7 ms·
Men's Shirts Button on the Right. Why Do Women's Button on the Left?
- jeffreygoesto 3y agoTL;DR: We don't really know.
- mcswell 3y agoAnd zippers. I am a man, but I have a jacket that zips the opposite way from most men's zippers (the tab is on the right, the receptacle for the tab is on the left). I suppose that means it's a woman's jacket, although I'm hard pressed to say what else is womanly about it.
- endofreach 3y agoI think european mens clothing has the zipper on the opposite side.
- darreninthenet 3y agoDepends what you mean by European... UK men's clothes are the same side (both before and after Brexit )
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoWhen Americans say European we mean continental, i.e. mainland Western Europe.
- kingkawn 3y agoPretty sure when Americans say European they mostly mean a bizarre conglomeration of stereotypes that fits no actual country
- gsliepen 3y agoTo be fair, that's the same when Europeans talk about Americans.
- yau8edq12i 3y agoThe USA is much, much more homogeneous than Europe.
- beretguy 3y agoI wouldn’t say that. I am from Europe and I’ve never seen as much diversity as in usa.
- michaelt 3y agoJust count the number of official languages.
- grardb 3y agoThe US has no official languages, so by that metric, the US is the most homogenous country in the world. FWIW, as an American living in Europe, I do agree that the US is far more homogenous.
- beretguy 3y agoA lot of people in usa don’t even speak English. I constantly run into those even in the South, let alone big big cities which have posters/ads/instructions label/etc. in foreign languages in public places.
- endofreach 3y agoGuess how many people in europe don't even speak: Bulgarian, Croatian, Czech, Danish, Dutch, English, Estonian, Finnish, French, German, Greek, Hungarian, Irish, Italian, Latvian, Lithuanian, Maltese, Polish, Portuguese, Romanian, Slovak, Slovenian, Spanish or Swedish... or even Esperanto!
- yau8edq12i 3y agoEastern Europe, Northern Europe etc are not "continental"? That's weirdly reductive.
- Rinzler89 3y agoAmericans don't think too much about those "commies" in Eastern Europe when doing comparisons. For them Europe is only where they go on vacation: Paris, Rome, Berlin, Barcelona, Lisbon, etc. Same how for us America is mostly New York, Los Angeles, Texas, etc
- ghaff 3y agoQuite a few Americans vacation in Eastern Europe these days, eg Prague. But you’re right that wasn’t historically the case. I didn’t really until my last job because we had a facility and associated events in Brno in cz.
- closewith 3y agoThree of your examples (Rome, Barcelona, and Lisbon) aren't in Western Europe, so don't fit the GP's definition of continental Europe. My own experience with Americans is that Europe could be any number of definitions. I'd be wary of assuming your own is generally accepted.
- simonbarker87 3y agoIsn’t Lisbon the most western capital city in Europe? Not sure how that doesn’t count as Western Europe? As a Brit I maybe have a different view of eastern and Western Europe but to me the dividing line is probably a vertical line through … Prague?
- walthamstow 3y agoTraditionally the dividing line is Vienna, though that doesn't make it any clearer because Prague is west of Vienna
- lupusreal 3y agoMost Americans consider the UK to be European.
- Angostura 3y agoExcept Ireland, Britain etc is on the same continent.
- toxik 3y agoCan confirm, moving part is held in right hand on everything I own, and also everything my daughter or partner own.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoThe receptacle is the moving part.
- swores 3y ago"Receptacle" isn't seemingly a common term for zips, but you're wrong - in the comment above they definitely use "receptacle" to describe the non-moving part, and as a word it is similar to the term I find on various diagrams of zips for the non-moving part: "retainer" / "retainer box". Quoting their comment: "(the tab is on the right, the receptacle for the tab is on the left)" [in the US]. "Tab" (or "pull tab") is definitely the bit that goes up and down, and it's typically on the right in UK/Europe, but on the left in the US. See for example https://i.pinimg.com/originals/a5/da/f8/a5daf8ec0566dac1826b9cd627dc10f8.png https://i.pinimg.com/originals/a5/da/f8/a5daf8ec0566dac1826b... I'd be curious to know what made you assume receptacle would be the moving part if you don't mind saying? Even though it's not a term I've heard used for zippers before, the second I read it I thought "that's a good clear term that's obviously for the bit that receives the moving tab".
