7 ms·
> but the cardinal rule of online communities is "once you post it, its out there" That's you opinion, not a cardinal rule. For example, Reddit comments and po
by creativeSlumber 2y ago
> but the cardinal rule of online communities is "once you post it, its out there"
That's you opinion, not a cardinal rule. For example, Reddit comments and posts are deleted by users all the time.Same for Twitter, where users delete their posts and reacts all the time.
- sethhochberg 2y agoIts a practical reality of the internet. It would be simply naive to believe that all content on Stack Overflow, Hacker News, and wherever else any of us post has not been scraped and archived by dozens of parties who I never explicitly authorized to archive my words. When I say "rule", I'm speaking in terms of "how each person posting content should operate". Once you make your words public, you (should) have no expectation of being able to take them back.
- add-sub-mul-div 2y agoIt's true that I can't undo Reddit having sold my content for models, I don't lose sleep about what I can't change. But we have every expectation (on every site but this one) that we can delete our content to empty out the original context.
- Arnt 2y agoSO lets your delete your unanswered questions, and also your unaccepted answers. It doesn't let you delete your question after someone has gone to the trouble of answering though. Good thing IMO.
- transcriptase 2y agoI don’t know if it’s still the case, but for many years deleting something simply hid it and there were browser extensions to “undelete” comments.
- Arnt 2y agoSO is different. It's a community effort, an asker and a set of answerers create something together, and SO+moderators clean up so that something is easy to find by searching (and also make the total collection downloadable). This asker ignored the rights of the answerers, moderators and SO, all of which put effort into creating that. I won't mind if someoen deletes his own unanswered question, but vandalising it after answerers put in an effort to answer? That's rude and egoistic.
- npc12345 2y ago[dead]
- add-sub-mul-div 2y agoUnlike on other sites, I don't participate here beyond anonymous throwaway comments because there's no freedom to delete my content. If sites don't allow that freedom, it changes how or if people will participate. If there is a delete button, it's fair game to use.
- Arnt 2y agoThere is a delete button for unanswered questions. As soon as someone else has put in effort and, the combined result is no longer yours to delete.
- add-sub-mul-div 2y agoI've never participated on SO, I don't know if you're saying that the site doesn't let you delete in that scenario, or if it's bad etiquette to delete. If the latter, I'd disagree and say it's my choice alone (unless the site reneges on the ability to delete.)
- Arnt 2y agoThe site doesn't let you.
- 2y ago
- SirMaster 2y agoAren't they just deleted on the front end though? I thought reddit keeps them still in the backend.