2 ms·
They specifically mention railway noise. I wonder whether there's something special about railways, or whether it would work for other noise as well? Especial
by eru 3y ago
They specifically mention railway noise. I wonder whether there's something special about railways, or whether it would work for other noise as well? Especially roads with cars on them?
- metters 3y agoI think there are noises specific to railways. And from what I believe this "MetaWindow" targets relevant frequencies. However, I am sure this also works for the frequencies generated by car traffic. At least the linked youtube video in this comment [1] does not mention anything about frequencies. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40384778 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40384778 EDIT: I was wrong about the video. There is _no mention_ about frequencies.
- crote 3y agoRailways are unique because they go right through the densest part of towns and cities. For them to be most effective, they should be within biking or ideally even walking distance of a significant number of homes and offices. If you place a railway on the outskirts of a city, nobody is going to use it. This means you're going to have to use very significant noise reduction to keep the area livable. Highways care a lot less about location. Place them a one-minute car ride outside the city, and its noise becomes basically irrelevant. The city grows and swallows the highway? Just place an industrial area or mall between the highway and any homes. When homes aren't an arms-length away you can get away with far more primitive noise reduction.