4 ms·
Project Gameface launches on Android
- iAkashPaul 3y agoOff the bat I can see on-device assistants be more capable & allow customized handsfree browser/PDF interaction
- DennisAleynikov 3y agoAwesome news, can’t wait to try it out
- endisneigh 3y agoIt’s a good day for accessibility between this and the stuff apple announced.
- square_usual 3y agoTomorrow is Global Accessibility Awareness Day: https://accessibility.day/ https://accessibility.day/ Hence the announcements, I assume.
- neverokay 3y agoIt’s interesting this tech is for disabled people when Nintendo just assumed their players were disabled to begin with. They always played their games with their left hand to simulate it. Software developers are pretty terrible in applying this kind of empathy in our UX. Assume your app is unusable and the user doesn’t know how to read or have hands. Hah.
- rafram 3y agoLeft-handedness is a disability? What?
- neverokay 3y agoIf you’re right handed, then yeah, playing with your left simulates a handicap. They designed a lot of their games around such handicaps.
- Titan2189 3y agoThey just had to swap out their tester every 6 weeks when they became ambidextrous
- n6h6 3y agoThat isn't what they said, and it's probably not what they meant. What they probably meant was that Nintendo testers use their non-dominant hands to simulate someone who has no prior experience with video game controls. (Though I'm not sure exactly what that would mean. Maybe OP meant they use "backwards" controllers with all the buttons swapped?)
- m463 3y agoIt could be a reminder to developers that they should not assume that they should develop for one kind of player. I remember watching an episode of MKBHD where he played a racing game, and the hands on the wheel were white male hands (he is black). He just looked at the camera and said nothing, but sighed. I thought it was well done. personally I hate PC games that assume WASD, or don't let you remap keys, or make other asumptions that are pretty easy to figure out you shouldn't do.
- neverokay 3y agoshould not assume that they should develop for one kind of player. Or even better, if they accommodate the lowest common denominator, you actually can end up with better experiences for even experienced players. I’m looking at this tech in reverse. Sure it’s going to help the disabled, but it’s also going to enable entire new things in games. I fly around a helicopter a lot in Arma, and I’d love some simple solutions for head and eye tracking just with my web cam and it looks like most of this r&d is happening in the accessibility space, not in the game design space.
- GaggiX 3y ago>I remember watching an episode of MKBHD where he played a racing game, and the hands on the wheel were white male hands (he is black). Is this actually a problem? Should every character you play be the same race and gender as you? Personally, I would not care.
- neverokay 3y agoIt depends how far they go. There are games where they insist I must play as a big titted whore even though I don’t identify as a woman and even if I was a woman, I’d opt for more subtle whoreness not the full whoreness some of these games insist I must role play.
- jaydeegee 3y agoAs a lefty who has written on whiteboards and blackboards I'd say yes in possibly the smallest way possible.
- sunshowers 3y agoI think games are fundamentally different from other software in many ways. For example, games tend to revel in selectively sharing information (Tunic for example) in a way that regular software doesn't. It's hard to apply lessons from one to the other.
- TomatoCo 3y agoI can't recall which standup comedian it was, but he had a bit about games where they're the only form of entertainment that tests you. A song doesn't make you dance along to continue. A book doesn't quiz you on its themes and slam shut if you're wrong. For some games, being hard to play is their point. That's why accessibility is great to make games where that isn't their point more, uh, accessible. And maybe even those hard games should have accessibility, I haven't given that front enough thought yet.
- serf 3y ago>It’s interesting this tech is for disabled people when Nintendo just assumed their players were disabled to begin with. oh, that's why the N64 controller was designed that way, to accommodate those of us with three hands -- I get it now.
- xnx 3y agoEven as a currently able-bodied person it's interesting to think about applications for this. I downloaded the Windows app and did a quick binding of mouth left and mouth right to my arrow keys so I can effortlessly flip through image galleries. (Couldn't figure out how to turn off cursor movement entirely though.)
- avereveard 3y agoAbsolutely. DCS is a plane combat simulator, hevely relies on head tracking for immersion, and the UX is literally you clicking buttons and some are below the HUD and left and right so you need all the head degree of freedom just to look around That doesn't leave much space to zoom in and out which is a issue because visual acuity is greater than monitor fidelity so some degree of zoom is required to keep tab of adversaries It'd be awesome to have a "squint" gesture to zoom in
- fnordian_slip 3y agoAccessibility usually benefits lots of able-bodied people. A lift or long enough ramp helps pregnant people, those with broken legs or the elderly instead of just wheelchair users. Decent UI design with good colours helps not only the visually impaired, and decent keyboard navigation can empower your power users instead of just blind people. It's a shame so many people still see accessibility through a rather narrow lens.
- rvnx 3y agoLast release and code changes on Aug 3, 2023 ?
- devindotcom 3y agoentire android directory added yest https://github.com/google/project-gameface/tree/main/Android https://github.com/google/project-gameface/tree/main/Android
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- disembiggen 3y agowhile I'm hopeful google will be responsible long-term maintainers of this accessibility feature, given their "ship and drop" attitude (music, reader, podcasts, stadia...) I'm glad they've chosen to open source this. In any case, an exciting project!
