6 ms·
Physicists now question the fate of the Universe
- zero-sharp 2y ago[flagged]
- jareklupinski 2y agoI'm questioning the fate of lunch (morning here)
- jmclnx 2y agoWell, I was with the article until half was through, it then proceeded to go over my head at a faster and faster rate. So I guess my brain as a huge negative curvature :)
- dotnet00 2y agoThe premise comes off as a bit of a surprise to me. My understanding had always been that physicists have not reached any majority agreement on which of the outcomes was likely, precisely because of the lack of understanding of the exact nature of dark energy.
- mnky9800n 2y agoIt's because these people all sit and talk with each other coming up with more high concept sci-fi rigamarole. occasionally, they share whatever they come up with other physicists but it kind of seems like everyone just shrugs and goes back to whatever they were working on.
- itishappy 2y agoI have a very different reading of the 60 years of theories and measurements detailed in the article. The results from the article come from a $50M instrument developed in the past 10 years for this exact purpose.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- thisaccount546 2y agoYears it was said that we were going to end up with the Big Crunch. Then in the past decade or two, it was said that we’d end up with a heat death. Now it seems like we’re heading away from that direction. Naturally, if you were immersed in the actual research, I’m sure the question would have seemed a lot more unsolved than it was presented. But it wasn’t just presented this way by pop science books; even scientists, when talking to laymen, tend to oversimplify things to a degree that they can become misleading. We’ve seen this discussed when it comes to things like string theory and quantum mechanics. Too many times people are saying “this is what happens” when they should be saying “we have no idea, there are a bunch of different theories, but we fundamentally don’t know.” Whatever happens to the universe, it won’t happen for billions of years. What people think will happen today might not be what they think will happen in ten, a hundred, or a thousand years from now. The research is interesting, but I have to assume that any answer we have now could be completely wrong.
- Percolator 2y agoI think there is a very valid argument to be made that what happens in the universe 10^14 years from now is not a valid scientific question. It is really just pseudoscience. It seems an easy bet to handicap that the chance what we know right now happens to be correct to basically be zero.
- mr_mitm 2y agoThere is nothing to agree on. You make measurements, see what model fits best, and then ask the model what will happen as time goes to infinity. And we did have a consensus: the standard model of cosmology. It fits the data best, that's how it became the standard model. Many cosmologists don't like the standard model, because it has some theoretical deficiencies. One example: The value of the dark energy density seems highly tuned. Its value is unnatural and there is no known mechanism that could produce such a finely tuned parameter. But what can you do if all observations agree with the standard model? I've been in cosmology grad school ten years ago and would listen to a visiting scientist presenting a novel model that might explain the standard model's shortcomings practically once a week. There is no shortage of speculative models. And as I said, science doesn't work by finding an agreement. You devise experiments that can show that your model explains more than the standard model and let nature find the agreement for you. If there are a few stubborn scientists left that cling to ruled out ideas (Fred Hoyle comes to mind), experience shows that they will die out over time. Euclid is one such experiment my group studied a lot, and it's finally collecting data. Hopefully it helps us find a better model than the standard model, and with all the news in the past few years, it's looking good.
- slowmovintarget 2y agoIt seems wrong-headed that even the hint of a Creator requires turning theories into pretzels to remove that hint even when it's not proof. The "problem" of fine-tuning isn't really a problem. Why that value? We just don't know yet. Maybe God set it. Maybe we're part of an infinitely large cosmos where our false vacuum has these parameters, and others don't (statistical multiverse / baby universe models). We just don't know, and sometimes it's enough to know that we don't know.
- karmakurtisaani 2y agoYou do realize that a creator hypothesis turns all theories to quite a bit more than just pretzels, and raises a lot more questions than it answers?
- 2y ago
- d_silin 2y agoTL;DR: the Big Rip is likely not to be the fate of the Universe as dark energy term in lambda-CDM cosmology is not a constant but weakens as time moves forward. Seems like Heat Death or Big Crunch options are back on the menu!
- codeulike 2y agoThanks. You'd think they'd end the article with a summary. Somewhere in that load of words they've managed to bury the new fate of the universe.
- digging 2y agoThe article does end with a summary.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- digging 2y agoI think your summary misses the mark. The Big Rip was not the most likely outcome before this new evidence. Heat Death has been the expectation/assumption. TL;DR of TFA: New evidence shows that dark energy may be weakening over time instead of staying constant, which could lead to a Big Crunch. We're eagerly awaiting further evidence.
