6 ms·
I love accessibility features because they might be the last features developed solely with the benefit of the user in mind. So many other app/os features are d
by xnx 3y ago
I love accessibility features because they might be the last features developed solely with the benefit of the user in mind. So many other app/os features are designed to steal your attention or gradually nerf usefulness.
- stacktrust 3y ago> developed solely with the benefit of the user in mind Hopefully accessibility features are never artificially segmented to higher priced devices.
- corps_and_code 3y agoI wonder if that would be legal, at least in the US. That feels like it'd be a violation of the ADA?
- diebeforei485 3y agoIt would only be a violation if it's purely software locked. If it requires a chip that supports specific operations, and entry tier devices have an older chip, that wouldn't be a violation.
- Loughla 3y agoAt least in the US, they kind of can't be. The disability community is pretty up front about lawsuits.
- stacktrust 3y agoiOS 17 audio image descriptions for blind people via Image Magnifier should work on all iPhones, but do not work on iPhone SE3 and iPhone 11 Pro. Audio image descriptions do work in iPhone 12 Pro. Lidar in 12 Pro increases accuracy, but should not be mandatory. Hopefully this is a bug that can be fixed, since text descriptions were still functional on the lower-end devices. Source: purchased devices until finding one that worked, since Apple docs indicated the feature should work on all iPhones that can run iOS 17. Edit: audio descriptions in Magnifier are non-functional on iPad Air, working on M2 iPad Pro.
- pxc 3y agoThat's because the ADA has no enforcement mechanism other than lawsuits, isn't it? Our whole legal disability rights infrastructure is designed to be driven by lawsuits, and sits inert if nobody sues.
- miki123211 3y agoThat's actually a good thing, especially if there are people specializing in bringing these lawsuits en-masse. Over here in Europe, where there's no lawsuit culture, some laws (not necessarily accessibility-related, our legislation in that area is far weaker) are violated almost without repercussions. When the government is the only party that can bring charges and the government is complacent / ineffective, nobody actually gets charged and nothing gets done. There's also the problem of incentives, if you can get a lot of money from a lawsuit, you have a far better incentive to sue and find a competent lawyer. You may even deliberately look for and sue violators as a moneymaking scheme, some companies in the US do this. This puts pressure on businesses to comply with the law. Even if you're piss-poor and never sue anybody, you still benefit. If this lawsuit culture doesn't exist, the best you can do is write a report to the government and hope they actually act on it. Many people don't know how to write these, and since there's no money in it, getting a lawyer to do it for you is an expense that nobody is going to help you recoup. The people handling these reports don't help either, they're usually 9-to-5 salaried employees who aren't judged too hard on performance, so they have far less of an incentive to actually pursue cases.
- miki123211 3y agoSome of them are, at least on Apple's side, but it's always for a good technical reason. Screen recognition is only available on devices that have a neural chip, things that require lidar don't work on devices that don't have lidar and so on. Google is worse at this, Talkback multi-finger gestures used to be Pixel and Samsung exclusive for a while, even though there was no technical reason for it. Apple has a different problem, many accessibility features aren't internationalized properly. Screen recognition still has issues on non-english systems, so do image descriptions. Voice Over (especially on Mac) didn't include voices for some of the less-popular languages until very recently, even though Vocalizer, their underlying speech engine, has supported them for years. Siri has the same problem.
- snoman 3y agoEvery attention thief is absolutely thrilled at the idea of tracking your eyes. Let’s all imagine the day where the YouTube free tier pauses ads when you’re not actively looking at them. Shit. I’m turning into one of those negative downers. I’m sorry. I’ve had too much internet today.
- Tagbert 3y agoIf this is at all like the eye tracking in Vision Pro, it is only available to the OS and apps are not given access to the data.
- happyopossum 3y agoUntil the EU comes in and forces them to ‘open up’ the functionality in the name of ‘fairness’…
- Tijdreiziger 3y agoIf you look at the current things the EU has forced them to open up (app distribution and NFC payments), both of them are things that Apple was already actively monetizing. To compare this to a non-monetized accessibility feature is a bit disingenuous. The whole notion of ‘fairness’ is that gatekeepers should allow others to compete on even footing. That can be fulfilled by granting EITHER everybody OR nobody access to the market (but not: only yourself).
