4 ms·
My dad taught business and finance at a college in the years after he left the AF. The first day of class, he announced that if any of the following were misspe
by WalterBright 3y ago
My dad taught business and finance at a college in the years after he left the AF. The first day of class, he announced that if any of the following were misspelled, it was an automatic F on the test/paper it was on:
business
entrepreneur
there, they're, their
its, it's
should have, could have
The students thought he was kidding (I've seen similar pronouncements in classes I've taken). But he wasn't, and when the hammer fell, the word got around, he never had to enforce it again.
The same went for term papers. They were assigned at the first session, with a hard due date. For every day a paper was late, the grade went down one letter. He said they had the entire term to do them, no excuses were acceptable. After all, in business, excuses are never acceptable.
Half the students submitted the paper a day late, and about 10% 2 days late. Their grades were downgraded as announced.
The next semester, there was only one paper one day late. None the next year.
Expect excellence, and you'll get it.
- squigz 3y ago> After all, in business, excuses are never acceptable. This bit made me chuckle, as a big part of business is coming up with appropriate (sounding) excuses
- WalterBright 3y agoGuess what happens when I'm late on a mortgage payment! And it's even worse if I'm late filing a tax return, or heaven forbid, late on a tax payment. My property tax statement says if I do not file the form on time with the full amount, the check will be returned and I will be liable for late fees plus interest.
- dataflow 3y agoMissing an apostrophe on "its" isn't remotely comparable to missing a mortgage payment, come on.
- WalterBright 3y agoIt's just as easy to forget the tax due date. But I take precautions to not miss it, because it's expensive to miss it. That's the point.
- squigz 3y ago> It's just as easy to forget the tax due date It is?
- dmoy 3y ago> Guess what happens when I'm late on a mortgage payment! It depends on how late. If it's not too late, generally nothing. If it's a little late, a penalty of a few % > And it's even worse if I'm late filing a tax return, or heaven forbid, late on a tax payment. If you don't owe taxes, then you don't even need to file. If you overwithhold, there's no penalty for not filing. If you don't, the the penalty is like a few % of the owed tax, per month late. Similar with nonpayment. And it caps at like 40-50% extra of the owed tax, if you're extremely late (though there's interest too). So actually it's not that bad. But an F on a single paper also isn't that bad either.
- WalterBright 3y agoSome of the taxes I pay have a 20% penalty for being a day late.
- dmoy 3y agoI guess you'd have to clarify which taxes then. US federal tax nonpayment penalty is like 0.5% (of the owed tax) per month.
- WalterBright 3y agoWA state business tax penalty is 9% for a day late, 19% for 6 weeks late, 29% for 9 weeks late.
- gnicholas 3y agoProperty tax in San Mateo County has a 10% penalty for being a day late, even if you have a medical emergency, unless that emergency lasted for 2 months (ask me how I know).
- jncfhnb 3y agoSounds like a great example of shitty metrics that probably have no correlation to standardized test scores.
- WalterBright 3y agoIf you're getting a business degree, what's the excuse for misspelling "business"? None of these requirements were difficult or unreasonable. The students didn't have a problem with them, either. His classes were well-attended.
- giantg2 3y agoThe requirements seem reasonable. The enforced punishment may not be depending on the circumstances. I feel like it's overkill - deduct points but dont make it an automatic F. Do I also get an automatic A in the class if the professor misspelled one? People are human after all, so it might happen. I guess it really sucks for people with language disabilities too.
- yowzadave 3y agoGiven that the requirements are so simple, and they are announced clearly and with plenty of time to comply, this does not seem unfair to me. There are many real-world tasks where an error could result in catastrophic failure--we approach those tasks with caution! It's useful to learn this lesson in college where the worst punishment you can get is just having a grade lowered (and really, when has anybody ever asked you what your GPA was in college).
- giantg2 3y ago"Given that the requirements are so simple, and they are announced clearly and with plenty of time to comply, this does not seem unfair to me." I don't have an issue with the requirements, but rather with the magnitude of the punishment. "There are many real-world tasks where an error could result in catastrophic failure--we approach those tasks with caution!" Then make it more realistic. You got the wrong numbers for the budget, broke an employment law in a mock interview, etc. "and really, when has anybody ever asked you what your GPA was in college" Job interviews right out of college.
- zer00eyz 3y ago> After all, in business, excuses are never acceptable. Clearly your father never built software. This shit is why people make up dates and then expect miracles to happen and then wonder why the code base looks like we empty a portapoty into the repo. Demming is still having a laugh about this type of nonsense.
- WalterBright 3y agoThe Caltech EE91 lab projects usually involved writing software. In one of my early jobs, I was assigned a programming task and given 6 weeks to deliver it. I delivered it in 4. The supervisor made a report via the project management system that I'd delivered it on time. I went to his office and complained about that, saying I wanted the record to show I delivered 2 weeks ahead of schedule. The supervisor said the project management software had no way to enter anything that was ahead of schedule. Another anecdote from the same company: They signed a contract with IBM to write some software for them, and was given 9 months to do it. The company hired a team of about 5 consultants to do it. If the software was delivered on time, each got a $10,000 bonus (this was back when $10,000 was a huge amount of money). The software was delivered on time. I asked one of them, did the bonus do the trick? He said, no, they were professionals. I laughed.
