7 ms·
Why Your Wi-Fi Router Doubles as an Apple AirTag
- exabrial 2y agoSilicon Valley does not understand the concept of consent. Everything should be opt in, not opt out.
- instagib 2y agoSo we’re at “ssid_optout_nomap” for hopefully abstaining from further mapping and password sharing. A few Microsoft threads some may be interested in concerning _optout and the additional preventing clients from sharing WiFi passwords: https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/insider/forum/all/clarification-on-the-optout-of-wifi-nonsense/71a87740-c8b3-4d08-abad-60f822d31429 https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/insider/forum/all/clarif... https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/all/turn-wifi-sense-off-for-a-network-without-adding/807c203f-0563-4fa1-975a-3949806b66de https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/all/turn-w... https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/all/preventing-any-wifi-user-from-sharing-my-passkey/a13e654e-3e19-4e99-b665-2e4085f38432 https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/all/preven...
- sneak 2y agoThis is also why I replace all of my APs when I move (new BSSIDs) and don’t put identifying information like phone numbers, names, or domains in SSIDs.
- ssl-3 2y agoWhy is that important to you? (And do you change the MAC addresses of your bluetooth devices, too? Some of us do gather up bluetooth location information, as well.)
- sneak 2y agoBecause I don’t want my residential location moves being tracked, as the person who goes from zip code A to zip code B to zip code C is possibly a unique track. I don’t use much bluetooth at home. Zigbee is becoming an issue, but I haven’t moved since I’ve set it up.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoIn the US, I would assume your employer (via payroll or “work number”, or your banks/credit cards/credit reporting agencies, or even retailers like Amazon or Walmart are selling that information. Or the USPS when you let them know where to forward your mail to after you move: https://www.forbes.com/sites/adamtanner/2013/07/08/how-the-post-office-sells-your-new-address-with-anyone-who-pays-and-the-little-known-loophole-to-opt-out/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/adamtanner/2013/07/08/how-the-p... Edit: and of course, as kstrauser points out, voter registration records.
- sneak 2y agoNone of those organizations ever receive my primary residential address, only my tertiary one. Fortunately in the US you are allowed to have more than one home. Absolutely nothing with my name on it goes to where I usually sleep. To divulge sensitive information like that is actively unsafe for certain types of people, because, as you note, almost every single vendor with whom you do business will blast it out all over the ecosystem until it shows up on SEO spam websites forever.
- kstrauser 2y agoThere are much easier ways to track authoritative details about a person's moves, e.g. voter registration.
- kube-system 2y agoOr through any of the data being sold by companies who send someone mail.
- DANmode 2y agoHackers often do not vote.
- kstrauser 2y agoUnless they legally can't, say because of a felony conviction, that seems highly unusual.
- NewJazz 2y agoCan't you set the BSSID? I am fairly sure hostapd exposes that knob in its config.
- Scoundreller 2y agoJust set it to mine: AA:AA:AA:AA:AA:AA:AA:AA (or something like that)
- chatmasta 2y agoYou should set it to the most common bssid of your preferred anonymity set. You can look up tables of most common MAC addresses and SSIDs and pick from there. Still, the distribution of these identifiers will vary by region, manufacturer and other factors. The best way to stay anonymous is to avoid using the wireless spectrum. You’ll never be in full control of your anonymity as long as anyone around you is broadcasting a unique identifier and your device is logging its observations of these identifiers, correlating them with GPS, and sending them to the cloud…
- hoherd 2y agohostapd definitely exposes this as it was used extensively to spoof 3DS streetpass relays for a variety fun reasons, back before Nintendo shut down the service in March 2018 :( https://github.com/danielhoherd/homepass/blob/master/RaspberryPi/hostapd.conf#L6 https://github.com/danielhoherd/homepass/blob/master/Raspber...
- Kerrick 2y agoI took the opposite approach: make the SSID equal the street address. If it's going to be mapped anyways, might as well name it with a location-based name.
- Terr_ 2y agoDisagree: That feels like a failure of defense-in-depth, handing unnecessary bonus information to an attacker while providing no actual convenience to legitimate users who already know their own street address. For example, suppose a device on your network is compromised: The attacker instantly get a freebie for a mailing-address they could use for identity-theft/impersonation, blackmail/extortion threats, or scams pretending to be an authority figure. If you also have something like a home security system, they'll immediately know where to go if someone wants to burgle a room full of goodies (possibly visible via camera) as soon as the owner leaves. The reverse direction is also an issue: Suppose someone already knows your street address, and is trying to figure out which wireless network to target in order to harass/hack/burgle you. Even if these all seem unlikely, the information leak is all downside, no benefit.
