5 ms·
4K 1000Hz Monitor Exhibited
- luyu_wu 2y agoThis site is an absolute gem besides the news articles! Grey-to-grey response times of LCDs offset basically any benefit received from higher refresh rates though as they mention. OLED definetly seems like the future here..
- jy14898 2y ago> Unlike mostly human-invisible refresh rate incrementalism (e.g. 240 vs 360), made worse by slow LCD pixel response, geometrics on near-0ms-GtG displays are where mainstream human-visible benefits are. 2x-4x increases in Hz and framerate, such as 120 vs 480, are more human visible.
- Aurornis 2y ago> This site is an absolute gem besides the news articles! They’ve done some great things around information sharing over the years. Interestingly, this site is also where the gaming equivalent of audiophile quackery congregates. Part of their forum (including an admin, IIRC) are convinced that EMI causes stuttering in games. They do things like upgrade the electrical outlets, cables, and other things around their computer and convince themselves that it’s improving their gameplay due to EMI/EMF.
- SushiHippie 2y agoWhat would be the use case for such high refresh rates?
- xnorswap 2y agoDoes better fidelity need a use case?
- thom 2y agoThere has to be some point of diminishing or indeed imperceptible returns.
- lylejantzi3rd 2y agoAccording to LTT, that's somewhere between 240hz and 500hz. Does High FPS make you a better gamer? Ft. Shroud (60hz vs 144hz vs 240hz): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OX31kZbAXsA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OX31kZbAXsA You don't deserve this monitor - does 360hz gaming make a difference?: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3iY0figLAwo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3iY0figLAwo I THOUGHT I Wanted This - AW2524H 500Hz Review: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ewo8tt6bgZU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ewo8tt6bgZU
- aranelsurion 2y agoAs a side observation, the clickbaitness of the titles seem to have increased with LTT over time.
- wongarsu 2y agoIt's only 4 times more than the 240Hz gaming monitors sold by basically every brand. You are getting into diminishing returns. 30->60 and 60->120 are big steps up, both in terms of smoother motion and enabling better human performance. For example various experiments seem to show that tracking enemies in first person shooters is easier with 120Hz. 240Hz is already in the realm where it's better, but not much better. 1000Hz is probably a pretty marginal improvement. But people pay big bucks for marginal improvements all the time. The audio space does much crazier things for much less tangible improvements
- Dalewyn 2y agoAs someone with a 240Hz, 1920x1080 IPS monitor from Dell, I definitely agree 120Hz -> 240Hz is nowhere as big an improvement as 60Hz -> 120Hz is. That being said, I would still buy a 240Hz instead of 120Hz if I had a choice and the price difference isn't that much. There is still a perceivable improvement as far as I'm concerned. On a tangential note, I frankly think 4K (let alone 8K) is a waste of money if you're still rocking 60Hz. The smoothness of 120Hz or above makes a far bigger impact than the higher DPI from rendering 4K. Everything from reading texts to watching videos to playing games benefits from higher refresh rates and to a greater degree than from higher resolutions.
- ssl-3 2y ago> Everything from reading texts to watching videos Video is still generally 24, 25, ~30, 48, 50, or ~60Hz, is it not?
- LightHugger 2y agoVideo needs to catch up to higher refresh rates, but there are also those of us who regularly watch videos at 2x or higher speeds, so there is that edge case where a 60hz video can benefit from a 120hz monitor
- mrob 2y agoYes. And 1000Hz lets you get reasonable frame pacing even at non-integer multiples of 60fps.
- mrob 2y ago1000Hz is enough for near-realistic motion clarity without strobing (which is visible well into the kilohertz via phantom array effect).
- rixrax 2y agoThis is what I am wondering every time I am updating my TV (to a larger model, better HDR, etc. ]). I almost exclusively use the TV to watch movies. Movies that have been shot at 24fps, or 29.97 or 48fps. So this being my use case, all I need is that the player chain and the TV can change refresh rate to the actual movie refresh rate/fps. For my use case, is there anything I am missing here? Or have I been in the wrong all these years to brush off the TV sales guys at the store trying to push me 240Hz etc. latest fads?
