5 ms·
Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low
- alephnerd 2y ago> Countries including Germany and Sweden have ceased or dialed back EV subsidies in recent months, which has put a damper on Europe’s sales growth. > Manufacturers including Volkswagen AG and Mercedes-Benz Group AG have meanwhile been rethinking product plans, with VW preparing more plug-in hybrids and Mercedes keeping combustion cars in production well into the 2030s. Seems like max demand for EVs have been hit in Western Europe much like the US. I'd be curious what is going on in the mind of an EV PM targeting the European market. Edit: Was wrong. It grew 14% as bryanlarsen below mentioned I'd recommend taking a look at the Industry data used in the article - https://www.acea.auto/pc-registrations/new-car-registrations-13-7-in-april-2024-battery-electric-11-9-market-share/ https://www.acea.auto/pc-registrations/new-car-registrations... Much of the growth seems to be driven numerically speaking by the Spanish and German markets. In Spain, that growth seems to be mostly caused by Tesla [0]. MG and Volvo XC30 (Geely) make a showing, but the Model Y sold more in a month than both combined. [0] - https://alternative-fuels-observatory.ec.europa.eu/general-information/news/spain-has-11-plugin-vehicle-share-new-monthly-market-share-report https://alternative-fuels-observatory.ec.europa.eu/general-i...
- bryanlarsen 2y ago> Seems like max demand for EVs have been hit in Western Europe much like the US. EV sales are up 14%, according to the article.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoI wish they had data on which models were sold. Maybe we would see something relating to cheaper and smaller EVs?
- ska 2y agoCould be some Tesla fatigue too, showing up in these particular numbers.
- rekoil 2y agoDollars to donuts it's Chinese brands like MG, BYD, Nio, Zeekr, etc. taking most of the recent sales, they're just so much cheaper.
- Hamuko 2y agoVolvo too. I've been seeing the Volvo EX30 a lot recently, possibly because it offers 337 km of range and whatever people see in crossovers for 36 900€ whereas Tesla will charge you about 9100€ more for the cheapest Model Y. And if you go for the extended range model, you still get it for less than the Model Y, with like 20 km more to boot.
- rsynnott 2y agoI suspect also a _lot_ of id.3s and 4s, and Hyundais. Anecdotally, in Dublin, when I see a newly-registered electric car these days (Irish number plates have the year of registration as part of the number), nine times out of 10 it's either a Hyundai/Kia, or some sort of VW. That said, I think BYD was pretty late to get a right-hand drive model on the market, so they may be underrepresented here.
- wood_spirit 2y agoA few years ago Teslas were common but pretty much the only electric cars you’d see on the Swedish roads. And their build quality reputation wasn’t stellar. Nowadays there are far more other brands of electric car on the roads. Kia are perhaps the most common, and not-previously-heard-of Chinese brands are starting to appear. I think Elons own not-a-nice-person story also hurts Tesla.
- soperj 2y agodemand at that price point anyway.
- have_faith 2y ago> Seems like max demand for EVs have been hit in Western Europe much like the US. * Based on current prices / range / charging infra rollout, etc. I think range has gotten to an acceptable place for most people's anxieties (still progress to make of course), price is coming down with the cars coming out in the next year or two but infra investment feels like it's dragging things down a bit. Particularly where I live in the north of the UK anyway.
- pclmulqdq 2y agoThe biggest problems for me (and I suspect a large number of people) are charging rate and battery endurance. On long drives, waiting 30 minutes at a supercharger is not my idea of fun. At the same time, losing battery capacity from parking in the cold or using the aforementioned supercharger will also make things bad. I live in the Northeast US, which has a very high density of EV chargers per unit area, so actual charger availability is pretty damn good. In other words, I wouldn't put a lot of hopes on more infrastructure adding more adopters.
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoIt's good to see that many manufacturers are reconsidering their views on plugin hybrids. There are tons of people who like the idea of EVS but who won't by them because they're not practical based on range limitations or charging infrastructure that isn't sufficient for their needs. PHEVs are ideal for a lot of these folks, and I think the industry realized they tried to "skip over" that option too quickly.