- cchance 2y agoTHIS! Lol knowing your in an area is one thing, knowing if it's coming from you or the neighbors window 5ft away easily is a big difference
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gruez 2y agoHonestly anything other than the auto-generated SSID is going to add more entropy and make you stick out. Moreover, AFAIK they track the BSSID (ie. MAC address), so unless you also spoof that, changing the network name is not going to matter.
- DANmode 2y ago
- schmidt_fifty 2y ago[dead]
- super256 2y agoWhen I visited the 37c3 my iPhone was always showing my location being in Leipzig instead of Hamburg (probably because the SSIDs weren't changed when the APs were moved from Leipzig to Hamburg). :)
- pard68 2y agoIs there a way to prevent this data from being used? Can I somehow not broadcast certain data over wifi or otherwise keep google and apple from using my wifi metadata without my consent?
- ssl-3 2y agoThere's a surefire way to prevent this kind of thing forever: Stop broadcasting your data on the air for anyone to hear, and others will stop being able to listen to it.
- NewJazz 2y agoTHIS IS A PRIVATE COMMENT; ANYONE READING THIS COMMENT IS IN VIOLATION OF NEWJAZZ POLIS-Y AND WILL BE SUBJECT TO PUNISHMENT.
- invalidlogin 2y agoI kinda love you.
- kstrauser 2y agoFrustrating, but true. It's our own hardware shouting its details into the wild for anyone to pick up.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- runjake 2y agoYes. From this article: > But in late March 2024, Apple quietly tweaked its privacy policy, allowing people to opt out of having the location of their wireless access points collected and shared by Apple — by appending “_nomap” to the end of the Wi-Fi access point’s name (SSID). https://support.apple.com/en-us/102515 https://support.apple.com/en-us/102515 (Search for "_nomap") Google also supports this scheme: https://support.google.com/maps/answer/1725632 https://support.google.com/maps/answer/1725632 Wigle.net, too: https://wigle.net/phpbb/viewtopic.php?t=2330 https://wigle.net/phpbb/viewtopic.php?t=2330 Would I trust any of this? No.
- ballenf 2y agoThis is a data goldmine for data brokers who have most certainly replicated the data set, but without any of the privacy measures that the researchers implemented. On another note, I had missed that Apple recognizes the '_nomap' suffix and stops indexing/reporting its WiFI AP locations.
- cpeterso 2y agoWould that data be considered Apple IP even though the AP addresses and locations are somewhat public information (because APs are broadcasting their addresses)? Apple’s API might return fake “trap addresses” that it could use to trace if their API data shows up in other companies’ location databases. Like the “trap streets” used to catch map plagiarists: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trap_street https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trap_street
- diebeforei485 2y agoMicrosoft requires _optout, Google and Apple require _nomap. This is ridiculous. Some industry body like the IEEE Standards Committee should agree on a standard.
- phh 2y agoExcept those companies hate standards and will use them exclusively when it commonize their complements. (well.. Even when it does they don't necessarily do.)
- kstrauser 2y agoI propose `_optin`. It'd never fly, but a guy can wish.
- beeboobaa3 2y agoopt in to what? I propose _trackme
- kstrauser 2y agoI can live with that.
- NewJazz 2y ago_optout seems like a shitty method... Opt out of what??? Knowing MS, they'll probably start recognizing _nomap sometime in late 2027.
- hoherd 2y agoWait, that wasn't me opting out of every cookie banner I visit over that network?
- qrohlf 2y agoWhile it's not particularly surprising that the location of a piece of radio hardware that broadcasts a static identifier is trackable, it is pretty interesting how the location awareness and ubiquity of modern smartphones are effectively creating a massive distributed sensing network. The focus on this piece is mostly on how apple (by designing their api in a way that avoids apple computing your exact location on their servers, presumably in an attempt to _preserve_ user privacy) inadvertently gave public access to that sensing network. I'd love to read a piece that also games out what exactly a red team or attacker could do with _privileged_ access. I.e. "if somebody was able to compromise the location services servers, but not iOS, what exactly would they be able to do with that"...
- tmaly 2y agoNot to sound cliche, but the modern cell phone beats anything they could have imagined in Orwell's 1984
- gruez 2y ago> "if somebody was able to compromise the location services servers, but not iOS, what exactly would they be able to do with that"... Aren't the locations on apple's servers end-to-end encrypted? I'm not sure what you'd be able to do with that.
