4 ms·
Yes. The last war China was involved in was the relatively small Sino-Vietnamese war in 1979. And the last one before that was WW2. It would be hard to count
by eru 2y ago
Yes.
The last war China was involved in was the relatively small Sino-Vietnamese war in 1979. And the last one before that was WW2.
It would be hard to count all the wars the US involved themselves in during that time.
However, with regards to China Americans seem to be mostly worried about Taiwan. Taiwan is a lot closer to the coast of the PRC than it is to the coast of the US. (On the other hand, the people living in Taiwan are even closer to Taiwan than the PRC is. And they would certainly enter the fray, too.)
- MaxPock 2y agoFunny how you forgot the Korean war and how Chinese entry ensured a stalemate
- eru 2y agoSorry, yes, you are right. However, that was before the Sino-Vietnamese war. So the point about their last war being almost half a century ago still stands.
- gonzo41 2y agoFor China to take Taiwan, it would represent China doing the most complex surprise invasion that even the US military couldn't probably pull off. Assaulting a beach head is up there as possible the most difficult thing you can do. In WW2 the Allies got lucky because, Radar, Missiles, and drones didn't exist yet. Taiwan has stacks of weapons, enough to repel and invasion and they also have, jungles, mountains and cities to extend the fighting into.
- ramblenode 2y agoChina doesn't need to take a beach in the first phase. If they gain sea superiority, they can blockade the island and eventually exhaust anti-air defenses with drones until they gain air superiority. At that point defenders wouldn't be able to mass to defend a beach.
- maxglute 2y agoBingo, PRC is not going to start amphib ops until TW has minimal weapons that can repel invasion left. They're not stupidly charging into a Normandy because they have magnitude more radars, missiles, drones etc, enough to make sure TW won't have much of theirs for long. TW is an island 16x smaller than UKR, much larger gap in MiC production vs PRC than UKR vs RU, and unabled to be resupplied via porous land borded by friendlies. TW also thoroughly covered by PRC ISR, including SAR to look through foliage, nearly every inch of which can be hit within 7 minutes with PRC rocketry. Less once PRC establishes persistent drone presence. It's why all the recent analysis depends on TW buying enough time for US+co to enter picture. The flip side of a contested amphib operation is an uncontested one, which is potentially siginifantly easier than land invasion because there's no where for defenders to hide / ambush. Crossing a shallow strait where subs can't hide is probably easier than US plowing through Iraqi desert where defenders can at least pretend to put up defense by entrenching tanks / digging trenches. It's basically untested sailing if PRC destroys TW platforms that can hit back and lock down with air supremacy. Also folks should look up TW river map, TW island is broken up into a series of bastions cut up by rivers where connections / bridges can be severed and sections attacked piece meal. If PRC's smart, they'll destroy most of TW weapon platforms that can reach out into water, bombard a few km of map squares of landing site to dust, have drones shoot everything that moves 5km out to carve a landing zone that can't be contested by large or small fires. If PRC smarter, they'd just blockade TW until world realize the only country with enough sealift to supply an island of 24m with food and water is PRC. As for taking urban centres, look at how Israel is doing in Gaza with 20x population density than TW, theoretically urban combat is suppose to be slaughter vs attacker but if you indiscrimantly bomb and starve the population until they can't put up organized high end fight, then it becomes a managable problem. And again if PRC smart and they have to land boots on ground, they'd likely just siege from outside urban centres and small fires range, and wait for factional struggle and find collaborators willing to do boots on ground enforcement in return for controlling food + water.
- DeathArrow 2y agoI think China won't attack soon. It seems they play a long time game vs Taiwan, where they try to bring Taiwan, closer, weeken it's ties to its allies and slowly making Taiwan to become more dependent on China. China is convinced they will get Taiwan back and whether that happens in 20,50 or 100 years, that is good enough. At least until China builds a self sufficient semiconductor industry, I don't think they are going to attack Taiwan.
- eru 2y agoYour argument proves at most that attacking Taiwan is a bad idea. Alas, as we've seen with Russia's attack on Ukraine, something being a bad idea and unlikely to succeed is not enough to declare it impossible.