- simcop2387 3y agoYea given that it's open source, I'm hopeful that it'll keep going as an accessibility tool for a long time. https://github.com/google/project-gameface https://github.com/google/project-gameface
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lakomen 3y ago[flagged]
- dialup_sounds 3y agoHave you considered reading the article? The one that has next to nothing to do with games?
- Fauntleroy 3y agoAlmost feels like OP's message was a "AI" generated
- Onawa 3y agoA quick browse through his comment history shows he's a real person. Just one that only saw the title and had a bone to pick. User also has complaints about Asus, which I also happen to have lol.
- localfirst 3y agoI think they saw "Game" and "Android and immediately made the conclusion about mobile gaming (complaints about dark patterns and pay to win is valid but irrelevant) without clicking the article. This is actually quite prevalent on social media/reddit Many people do not read past the headline but eager to jump on the discussion by being cynical.
- localfirst 3y agoYet to see how well this tech works but congratulations to Google engineers for making this open source. This could be another dimension to gestures that adds even more convenience for end users. ex) Swipe right on Tinder by winking, swipe left by simply blinking.
- solardev 3y agomacOS has a lightweight version of something similar built-in: https://eshop.macsales.com/blog/64948-control-mac-with-head-gestures/ https://eshop.macsales.com/blog/64948-control-mac-with-head-... You can move your head around to move the cursor, smile to click, raise your eyebrows to right-click, and fart to make it to type the embarrassed emoji (not really, lol). But it's pretty cool. Also reminds me of the Dasher app, an eye-tracking typing app with text prediction. You stare at the a letter, one at a time in an ever-zooming tree, in order to form words: https://www.inference.org.uk/dasher/DasherSummary2.html https://www.inference.org.uk/dasher/DasherSummary2.html
- curiousgal 3y ago[flagged]
- ygjb 3y agoKill it? It's a local app, with the model included, and Apache 2.0 license. It might bit-rot, but you could fork and maintain it if you want to.
- yesbut 3y agoCan this be used without internet connections or is it just continuously streaming your face video back to Google?
- ygjb 3y agoThe model runs locally on device, you can find the mediapipe model in the repo.
- maxlin 3y agoWas instantly confused as this is already a name of a product (Coherent Gameface for making a game UI in HTMl5 for multiple engines). Seems this might well be useful, possibly even for normal people. But if I was suddenly full-body paralyzed, I would do everything and anything to get a Neuralink after seeing the first human user of that get ~80% of my score in a test measuring fast and accurate mouse movements.
- chefandy 3y ago> Neuralink Yeah, but that's not a realistic hope even among fairly wealthy Americans right now, and its many orders of magnitude less accessible to most of the world. Considering the smartphone market penetration in some profoundly impoverished areas, this could be really huge for a whole lot of people.
- numpad0 3y agoBesides that project is just "some sucker is gonna come and figure it out for me" bounty in form of a company, and importantly built on a known dead end
- ZoomerCretin 3y ago[flagged]
- rsingla 3y agoAs tech giants delve deeper into markets like gaming, do they enhance the industry by driving innovation and offering new platforms, or could this stifle smaller developers and lead to less diversity in the gaming landscape?
- gokuldas011011 3y agoGaming industry couldn't have any worse-er giants
- immibis 3y agoIf it's Google, the answer seems to be: no. Nothing happens except Google pays a bunch of developers a bunch of money.
- chpwssn 3y agoIssue #1 is still an interesting albeit sad read https://github.com/google/project-gameface/issues/1 https://github.com/google/project-gameface/issues/1
- tripdout 3y agoWith Laurence's response it doesn't sound like he stole anything at all.
- mertd 3y agoYes, people should read the whole thread instead of jumping to conclusions after the first post.
- nullify88 3y agoBut it does seem like there was an opportunity to collaborate?
- flumpcakes 3y agoI think there's a gap between "opportunity to collaborate" and "my life is hell and you stole my idea"? If something is open source (and licensed appropriately) then even collaboration becomes moot. There are a lot of takers in the world, and not many givers.
- dagmx 3y agoTo what end though? They’d exist at completely different ends of the technical stack to the point where it’s likely very unusable for the final product. Even though they do similar things, it’s very doubtful collaboration would have netted anything.
- politelemon 3y ago> Since the issue was raised on HackerNews -- my life has been hell. Not an hour goes past without some kind of personal attack that ranges from a shaming to an outright physical threat. It has affected my livelihood, my career, and my health. It destroyed a family vacation when I was supposed to unplug. Nobody deserves that, and certainly not someone who is innocent of what they are accused of. Please be aware of that should you ever feel emotional again. We are toxic and we're not seeing it. We should stop posting a link to that thread imo.
- rock_artist 3y agoThe biggest issue I see with such things is lack of standarization. For us lucky, "regular" human beings, the interfaces has some standardisation. - Touchpad - Touchscreen - Keyboard We can complain on some minor differences but it's not like going from one device to the other the controller becomes that much different. Ideally, if big tech players are into really making such things useful (eye-tracking, face gestures, etc), there should be standardisations. So if I need those accessible interfaces, they're agnostic as possible to the platform itself.
- c0deR3D 3y agoIn the near future, people can control appliances with purely their own consciousness, and the only prerequisite is that it requires a minimum consiciousness level, which is reachable for most of the human being. Lastly, we usually think that people living in the Stone age are primitive people. Are they? https://twitter.com/Michell51304 https://twitter.com/Michell51304