7 ms·
PeaZip: Open-source file compression and encryption software
- theandrewbailey 3y agoI've been using this for over a decade. I keep using it because it extracts files directly where you want them, instead of extracting to a temp folder, then copying to where you want, multiplying IO traffic by up to 2. It also lets me use 7z files with zstd compression, though I'm not sure which other software supports it.
- shawnz 3y agoMoving files from one directory to another directory on the same filesystem doesn't actually result in any data getting moved, only the directory entries are changed
- iwwr 3y agoIn some restricted environments (e.g. containers in CI, build servers or AWS Lambda) you may have limited disk space or no write access at all, so it is useful to have a tool that can stream to memory while decompressing on the fly, and discarding what you don't need.
- maccard 3y agoYou’ve made a big assumption about being on the same file system there. We had a CI job that was spending an awful lot of time in fetching cached artifacts. We investigated and it turns out that CI was pulling to %TMP%, but we were actual executing the builds on a separate EBS volume meaning we downloaded and wrote to an EBS volume, then had to copy it to another remote volume, it was super easy to spot on windows, but I’m not sure I would have twigged it as easily if we were moving from /tmp to /data/dira
- shawnz 3y agoSure, but you're probably not using PeaZip (which is primarily a GUI front-end for existing compression tools) in CI or containerized environments. For those situations there are specialized tools which are more appropriate.
- maccard 3y agoI’m not in this case, but if something writes to /tmp and then copies it to /data, there is no guarantee that they are on the same device or even network.
- bravetraveler 3y agoLet's start slicing the pie, everyone. On Linux this is becoming a rarity; '/tmp' (the usual $TMPDIR) is mounted using tmpfs, a distinct memory-backed filesystem. Windows on the other hand is happy for this to reside on your physical disk, persistently. I think - this isn't my area. This almost guarantees your "yes, but" doesn't apply for anyone using Fedora Linux, for example. I dare say nearly any distribution that includes systemd, and probably/consequently, 'tmp.mount'. While it is memory backed, one can only copy/read from this as fast as the destination can write.
- edflsafoiewq 3y agoYou shouldn't use /tmp for that for that reason. aunpack for example extracts into a temp directory in the same directory as the final destination.
- bravetraveler 3y agoI'm fine with either, I think you and Andrew at the top of the thread agree - PeaZip does as you suggest. I'm just piling on :D Things that naively use temporary directories otherwise may run into an extra copy... because it's not necessarily on the same filesystem. It's rare, in fact, on modern Linux
- dataflow 3y ago/tmp is often not tmpfs, in fact. /dev/shm or /var/run are.
- bravetraveler 3y agoYes, and? It still is very common to find. Turns out things aren't homogeneous. People often both die forever-alone and happily married, too. I already said it's up to the distribution. I wasn't really interested in splitting it more than I have, I hoped to avoid it... but let's go. It's been upstream over a decade https://github.com/systemd/systemd/commits/main/units/tmp.mount https://github.com/systemd/systemd/commits/main/units/tmp.mo... Participation, as always, has been/remains optional. Anything using 'systemd' will likely have this be 'tmpfs', unless 'ConditionPathIsSymbolicLink' is violated. Anything not using 'systemd' is a niche that most of the industry ignores. See how uninsightful/unhelpful these statements are? More specifically, this leaves the one directive/condition to consider... and a subset of a subset that's relevant - systems using runit/s6/whatever. Anyway, that's the fun thing about 'often'. It both often is and isn't. Put simply, word games. We're both right, '/tmp' often is and isn't 'tmpfs'. It's an implementation detail. It's codified into some standards, and it turns out some distributions are more prepared/cognizant than others. The inconsistency in applying this makes the assertion that lead to this whole thread off base. edit: I originally mistook the last edit two years ago for the creation time - adjusted. This has been established for ~14 years!
- baal80spam 3y agoThe trick to do it using the default 7zip file manager is to open the .7z file in the manager (double clicking it, not right clicking it), and extract the archive whenever you want it - it will be extracted straight there with no transition using temporary folder.
- Adj_and_Styles 3y agoThe atool script is just a wrapper around many compression tools. Try atool -x which creates the temp folder under final destination. https://www.nongnu.org/atool/ https://www.nongnu.org/atool/ Edit: just noticed it was mentioned in other reply, but as aunpack, a symlink to atool. I got used to the -x|-l|-a|... style and rarely remember the alternative names.
- causality0 3y agoCan anyone explain why this is better than 7zip?
- jsheard 3y agoI don't know if this is better, but 7zips developer has an unnerving track record when it comes to security practices. He resisted adopting basic mitigations like DEP and ASLR for a long time, only relenting after a security researcher basically begged him to after finding arbitrary code execution exploits, and he still doesn't want to use any more advanced hardening techniques because they (slightly) bloat the binary size or have a (tiny) performance overhead. I'm all for lean software but breaking ASLR by stripping the relocation tables, just to shave a few kilobytes off an executable which is primarily intended to parse untrusted files is just reckless.
