have interop on messages at some point, it was much later than when ICQ moved protocols to OSCAR and TOK though.
- lxgr 2y agoOh, did I mix it up with MSN then, or maybe early Skype? Or did this possibly happen after the OSCAR migration? I vividly remember being amazed by offline delivery in Jabber, so at least one of ICQ or MSN must have not had it for me to even notice.
- toast0 2y agoI can't remember, but I don't think MSN had offline messages. And I don't think ICQ lost offline messaging in the OSCAR transition, IIRC, ICQ moved to OSCAR with offline messages, then AIM got them, then AIM and ICQ could talk for a while (but all my ICQ contacts that I kept had moved to AIM or MSN by then anyway). As I recall, originally, the ICQ client polled the server via UDP to see if it had any messages, and then you would do peer to peer for online messaging. But when you logged in, you'd get a cascade of the offline messages (uh, uh, uh, uh-oh)
- lxgr 2y agoWoah, ICQ had peer-to-peer? I thought it was quite centralized! Was that before the OSCAR migration? I only remember Skype being "true" peer-to-peer, with your PC randomly becoming a presence/call relaying "supernode" if you had a publicly reachable IP and good connectivity. Different times!
- toast0 2y agoYeah, ICQ was peer to peer for online messaging as I recall in the say 97-99 timeframe. I think Yahoo was too. They'd fall back to server message passing, of course. But this was just for messaging (and file transfer), not for presence/buddy list which was all server driven. In that time frame, few had firewalls or NAT or two computers at the same location, so (server mediated) peer to peer just worked unless you were on a corporate network.
- grishka 2y agoThe "proper" way of using ICQ from your phone was Jimm, an unofficial Java client. I was the cool kid with a patched Siemens phone, which could run native apps, so I used NatICQ.elf instead.
- lxgr 2y agoHaha, what Siemens phone could you patch to run native apps on? I must have switched to Nokia/Symbian before that became a thing. (That could run both native S60 and J2ME apps – basically infinite apps and games!)
- grishka 2y agoThe x65-x75 series ones, aka the "SGold" platform. I still have my CX75. That ELF loader patch was, without doubt, a pinnacle of patch engineering. My next phone was a Nokia 5800, one of the last Symbian ones.
- xp84 2y agoYour phone experience reminds me of how, at about age 18, I coveted a Sidekick so much. I knew that it had AIM built-in. Since SMS was too expensive for me to consider a replacement for instant messaging, this seemed to me like the holy grail of teen socializing. To be able to use AIM anytime, anywhere...I could only imagine how cool it would be, especially if all my friends had it too. I finally got something exactly like that in 2008 (both with mobile AIM clients, and as SMS and iMessage steadily overtook AIM for the purposes we used IM for), but it strikes me as poignant that as an adult, it wasn't really as meaningful to me as it would have been as a teen. I guess what I'm saying is actually, I kind of get why the gen-z kids became so terminally online. I would have availed myself of the ability to socialize, privately, nonstop day and night!
- dunham 2y agoDecades ago there was encryption that one of those clients (maybe pidgin) layered on top of AIM. It used 128-bit blowfish for the cipher, but the key was negotiated with 128-bit diffie hellman, which killed the security. I started to implement the number field sieve to demonstrate this, but got lost in the weeds and moved on to other stuff.
- shmoe 2y agoI was ICQ'ing my buds from a Motorola Talkabout 2-way pager for a bit there :) Memories...
- pbj1968 2y agoNah, dawg, ICQ supported offline messages and AIM didn’t.