3 ms·
Many argue that smaller scale models are the only way to learn the things needed to make safer bigger models. Yudkowsky thinks they're crazy and will kill us a
by ben_w 3y ago
Many argue that smaller scale models are the only way to learn the things needed to make safer bigger models.
Yudkowsky thinks they're crazy and will kill us all because it will take decades to solve that problem.
Yann LeCun thinks they're crazy and AI that potent is decades away and this is much too soon to even bother thinking about the risks.
I'm just hoping the latter is right about AI being "decades" away, and the former is pessimistic about it taking that long.
- marcosdumay 3y agoIMO, things are looking like somebody will pull AGI outside of their garage once computing gets cheaper enough, and all the focus on those monstrosities based on clearly dead-end paradigms will only serve to make us unable to react to the real thing.
- ben_w 2y agoCould be. But that's why I put any value at all into what Yudkowsky has to say, even though LeCun correctly says that talking about this stuff today is like talking about large scale aviation safety in the 1920s: Yudkowsky is talking about universal incentives that don't rely on any particular paradigm. Metaphorically, he's talking about climate change and LeCun is saying we can't predict the weather a month from now — in both the metaphor and AI these are true satements, so you can see why it's convincing to a lot of people, but it's actually a claim about a different thing. (Yudkowsky may also just be wrong; the metaphor reminds me like many of the climate scientists a century ago who thought it would be a slow transition and an improvement, though obviously I hope he's making the opposite mistake on both counts given how pessimistic he is).