9 ms·
Degoogled Android – My Experience
- Ender-events 2y agoI've been using sailfish os with android app support + microg for over 5 years. It work for my daily low usage (browser, music, sometime bank) but missing nfc + bluetooth on andoid vm > Graphene describes itself as “The private and secure mobile operating system with Android app compatibility”. Like yeah no shit you have Android app compatibility. YOU’RE FUCKING ANDROID. If I remember an anecdote from the android course, to get the android logo and the right to call an android device, you have to pass the android certification. And according to the teacher, it was a real pain.
- jcul 2y agoI was really tempted to try sailfish a few times in the past. Do you have any issues with banking apps? It's a little scandalous that using a bank is so difficult these days without a smart phone.
- Ender-events 2y agoI don't have issue with my banking apps (banxo caisse d'epargne) but i think they don't use strict safetynet test My issue is more oomkillers (with my 3GB ram phone, twice a week i have the android support kill) and geolocalisation is really slow (took 5 to 10 minutes after toggle)
- Qision 2y agoI would have been curious to read about WhatsApp since it is a widely used app. Also for youtube I use NewPipe which I find incredibly good (no ads, can manage playlists and audio only).
- deadly_penguin 2y agoYes, WhatsApp works perfectly fine (including notifications) on plain Lineage - even without microg. It doesn't integrate with Lineage's backup system though, you have to use WhatsApp's own transfer system.
- SahAssar 2y agoRegarding the maps thing... > My dad’s house wasn’t on the map. Neither was my mom’s house. Neither was my friend’s place. Obviously I can’t use apps based on OpenStreetMaps to get me places if the places I want to go aren’t on the map. What do they mean by not on the map? Is it not showing up in search? Is it the housenumber wasn't there? Is it the street not existing at all? If manually zooming to the place was it showing with the correct street and number? I'm curious since I've found OSM coverage to be pretty good for things like streets and housenumbers since they are generally based on imported data, no?
- jcul 2y agoYeah this is surprising to me too. Also, you can contribute to osm if a street was missing. The complaint about having to download the map seems unreasonable too. It downloads the world map and then the local map and you're done. Generally the local map for an area is like 50 to 100MB from memory. Perhaps they are in a very remote location with slow internet and no map data, but downloading the lineage ROM would be a lot slower than downloading a single map.
- tadfisher 2y agoThey should learn from Google, and package their maps so they can be streamed to clients piecemeal. I bet they spend more in data egress than compute, and PostGIS is basically made for this.
- SahAssar 2y agoThat's the default way to use OpenStreetMap, either with vector or raster tiles. I'm guessing these apps did it this way for a reason, probably to support the offline usecase and not need a separate way to do it.
- jcul 2y agoYeah I think organic maps and maps.me (the original organic maps was forked from) had the main purpose of being offline maps. Great for travelling. Also cool to check where you are on planes, on non intercontinental flights that don't have screens.
- navigate8310 2y agoFor synchronizing contacts and calendar, OP may use DAVX5
- jcul 2y ago> Graphene describes itself as “The private and secure mobile operating system with Android app compatibility”. Like yeah no shit you have Android app compatibility. YOU’RE FUCKING ANDROID. For some reason custom roms like to advertise themselves as their own OS that can run android apps. You’re not your own OS you’re just a distro of android. Quit trying to sound more unique than you are. This is a little unfair. Graphene does not come with any google apps installed by default (of course android itself is a google product, whether running calx, graphene, or lineage). It gives you the option to install google apps like the play store, but these are installed like any other app. You can restrict permissions, deny internet access etc. But they are totally optional. Also, a nitpick, but these are all android, including lineage os.
- _rdvw 2y agoMost "degoogled" systems are not degoolged: https://eylenburg.github.io/android_comparison.htm https://eylenburg.github.io/android_comparison.htm
- em-bee 2y agothis comparison looks good, but it claims that there is no opt-out for microG in /e/OS. yet, in the app settings i can simply disable microG completely. is that not sufficient for opt-out?
- potatoball 2y agoPerhaps there are some settings that still rely on Google that can’t be disabled, such as push notifications. Most if not all apps from the Google Play store will use their framework to send push notifications to your device. If you get notifications on messaging apps with microG disabled, this could be an indication that your device is still using Google services under the hood
- _rdvw 2y agoThat row covers whether or not the opt-in/out is provided during setup wizard, not post install. If there is such an option then you can report it here: https://github.com/eylenburg/eylenburg.github.io/issues https://github.com/eylenburg/eylenburg.github.io/issues
- em-bee 2y agofair point, though when looking at things like that i'd also like to know if it is possible to disable at all.
- mpalmer 2y agoI question the logic of excluding Chromium users from reading one's writing about de-googling. Sorry, I'm not switching browsers to receive this particular brilliance.