- lobito14 3y agoCan you please provide the source of this thread?
- tylerritchie 3y agohttps://landave.io/2018/01/7-zip-multiple-memory-corruptions-via-rar-and-zip/ https://landave.io/2018/01/7-zip-multiple-memory-corruptions... but also see: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16986377 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16986377
- lobito14 2y agoThank you.
- soraminazuki 3y agoPeaZip appears to rely on 7zip for most of its supported formats. So Peazip isn't really an alternative if you want to avoid 7zip out of security concerns. > 7z ... should be placed in (peazip)/res/bin/7z, to manage 7Z files and most of the other supported formats https://peazip.github.io/peazip-sources.html https://peazip.github.io/peazip-sources.html I personally like libarchive and its bsdtar CLI, which also supports a wide range of formats. I don't know if there's any popular GUI frontend for it though. https://libarchive.org https://libarchive.org
- sneak 3y ago> Offer two factor authentication (password + keyfile) for all formats supporting encryption, to increase security against guessing and dictionary based attacks on weak passwords. uhhh, that’s not how symmetric encryption works. We have salted password-based (PB) KDFs for exactly this purpose. Encryption probably doesn’t belong in the compression container format.
- Retr0id 3y agoPeaZip also uses a PBKDF (PBKDF2). No longer the latest and greatest, but fine.
- lucb1e 3y agoI guess I agree with calling PBKDF2 fine, but it may be good to know the caveats: - Just because it says it uses PBKDF2 doesn't mean it is strong. The strength fully depends on the number of rounds it uses, and especially in legacy (>10 years old) software I see it a lot that some amount of rounds are hardcoded which can now be computed in a few milliseconds on a CPU - PBKDF2 gives the attacker a ~1000x speedup. If your CPU spends 2 seconds on computing the hash every time, an attacker with a run-of-the-mill GPU spends 2 milliseconds per guess (500 guesses per second). Using something like Bcrypt or Argon2, that speedup gets to iirc "only" 12x (so if you spend 2 seconds, the attacker spends ~170 milliseconds or 6 guesses per second). Iirc this speedup is due to GPU RAM being faster than the main RAM. So while PBKDF2 isn't great, it's also not like it's broken: this has been a known property since forever and it's still orders of magnitude better than a plain hash
- lucb1e 3y agoThe quote is correct. It does not say they're not using a KDF or salting, which you seem to read into it? The keyfile is the "something you have" and the password "something you know", so two-factor checks out, even if it's not a time-based token that people expect nowadays (though TOTP is essentially the same but on another device, extracting time-based short codes from the long key to make it convenient to type over). No matter how good your KDF, a weak or reused password can still be crackable, so a key file can make sense even if you use a salted KDF
- lobito14 3y ago[flagged]
- cess11 3y agoLooks fine in landscape on my hand-held.
- efilife 3y agoDo you use your phone in landscape mode?
- pheatherlite 3y agoLooks fine in portrait on my Samsung galaxy s20 on Firefox. Sure, it's not "mobile first class" websit, but it's a desktop application after all
- gkbrk 3y agoWhy? Were you planning to use it on mobile?
- c0l0 3y agoPeaZip is great software, and doubly so because it is written using Lazarus and compiled with Free Pascal. I highly recommend giving it a try, if only to experience that high quality software can be built using tools that lead you somewhat off the beaten path. Unfortunately, its lead developer has recently posted[0] that he has to undergo what seems to be complicated, major eye surgery, and that he will probably be unable to continue development :( [0]: https://old.reddit.com/r/PeaZip/comments/1bn7pu0/communication_from_the_developer/ https://old.reddit.com/r/PeaZip/comments/1bn7pu0/communicati...
- stefanos82 3y agoSeems like he's doing OK, thank goodness! https://old.reddit.com/r/PeaZip/comments/1cpdvum/peazip_980_released/ https://old.reddit.com/r/PeaZip/comments/1cpdvum/peazip_980_...
- cxr 3y agoNeither the existence of this link nor anything in it contradicts the developer's earlier post. It looks like the situation was inaccurately summarized by the HN user with the top comment here—the PeaZip developer didn't announce that he or she was going to stop working on PeaZip.
- parhamn 3y ago> Drag & drop from app to system is certainly a mayor usability boost, but it is not simple to implement as it requires a dedicated solution for each supported OS and desktop environment. Off topic, but this is why many devs choose electron.