- boole1854 2y agoI think that's a slightly incorrect TL;DR. Here's an updated version based on my reading: TL;DR: a heat death (Big Freeze) due to eternal acceleration was the previously favored candidate for the fate of the universe; but there's now evidence that dark energy varies, so acceleration may not be eternal; we may still get a Big Freeze (if it stop varying soon) or we may get a Big Crunch (if it keeps going far enough in the direction it has been going) or we may get a Big Rip (if it starts going in the opposite direction that it has been going)
- mr_mitm 2y agoYou seem to have mixed up your scenarios. In the standard model, i.e. constant dark energy, the universe ends in heat death. Big Crunch or Big Rip were never off the menu in the sense that our measurements couldn't exclude a value of w!=-1. But it's a critical value, you'll never be able to exclude the other scenarios if it's truly -1, because you always have a positive measurement uncertainty. The standard model is the standard model because it fits the data best. This can change as measurements become more precise. Now new data hints at the standard model being incorrect (to the surprise of basically no one in cosmology), making a big crunch more likely, but still not strongly ruling out the other scenarios.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- fasteddie31003 2y agoThis kind of research is non-falsifiable and I think it's just a waste of these scientists' talents. You will hear never-ending theories of the Big Bang, black holes, and the end of the universe because all this research is non-falsifiable and just people playing with math and coming up with different ideas that humans find interesting, but will not affect your quality of life at all. Science has to be falsifiable or else it's just a new type of faith.
- vletal 2y agoThis kind of reserach, which comes with new ideas which better explain our observations, helps balance exactly the blind faith in religion. People will always ask "where everything came from" questions. And if there is no science with plausible big-bang => background radiation... theories, you can just as easily return back to creationism.
- Aardwolf 2y agoNot sure about whether it's falsifiable or not, but maybe it can affect quality of life? I mean, imagine we do find the answer to a cause of the big bang or the fate of the end of the universe, there might as well be some knowledge in there that allows new kinds of engineering that can be useful for daily life E.g. (silly example): understanding how to create a big bang might allow creating an entire universe from scratch with minimal compute resources, in which we can then game
- 2four2 2y agoNo one is claiming that their speculative models and hypotheses are "truth". Before sufficient evidence is available, you start with a model and a hypothesis, which drives the search for evidence. Then it becomes falsifiable once you gather the evidence. I think you may have missed the explanation of science where the first step is to create a guess and that drives your experiments. As far as "not affecting your quality of life at all", people have been saying this about cutting edge science since forever. "Time can't be relative, it's just scientists playing with math. Besides, we'll never travel fast enough for it to matter and it doesn't affect our lives anyway." Yet time dilation is an important factor in your daily life if you ever used GPS.
- thriftwy 2y agoMatter cools when universe expands. Where does that energy go to? I would expect that delta E = delta V (with some clear way to represent volume in Joules). Shouldn't dark energy density also fall?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pdonis 2y ago> Matter cools when universe expands. More precisely, the energy density of matter decreases as the universe expands. > Where does that energy go to? Stress-energy density is locally conserved; there is no energy being created or destroyed. In fact that local conservation of stress-energy density is what requires the energy density of matter (which in cosmology-speak means a perfect fluid with zero pressure) to decrease as the universe expands (as the cube of the scale factor). > Shouldn't dark energy density also fall? No, because dark energy, considered as a stress-energy density, includes negative pressure equal to minus the energy density, and the same local conservation of stress-energy density I referred to above requires that in this case, the energy density is constant in both space and time. Note that the new findings described in the article amount to raising the possibility that what we thought was "dark energy", i.e., a cosmological constant with pressure exactly equal to minus the energy density (that is what w = -1, mentioned in the article, means), is in fact something else whose equation of state (relationship between pressure and energy density) can change over time, with pressure becoming less negative (w less negative than -1). If that is the case, the energy density would also be decreasing over time, though much more slowly than for ordinary matter.
- thriftwy 2y ago> In fact that local conservation of stress-energy density is what requires the energy density of matter (which in cosmology-speak means a perfect fluid with zero pressure) to decrease as the universe expands (as the cube of the scale factor). That makes total sense! Does this meak we know how much the total density of matter has to decrease in order for universe to expand one cubic meter? What's the energy equivalent of one new cubic meter of space, in Joules? Do we know that? Does it fit the observed matter density, with and without dark matter? It looks to me that "dark energy" / cosmological constant is just a measure of preference for matter+volume (or at least energy+volume) to take the form of volume rather than matter, in an otherwise conserving process.
- dgsm98 2y agoIf the fate of the Universe is on the line, I want Iguodala.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- makk 2y agoLooking at the chart, it appears they’ve narrowed it down to absolutely anything.
- MilStdJunkie 2y agoWhen I hear debates about whether or not the universes are black holes nested inside each other, or what the fate of the cosmos is, I often have an instinctive reaction to question whether or not concepts like "inside", "nested", or "fate" have actual fundamental qualities at the scales and timeframes under discussion.
