6 ms·
Police in Austin, San Francisco skirt facial recognition ban
- baggy_trough 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rntn 2y agohttps://archive.ph/DMBii https://archive.ph/DMBii
- nick7376182 2y ago"Police officers in SF and Austin circumvent city bans on use of facial recognition."
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Bostonian 2y agoI'm glad that the man 'charging toward someone with a knife' was apprehended with facial recognition technology. In general I favor its use for catching violent criminals. 'Austin police officers have received the results of at least 13 face searches from a neighboring police department since the city’s 2020 ban — and have appeared to get hits on some of them, according to documents obtained by The Post through public records requests and sources who shared them on the condition of anonymity. “That’s him! Thank you very much,” one Austin police officer wrote in response to an array of photos sent to him by an officer in Leander, Tex., who ran a facial recognition search, documents show. The man displayed in the pictures, John Curry Jr., was later charged with aggravated assault for allegedly charging toward someone with a knife, and is currently in jail awaiting trial. Curry’s attorney declined to comment.'
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 2y agoYeah, having police say, we could find out who the guy charging towards someone with a knife is, bland we have the technology, but we can’t do it is not likely to be a winning political argument.
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoIf I have to chose between a state where that dude with the knife is still at large, and a state where people are too afraid of dissent because they're worried about their attendance at a protest showing up on their public record, I'll take the dude with the knife.
- hexis 2y agoWell, in many places in the US, you already have both.
- fallingsquirrel 2y agoNow go type "facial recognition arrest false positive" into your favorite search engine. https://www.aclu.org/news/privacy-technology/police-say-a-simple-warning-will-prevent-face-recognition-wrongful-arrests-thats-just-not-true https://www.aclu.org/news/privacy-technology/police-say-a-si... > And in New Jersey, police wrongfully arrested Nijeer Parks in 2019 after face recognition technology incorrectly flagged him as a likely match to a shoplifting suspect. An officer who had seen the suspect (before he fled) viewed the face recognition result, and said he thought it matched his memory of the suspect’s face. I bet this officer also sent the same email: "That’s him! Thank you very much," before arresting an innocent man.
- mindslight 2y agoFalse positives are the main problem here, exactly. We'd all feel a lot better about facial recognition technology with police reform that ended/compensated the widespread harm being done to mere suspects, as well as fixing courtroom standards of evidence to take into account that things like facial recognition are essentially pulling signal out of noise. If facial recognition turns police onto a suspect who is then found to possess the stolen items, the latter is corroborating evidence that they've found the right person. If facial recognition turns police onto a suspect who then merely looks like what eyewitnesses remember, that part of the witness's recollection is inherently correlated to how the suspect was picked and so it needs to be disregarded.
- MeImCounting 2y agoAlso as a US citizen I am totally unsurprised to hear about multiple law enforcement agencies continuing to conspire with eachother to violate rights and break laws with no consequence. I would love to see a federal ban on any law enforcement using facial recognition for the near term at least until it becomes much more accurate. This, abolition of qualified immunity, mandated body cameras and the demilitarization of departments would be a great step in making this country safer.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dylan604 2y ago> demilitarization of departments would be a great step in making this country safer. there needs to be a qualifier attached to that comment: safer from police. It won't make the country itself safer. demilitarizing the police will not prevent schools/churches/movie theaters from getting shot up by someone. demilitarizing the police will not stop gang violence. by all means, reign in the out of control over weaponized "peace" officers, but please, let's be realistic on what that will actually do to overall safety.
- thethirdone 2y agoI do not agree that it needs a qualifier. My opinion is that safety as a whole would improve with those four suggestions implemented. You can disagree, but if you think it would make safety worse you probably should point out how those changes would result in a more unsafe country not just that it wouldn't solve all problems.
- dylan604 2y agoI just listed how. I stipulated it would make it safer from police, but then listed how other things would not be improved. I do not believe I wrote it in a confusing manner. You not willing to accept that improving on type of danger does not make all danger safe. By all means, move the needle, but don't paint with a wider brush than what the needle is actually moving.