- ipython 2y agoDon't forget in-vehicle Wi-Fi access points, which are active in most modern cars/trucks. Plus you can't "opt out" as these are usually fixed names (you can't append "_nomap")
- banish-m4 2y agoBluetooth MAC address is also a means of tracking individual customer phones. If a car supports bluetooth, that's another way to track it also.
- cpeterso 2y agoSince MAC address ranges are allocated to different vendors, Google and Apple could choose to not report the locations of certain vendors’ devices, such as Starlink or known transportation APs.
- sixhobbits 2y agoThis was already a story in 2015 when Google collected the SSID and location data as well as 'accidentally' storing the actual network data from open networks [0] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2010/may/15/google-admits-storing-private-data https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2010/may/15/google-ad... Also surprised how many people don't know that their phones regularly try to connect to all wifi networks saved on the device, and that this unique combination which includes things like "my town mcdonald's" or whatever is enough to uniquely identify someone and usually locate them too.
- dsalfdslfdsa 2y agoSomewhat related story: https://www.wired.com/story/99-phones-fake-google-maps-traffic-jam/ https://www.wired.com/story/99-phones-fake-google-maps-traff...
- gruez 2y ago>as 'accidentally' storing the actual network data from open networks [0] What's with the scare quotes? It seems entirely plausible to me. eg. their process for capturing beacons were to put a wifi card in monitor mode, capturing any packets they see, and then filtering only for beacons. Somewhere along the way they forgot to add the filter, and as a result they were inadvertently recording all packets. Trying to imply that they were doing something nefarious makes little sense. The cars were constantly moving, so at best you got a few seconds of web browsing data before going out of range. As google should know, the value in data comes from being able to build a complete profile of someone, not knowing what one page someone visited was. Moreover, thanks to third party cookies and their embeds everywhere on the web, they don't need to drive around to capture your web browsing traffic. They can get a continuous feed just by operating their cdn/ad networks.
- DANmode 2y agoThis had essentially nothing to do with web browsing packets, and everything to do with Google building a map of citizen bSSIDs and MAC addresses without their consent.
- Asmod4n 2y agoOn a related note: android devices try to continuously connect to all WiFi networks they have been connected to before, no matter if you are „near“ them or not. Doesn’t even matter if the access point is broadcasting the SSID or not. Found this out by just having the personal hot spot of an iOS device enabled and then turning on a android tablet. iOS doesn’t broadcast the SSID unless you have the settings screen of the personal hotspot open. Scary.
- gruez 2y ago>Doesn’t even matter if the access point is broadcasting the SSID or not. Source? AFAIK this behavior only gets engaged if the hotspot has a hidden SSID. >Found this out by just having the personal hot spot of an iOS device enabled and then turning on a android tablet. iOS doesn’t broadcast the SSID unless you have the settings screen of the personal hotspot open. Scary. This is opposite to my experience. I specifically have to enable "allow other devices to join" for non-ios devices to be able to join.
- russdill 2y agoFree Airport WiFi!
- willcipriano 2y agoWhen I make a hot spot hidden, devices that previously connected to it can still do so in most implementions I've seen. That's how you work around them not supporting hidden networks. So I'll call "Source?" on it working like you describe.
- gruez 2y ago>When I make a hot spot hidden That's a misnomer. It doesn't actually make it hidden, only transmit beacons with a blank ssid. That's why even if your network is hidden, it will show a "hidden network" option for you to manually enter the SSID[1]. Moreover, client devices that have hidden networks saved will send out probe packets with network names it has saved[2], so it can determine whether the hidden network is actually around. This is actually worse for privacy, especially if your network name is vaguely unique, because you're broadcasting this high entropy information everywhere you go. [1] https://www.digitalcitizen.life/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/hidden_wifi_5.png https://www.digitalcitizen.life/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/h... [2] https://www.acrylicwifi.com/en/blog/hidden-wifi-network-secure-hidden-ssid/ https://www.acrylicwifi.com/en/blog/hidden-wifi-network-secu...
- banish-m4 2y agoSkyhook was the original but Qualcomm calls it TPS now. Public dbs: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wi-Fi_positioning_system#Public_Wi-Fi_location_databases https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wi-Fi_positioning_system#Publi...