- nutrie 2y agoIn other words, we don't know shit.
- MilStdJunkie 2y agoNot quite. I don't ascribe completely to the notion that we can't figure stuff out. But we do need to be careful about assuming that things like 3d topology (aka "inside", "outside", when the mathematical spaces we're looking might have no equivalent concept), cause/effect -- or even the spatial dimensions themselves -- are fundamental. Particularly when we're talking about black holes. It's hard, because our brains are optimized to deal with this very specific slice of spacetime we've evolved in, so we keep falling back into the trap of our words.
- nutrie 2y agoThe thing is, I'm not sure how much an actor emerging from a system can learn about the system. Not saying we can't, 'cause I don't know, nobody does. It's just intriguing in it's own way.
- sdht0 2y agoWe may not be able to probe the system directly, but we can take guesses at some of its properties using a powerful tool: logic. For instance, if it is true that something cannot come out of nothing (ex nihilo nihil fit), and its clearly true that something exists (cogito, ergo sum), then it must be the case that whatever base reality is, it must have always existed. This base reality could be god or some base physical laws or something else, but unless someone can show that the premise is incorrect, we can surmise the eternal nature of reality.
- pryelluw 2y agoFive fish in a bowl. They argue about the fate of the bowl. Careless person vacuuming hits bowl. One fish survives. All get flushed down the toilet. It then ponders if this is the so called afterlife. Unclear. It does have to watch out for gators.
- rybosworld 2y agoArticle starts out like clickbait. There has never been consensus that the universe would end one way or another. Today, there still isn't.
- gilmore606 2y ago"What’s reality? I don’t know. When my bird was looking at my computer monitor I thought, ‘That bird has no idea what he’s looking at.’ And yet what does the bird do? Does he panic? No, he can’t really panic, he just does the best he can. Is he able to live in a world where he’s so ignorant? Well, he doesn’t really have a choice. The bird is okay even though he doesn’t understand the world. You’re that bird looking at the monitor, and you’re thinking to yourself, ‘I can figure this out.’ Maybe you have some bird ideas. Maybe that’s the best you can do." -- Terry Davis
- slowmovintarget 2y agoWhat would the dark energy value weakening do to something like Penrose's Conformal Cyclic Cosmology? Seems like it should falsify that idea, as C3 depended on a point where there was nothing left but photons that could never meet causing the end of time and a boundary for another big bang. (If my impression is correct.)
- OutOfHere 2y agoI always thought C3 was strange since each cycle expands greatly in space. The size of any new cycle is vastly bigger, making C3 insensible to me. Anyhow, the absence of strong dark energy makes things very easy for Penrose for the general concept of a cyclical universe. If gravity wins against dark energy, then a big crunch is easy, following which a new cycle starts. If instead gravity stays balanced with dark energy, then black holes slowly evaporate into photons anyway, preserving C3.
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoI have some questions: 1. When they say "70% of the universe is made up of dark energy, the rest is matter and dark matter", in what sense is the universe "made up" of those things? Or, perhaps, what is the "universe" that is made up of those things? If dark energy is this cosmological constant, in what sense does it "make up" 70% of the universe? 2. If the value of w is changing, and w is this cosmological constant that is dark energy (I'm probably not using the right words here), and dark energy is part of what makes up the sum total of the universe, did the decrease in dark energy go somewhere? Did it show up as an increase of something else? If so, what? 3. If w is changing over time, even if very slowly, should we suspect that other things might also be changing? The speed of light? The fine structure constant? For that matter, if w changes, does that require something else to change as a cause? 4. How did w change? Was it a step function, a corner (discontinuous first derivative), or a smooth change? Is it now constant, or is it continuing to decrease? (Yeah, I know - we just discovered this at all, I'm almost certainly asking for more precision than we have data for yet...)
- mr_mitm 2y ago1. It's the energy content. The stuff you can see (baryonic matter) is 5%, dark matter is 25%, the rest is dark energy. Technically you should take radiation into account, but this is negligible in today's universe. The types of energy can be characterized by how it changes as the universe expanda. If it becomes larger by a factor of a, matter density goes down as a^3, radiation density goes down as a^4 and dark energy density stays constant. Energy is not conserved in an expanding universe, so don't worry about that. 2. W is not the cosmological constant, but a related parameter. It does not go anywhere, the density just changes. 3. These things are unrelated. We do look for changes in these constants either way as good as we can, because imagine the excitement! But so far they all look very constant. 4. No one knows. It's probably always been close to -1, or else the universe would look very different, but you can play around with all kinds of time parameterization of w. The math gets complex very quickly, so the most common parameterization is a linearization. Simply measuring that is a challenge, so measuring this quantity in a model independent way is extremely difficult.