- thaumasiotes 3y agoWhat made me assume that the receptacle is the moving part is pretty straightforward - the moving part is the only part of the zipper that you put something else into. I still don't see how "receptacle" could apply to anything else. You zip up a zipper by picking up the bottom of the other side and inserting that into the moving part. That makes the moving part a "receptacle". The zippers that I'm familiar with don't have bottom stops or retainer boxes. I'm looking at a YKK zipper on my jacket right now; there are two pull tabs, one above the other. This allows you to have the top zipped while the bottom is unzipped. (I should note that my all-American L. L. Bean jacket has the tabs on the right, and I'm inclined to say that this is true generally of American zippers. But I only have the one zipper on hand. This is another reason why indicating that having the receptacle on the left is backwards from normal might tend to indicate that the receptacle is the moving part.) Because it's obvious that the "receptacle" must necessarily refer to the moving part of the zipper (as described above), I assumed that "tab" referred to the bottom of the other side of the zipper, basically just the part of the zipper where the teeth end and the whole thing comes to a stop. I guess in your image this is the "insertion pin". I still feel justified in assuming that the "receptacle" is the part that receives the "insertion pin".
- KineticLensman 3y agoBrit here. I bought a jacket in the US once and the zip was opposite to what I would normally expect.
- HKH2 3y agoIt's okay to wear your jacket inside out.
- throw310822 3y agoSo that from each other's perspective they button on the same side? Makes it quicker to undress each other when the urge comes :)
- rTX5CMRXIfFG 3y agoNo one thinks about the gays
- mbg721 3y agoIt's not like they'd be involved in fashion design in any way.
- hkt 3y agoI always assumed this too, alongside an unfortunate handedness bias
- itomato 3y agoGrab the wrong shirt in the dark a second time? Never.
- mk89 3y agoAhahahah
- isoprophlex 3y agoUntil my brain saw "Button" as a verb, I couldn't really parse that title! "Eats shoots and leaves", haha.
- sakjur 3y agoAnother theory I’ve heard (but have no source for except for a number of unreliable swedish blogs) is that women sat on the left side in the church and men to the right, and the buttons on the side to having the shirts appropriately closed to the other sex.
- bell-cot 3y agoI'd somewhat favor the "women were dressed by servants" theory. While noting that, historically, female servants were extremely common - in even fairly modest middle-class households. And that women who merely aspired to having a servant to dress them would still support that convention for clothing.
- EdiX 3y agoSuppose you sell, or make, clothes. You don't want to sell a man's shirt to a woman or vice versa? With many designs it's obvious but for some it's close but you can't make that mistake so you need an easy, subtle way to distinguish them that won't impact form or function...
- lupusreal 3y agoProbably the same reason women's pants have fake pockets despite many women complaining about not having real pockets. The fashion industry gets stuck in patterns of doing things. Even if some historic reason for button handedness can be found, why does it persist? The industry is stuck in a pattern. The reason it's done that way today is because it was done that way yesterday.
- scaryclam 3y agoAnd shirt + jumper combination outfits, where the "shirt" is just the collar stitched in. Drives me nuts when you see a nice jumper that comes with a "shirt" only to realise you'd need to unpick it to at least get one of them.
- deprecative 3y agoThe fashion industry may get stuck in ruts but it also responds to demand. It's simple that there is no demand for functional pockets for women's clothes despite what is expressed socially. It's quite simple in that regard. To that end, there's no demand to alter button handedness.
- simonjgreen 3y agoHave you also noticed that it’s inverted between US and UK? (At least in my limited experience)
- smitty1e 3y agoMy Barbour jacket was awesome but zipped on the left.
- pantulis 3y agoAnother similar theory, my grandma told that it was because men were dressed by their wives while the women had to dress themselves.
- Gys 3y agoThere is also something like this with belts? I wear my trouser belt always in the same direction and remember (being much younger) once someone said it was the female way. Never give it much thought now but seeing this article I remember that again. I should check this around me.