3 ms·
What passes for "AI regulation" is an attempt to divert attention from the real problem - arbitrary exercise of corporate power. AIs which just answer question
by Animats 2y ago
What passes for "AI regulation" is an attempt to divert attention from the real problem - arbitrary exercise of corporate power.
AIs which just answer questions people pose seem to be mostly harmless. Some people might not like the answers, and some of the answers might be wrong. That's true of web search results now. That's just an extension of the social media controversy.
AIs which have authority over people are scary. "AI says No!" This is a
corporate power problem, not an AI problem. If corporations or landlords have arbitrary
discretionary power to affect people's lives, that's the problem. Not that they delegated that
authority to an AI. The EU regulates decisions against individuals made by algorithms.
The EU has already stopped Uber from "robo-firing", where the app back end fired underperforming drivers.
Few proposed AI laws make this distinction. That's because it would raise the issue of arbitrary exercise of power and collective individual rights. That might lead to political unrest, or even unions.
- buzzert 2y agoHow do you disarm corporations from having this power without giving it to the government?
- dns_snek 2y agoThat's an odd question, a democratically elected government is supposed to have the power to regulate, and they're supposed to exercise that privilege in a way that benefits their constituents - but that's a different debate. Corporations, meanwhile, are not supposed to wield disproportionate power over the laws and regulations. Separate issues.
- incangold 2y agoIndeed. Who else do you give the power to regulate companies to? There are no other options.
- NavinF 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-regulatory_organization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-regulatory_organization Works well for the US financial sector despite claims to the contrary
- Rinzler89 2y ago>without giving it to the government? At least the [elected] government is under the responsibility of its citizens, while corporations are only responsible to their shareholders.
- alpinisme 2y agoEven if we entrust governments with enforcing this, that doesn’t mean “arming” the government with the power you’re taking away from employers (arbitrary discretion in firing people, for example) any more than trusting the government to outlaw murder is empowering it to murder
- buzzert 2y ago> any more than trusting the government to outlaw murder is empowering it to murder That is precisely what happens in practice though. Referencing the thousands of people killed by police in the US every year, with little to no accountability (who is to hold them accountable?)
- int_19h 2y agoThat does not happen in other countries, though, even though murder is just as illegal there. Our government in general and our law enforcement specifically are very much out of control in many ways, but that is not an inherent state of affairs.
- buzzert 2y agoI don’t see the government as being very different than a huge corporation. I haven’t seen very much evidence to the contrary, and this isn’t just a US perspective.
- alpinisme 2y agoNo. The government, via the police, can and does kill in the name of enforcing laws. But that power is not related to the fact we’ve made killing illegal for ordinary citizens. Outlawing murder is not what gave the government the right to kill, and outlawing discretionary firings would not be what gives the government the right to fire at its discretion (if it ever claimed that right).
- wunderland 2y agoIn a democracy, the government having this power ostensibly means the people have this power. If the corporations have power beyond the reach of the government, then it's not really a democracy.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Animats 2y agoStrict liability for errors.
- pomian 2y agoThis is and has been already going on. How often do we try to do something at some office, and the answer is no - we ask why? " because the computer says so." We need to keep the human element, alive.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- SpicyLemonZest 2y agoShould proposed AI laws make this distinction? The EU regulates decisions against individuals which are determined by algorithms, but it doesn't and realistically couldn't prohibit a corporate director from running a financial model to help inform whether team X should get more staff. If you want to regulate that director's use of AI to exercise her corporate power, it seems like you have to be concerned about the question-answering AIs which might be easier to use than her spreadsheets.
- phailhaus 2y ago> Some people might not like the answers, and some of the answers might be wrong. That's true of web search results now. Nobody blames Google when the answers are wrong, because search doesn't give you answers. Search only returns results, and it's your job to evaluate those results and decide which is most likely. AI skips this and tries to give you the answer directly, which makes it responsible for its accuracy. But there is no signal for whether an answer is right or not, especially because it usually doesn't give you a source for its response. You have to roll the dice in a way you never have to for search. This is a fundamental issue with AI, which will always exist until it stops pretending to know everything and instead work by finding the answer and being transparent about its "thought process".
- SpicyLemonZest 2y agoI don't think that's an accurate description of how search engines work today. I just googled "What is a dog?", and I don't get any traditional search results at all until I scroll down half a page - the landing UI just shows me an info page describing what a dog is and depicting various breeds of dogs.
- phailhaus 2y agoEach one of those cards is associated with a source that you can go to directly. Google itself isn't "learning" what a dog is and telling you with authority. Instead, it's saying "Here's a bunch of basic stuff about dogs I pulled verbatim from this, this, and this site."
- SpicyLemonZest 2y agoNo, Google is telling me with authority. The UI calls it a "knowledge panel", and the "About this result" descriptor tells me that "This content comes from the Knowledge Graph, Google's collection of information about people, places, and things". Some of it has links to other sites embedded, but multiple displayed components, such as the lifespan and gestation period, have no non-Google source whatsoever associated with them.
- ben_w 2y ago> What passes for "AI regulation" is an attempt to divert attention from the real problem - arbitrary exercise of corporate power. Trouble is, everyone puts a different thing after that dash. It's not that arbitrary exercise of corporate power isn't a thing, it totally is, but AI is every problem that humans can come up with, because AI is all about automating things and solving problems, and that includes as a subset all the bad stuff we do to each other both on purpose and also when we just fail to care about the side-effects of our actions.