8 ms·
Which of the Basic Assumptions of Modern Physics are Wrong?
- raverbashing 14y agoThe real problem is testing 'theories merging' There are several areas where relativity and quantum mechanics merged, for example, in the discovery and theory of antimatter But most of the experiments of relativity were on 'big things' like planets, and quantum mechanics on 'small things' And between them, the real mystery: gravity. General relativity knows a lot about what gravity does but not so much about where it comes from Edit: fixed GR for SR
- iskander 14y agos/Special relativity/General relativity Special relativity ignores gravity altogether, whereas general relativity sneaks gravity into the relativistic framework by equating it with curvature. Both theories are, to me, frustratingly intangible. Like you said, we don't really know where gravity comes from. Really, we don't even have any sort of good intuitions for how to describe what it is. Stuff resists being shoved around. Stuff also attracts other stuff to itself. Einstein tells us these are both symptoms of stuff being curvature. It's all a bit too abstract for my taste (that is, I hope a more tangible/intuitive model will eventually win out). Field equations are predictive but not really descriptive. Is there a mechanism in there somewhere?
- raverbashing 14y agoOops, true! I mixed GR and SR
- klodolph 14y agoThe problem with tangible/intuitive models is that our sense of what is tangible/intuitive is based primarily on our millions of years living in the Newtonian realm of the universe.
- chii 14y ago> Both theories are, to me, frustratingly intangible Yes, and it is frustrating. However, like you, a lot of laymen assumes that these theories can be explained in terms of analogies with "everyday life" things. I recently watched all of Richard Feynmen's lectures (the easiest to understand is "the character of physical law" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Character_of_Physical_Law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Character_of_Physical_Law),and in it, he explained, quite well, what it means to have a mathematical law. It goes on to some detail explanation of what quantum chromodynamics is, and how photons' behaviour cannot possibly be analogous to anything you can experience at the macro scale. I understand your frustration (since i feel the exact same) - why is it that we have advanced so much, and yet still have no idea what inertia really is? Or mass for that matter. We know how to predict things from using various mathematical laws, but i think we are no closer to understanding "the truth", than 100 years ago. Perhaps it is impossible. or perhaps, in the next century, or the next millenium, humans will look back, and see today's physics being just as primative as what we would see the cavemen's theories of the world is.
- morpher 14y agoBe careful not to conflate special (SR) and general relativity (GR). SR has nothing to say about gravity, and, as you point out, has already been successfully merged with Quantum mechanics to form relativistic quantum field theory (Dirac's early versions of which led to the proposal of antimatter). It is GR that describes "what gravity does", and which is difficult to enmesh with quantum mechanics.
- fidotron 14y agoI think it's fairly simple in that the overwhelming majority of people (including most physicists) haven't got an intuitive grasp of exactly how relativity works. This possibly includes Einstein. It wouldn't surprise me one bit to find out that the basic assumptions are not flawed at all, but that whole piles of stuff is being assumed in proofs regarding expected consequences of these things which prove to be complete nonsense. The other aspect of it is mathematics itself, which is probably not up to the task.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- genwin 14y agoI'm convinced that even if someone did prove that a basic assumption of modern physics is wrong, it would automatically be assumed in turn that the author is a crackpot, hence the work can be ignored. I'm convinced that the physics community isn't interested in the slightest in new ideas. Of course I'm automatically a crackpot (even beyond a conspiracy theorist) for even suggesting that. As an example to how bad things have become in the realm of physics, it's safe to say that the vast majority of thinking adults believe that black holes exist, because so much major media has told them so. But when you look deeper you find that there's no definitive evidence. Sites like the Chandra X-Ray Observatory admit that, deep in their FAQ, but in words that many people can misconstrue as a technicality. When I point out in physics discussions that that there's no definitive evidence of black holes, I'm automatically labeled a crackpot, especially by the working physicists. One of my books suggests that this is a grant problem, as in black holes bring in a lot of grant money, so physicists must be careful to pretend that black holes are a definite reality in nature.
- aaronbrethorst 14y agoreference?
- daeken 14y agoI think the problem here is that you're conflating the absence of evidence with the evidence of absence. There's definitely no definitive evidence for the existence of black holes, but (as far as I know) we have no evidence that contradicts current models. Science works by coming up with a nullifiable hypothesis, then seeing how it holds up as evidence is gathered. When you see contradictions, you adapt your model. I think you're missing the middle step, where you see contradictions.
- 2muchcoffeeman 14y agoNot to mention that "black hole" and "dark matter" are sort of place holder names that end up sticking. These phenomena are also attempts to fix the old model because they didn't produce the correct predictions. Physicists are doing exactly what the OP would like them to do. Paradigm shifts are also very hard. Your current models predict a lot of things very very accurately. Just look at all the stuff we've built. A new model has a lot to live up to if we want to use it.
- iRobot 14y agoWhich of the Basic Assumptions of Modern Physics are Wrong? As a Sci-Fi fan, "Nothing can travel faster than the speed of light" would be a nice one to be wrong
- planetguy 14y agoUnfortunately the universe doesn't care about what you'd like.
- Cushman 14y agoFor what it's worth, it's not "Nothing can travel faster than the speed of light" so much as "Moving faster than light is a concept which makes no sense physically."
- Mz 14y agoYour comment looks kind of greyed out. I may have accidentally downvoted you while trying to click on your name. Sorry 'bout that.
- liber8 14y agoI'm sure this theory will be proven to be not entirely correct someday. As a corollary, I expect that e=mc^2 will also be slightly modified.
- busted 14y agoI don't know from what background you're making that statement but in general it's good for people to know that E=mc^2 only when the object is at rest, otherwise you must account for momentum. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass%E2%80%93energy_equivalence#Applicability_of_the_strict_mass.E2.80.93energy_equivalence_formula.2C_E_.3D_mc.C2.B2 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass%E2%80%93energy_equivalence...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jarek-foksa 14y agoPardon the silly question, but what is the actual meaning of "right" and "wrong" in physics? I would expect a model which works in all possible conditions to be right, but clasical physics breaks when you reach the speed of light or atom level scales. Also, my intuition tells me that there can't be two completly different models that are describing the same thing and both of them are right, but we have e.g. definition of light as EMV and as a stream of particles. So it's enough for physical model to work only in specified conditions to be considered right, but "Basic Assumptions of Modern Physics" must be ultimately right (must work in all possible conditions)?
- davyjones 14y agoSomehow, I suspect that we are missing a dimension or two altogether and that will 'fix' most of our shortcomings in understanding the Universe.
- rdtsc 14y agoIsn't that the running joke with string theorists -- if stuff doesn't work out, add another dimension.
- pwang 14y agoWave-particle duality is nonsensical. It certainly makes a lot less sense than "there is an as-yet unknown kind of medium that supports the propagation of waves".