- coldpie 2y ago> There are tons of people who like the idea of EVS but who won't by them because they're not practical based on range limitations or charging infrastructure that isn't sufficient for their needs. Anyone thinking like that is using outdated information. Current EVs have sufficient range for effectively all but the very most extreme use cases. Charging infrastructure could be better, and will rapidly become better, but it is sufficient now if you have access to a plug overnight and don't go on weekly long-distance road trips, which covers a lot of people.
- hn_throwaway_99 2y ago> Anyone thinking like that is using outdated information. No, it just means people have different personal situations. I have a friend who was excited to get an F-150 Lightning, and ended up selling it because it was not practical - he needed to take it places in rural areas where he lived where there wasn't sufficient charging infrastructure. I'm a huge EV fan, but I hate it when people say that an EV won't work for them and the response from other people is essentially "you're holding it wrong". For a lot of folks, even if they only take a trip, say, every 3 months where an EV wouldn't be a good option, it still means they would never consider getting an EV. As for charging infrastructure getting better all the time, I agree, but that's not something I would factor into a buying decision today, especially if I travel places that would be in the "long tail" of getting sufficient charging stations.
- asadotzler 2y agoThe average commute in this country is ~40 miles which is easily covered with weekly charging on 60-70 mWh battery packs. A typical $30,000 EV (matching the average price of US ICE sedans and hatchbacks) with those sized batteries today gets 260 miles on a full charge or about 200 miles driving it down to 20%. So half the country today could charge weekly or less and commute just fine with an EV that costs the same as an ICE, even if they live in apartments with no charging infrastructure, even if their town or city has little to no public charging infrastructure, and it's cheaper than ICE for most of them who have some access to cheap charging, like home charging or work charging. That's the tipping point, half can have their needs met with today's tech at today's prices. Most others could get by but they might have some slightly higher burden in charge times or vehicle price, especially outliers with very long commutes to and from locations with no good infrastructure. For example a truck driving construction contractor in a rural home commuting to a new subdivision under development also in a rural area but 65 miles away has a 130 mile daily commute and his truck has a 150 mile range from 80% to 20% so he has to charge daily, either at home, or at the construction site. Hopefully being rural he's in a house and not an apartment building so can charge overnight, but if he lives in a suburb that's pretty rural and has no charging at home, he's kinda screwed. Or, if he's gotta carry 20 bags of cement mix in the bed or tow a trailer, then he's gotta charge at home and maybe also at the construction site to even finish the commute. So, for some rural construction workers, EVs may not quite be the optimal solution (yet.) But most people, yes, they're holding it wrong. They're holding their 20th century car notions in 2024, where we're now decade before ICE cars get phased out in the US and as we're on a clear trajectory toward enough range and infra for no one to care just like no one cares about ICE cars and the gas stations they visit weekly.
- coffeebeqn 2y agoIt seems like other manufacturers have caught up to Tesla. There’s a lot of choice in EVs in Europe and Tesla doesn’t really outshine them in any way I can see. And the Chinese cars have not really arrived yet which will be a huge change in price
- alephnerd 2y agoBased on the numbers I found, it looks like the slowdown happened somewhat in Germany because EV bonuses have ended, so people are migrated towards cheaper Mercedes or BMW PHEVs versus how pricy a Tesla is in Germany.
- copx 2y ago>Seems like max demand for EVs have been hit in Western Europe much like the US. Given that the EU wants to straight up ban combustion engine cars in future [1] I doubt that. [1] https://www.europarl.europa.eu/topics/en/article/20221019STO44572/eu-ban-on-sale-of-new-petrol-and-diesel-cars-from-2035-explained https://www.europarl.europa.eu/topics/en/article/20221019STO...
- pptr 2y agoJust because the EU wants to ban gas cars in the future doesn't mean there is demand for EVs today. It's called an unpopular decision.
- asadotzler 2y agoCalifornia and most of the US will ban the sale of ICE vehicles in just over 10 years.
- bdcravens 2y agoPerhaps that's due to waiting for the refreshed Y?
- thebruce87m 2y agoProbably. There are so many Model Ys on the road. I’m glad I went for red as they are a bit more unique.