- amlozano 2y agoIf I recall correctly the ordinance only barred the city's police from "acquiring or using" the software without approval and reports to a committee. Merely asking someone else to use it on their behalf is probably ok (per the ordinance). Its kind of hard to actually ban any particular technology, if it is useful, people will find a way to use it.
- creer 2y agoOrdinance version 3 starts "Ordinance amending the Administrative Code to require that City departments acquiring surveillance technology, or entering into agreements to receive information from non-City owned surveillance technology". But after that it's 21 pages and I don't know if that's the version that was adopted. then "(d) Notwithstanding the provisions of this Chapter 19B, it shall be unlawful for any Department to obtain, retain, access, or use: 1) any Face Recognition Technology; or 2) any information obtained from Face Recognition Technology. A Department’s inadvertent or unintentional receipt, retention access to, or use of any information obtained from Face Recognition Technology shall not be a violation of this subsection (b), provided that: (1) The Department does not request or solicit its receipt, access to, or use of such information; and" So asking the neighbors to use theirs does seem barred. (But then again it's 21 pages.)
- yonran 2y agoNote that the section you quoted was unanimously amended to only apply to SF city-owned devices (https://sfbos.org/sites/default/files/o0286-19.pdf https://sfbos.org/sites/default/files/o0286-19.pdf). To see the current version of the surveillance ordinance see Admin Code 19B.2 (https://codelibrary.amlegal.com/codes/san_francisco/latest/sf_admin/0-0-0-61746 https://codelibrary.amlegal.com/codes/san_francisco/latest/s...)
- singleshot_ 2y agoThought experiment: if murder is illegal, what is it called when you ask someone to murder on your behalf? “Probably ok” does not spring to mind.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- alsetmusic 2y ago> SFPD spokesman Evan Sernoffsky said these requests violated the city ordinance and were not authorized by the department, but the agency faced no consequences from the city. He declined to say whether any officers were disciplined because those would be personnel matters. Police departments should have a requirement to be transparent about disciplinary actions with a citizen review board that ensures reasonable enforcement. Budgets should be tied to the findings of the review board. This should apply to every PD.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jedberg 2y agoUnless the board were anonymous, which wouldn't be very fair to the officers, that board would just be rife with intimidation and corruption. There is a reason Grand Jurys are secret, but they don't have any direct impact on the cases they hear. They can only move them on to the next step.
- digging 2y ago> Unless the board were anonymous, which wouldn't be very fair to the officers What? How so?
- jedberg 2y agoThere is a reason our justice system is set up so that you must know who your accusers are. If the board were able to discipline or fire officers, it would not be fair to them to not know their accusers.
- CWuestefeld 2y agoOur justice system is completely distinct from employment hiring/firing decisions. The latter isn't considered at all in the right to confront your accuser, nor right to an attorney, nor freedom from self-incrimination.
- tigerBL00D 2y agoI live in Marin and police in my small town frequently arrest criminals using automatic license plate scanners that guard every road that leads into town. Most of them drive from SF over the bridge after committing various crimes. Our town is a very safe town. I feel safe leaving the front door unlocked or keys inside the car in the driveway. Unfortunately everything changes as soon as I cross the bridge. So the question is this: if your house got robbed and/or you family got hurt, wouldn't you want technology to be on your side?
- wswope 2y agoYour question is a cop-brained false dichotomy. The real world isn’t divided into good guy/bad guy “sides”. It’s not an either/or - we can and should address crime while also respecting civil liberties.