- mateus1 2y agoSo they found 488 million vulnerable locations and the solution is that users should rename them individually? This is Apple and Google’s vulnerabilities.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago“Google’s WPS computes the user’s location and shares it with the device. Apple’s WPS gives its devices a large enough amount of data about the location of known access points in the area that the devices can do that estimation on their own.” This sums up the companies’ philosophies neatly.
- ncruces 2y agoHow is sharing the locations of 400 nearby BSSIDs better? It's the fact that Apple spews this huge amount of info that allowed this research to happen, after all. That’s according to two researchers at the University of Maryland, who theorized they could use the verbosity of Apple’s API to map the movement of individual devices into and out of virtually any defined area of the world.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> How is sharing the locations of 400 nearby BSSIDs better? Apple isn't constantly computing your precise location. It's happening on device. The fundamental problem is our devices are inadvertently broadcasting their own locations. Not that Apple is providing, in essence, a report on the public radio spectrum. (Do hidden SSIDs broadcast a BSSID?)
- ncruces 2y ago> Not that Apple is providing, in essence, a report on the public radio spectrum. Of the entire world. Provided in a nice enough package that with a little patience researchers could collect the location 480 million devices. > Do hidden SSIDs broadcast a BSSID? They do something worse: they force devices that want to connect to them to broadcast the BSSID all the time, which allows passive listeners to track them (e.g.) across a shopping mall.
- etc-hosts 2y agoWhy does Starlink still have Russian customers?
- JetSpiegel 2y agoThose are the Ukranian spies?
- kornhole 2y agoThis highlights the need for access points that can broadcast a random BSSID periodically similar to how handset hotspots implement. I am looking for a new WIFI 7 access point and would love to find one that does this.
- fragmede 2y agoin absence of a commercially available product, OpenWRT will do this on bootuo via https://github.com/janost/openwrt-wan-mac https://github.com/janost/openwrt-wan-mac and you can schedule reboots.
- brundolf 2y agoWhy is this API public at all? Could Apple not just restrict access?
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 2y ago"Apple did not respond to requests for comment. But in late March 2024, Apple quietly tweaked its privacy policy, allowing people to opt out of having the location of their wireless access points collected and shared by Apple - by appending "_nomap" to the end of the Wi-Fi access point's name (SSID)." Have never seen new computers out of the box that phone home more than Apple computers. "Privacy is a fundamental human right" - Tim Cook, Apple CEO "We don't collect a lot of your data and understand every detail about your life. That's just not the business that we are in," says Apple CEO Tim Cook, shown here at the NPR offices in Washington, D.C., on Thursday." https://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2015/10/01/445026470/apple-ceo-tim-cook-privacy-is-a-fundamental-human-right https://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2015/10/01/44... Imagine if in order to enjoy a fundamental human right one had to "opt-in". To enjoy the right to life, append "_keepalive" to your name. To enjoy the right to be free, not a slave, add "_master" To enjoy the right to avoid torture, add "_notorture" Apple marketing works. Reality distortion field. Whatever business Apple is in, it collects a motherlode of data.
- betaby 2y agoI read the article but didn't get how the authors got the data. I understand that IOS/Android leak nearby Wi-Fi to Apple/Google and that was like that for years. But how I can get access to such bulk data to reproduce the map from the article?
- _lvbh 2y agoI went on my Mac and used mitmproxy while requesting location. The API is here: https://gs-loc.apple.com/clls/wloc https://gs-loc.apple.com/clls/wloc. It uses protobuf and you basically send a list of BSSIDs and it returns a list of BSSIDs with Long/Lat attached. My question would be: are iPhones reporting locations with nearby access points or does Apple have other means of collecting the AP locations
- cpeterso 2y agoThe authors wrote a client to ask Apple’s WiFi Positioning API for the locations of random AP addresses. Enough of the random addresses were known to Apple’s location database that it returned real location data. Apple’s API also returns the addresses and locations of 400+ other nearby APs. That enables iOS devices to do faster and offline content geolocation in the same region. > Apple’s API will return the geolocations of up to 400 hundred more BSSIDs that are nearby the one requested. It then uses approximately eight of those BSSIDs to work out the user’s location based on known landmarks. > In essence, Google’s WPS computes the user’s location and shares it with the device. Apple’s WPS gives its devices a large enough amount of data about the location of known access points in the area that the devices can do that estimation on their own.
- _lvbh 2y agoDoes anyone know if IOS randomizes the BSSID of hotspots? I’ll need to test this out & see if this could track a known device