- atemerev 2y agoThe market has saturated probably. I look out of the window and I see Model 3s everywhere. I bought one this year, too.
- tinyhouse 2y agoAre you serious? In Norway maybe. EV has just started in most places. Most people still drive gasoline / hybrid cars. It's just that most car manufactures have EV cars right now and infrastructure is getting better for non-Tesla, so much better deals out there. Tesla doesn't even look good anymore compare to a lot of the new EVs our there from Rivian, Hyndai, Volvo, Honda, Lucid, etc. Tesla keep lowering prices cause they have no other choice.
- dangus 2y agoI agree with the comment parent to yours that the market is saturated under the condition that the size and quality of the US charging network doesn’t increase greatly. Only EV early adopters want to sit in Walmart parking lots for half an hour charging. The rest of us want to see mainstream truck stops have chargers that have us in and out in 15 minutes.
- coldpie 2y ago> Only EV early adopters want to sit in Walmart parking lots for half an hour charging. You only need to do that on road trips, which aren't all that frequent for most people. It's not a reason to avoid buying an EV. At home, you just charge it overnight at your wall outlet. Yes, I know, not everyone has access to a wall outlet overnight, but lots of people do. EVs are ready for them right now.
- atemerev 2y agoIt is not a good idea to buy a car in most European cities if you only use it for commuting. We have working public transportation for that. So, you buy a car if you want road trips. There are exactly two fast charging networks in Europe: Tesla Superchargers and Ionity. The latter is two times more expensive (yes, you can use Superchargers with other car brands, but it costs more). Which is why I bought a Tesla, and from what I see here in Switzerland, many people share this reasoning. Also, many people in Europe tend to live in _apartments_, where you can’t plug a car overnight. So, access to a fast charging network is essential. Once again, Tesla wins.
- mhandley 2y agoIn my case, Tesla just don't make the car I want. If they made a hatchback variant of the Model 3 and gave it physical controls, I'd probably buy it. But I don't want a Model Y - it's ugly, I really don't want an SUV, and I'm not a fan of touchscreens in cars. But I've also heard from friends that they don't want to buy a car associated with Elon Musk, so perhaps that is also hurting their sales.
- processing 2y ago[flagged]
- Analemma_ 2y agoEntering a highly-politically-polarized market category, where one tribe sees "hating your product" as central to their personal identity, then loudly aligning with that tribe and going out of your way to antagonize the other one which actually likes what you make, is going to be taught in business schools for decades as a What Not to Do example. What an absolute fucking moron.
- sfblah 2y agoIs there really any reason to buy a Tesla if you want an EV other than as a status symbol? I bought a lightly used Chevy Bolt which, after rebates cost me $8000. Its range is around 230 miles. Why are people paying $40k for cars?
- LeoPanthera 2y agoThey're not even status symbols anymore. I think it's quite common knowledge now that they're poor quality cars made with very little care.
- nine_k 2y agoTeslas, maybe. How about Nissans and especially Volvos?
- dangus 2y agoIn the US, the obvious answer is charging network. I would also say that the Chevy Bolt is solidly smaller than the average vehicle that most Americans buy, especially those that buy new cars. Car manufacturers don’t really care what used buyers like you want. They don’t make money from a used sale.
- ars 2y ago> Car manufacturers don’t really care what used buyers like you want. They don’t make money from a used sale. That's not true. Someone buying a new cars pays attention to resale value, so car manufacturers want the resale value to be as high as possible to encourage someone to buy a new one.
- sfblah 2y agoI don't understand the value of the charging network. Who drives 400 miles in a day? It's much more efficient to either have access to a gasoline car when that's necessary or just rent one for $50 a day.
- 2y ago
- insane_dreamer 2y agoScary headlines are misleading. Being first meant that Tesla captured nearly 100% of EV sales. Now that there are reasonable competitors in the mix, it's only natural that its sales volumes will regress to the mean over time.
- MisterBastahrd 2y agoThat's of little consolation to the people who bought Tesla stock when it was far more overvalued than the still grossly overvalued price that it has today. The quality of their products is bad. The quality of their leadership is even worse. People have taken notice and are voting with their wallets. Even if I could buy a Tesla for $19K and it did 800 miles per charge, I wouldn't, because the control system alone is beyond terrible.