- zer00eyz 3y ago>> consultants I do this now for a living. Phased releases, change of scope means pay out the phase and start a new contract. I collected 75% of cost of ONE project 3 times from a single client... DO A, no do B, no do A... they canceled A for a whole year. I came back and finished it on a new contract the 4th time for 1/2 the first contracts cost (cause it was done). It was not a trivial sum of money either.
- WalterBright 3y agoThere was something similar at Caltech, EE91 lab. At the beginning of the term, you submitted a proposal for a project you would design and build. It had to be approved by the professor. At the end of the term, you turned the completed project in. If it was a day late, or did not meet any part of the spec, you got an F. Otherwise, an A. My project was to design and build a glass tty. But I was careful with the spec, and specified a keyboard entry device. I designed a single board computer out of a 6800 uP, wirewrapped it. I made a keyboard out of random keys. I wrote the software (about 2K of asm). But I did not get the display to work. The prof gave me an F because the display didn't work. But I pointed out that the spec did not require a display(!). So the prof changed it to an A. Later, I finished it and got it all working properly. The EE91 lab space the two days before the due date was packed with students working 24/7 to get their projects done.
- SkyBelow 3y agoI don't really like being overly strict. I think professors and especially teachers have gone too soft on students (often forced to do so by admin), but I also find being too strict means the grade is now less about the topic and more about minor nuances that aren't all that important in the larger scheme. Would you fire a programmer who let a bug slip through? Would it be acceptable to give a zero to a student who had a bug in their code? I've seen successful books with spelling errors. They should be minimized, but having a single spelling error doesn't mean the write gets 0 income. I've seen math professors forget a negative many times, doesn't mean they are idiots who don't know math or that they are no longer worth learning from. I personally find professors who are overly strict to be compensating for not being able to make their material appropriately difficult. Effectively, if they didn't do this, their class averages would be abnormally high. I have many professors with hard classes that taught well yet didn't need to resort to this style of grading to think that one must do this to avoid grade inflation.
- ryandrake 3y ago> Would you fire a programmer who let a bug slip through? Would it be acceptable to give a zero to a student who had a bug in their code? I've seen successful books with spelling errors. They should be minimized, but having a single spelling error doesn't mean the write gets 0 income. I think it depends on the error. For the code example, the code should at least be compilable, with no syntax errors. How could you give anything other than an F on a code assignment that doesn't even compile?
- WalterBright 3y agoCaltech had other institute rules: 1. Calculating intermediate results and carrying them forward was an automatic F. (This was because accumulating roundoff errors was a big no-no, and often if you worked through the algebra a lot of the terms that contributed to errors would cancel out.) 2. Coming up with absurd answers got you not just an F, but negative credit. Caltech expected students to know what was reasonable. Negative energy was not reasonable. If you produced such an answer, you'd need to annotate it with "I know this answer is absurdly wrong, but I cannot find my mistake" and then you'd get partial credit for how far you'd gotten in the derivation. Caltech was training engineers and scientists, where such mistakes can have disastrous consequences.
- dataflow 3y agoI used to enjoy hearing things like this, but it feels better suited to previous generations than today's. In this day and age I feel it's just cruel. You have kids and young adults literally questioning their life's worth and committing suicide over the stress school and the prospects of the future puts over them. Is it really worth hitting someone with a hammer just because the poor soul didn't quite hit the keyboard hard enough to get an apostrophe to appear on the screen that 1 time? The higher the stakes, the more careful anyone will be, but surely that's not a license to increase them arbitrarily?
- WalterBright 3y agoThis was college, not kindergarten. Note that the students did not have any problem with those requirements, and his classes were full.
- dataflow 3y ago> This was college, not kindergarten Were you under the impression it's kindergarteners who are committing suicide?
- WalterBright 3y agoA college cannot operate under the presumption that A's must be handed out so someone doesn't commit suicide.
- dataflow 3y agoNobody was asking for A's to be handed out. Why the constant replies with strawmen? I'm not going to keep continuing.
- WalterBright 3y agoWhat's the minimum grade you think should be handed out in order to maintain the mental health of students?
- gnicholas 3y agoFunny, my kid's teacher regularly hands out ELA worksheets that have these types of mistakes in the instructions/prompts.
- WalterBright 3y agoThe principal of the local elementary school had typos on her public web page.
- ryandrake 3y agoIt warms my heart to hear about someone fighting the good fight over people's atrocious grammar and usage. The battle is completely lost online. I'd add: your/you’re who’s/whose were/we’re/where to/too/two then/than are/our lose/loose wary/weary affect/effect aloud/allowed definitely/defiantly
- WalterBright 3y agoyour/you're, to/too/two were on his list, too. I forgot those. The one I hate is swapping complement/compliment. It's like smoothing a sheet and encountering a burr in it.