- Teever 2y agoYeah, that's a good question. Another good question is "What if we spent these resources on actually eliminating the cause of this sort of crime instead of further cementing a police surveillance state that may actually paradoxically cause the increase in crime in the first place." Another good question is "What would nightmare scenarios from the application of this kind of technology look like and how could they affect me personally?" Imagine what this guy[0] could do to your family if he had access to the kind of technology you're promoting. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Holtzclaw https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Holtzclaw
- gretch 2y agoI support technology in law enforcement. For example body cams that exonerate officer behavior in extreme situations. Non-lethal restraining mechanisms. From what I’ve seen of facial recognition technology at this time, I think it’s extremely unreliable and more likely to cause harm to innocent citizens (by way of police) than to protect innocents. This technology can lead to false positives, kinda like Swatting, and then non-criminals (like you) get hurt. Also, I believe you mis attributed the safety in your town to the technology used. In fact I would wager it’s based on many other factors like, race, socio economics, population density, etc
- 2y ago
- Teever 2y agoThe correct response to this sort of behavior by law enforcement is sousveillance. We as a society need to start coordinated programs of sousvaillance on law enforcement and any time they step out of line society can just spill some of their greasy secrets like which corrupt cop is cheating on their wife or whatever. Do this publicly, name and shame and explicitly state what actions these individuals took that brought about this sort of reaction. This is a start to correctly identifying and and modifying unacceptable behaviour from law enforcement. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sousveillance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sousveillance
- abeppu 2y agoI get why this idea has appeal, but unless you're able to get a large group to do it with great operational security (probably not achievable), I think this story leads to the organizers being endlessly harassed by the police, charged with terrorism, dying mysteriously, or some combination thereof. And if there are enough people willing and able to conduct this sousveillance, maybe their efforts would be better organized by just trying to directly shrink police budgets.
- Teever 2y agoThe thing is, that this kind of sousveillance is what we the people should be doing by default. All people in positions of power should be watched by everyone else to ensure that they're not abusing those positions of power. That's the first step to shrinking parts of police budgets that are excessive and improving parts of their budgets that aren't. I agree with you that this leads to harassment and more from the police but I can't imagine there's any way to deal with them that doesn't involve that outcome. Like that's just what bad people do, and they do it more when you try and stop them from abusing positions of authority.
- abeppu 2y ago> spill some of their greasy secrets like which corrupt cop is cheating on their wife or whatever > Do this publicly, name and shame I think these are the parts that are most likely to trigger dangerous retributive action. I think a less dramatic approach is to make sure everyone's on the same page about how much cops take from our communities and how little they add. I sometimes look at the pay information for my city. A lot of the people making over 400k are cops whose overtime pay is significantly more than their salary. But whenever I see cops, they're just standing around chatting. Even "responding" to some situation, there will be 3 cop cars blocking traffic so 5 of them can chat while one talks on the radio looming over a homeless person in cuffs on the sidewalk. And they take forever to do anything. I watched them take a whole day to try to get a trespasser off the roof of a building across the street. Eventually they ordered several pizzas told the trespasser that he could have some food and ice water if he came down. Then the cops just ate and chatted with each other while blocking traffic and causing a scene for multiple more hours. But sure, they're all legitimately doing 60 hours a week of overtime that's totally necessary police work. This is the kind of thing that can get moderates and conservatives annoyed: those cops are probably making more money than you as they hang out and gab, and they're causing traffic and transit delays. Tell your friends.
- Bostonian 2y agoPeople are generally supportive of the use facial recognition by police, according to a Pew poll from 2021 https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2022/03/17/public-more-likely-to-see-facial-recognition-use-by-police-as-good-rather-than-bad-for-society/ https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2022/03/17/public-more-... '[M]ajorities of the American public believe widespread use of facial recognition would likely help find missing persons and solve crimes, but majorities also think it is likely that police would use this technology to track everyone’s location and surveil Black and Hispanic communities more than others. In terms of potential impact, 46% of U.S. adults say widespread use of facial recognition technology by police would be a good idea for society while 27% believe it would be a bad idea. An additional 27% say they are unsure whether it would be a good or bad idea for police to widely use facial recognition technology.'
- digging 2y ago> People are generally supportive > 46% of U.S. adults say widespread use of facial recognition technology by police would be a good idea for society I wouldn't say the first statement can be reasonably derived from the second, since most people in that poll think it is not a good idea.
- renewiltord 2y ago> I wouldn't say the first statement can be reasonably derived from the second, since most people in that poll think it is not a good idea. 46% good, 27% no idea does not imply majority supportive But it also doesn't mean "most people think it's not a good idea", which in colloquial English would be majority bad idea.
