4 ms·
We have a not quite and ally fighting a war, I'm sure they will take a donation of 10 missiles and one will go off course from a nearby military target [wink wi
by bluGill 3y ago
We have a not quite and ally fighting a war, I'm sure they will take a donation of 10 missiles and one will go off course from a nearby military target [wink wink] and hit this address for us.
- free_bip 3y agoPreeeeeetty sure that's a war crime, not that the US is any stranger to those
- psunavy03 3y agoIf it's the Ukranian military doing the launching and the targets are KGB/FSB or otherwise aiding the Russian government, that's not a war crime. It's hitting a legitimate military target. But please feel free to snark on the US military; I know that's cheap karma around here.
- GauntletWizard 3y agoNo, targeting opposing warfighters (the hackers are certainly such) is not a war crime, even if they attempt to hide among civilian populations. Nor is lying about the specifics of your targeting.
- free_bip 3y agoI don't understand how a hacker that's targeting US infrastructure would be considered an "opposing warfighter" in the context of the Russia-Ukraine war?
- GauntletWizard 3y agoYou think his targets are limited to the US? A general doesn't have to be assigned to the front to be a valid target.
- selfmodruntime 3y agoThey are an opposing warfighter in the Russia led global destabilization efforts.
- vkou 3y agoIf bombing a hacker's house isn't a war crime, is a Russian missile hitting a mall in LA, because a colonel working in logistics took his kids shopping there also kosher, or..? I assume the triumphant press release would be something like 'a number of confirmed enemy fighters killed'. It's always interesting to see warhawks (who have never been the victims of war) do their best to expand the list of who they consider acceptable enemy targets are, with no regard to what this means to them, domestically.
- bluGill 3y agoIf russia played nice with the world they would extradit this guy to the courts. Since russia won't all that is left is war.
- vkou 3y agoSo, you're telling me that the US refusing to extradite a national is, indeed, sufficient justification for another country to start bombing LA? Or is it one of those 'we make the rules, but we aren't bound by them' things?
- ribosometronome 3y agoIt seems pretty obvious that America is playing by the rule of "We have the power, so you're going to do what we say" when it comes to these scenarios. I find it hard to imagine, for example, an assassination on an American official of rank similar to Qasem Soleimani would result in nearly as timid of a response as Iran gave.
- bluGill 3y agoThe us generally will extradite if your justice system isn't corrupt. There are exceptions, but everyone has them.
- vkou 3y agoDemonstrably false. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Service-Members%27_Protection_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Service-Members%27_Pr... > The Act authorizes the president of the United States to use "all means necessary and appropriate to bring about the release of any U.S. or allied personnel being detained or imprisoned by, on behalf of, or at the request of the International Criminal Court". > This authorization led to the act being colloquially nicknamed "The Hague Invasion Act", as the act allows the president to order U.S. military action, such as an invasion of the Netherlands, where The Hague is located, to protect American officials and military personnel from prosecution or rescue them from custody.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoOnly if cyber attacks don't make you an enemy combatant. The line between civilian and military is blurred often intentionally.
- sedev 3y agoPlease go into detail about how this would be implemented, with particular attention to what could go wrong at each stage of the process and what the consequences would be, especially consequences originating from stakeholders who possess nuclear weapons and whose territory you are proposing to exert military force against, and compare the difficulty and expense of implementation in terms of expected value to the magnitude of what might be gained by a successful operation of this kind. Yes, I mean "you clearly did not think about this and your idea is very, very, very bad."
- bluGill 3y agoappeasing brutes like russia has a long history of not working.
- vkou 3y agoFalse dichotomy, there are many responses on the spectrum between 'do nothing' and 'start a war with a nuclear power'. (Also, what about when we act like brutes? Why do other countries tolerate us? Should they not, like, get together and push back, or something?)
- bluGill 3y agoRussia started this war - have you forgotten that they have troops in Ukraine right now?
- vkou 3y agoI seem to have forgotten the part where the US is at war with Russia. Pray tell, what day was it declared? Should I be running for my crazy prepper bunker? But I'm glad that you mentioned the proxy war that is being fought right now, that's one example of how you can respond to a country's bad behavior without actually starting a war with it. There are many others.
- sedev 3y ago"appeasing brutes like russia has a long history of not working" is a true statement that, in this context, does not do any of the work one would like a true statement to do, but it does do much of the work that one would like a statement to do if one were behaving with malice and dishonesty. It collapses the critique it's replying to into an inaccurate summary ("all of the things you said amount to 'appeasing Russia'") and uses a weighted, emotionally loaded verb to do so ("appeasing"). What this response actually says is "all of the problems that sedev pointed out are irrelevant because Russia is bad," and I am not surprised that you didn't say that out loud because when it's said directly, it's obviously wrong. Do better.