- rchaud 2y agoI just read the article on Brave (Chromium) on Android.
- dsalfdslfdsa 2y agoIt's especially strange, given the amount of effort the blog author went to, to add Google apps back to their de-googled phone. Having started on this path, in my opinion it's a losing battle and a waste of time. Google have thousands of engineers just waiting to patch whatever hack you are using in your "de-googled" phone. Android serves the purposes of its creator.
- poulpy123 2y agoI read the article without trouble with both chrome and chromium (under windows)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- intelVISA 2y agoPerhaps author feels you're too Googled to be saved?
- PenguinCoder 2y agoThat's how the rest of us Non-Chromium users feel about other websites.
- RealStickman_ 2y agoThe microg_installer_revived module isn't necessary anymore if you're using a build from within the last month. The Lineage folks finally implemented signature spoofing for microg, simply downloading it from the official website or f-droid repo works now.
- brnt 2y agoDownload what from F-droid? When I search for microg I only find location providers.
- RealStickman_ 2y agoYou have to add the microg repo. F-droid used to have microg, but it was causing issues in the past.
- brnt 2y agoThanks for the tip! However, I get a signature error after freshly adding their repo and trying to install it. Also their QR codes are broken on the website. Are we talking about microg.org?
- RealStickman_ 2y agoMicrog.org is correct. The official f-droid client won't care about the signatures, but this is a known issue with 3rd party stores like NeoStore. https://github.com/NeoApplications/Neo-Store/issues/564 https://github.com/NeoApplications/Neo-Store/issues/564
- thrtythreeforty 2y agoOh that is great news! It's always been a pain for exactly that reason.
- rumpelstilzchen 2y agoHow about Play Integrity and Key attestation results? What are the results of test apps (e.g. SPIC - com.henrikherzig.playintegritychecker and io.github.vvb2060.keyattestation) in your setup? I feel like more and more big apps rely on these security features.
- HeatrayEnjoyer 2y agoIntegrity will eventually (soon) switch over to hardware attestation. At that point nothing will pass that isn't stock out of the box, no amount of software hackery will bypass it.
- prirai 2y agoIt's still there. Basic, device and strong integrity. Device integrity is what you're referring to and it's still offered by the API but most apps do not use it. And perhaps, they should not.
- bitfilped 2y agoShame the author immediately threw out grapheneos "because they purley focus on privacy", the user experience is much better than lineage these days.
- winterqt 2y agoGraphene also has a way to sandbox Play Services, and may even allow Google Wallet using that, making it so that they don't have to dual boot.
- em-bee 2y agoalso completely missed /e/OS-murena. based on lineage, de-googled and customized to be very user friendly. microg is available but optional. if graphene or calyx don't fit, then /e/OS is really the best option from all the remaining alternatives.
- noman-land 2y agoGrapheneOS is better than LineageOS by every metric. It's basically flawless.
- brnt 2y agoIt has a very limited set of supported phones though, compared to LineageOS or /e/.
- rkagerer 2y ago
- skhameneh 2y agoI opted for postmarketOS, which doesn't support microG, on an old device. Going Degoogled was my only option for anything remotely maintained, which was a priority. It's nice to see my old device get some patches, but I'm not sure how much I'll use it since ARMv7 is mostly being phased out. Overall, using postmarketOS and trying to go completely without Google apps (and without microG) has been interesting. Not sure I could recommend it, but it did force me to discover some very useful (and quite nice) OSS apps.
- echelon_musk 2y agoMy deGoogled phone is an iPhone. Freedom isn't free and unfortunately the time wasted in trying to maintain a high standard of smartphone privacy is time I will never get back. That and the social isolation from trying use a phone that can't keep up with the activities and communication preferences of friends makes an iPhone a necessary compromise.
- poulpy123 2y agoThere is nothing free in the Apple ecosystem, neither as n free beer or in free speech. You can't even install an app that isn't approved by Apple on an iphone of ipad
- Zambyte 2y ago> You can't even install an app that isn't approved by Apple on an iphone of ipad I thought this was changing? I heard a lot about non Apple repositories recently
- prirai 2y agoYeah, but to open an alternative store, you need to pay a hefty sum. Even to publish apps on that alternate store, there will be high fees. Open source projects simply cannot afford that.
- tadfisher 2y agoHas anyone tried asking Apple? I think an offer like: 1. Apps must be FOSS and reproducibly buildable on the store's servers, like F-Droid. 2. No monetization allowed, not even donation links. 3. The store itself undergoes yearly security review by an accredited third-party firm at its own expense. 4. The store undergoes yearly compliance review for these terms at its own expense. Would be pretty much all upsides for Apple: non of their services are used; they don't pay infrastructure or human costs for app hosting, review, or developer support; and they don't pay these costs for apps that don't make them money anyway.
- 2y ago
- houstonhams 2y ago[dead]