- throwuxiytayq 2y agoIf I recall correctly what a TV was, it’s not clear to me why you’d ever want to have one. This article is about monitors.
- wegfawefgawefg 2y agoOkay you. Its common for people to call the big led/oled monitor you put in ur living room a tv. And as far as I know there's no difference between them tech wise. My tv is a 65inch 4k 120hz oled panel. Everyone calls it a tv. They are also still sold as "tv"'s online. Smart tv, etc. Sidenote the word monitor is also a pretty clear sign of age. If I hear somebody call my screen a monitor its like when my grandma calls the toilet the comode.
- Filligree 2y agoThere’s a pretty big difference between them technically, mostly the latency of the display chain. TVs can have signal input to picture on screen latencies of dozens of milliseconds, whereas a monitor would be considered defective if it was more than one frame. This only matters for interactive content, but it’s where a lot of the price difference comes from.
- jasomill 2y agoMost TVs have a "game mode" that reduces latency to a single frame time, give or take a few milliseconds[1]. Not as good as the best monitors, but close, and certainly not dozens of milliseconds. [1] https://www.rtings.com/tv/tests/inputs/input-lag https://www.rtings.com/tv/tests/inputs/input-lag
- Aurornis 2y ago1000Hz is into the point of marketing gimmicks. Higher refresh rates in general produce smoother scrolling, lower latency screen updates, more fluid motion, and a generally more immersive computing experience. Going from 60Hz to 120Hz is a noticeable upgrade for most people, though others don’t notice much. Higher rates offer marginal improvements in smoothness and latency, but it’s really marginal. At 120Hz you’re getting a frame every 8ms (if the GPU can provide it), while 240Hz drops that to 4ms and 1000Hz to 1ms. Competitive FPS gamers will already push hardware and settings to 200+ fps for optimal smoothness. Add AI frame generation and you could get even higher rates, though frame generation introduces its own lag by necessity of having to interpolate between two frames.
- chongli 2y agoThe ability to use touch and drag gestures without any visible delay [1]. This dramatically improves usability as a drawing and painting tool for artists. [1] https://youtu.be/vOvQCPLkPt4 https://youtu.be/vOvQCPLkPt4
- luyu_wu 2y agoGreat video! This is more a problem of the various other hardware interfaces though, considering even a 120Hz panel has a maximum of 6ms of latency between it's refreshes. As a person who does some digital art from time to time though, I'm depressed we still don't have that tech 12 years later...
- chongli 2y agoWell even with a 6ms refresh rate, you still have the inherent LCD grey-to-grey latency issue. Latency is a pipeline issue though. Every stage can add a bit of latency and the total is the sum of all the stages. So with a 120Hz panel you really have a minimum of 6ms latency, with more to be added by software and other hardware in the pipeline.
- atoav 2y agoOne odd usecase is monitors that you can take videos from without weird flicker artifacts.
- londons_explore 2y agoThere are various visual effects that can be done with high frame rates. For example, mount the screen on the wheel of a moving car and show an image spinning the opposite direction at the same speed and it appears stationary. But if you have a low refresh rate, it just appears blurred.
- willis936 2y agoAnother blurbusters article has the answer. We're reaching for "allegory of the cave" tier visual reproductions. https://blurbusters.com/blur-busters-law-amazing-journey-to-future-1000hz-displays-with-blurfree-sample-and-hold/ https://blurbusters.com/blur-busters-law-amazing-journey-to-... https://www.lrc.rpi.edu/programs/solidstate/assist/pdf/AR-Flicker.pdf#page=7 https://www.lrc.rpi.edu/programs/solidstate/assist/pdf/AR-Fl...
- layer8 2y agoCRT-like motion clarity. It will also require higher brightness though, to compensate for black frame insertion.
- prmoustache 2y agoThe simple fact that it is announced by a company selling refresh rate testing hardware shows the improvements in term of ergonomy/real world usage have plateaued past a certain refresh rate. The only remaining practical use case for increases is a metaphorical penis size contest.
- zamadatix 2y agoThe site has been around since anything over 60 FPS was blazing and has been saying 1000 Hz is the ideal target for nearly as long, some articles on why are linked throughout.