- mistrial9 3y agofor now - it is naive to think this is safe
- sroussey 3y agoEye tracking has been on iOS for many years (as an option for faceid called attention).
- 3y ago
- jonpurdy 3y agoI often use them to get around bad UI/UX (like using Reduce Motion), or to make devices more useful (Color Filters (red) for using at night). Even outside of this, even able-bodied folks can be disabled due to illness, surgery, injury, etc. So it's great to see Apple continuing to support accessibility.
- gerry_shaw 3y agoThe red color filter for outside when trying to preserve night vision is a great tip. Some apps have this built-in but much better to have the OS change it everywhere. Recommend creating a Shortcut to toggle this setting.
- throwanem 3y agoYou can also add it to the accessibility shortcut, available anywhere by triple-clicking the power button.
- dylan604 3y agoThe issue I've seen when the app itself offers a red filter is if that app calls an OS native widget like a keyboard does not get filtered. The system level accessibility feature does filter the OS widget. I would almost rather the app's setting to just enable the OS filter, but I can understand why that might not be possible.
- justsomehnguy 3y ago> Recommend creating a Shortcut to toggle this setting. Huh? It's not built-in? Android (or at least Moto) has it for years, auto enable on the schedule or the sunrise/sunset.
- ben_w 3y agoThere's a built in "night shift", but that just changes the colour temperature, it doesn't make everything monochrome red.
- ErigmolCt 3y agoAccessibility features stand out as user-centric developments, love that
- ljm 3y agoI don't love that solid UX gets pushed under the accessibility rug, as an option you might never find. I don't care how cynical it sounds, user experience became user exploitation a long time ago. Big Tech have been running that gimmick at too-big-to-fail scale for the last decade or so.
- philistine 3y agoAccessibility benefits everyone, but in the basics you’re right. Too many simple straightforward options are now strictly inside accessibility. At least on the Apple side. And don’t get me started on hidden command line settings.
- a_wild_dandan 3y agoI'm here to intentionally get you started on hidden CLI settings. Learn me somethin'!
- ibll 3y agonot OP, but macOS has a ton of options available with arcane commands. my favorites are the auto-hide dock speed setting, the third hidden window minimise animation, and the hidden system accent colours usually locked to the colourful iMacs
- philistine 2y agohttps://github.com/mathiasbynens/dotfiles/blob/main/.macos https://github.com/mathiasbynens/dotfiles/blob/main/.macos
- nottorp 3y ago> Too many simple straightforward options are now strictly inside accessibility. <cough> Reduce Motion. Is it an accessibility feature or does it just get rid of an annoyance and is good for everyone?
- ornornor 3y ago
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoFunny, I was just thinking it was so that they can get more attention-economy eyeballs for ads.
- 0xEF 3y agoThis will happen. These features are always ushered in as ways to make someone's life easier, and often that is exactly what it does, for a time, before some product manager figures out how they can maximize profit with it. Growth at all costs, I guess.
- cqqxo4zV46cp 3y agoDon’t say “I guess” as if you aren’t the one making the rather baseless accusation. What other accessibility features have been abused?
- astrange 3y agoApple doesn't have product managers. (More importantly, the hardware has been technically capable of eye tracking since Face ID was added.)
- bentruyman 3y agoCan you name a single accessibility feature where this has happened ever? Kinda seems like you just made up some fake reality.
- lucb1e 3y agoWouldn't a lot of the companies that build in accessibility do it from a viewpoint of gaining an even wider reach and/or a better public image? I don't see optimizing for that as bad. If they think we'll love the product more by making it better for a given audience, especially if I'm in that audience, I'm happy. Does that mean this company now gets richer? Perhaps, and that's fine by me
- tambourine_man 3y agoThat’s a profound and surprising insight. You’re absolutely correct.
- hanniabu 3y agoAccessibility features can be used to steal attention too