- ripjaygn 2y ago> That's of little consolation to the people who bought Tesla stock when it was far more overvalued than the still grossly overvalued price that it has today. You make it sound like HN is a forum for Tesla shareholders. Or Tesla short sellers. If you think Tesla is overvalued then short it instead of adding contentless noise and rants.
- MisterBastahrd 2y agoAnd here, gentle readers, we have a poster with a long history of astroturfing for Tesla.
- ripjaygn 2y agoTesla doesn't even have a PR department, you think they're going to pay astroturfers? The oil lobby on the other hand...
- insane_dreamer 2y agomy comment has nothing to do with Tesla's overinflated stock price I don't like Tesla's leadership (Elon) but I disagree that the product is bad; everyone I know who owns one (including myself), is happy with it, and it's still far more popular than other EVs. Not my favorite EV, but they got a lot of things right.
- ArtTimeInvestor 2y agoTesla is all about self-driving now. And they don't offer that in Europe. As far as I know, there is no self-driving in Europe at all. No Tesla, no Waymo, no nothing. Will Europe fall behind with self-driving like it did with the internet? There are a similar number of cars on the road in Europe and the US. About 250 million. I wonder how much they are driven? Maybe one hour per day? That would be 250M*365 = 91B man hours per year. If we value an hour at $20, that is $1.8T per year which can be automated. That is about 10% of the European GDP. Plus many other benefits of self-driving cars, like more public space because fewer cars are needed, and they can park outside the center.
- k8sToGo 2y agoEurope already has self driving to a degree. Mercedes was faster than Tesla.
- UncleOxidant 2y agoIsn't Mercedes ahead of Tesla in self driving tech?
- ripjaygn 2y agoIt's not. Mercedes just follows the car in front and even that in very limited scenarios. It's just used as an anti-Tesla talking point on the internet, so lots of people believe what you said.
- mackman 2y agoMercedes launched level 3 autonomous vehicles in Germany a year or two ago I thought? https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/a39966189/2022-mercedes-benz-eqs-drive-pilot-drive/ https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/a39966189/2022-mercedes...
- ArtTimeInvestor 2y agoI have seen nothing that indicates that Mercedes stands a chance to catch up with Tesla. All I have seen Mercedes do could have been accomplished by manual programming. But manual programming does not scale. Look at the progress Tesla made from FSD 11 to FSD 12. Nothing indicates that Mercedes is capable of this type of progress.
- Fischgericht 2y agoI'm from Germany. When I bought my model 3 three years ago, I was amongst the first to have a Tesla in my (small) city. I bought it because I wanted an EV, and Tesla was the only one you could actually buy instead of having to wait for your car being delivered months or years later. Then, for a long time when I stopped at a Supercharger, every conversation went like this: "TeslateslateslateslaTesla!". If I stop at a charger today, where both Teslas and other EVs are parking, you typically hear the Tesla people apologize in shame. "I bought it before Elon became crazy", "Yes, I have looked at the hyundai, too!" etc. In the US I think it is very common these days to deal with very powerful people who are VERY crazy. So it has become normalized and no longer appears to be a concern. I'm also part of a very big fan German Tesla online fan forum. Mentioning Elon is now banned there. And "In MY tesla the windscreen wipers really work now!" these days will get you a request for a video proof. Over here, people have shame. They don't want that anyone associates them with a psychopath. I still like my M3. Not because it does what was advertised (it does not), but because I like the nerd humor in it and the acceleration. But: I have a M3 because I bought it before Elon turned bat shit crazy, so next car will be a Hyundai. There I don't know anything about the founder or CEO, and he probably will never push himself into my daily newsfeed, and I like that idea.
- UncleOxidant 2y ago> In the US I think it is very common these days to deal with very powerful people who are VERY crazy. So it has become normalized and no longer appears to be a concern. I think a lot of potential Tesla customers in the US have been put off by Musk's behavior. There are even bumper stickers for Tesla owners that say something to the effect of "I bought it before I knew he was crazy".
- brink 2y agoWhy do you think Elon is crazy?
