13 ms·
TSMC EUV machines equipped with remote self-destruct in case of invasion
- 1over137 3y agoRemote?! Now there’s a valuable target for their adversaries!
- atonse 3y ago1. If it's a remote switch, wouldn't Chinese hackers also be able to potentially block this kind of kill signal? (Unless it's a dead man's switch I suppose). 2. What would be the strategic implications of China getting access to these machines though? I mean if they didn't, they could just make 5 or 8 or 10 nm chips, right? What is the strategic advantage of the better manufacturing that would make it worth the US gov saying it would bomb those foundries, or installing kill-switches?
- tivert 3y ago> 1. If it's a remote switch, wouldn't Chinese hackers also be able to potentially block this kind of kill signal? (Unless it's a dead man's switch I suppose). Not necessarily. It could be triggered by, say, a shortwave radio embedded in the machine that listens for a code on secret frequencies. > 2. What would be the strategic implications of China getting access to these machines though? I mean if they didn't, they could just make 5 or 8 or 10 nm chips, right? I don't know. I'd say it would probably give them something to reverse engineer. But I'd say the bigger strategic implication of an invasion would be getting access to the TMSC engineers. They could fly them all up to SMIC, and some would probably cooperate (because they'd have to move on to the new reality after a defeat).
- atonse 3y agoSo it probably could be MORE about reducing the west's access to modern chips rather than gaining an advantage for their stuff? I have to imagine a lot of the expertise with the EUV stuff comes from ASML which is a Dutch company, thankfully. I have to give props to the US gov for getting the CHIPS act going and we're already seeing Fabs built in the US as a result. This might end up being a Y2K thing, where good preparation reduced the impact.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mensetmanusman 3y agoWon’t the tsunami generating nuclear wall between China and Taiwan accomplish that?
- ctoth 3y agoIsn't this just installing a really big "Push me!" button for our adversaries? Why do they need to take control of the fabs if they can just blow them up remotely Without taking responsibility? "Oh I guess there was a bug in the self-destruct system..."
- tivert 3y agoThat would be a vulnerability of a naive, always on implementation. But I'd think that risk would be significantly mitigated if the self-destruct system has to be armed first. e.g. China invades Taiwan, someone then immediately presses the "self-destruct enable" button, which cannot be disabled for a long period of time. If the invasion succeeds, someone transmits the self-destruct code. If it fails they don't, the machine stays intact, and someone gets to work disarming the self-destruct. I think it's plausible such a device could be built. Just make it battery powered and tamper-proof fail-deadly except when the battery runs down. Size the battery for two or three times the time Taiwan could be expected to hold out against an invasion.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tibbydudeza 3y agoAfaik those laser mirror assemblies are fine tuned to the nano meter range and still they need to finetune for a few months on site to account for the environment where the machine will be operating. All it takes is a bolt or some hardwired mechanism to render a 300 million dollar machine useless.
- chii 3y agoOr just spray the molten tin onto the mirrors. That's irreparable
- torpfactory 3y agoI don't think people realize just how complicated these machines are. A remote off switch just works faster than the alternative. A steady stream of parts and experts from various locations around the world is required to keep these things operating smoothly. Without the ASML service contract most would be unusable after a few months. The amount of technology brought to bear here is really only possible because of worldwide cooperation among thousands of vendors and tens of thousands of engineers. These machines are an extension of some pretty impressive institutions (ASML corp, for example), not just metal and glass. If China were to invade and if Taiwan or the US fought back, we would all be in a world of hurt, economically. Taiwan makes most of the high end logic chips the world uses, and China makes many of the lower tier, but still necessary chips for things like power management, etc. With sources for these devices offline, a lot of economic activity would begin to halt. We really must avoid war at all costs.
- questhimay 3y agoChina is not going to be able to invade Taiwan, it's too old and too broke to do so. Too old as in its demographics will be 30% over 60 years old in 10 years. Too broke as in the local governments are bankrupt, and the central government is barely hanging on, so much so that it had to issue ultra long bonds in 2 of the last 3 years. Keep in mind that Chinese government differs from other governments in that the other governments source of main revenue is taxes. Whereas the Chinese government has the revenue from all the state owned enterprises which are monopolies in major industries such as banking and oil. so if the Chinese government still can't get enough revenue from those state owned enterprises to cover existing debt payments, it is pretty fucked. It's also hard to attack an opponent, when the opponent has been preparing for a number of years, with its allies. US, Japan, Australia, India.
- cko 3y agoI hope you're right but think about it like this: with a high youth unemployment and supposedly more men than women, they can throw away a couple million people. Also them being a manufacturing powerhouse, I think they may have enough, even if they're at low point in the economic cycle. It wouldn't be smart and even the invasion were successful, not sure what they'd gain, besides more hate from all of Southeast Asia and maybe Western sanctions. I have family in Taiwan and I'm told their military isn't very well funded or equipped.
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40426843 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40426843
- kernal 3y agoThat's nice and all, but China's SMIC already has 5nm capability, so not sure why this was necessary, but whatever.
- linearrust 3y agoWe just had this same story yesterday. 'ASML and TSMC Can Disable Chip Machines If China Invades Taiwan' https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40426843 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40426843 Besides, who really cares? China isn't going to invade taiwan for silly companies like TSMC. If it invaded, it would be to take back their territory. What's with the constant artificial media blitz regarding tsmc? China's aim for reunification dates back decades before tsmc existed. Also, it would be nice if 'news' companies stated who ( public or private ) is sponsoring their articles.
- snakeyjake 3y agoTaiwan is not now, has never been, and will likely never be a part of the People's Republic of China.
- linearrust 2y ago> and will likely never be a part of the People's Republic of China. What's your definition of 'likely'? That taiwan will be a part of the mainland is pretty much a certainty. It's demography, geography and economy. One has 1.5 billion people and the other is 20 million people.
- gravescale 3y agoI feel like just chucking a big ol' jug of sand or salt water into the machine would probably be enough to pretty much permanently disable it, let alone something flammable. It's not like TSMC engineers and technicians would be raptured the first moment, leaving the fabs just standing there deserted and intact. This really seems like an answer someone gave to a clueless politician asking a stupid question. "Yes senator, there's a 'self-destruct' (eye roll)". Just leave out that the self-destruct is one dude with the fire bucket from the smoker's shelter in the car park.
- Log_out_ 2y agoThe actual deterrent are rockets aimed a the three gorges dam. The moment they start to lower the water level, is the start of the invasion.