- NavinF 3y ago> and desktop environment Off topic, but this is why many devs choose not to support Linux. Every distro is its own special snowflake
- patrickaljord 3y ago
- Dwedit 3y agoPrograms like 7-zip and PeaZip both have an unusual feature: Ability to explore NT paths that Windows Explorer will refuse to load. You can go to a path like "\\?\Harddisk0Partition2\" in 7-zip file manager or PeaZip. On my PC, that happens to be the EFI partition. (Need to run as Admin before it lets you access the EFI partition) Sysinternals WinObj will let you see all the paths in the NT Object Namespace. To convert an NT Object Namespace path into a standard Windows path, put "\\?\GLOBALROOT\" at the beginning of the path. Windows Explorer and the File Dialogs will refuse to open such paths, but many Win32 applications will accept those paths as command line arguments.
- supriyo-biswas 3y agoTIL, thanks! To add to this list of unusual features, 7-zip can also parse many self-extracting PE executables and display the executable sections of ELFs and PEs. I'm not sure if this has been documented anywhere, though.
- Dwedit 3y ago7-zip version 15.05 will also decompile NSIS scripts (Nullsoft Installation System), but the feature was taken out of newer versions.
- panzi 3y agoReminds me of when I used WinZip to copy files from a shared directory that had non-ASCII (non latin even!) characters in the file names over 20 years ago. Windows Explorer refused to do it. Can't remember the error message, WinZip did the job.
- Qem 3y agoCurrently using it under Linux because it's able to extract the malformed large zip files generated by onedrive, that give a corrupted file error when you try to open them using the native file extractor. See https://www.bitsgalore.org/2020/03/11/does-microsoft-onedrive-export-large-ZIP-files-that-are-corrupt https://www.bitsgalore.org/2020/03/11/does-microsoft-onedriv...
- bobbob1921 3y agoLOVE peaZip! What I especially like about it is in my experience it’s been very portable on linux, and the gui has always been portable as well. (it works on Tails - so it’s great for putting onto a USB stick that contains encrypted zip / veracrypt archives for when you need to access those on an air gap d machine.)
- aquova 3y agoI've been using Ark on Linux for some time now, but have always heard people sing PeaZip's praises, curious if anyone has any experience or preference between the two.
- tahoeskibum 3y agoCan't wait to see an irreverent logo
- exposition 3y agoThere’s also pzip[1], which lets you create zip files and extract them in parallel. [1] https://github.com/ybirader/pzip https://github.com/ybirader/pzip Disclaimer: I’m the author
- synergy20 3y agohow is the GUI done for cross platform? not familiar with Pascal ecosystem
- gattilorenz 3y agoLazarus/FreePascal compile to a native binary for more platforms than you will realistically need
- seam_carver 3y agoIf your needs are basic I just use tar. It's built into macOS and Windows 10. It even supports rar!
- hgyjnbdet 3y agoGenuine question: why would I use this over 7zip?
- UberFly 3y agoNo reason to if you like 7zip. They all do the same thing just look different for the most part.
- ies7 3y agoI really don't remember well, long long time ago in Window (XP?) either you can select multiple folders and zip each of them separately and/or you can select multiple zip files and extract them to separate folders within a single context menu
- pennybanks 3y agodoesnt windows now have all the similar tools default?
- marwis 3y agoThe feature built into windows (even after recent update) is a lot slower
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- recursive 3y agoWhy use 7zip over this?
- jojohohanon 3y agoIt blends the CLI by incorporating scripting engine?! That’s not what mean by cli friendly.
- user20180120 3y agoCan it do lrzip? Did a quickish search https://github.com/nakijun/peazip/issues/149 https://github.com/nakijun/peazip/issues/149
- tripflag 3y agoI've found zstd --long=31 to be an excellent replacement for lrzip. Mentioned it in the github issue as well, cross posting for context. I'm not associated with either zstd or lrzip, but would still be curious to hear if you find any remaining usecases in favor of lrzip.
- teo_zero 3y agoThe fact that GTK3 is considered the new thing still in alpha is a red flag for me.
- croemer 3y agoNitpicks: 1. Command to unquarantine in docs is wrong. It should be `xattr -d com.apple.quarantine /Applications/peazip.app` not `xattr -dr com.apple.quarantine /Applications/peazip.app` 2. Not available via homebrew 3. Can't open issues, neither on Github nor sourceforge
- someonehere 3y ago1. Right click on the app and choose open. When prompted, click open 2. https://github.com/rogeriopradoj/homebrew-cask-peazip/blob/main/README.md https://github.com/rogeriopradoj/homebrew-cask-peazip/blob/m...
- sigzero 3y agoThere is noting wrong and it is probably better to use 'xattr -d -r' since an .app file is just a directory structure.
- victorio 2y agoYou do can open issues (well, they are called tickets) on SourceForge https://sourceforge.net/p/peazip/tickets/ https://sourceforge.net/p/peazip/tickets/
- Linda231 3y ago[dead]
- lucifer153 3y agoI was surprised that the software was written in Pascal which is the dead language