7 ms·
Dehydration associated with poorer performance on attention tasks among adults
- jonahbenton 2y agoThis very much happens to me. What has been so odd about understanding it is that I don't detect the sustained attention problem as dehydration or thirst. I detect it as hunger or a general malaise, a need to be woken up, for which the answer can feel like- should consume caffeine. Neither food nor caffeine help. If my system 2 is able to intercept this processing and logically hypothesize- try plain water first- after starting to drink water I then realize I am very thirsty, and will consume 24-32 oz very quickly. Afterwards I feel great, re-energized. But my body/autonomous system 1 still hasn't learned this, and it has now been a few years since first making this realization. So odd.
- retrac 2y agoSimilar for me. It feels like hunger, or sleep deprivation. I think it's detected by system 2, from an awareness of cognition not being great, in general. It's like a touch of delirium. Hunger as a response to mild dehydration makes sense though. We get a significant proportion of our water intake from food. That instinct doesn't work quite as well in our engineered era of potato chips, but that's a recent problem.
- theGnuMe 2y agoSame experience here. Now that I know I will be drinking more water.
- hnick 2y ago> Hunger as a response to mild dehydration makes sense though. We get a significant proportion of our water intake from food. This is truer than I used to think. Our dogs are mostly on a raw diet - some days I don't even see the older one drink water, or just once (the younger one is still an idiot puppy so runs around and goes to the toilet a lot more and has to top up). When we look after dogs on a kibble diet, it's amazing how much they drink in comparison.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> I don't detect the sustained attention problem as dehydration or thirst. I detect it as hunger or a general malaise So I have trouble differentiating these. The trick is to figure out which ones you're least susceptible to. For me it's hunger. So when I consciously feel that tired/hungry/thirsty feeling, I know it's sleep or thirst, and based on how you slept, you can usually deduce whether you need a nap or glass of water.
- the_hoffa 2y agoOne of the first things you learn in survival training is the difference between hunger and thirst. Most of the time when your stomach starts to "grumble" you might be surprised how often it's thirst and not hunger. Personally I wake up and I feel "starving", but the reality is that I'm just really thirsty because I haven't had any water for 6-8 hours. You can go weeks without food, but typically can only last a day or two at a absolute maximum without water.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoEasily one of the nicest part of wfh is the frictionless bathroom experience. No long walks. No mess, no smells or grunts from others. No trying to find time to even do it at all, just up and go. As a heavy water drinker I could easily be going once an hour. The office was literal torture some days, stuck in ‘important’ meetings with what feels like a knife in your gut and practically running out before small talk ropes you in for another 20 minutes. It’s a certain kind of hell for sure.
- bamboozled 2y agoI used to have a 1L water bottle and I asked my manager for a water cooler, which had a bunch of benefits, it was never as dramatic as you make it sound.
- plasma_beam 2y agoOn the flip side, when you get up and go off camera or turn camera off in a small video call (few participants), it feels awkward to get up and leave and I usually hold it and suffer through it. In person for some reason it felt less awkward to excuse yourself for a few minutes. Not to mention I always leave the airpods in when I go now and have to triple check I’m on mute :)
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoIn a pinch like that I'll just put "brb" in the chat, turn off mic and camera, and take the laptop with me.
- lynndotpy 2y agoI have a five-step ritual. 1. Mute myself. 2. Double check I am muted. 3. Ask, "Can anyone hear me?" 4. Ask, "Can anyone hear me?" again, louder. 5. State, "I'm about to urinate." Increasingly embarrassing failsafes, but not as embarrassing as broadcasting a bathroom break. I'm happy that I never needed anything past layer 2.
- mordechai9000 2y ago
- anon291 2y agoYeah I noticed I was tired in the afternoon and then not tired after dinner. It was because I wasn't drinking water.
- dylan604 2y agoI had a kidney stone, and in the follow up with the doctor, it was obvious I was not getting enough fluid intake. After an additional follow up, there was a profound difference after following the doc's advice of increasing fluid intake. It wasn't specifically increase water or decrease anything else so it was easy to do after become aware of it. Now, I can definitely tell when I haven't had enough. I used to think it was hangry, but I now can tell the difference.
- ImPostingOnHN 2y agoYeah, imagine if an ICE car made all its fluids from one other fluid, and that other fluid ran dry.
- anon291 2y agoYeah I also noticed that fluid intake reduced my food consumption. I was eating to get water.
- n8henrie 2y agoNon-interventional study design. Hydration measured by osmolality. I wonder if other factors like glucose level could affect both osmolality and cognition? Would be much more interesting as a randomized trial (though I'm not sure what would make a good placebo intervention as a control).