- digging 2y agoThat's fair. Statements: A. majority think it's not a good idea B. majority do not think it's a good idea C. majority think it's a bad idea Usually, A and C would be read as equivalent. I was using A and B as equivalent. But I understand that it's not very clear how I meant it. Certainly B is what's supported.
- CTmystery 2y agoFunny how when one of us finds a workaround it's regarded as a hack and clever and a sign of how talented and 'relentlessly resourceful' we are. When a cop does it, oh god no the sky is falling. Asking a neighboring dept for an assist is within the law and from this own reporting not abused at all. It was used "at least 5 times" (ok, that is lazy, what is the upper bound?) and "no matches were returned". It's not some crazy surveillance state. It's cops trying to catch criminals. Which we need
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- phyzome 2y agoWhat matters is whether the "workaround" is harming people.
- CTmystery 2y agoThe article mentions a guy "charged with aggravated assault for allegedly charging toward someone with a knife". I'd say getting that guy into trial is good for NOT harming people
- AnthonyMouse 2y ago> Funny how when one of us finds a workaround it's regarded as a hack and clever and a sign of how talented and 'relentlessly resourceful' we are. Indeed. Which is why when somebody gets pulled over for speeding and points out that because of the theory of relativity speed limits are meaningless without a frame of reference, but the law doesn't explicitly specify one, and laws are required to be interpreted most favorably to the accused in a criminal case, the police always let them go instead of giving them a ticket. > It's cops trying to catch criminals. Corporations dumping mercury in the river are "businesses trying to create jobs". Muggers are "disadvantaged youths trying to put food on the table". They're supposed to do the second thing but not in that way.
- CTmystery 2y ago
- creer 2y ago> "Police officers’ efforts to skirt these bans have not been previously reported and highlight the challenge of reining in police use of facial recognition." NO! They highlight a systemic issue in the US. Where day to day corruption and cutting corners is a sport. Where much of the population celebrates these forms of "ingenuity" (whether they agreed with the bans in the first place or not.) Even the press - like in this case - considers this minor matters: worth an article on someone's resume but not much more. Sometimes a whole series of such articles (see NSA affairs) - but again not much more. See also "parallel construction" See also private groups such as associations of chiefs of police, sheriffs, etc. On the matter of "sport", perhaps that's because it is: US education celebrates winning at sports, by hook or by crook. And guess which fields favor jocks?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mistermann 2y agoDemocracy is a gift that keeps on giving.
- ysofunny 2y agofunny how this is truly a common point between Texas and California...
- yieldcrv 2y agoI mean if it was anywhere besides Austin sure
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoIt's really not just Austin anymore. All the big cities (Houston, Dallas, San Antonio, Austin, El Paso) are considerably more left-leaning than the rural parts of the state, https://www.texastribune.org/2016/11/11/analysis-blue-dots-texas-red-political-sea/ https://www.texastribune.org/2016/11/11/analysis-blue-dots-t... .
- selimthegrim 2y agoThis is an old map, RGV has turned substantially more Republican since
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoI mean, depends on your definition of "substantially", but yes, there was a big rightward shift, especially of Hispanic voters, in the RGV in 2020 compared to 2016, https://www.politico.com/2020-election/results/texas/ https://www.politico.com/2020-election/results/texas/. There was a ton of hand-wringing and speculation about why this happened. My best guess is because there was a ton of press near the end of the 2020 campaign about Biden saying he would "transition from the oil industry." It obviously has to happen eventually, but this was the case of "a gaffe is when you say the truth out loud". In the RGV many of the best jobs (if really the only good jobs for lots of people) are working in the oil industry and on offshore rigs. Also, obviously, these folks have to deal with the brunt of the migration crisis.
- 2y ago
- IncreasePosts 2y agoPeople often lament loopholes, but understand that the correct course of action is to fix the loopholes, not to expect eg someone to pay more tax than they are legally required to. I don't think it should be any different for police officers - if a city really doesn't want them using facial recognition, then ban the practice, close the loopholes, and put real consequences in place for violating the policy.
- nojvek 2y agoWho's gonna police the police?
- AidenSylvester 2y ago[flagged]