- Fischgericht 2y agoAs a person on the autistic spectrum and with a narcissistic personality disorder I would give this planet the following advice: Don't make one of us the richest and most powerful person in the world. You will come to regret it.
- weinzierl 2y ago"The carmaker registered just 13,951 vehicles in April, the European Automobile Manufacturers’ Association said Wednesday, down 2.3% from a year ago and its worst tally since January 2023. Tesla’s result was an exception in an otherwise encouraging month for battery-electric vehicle sales, which rose 14% industrywide." So Tesla is down 2.3% in Europe compared to 14% up industrywide. The much more interesting comparison would be battery-electric vehicle sales in Europe in the same time frame for Tesla vs all other manufacturers. I'd be surprised if they did not both trend in the same direction.
- alephnerd 2y agoI was wrong earlier, as the overall EV market within Europe grew 14% I'd recommend taking a look at the Industry data used in the article - https://www.acea.auto/pc-registrations/new-car-registrations-13-7-in-april-2024-battery-electric-11-9-market-share/ https://www.acea.auto/pc-registrations/new-car-registrations... Much of the growth seems to be driven numerically speaking by the Spanish and German markets. In Spain, that growth seems to be mostly caused by Tesla [0]. MG and Volvo XC30 (Geely) make a showing, but the Model Y sold more in a month than both combined. Germany's seems to be driven by Mercedes-Benz and BMW [1] It seems more like the Tesla is less popular in Germany than it used to be previously, but I'm reading mixed information that Germany has also phased out environmental bonuses [2] (German penny wise pound foolish thinking strikes again). It seems the biggest hit to Tesla is France, where French companies like Puegot (Stellaris) and Renault have outcompeted the Tesla. Surprised by Renault because they are also a prominent EV seller in the Indian market. [0] - https://alternative-fuels-observatory.ec.europa.eu/general-information/news/spain-has-11-plugin-vehicle-share-new-monthly-market-share-report https://alternative-fuels-observatory.ec.europa.eu/general-i... [1] - https://insideevs.com/news/719822/plugin-car-sales-germany-april2024/ https://insideevs.com/news/719822/plugin-car-sales-germany-a... [2] - https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/germany-end-e-vehicle-subsidy-programme-2023-12-16/ https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/german...
- jaggs 2y agoOne thing I'm surprised that no-one mentions is the fact that, at least in Europe, buyers aren't stupid. They hear the news coming out from China about 1000km range EVs at decent prices, and they're waiting for the improved battery tech which everyone knows is coming. CATL and BYD are already shipping some cool battery tech right now, and it's only getting better. And unfortunately Tesla isn't a battery company.
- kmeisthax 2y agoThe thing to note about EVs is that car manufacturers fought tooth and nail to avoid having to sell them[0]. Ergo, for a while Tesla was the only option. Other car manufacturers were selling EVs either because Tesla successfully embarrassed them into looking old, or because California literally mandated they sell a certain number of EVs. Hell, for some car brands they were literally paying Tesla money because they didn't have a compliance car to sell. And then Musk goes and completely trashes his own reputation. First by calling rescue divers in Thailand pedos, then by lying about FSD, wasting a bunch of money buying Twitter[1], and most crucially, surrounding himself with a bunch of far-right nutjobs. The thing is, the far-right doesn't buy EVs, they want cars that command respect by frightening everyone else. The kinds of people actually buying EVs live in or near a city, in suburban housing that can support a dedicated overnight charging circuit. Which makes them far more likely to be progressive or left-leaning. In other words, Musk sunk his own company so he could go play Twitter culture warrior against his own customers. While not all of the culture war nonsense in the US transposes 1:1 to Europe, it's analogous enough that I suspect a lot of European Tesla buyers are feeling just as shy about their car purchase as American ones. [0] My personal conspiracy theory was that they were too durable to sell. Everyone but Tesla sells through dealers - in some cases, they HAVE TO - and dealers only make money when you take the car in for service. And EVs simply have fewer things to break, so moving to EVs means less maintenance money. The way Tesla gets around this is with parts pairing. [1] It is always moral and ethical to deadname corporations.