- 8372049 2y agoIt's worth emphasizing, which they also do, that this primarily affects middle-aged to older people, and "extreme" conditions. There is no benefit to "stay hydrated" beyond not being dehydrated and in fact it can be somewhat harmful to drink too much water. If you are middle aged or above, if you are in an excessively warm or cold climate, if you do great physical exertion etc. you may need to be mindful of your water intake and make sure you drink enough (and not too much), but generally your body will regulate this through the sense of thirst. Obviously being too focused on your work can also mean you neglect said thirst, so frequent breaks are healthy for several reasons.
- Carrok 2y agoYou would have to try VERY hard to drink too much water. Every one of all ages can benefit from staying hydrated.
- bongodongobob 2y agoThe point is that the 8 glasses of water a day thing is bullshit. I see people carrying giant jugs of water around all the time and people commenting on basically forcing this on themselves. Drink when you're thirsty. That's all you need to do.
- Carrok 2y agoI live a mile in elevation, if I wait till I am thirsty to drink, my hands turn to ash, my voice gets coarse, and my brain turns to mush. Not everyone has the same needs. Don’t worry about anyone else drinking too much water please.
- 8372049 2y agoYour specific circumstances don't change the general rule, which is that for most people and under most conditions, hydration status is correctly balanced by thirst. There are indeed exceptions, such as when getting older, which I addressed in my initial comment.
- mzarate06 2y agoOne of the best moves wrt nutrition, fitness, and productivity I've made the last couple years is adding electrolytes to my supplement stack. I've always been deliberate about having sufficient water intake, but supplementing electrolytes on top of that made a small, but noticeable, difference. I take a small amount by pill w/each meal (along w/a multi-vitamin, etc.), and via powder form in my water or beverage once a day. I feel more refreshed and focused while at work or at the gym, and I no longer experience muscle cramps (I never had them frequently, but being deliberate about electrolyte intake has removed them entirely). So, while the study focused on 'hydration', it's worth remembering that doesn't comprise of water intake alone. My performance and focus on sufficient water intake, while ok, felt inferior compared to sufficient water intake + electrolyte supplementation.
- jairuhme 2y agoAny brands/products you recommend? I've done Liquid IV, but they can get costly and not sure if its just because they are a brand name at this point
- IAmGraydon 2y agoMake your own. Look up oral rehydration solution. Use the newer formula. You can buy the ingredients on Amazon as bulk powder.
- canucktrash669 2y agoAll great till the last line. Given fakes and product commingling, I’d be careful about ingesting anything bought there.
- IAmGraydon 2y agoOk fair enough. Certainly you should be careful when sourcing.
- firloop 2y agoI like Nuun a lot
- DantesKite 2y agoAnecdotally I've noticed adding electrolytes seems to help reduce the incidence of headaches and possibly migraines, at least according to what my family members say. n=2
- jairuhme 2y agoTwo people I work with have said the same thing, so feel free to use n=4 going forward
- sakesun 2y agoShould we avoid coffee ?
- reducesuffering 2y agoCoffee is less hydrating than water, not dehydrating. People think coffee = caffeine = dehydration, ignoring the 8-20oz. of water they're consuming.
- CuriousCosmic 2y agoThe issue is that caffeine is a mild diuretic and depending on your caffeine sensitivity and other factors, that may have a more outsized effect on you in terms of fluid loss than the water you consumed with it. So if you drink a dilute coffee (ex: weak iced milk base coffee drinks), you are probably fine but if you are drinking plain, hot coffee or low milk espresso drinks and you are sensitive to caffeine's diuretic properties, you are probably going to lose more than you gain.
- reducesuffering 2y ago> you are probably going to lose more than you gain. There isn’t any science to support that. Feel free to only drink hot coffee for 3 days and see if you die of dehydration… Maybe you even think it's 2 days since hot coffee is even worse for hydration than nothing, apparently...
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- CuriousCosmic 2y agoNot necessarily. Just make sure that you aren't only drinking coffee. Things kind of differ for everyone but I find that matching my drinks helps. If I drink a mug of coffee, I drink a tall glass of plain water. That seems to be pretty effective.
- bevan 2y agoThere’s a Huberman Lab for that: https://youtu.be/at37Y8rKDlA https://youtu.be/at37Y8rKDlA He cites more evidence showing that even moderate dehydration (when you aren’t thirsty) leads to lower performance (mental and physical). And talks about overhydration and hyponatremia. IIRC also discusses how hydrating at different times of day affects you, turns out your kidneys dump water quickly if you drink too late. So hydrate before six.
- nikitay 2y agoTry out https://takesip.com/ https://takesip.com/ app for macOS. Find out your recommended level of water intake: https://takesip.com/calculator/ https://takesip.com/calculator/. Cheers.