4 ms·
The license is not good: https://falconllm-staging.tii.ae/falcon-2-terms-and-conditions.html https://falconllm-staging.tii.ae/falcon-2-terms-and-conditio... It
by simonw 3y ago
The license is not good: https://falconllm-staging.tii.ae/falcon-2-terms-and-conditions.html https://falconllm-staging.tii.ae/falcon-2-terms-and-conditio...
It's a modified Apache 2 license with extra clauses that include a requirement to abide by their acceptable use policy, hosted here: https://falconllm-staging.tii.ae/falcon-2-acceptable-use-policy.html https://falconllm-staging.tii.ae/falcon-2-acceptable-use-pol...
But... that modified Apache 2 license says the following:
"The Acceptable Use Policy may be updated from time to time. You should monitor the web address at which the Acceptable Use Policy is hosted to ensure that your use of the Work or any Derivative Work complies with the updated Acceptable Use Policy."
So no matter what you think of their current AUP they reserve the right to update it to anything they like in the future, and you'll have to abide by the new one!
Great example of why I don't like the trend of calling licenses like this "open source" when they aren't compatible with the OSI definition.
- cs702 3y agoWell, that really sucks. Thanks But No Thanks.
- tantalor 3y agoIt's probably unenforceable
- Perz1val 3y agoMaybe, but would you risk trying?
- SiempreViernes 3y agoWhen it is backed by the UAE the muscle you have to contend with is not simply legal muscle, it also includes armed muscle of questionable moral fibre (see support for the RSF).
- CityOfThrowaway 3y agoDo you have any examples of the UAE using its military force to force foreign companies to abide a contract?
- notatoad 3y agothey're not going to send their army after you, but that's not what this means. friendly middle-eastern countries negotiate all kinds of concessions from western governments in exchange for allowing military operations to stage in their country, and "we want you to enforce our IP laws" is an easy one for western governments to grant.
- davedx 3y agoHow is changing a software licence unenforceable?
- tantalor 3y agoscolson said it best: You can retroactively make a license more open, but you cannot retroactively make it more closed. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10672751 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10672751
- selimthegrim 3y agoDidn’t Oracle try with OpenSolaris?
- CuriousCosmic 3y agoAnd even then you aren't retroactively making it more open. You are just now offering an additional, more open license as well as the existing one. You haven't taken the original license away, you just provided a better default option. The same weirdly enough goes in reverse as well. You can provide a more restrictive license retroactively even if the rights holders don't consent as long as the existing license is compatible with the new, more restrictive license. i.e. you can promote a work from Apache-2.0 to GPL-3.0-or-later as the former is fully compatible with the latter. However you can't stop existing users from using it as Apache-2.0, you can only stop offering it yourself with that license (but anyone who has an existing Apache-2.0 copy or who is an original rights holder can freely distribute it).
- binarymax 3y agoNot the first time they did some license shenanigans (happened with Falcon 1). I applaud their efforts but it seems they are still trying to figure out if/how to monetize.
- Havoc 3y agoThey’ve got Saudi oil money behind them no? Falcon always struck me more as a regional prestige project rather than “how to monetise”
- spacebanana7 3y agoI doubt the Emiratis have much interest in monetisation. The value they’re probably looking for is in LLMs as a media asset. Just like Al Jazeera is valuable for Qataris and sports are valuable for the Saudis. These assets create goodwill domestically and with international stakeholders. Sometimes they make money, but that’s secondary. If people spend a few hours a day talking to LLMs there’s some media value there. They may also fear that Western models would be censored or licensed in a way harmful to UAE security and cultural objectives. Imagine if Llama 4’s license prevented military use without approval by some American agency.
- abhorrence 3y ago> So no matter what you think of their current AUP they reserve the right to update it to anything they like in the future, and you'll have to abide by the new one! I'm so curious if this would actually hold up in court. Does anyone know if there's any case law / precedence around this?
- davedx 3y agoOf course, projects change their licences all the time, why wouldn't it be legal? There's a long history of startups who started with open source/open core gradually closing off or commercialising the licence. This isn't anything new at all. This is why it's good to read licenses before adopting the tech, especially if it's at all core to your business/project.
- tux3 3y agoNo. Projects sometimes stop offering the previous license and start using a different one for new work. But if your project is Apache-2, you cannot take away someone's license after the fact. You can only stop giving away new Apache-2 licenses from that point on. The difference here is the license itself has mystery terms that can change at any time. That, is very much not done all the time.
- mmoskal 3y agoProjects change license for new code going forward. The old code remains available under the previous license (and sometimes new). Here, they are able to change the conditions for existing weights.
- wtallis 3y agoReleasing a new version with a new license is not the same as retroactively changing the license terms for copies already distributed of existing versions.
- Havoc 3y agoThe 40b model appears to be pure apache though
- coder543 3y agoThat is Falcon 1, not Falcon 2. Falcon 1 is entirely obsolete at this point, based on every benchmark I've seen.
- JimDabell 3y agoSo basically you can never use this for anything non-trivial because they can deny your use-case at any time without even notifying you.
- dclowd9901 3y ago[flagged]
- worldsayshi 3y agoAre licenses that can be altered after the fact even legal? Feels like more companies would use them if it was...
- Domenic_S 3y agoA large company I work for declined to buy licenses from a supplier that had this clause. From my understanding it's not really legal - or at worst it's a gray area - but the language is just too risky if you're not looking to be the test case in court.
- taneq 3y agoExactly. It’s not about whether it’s enforceable, it’s about the fact that a sketchy license indicates that they might not always operate in good faith.
- tptacek 3y agoWhy wouldn't they be? The starting presumption for a new work is that you have no permission to use it at all.
- xmprt 3y agoI suppose a better question would be "how drastic can the change be to the license?" because by adding that term, you're basically superseding every other term on the license. How do licenses deal with contradictory terms if that's even possible?
- darby_eight 3y ago> Great example of why I don't like the trend of calling licenses like this "open source" when they aren't compatible with the OSI definition. Open source was always a way to weasel about terms, that's why it's open source and not free.
- croes 3y agoMore the other way around. Just because it's free doesn't mean you can change anything or get the source. Some claim something is open source but it's just for free.
- hhreefgguu 3y ago[flagged]
- basil-rash 3y ago[flagged]
- darby_eight 3y ago> Just because it's free doesn't mean you can change anything or get the source. Free as in speech, not beer. > Some claim something is open source but it's just for free. Gratis, not free.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]