- mdre 2y agoThis is cool and all, but it's been 10 years since 4K monitors. Where are (affordable) DUHD ultrawides and why there is not a single 42 inch 6K or 8K panel in the entire world?
- a13o 2y agoThere's not a mainstream use case for 4k content. Show watchers don't care enough about the quality improvement to pay their streaming provider $5 more for the 4k stream. Even the gaming enthusiast market has rejected 4k, opting to spend their precious gpu cycles on refresh rate improvements instead. Panel marketers are going to figure out what number consumers comprehend and make it bigger regardless. Hence their focus on 4k, 8k, and now these silly refresh rates. But their big problem is that consumer behavior is currently bottlenecked by streaming bandwidth and GPU cycles. Two things panel manufacturers have no control over. Buy a nice 1440p @ 120 Hz panel and ride out the next decade in comfort.
- persedes 2y agoThanks for those datapoints. I've checked out of the screen race for over a decade now (around the time 3D glasses were a thing) and have not really kept up. The displays look incredible, but I was always wondering if that was just me or if other people really bothered to keep up with the latest tech to have a slightly better viewing experience.
- varispeed 2y ago> Show watchers don't care enough about the quality improvement to pay their streaming provider $5 more for the 4k stream. I'd say it's more about show producers and safety. They don't want audience to see specks of coke in the host's nose.
- vsskanth 2y agoI see lots of progress and resources put towards monitor refresh rates but very little progress on making 5K displays cheaper. Any reason why ? Is this due to gaming ?
- LeonM 2y agoThe gaming market is huge. And gamers are typically willing to spend top money on hardware (thanks to nVidia raising the bar every time). That's why the market is flooded with expensive 1440p models featuring ridiculous refresh rates and RGB lightning. This is the same reason why you can get a 65" 8K OLED TV from Samsung for "just" €2500, but you still pay €4000 for a Dell 32" 8k monitor. The market for 8k TVs is just so much bigger than 8k computer monitors.
- nordsieck 2y ago> This is the same reason why you can get a 65" 8K OLED TV from Samsung for "just" €2500, but you still pay €4000 for a Dell 32" 8k monitor. The market for 8k TVs is just so much bigger than 8k computer monitors. Speaking of which... the market has this really obnoxious hole in it. There are 32" 8k monitors and 65" 8k TVs (I think there are a few older 55" models), but there's nothing really in between. I really hope someone either makes smaller 8k TVs or larger 8k monitors, because the situation is a little absurd. From what I can tell, 8k monitors are one of the few areas where people could be expected to notice the difference in resolution from 4k at normal viewing distances.
- varispeed 2y agoYou should be able to see the difference on a TV as well. Problem is that there is not much content shot natively at 8k or more.
- nordsieck 2y agoI was going off of this chart[1]. It's true that some people sit relatively close to their TV, but in most of the living rooms that I've been in, the TV has been more than 6 feet away. --- 1. https://i.rtings.com/images/optimal-viewing-distance-television-graph-size.png https://i.rtings.com/images/optimal-viewing-distance-televis...
- amelius 2y agoThe refresh rate is 1000Hz. But let me guess. When you open the sources menu on the monitor, then select one source, you still have to wait 5-10 seconds before it shows anything :/
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mmastrac 2y agoThis would be fantastic for people like me that are extremely sensitive to flicker. LED lights and alarm clocks drive me insane at lower refresh rates because they leave dotted trails at night time. I would kill for a computer that didn't show mouse trails on bright screens. If I move my MBP's cursor around on this HN page, I can count approximately how many frames of cursor I can see. If I had any legislative power, I'd outlaw LED brake lights or headlights with refresh rates lower than 1kHz as well. :)
- Szpadel 2y agoMy car actually have rapidly blinking brake lights as a feature :) this happens only with rapid braking, but it supposedly brings attention more quickly I personally have some dimmable AC LEDs in my home that blink at 50Hz (EU power), that seems to distract only me
- mmastrac 2y agoBlinking for attention is fine. It's more the 50-100Hz flicker that drives me crazy! :)