13 ms·
Roman Tyrian purple snail dye found in UK for first time
- sublinear 3y ago> The chunk of Tyrian purple, roughly the size of a ping pong ball, was dug up at Carlisle Cricket Club as part of ongoing yearly excavations. Is anyone surprised how geographically stable these kinds of gathering places are?
- gostsamo 3y agoHow often do you find roman baths in cricket clubs?
- debesyla 3y agoI think OP meant social gathering places?
- sublinear 3y agoI don't really know, hence my comment
- olddustytrail 3y agoI suppose you could tell from how many ducks there are...
- jl6 3y agoCarlisle has been a continuously occupied town since before the Romans, and continuously since. I don’t think it’s too surprising that we find Roman things underneath modern things (in fact I strongly suspect that we have yet to discover most Roman things because they lie under modern structures that are difficult/controversial to excavate).
- jdietrich 3y agoThe river Eden is prone to flooding, creating a natural separation between Carlisle on the south bank and Stanwix on the north. In between, there's a lot of land that is conveniently located, but unsuitable for either intensive development or arable farming. There's the cricket club on this land, but also several parks, public gardens and other sports clubs. When the baths were in use, there were also two separate settlements - the milecastle on the north bank forming part of the defensive line of Hadrian's Wall, and the civilian settlement of Luguvalium on the well-protected south bank. Being directly adjacent to the Eden bridge, the site would have been convenient for both settlements. https://www.google.co.uk/maps/place/Roman+Archaeological+site/@54.9009283,-2.9385443,424m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m6!3m5!1s0x487d1b45909f7141:0x7176b755415b08b!8m2!3d54.9009835!4d-2.9378224!16s%2Fg%2F11tmsvrzyn?entry=ttu https://www.google.co.uk/maps/place/Roman+Archaeological+sit... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindy_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindy_effect
- logikblok 3y agoAdditionally from the article > Semi-precious gems, which had probably fallen out of rings after the bathhouse steam loosen their glue settings, were recovered from drains at the site To think about the frustration the original owner might have felt when those were lost and now they're found all these years later for us to study and learn from.
- boffinAudio 3y agoWhat amazes me is the idea that at some point, a human being took their last look at the artwork of their gemstone jewellry, and then .. some thousands of years later, here we are gazing into the same nooks and crannies in wonder at the skills of the artist. One wonders, will some AI archeologist in the future, be digging through a cacaphonic digital noise, find some long-forgotten iCloud backup, and wonder at the collection of garden pictures I've left behind ..
- 48864w6ui 3y agoIt used to be standard practice, at the end of a year, to cut all the ads out of that year's issues and bind them in a single hardback volume. Now historians realize that often the ads may be more interesting than the articles.
- bcraven 3y agoSorry, standard practice by whom, and issues of what?
- 0xEF 3y agoI think the other reply is referring to folks who collect and sell old magazines. I can only speak from second-hand experience, though, as I knew a person who used to do this. When eBay was just getting started, she was collecting old magazines and trimming the ads from them, then selling them as a lower bulk collection (she also took jeans with holes in them, patched them with colorful fabric and resold them on early eBay but different story). I don't know why this was a thing, but I remember her telling me she got the idea from a local library that preserved its periodicals, so maybe it started at libraries. Personally, were I to collect magazines, I would want the ads intact. Not because I love adverts (quite the opposite, actually), but my collector brain's notion of preserving a thing in its original state is at odds with the idea of removing the ads.
- mjamesaustin 3y agoI always find it fascinating how color by itself used to truly be a status symbol, due to the rarity and challenge of making natural dyes.
- jl6 3y agoA modern comparison might be a vantablack cloak.
- Gud 3y agoNobody will kill you for painting your car in vantablack without the kings permission.
- baq 3y agoNot the police and not vantablack, but don't try certain football team colors on certain other teams' stadiums
- yieldcrv 3y agowe should bring back sumptuary laws, can make it legal by prohibiting the sale of some materials to nonaccredited investors with the consequences of unlimited tax to the business circumvents freedom of expression by giving no consequences to the individual if they someone procure the material themselves but leverages the unlimited right to regulate commerce and unlimited right to tax
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jdietrich 3y agoThe proper Vantablack coatings are ITAR restricted materials that require an export license, so the comparison is really quite meaningful. You wouldn't be killed for using it without the King's permission, but you could serve time at His Majesty's pleasure for it. https://www.surreynanosystems.com/purchasing https://www.surreynanosystems.com/purchasing
- ronyfadel 3y agoI’m surprised the Phoenicians are not mentioned in the article, as they’re the first to use it, and Tyre was in Phoenicia.
- mdp2021 3y agoWell, "Phoenician" itself is said to mean "purple" ("blood reddish"), although some of us prefer the idea that it means "carpenters" (coming from Egyptian "pheneku") - it makes more sense in terms of an expression "the Canaanite carpenters [of Tyre, Sidon, Byblos]" (all Canaanites, some of them in city states of that "special" region and culture). Or: "Phoenicia" is a culturally sound area (the producers of lumber, dye etc., colonizers etc., in the Levantine coast) - not a Statal entity. The term is thought to have meant "those of the purple" or "those of the lumbers" within the Canaanites.
- debatem1 3y agoHuh, very interesting. Who is 'us' above, and do you have any recommended reading on the Phoenician maybe-not-state?
- mdp2021 3y ago> maybe-not-state Take into account that you had * populations, * statal organizations, * empires. Chunks of populations could be organized into statal organizations, which could easily simply be city states. Their governments could be independent or subjected to other powers. An empire is the acquired power of an entity over statal organizations of different populations - the first empire being that of Sargon the Great of Akkad, ruling from -2334: he was ruler of the Akkadians but also conquered the Sumerian city states. The whole history from Jericho (the first city, -10000) to, say, the "classical" period of the Graeco-Persian conflict (-490, -480) and Pericles in Athens (-461) is quite interesting, showing "history-in-the-making", the emergence of the patterns that will continue in later history and that will have prepared it. But I cannot indicate a single especially good source: I can only recommend the scattered material you will find around - and which will already show many inconsistencies, gaps, attempts, clashing of different proposals.
- junto 3y agoRelated HN post from 5 months ago links to another article that I found fascinating about the quest to recreate it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38513073 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38513073
- epolanski 3y agoOT but interesting fact. The first evidence we have of purple or red shoes used for kings is more than 3000 years old. Etruscans (an ancient Italian population) used red shoes for their kings[1], albeit its uncertain whether they could be purple which is more likely. This habit then moved to the roman kings and later the Roman emperors. It is uncertain when it went from purple to red, but it's likely a practical reason: when going outside you don't wear slippers but leather boots, which were very easy to get in a red color, purple? Not really. You can easily find purple used anywhere in clothing, but not shoes. And who else claims (or claimed) to be the heir of the Roman empire other than the Pope? The emperor of byzanthium [2], notice how he's the only one depicted with red/purple shoes. The German emperor [3]. The Tsars [4] (Tsar word comes from Caesar, same as Kaiser) too claimed the inheritance of the Byzantine (and thus Roman) empires after the Ottomans took the city. [1] https://www.pope2you.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/Etruscan-times.jpg https://www.pope2you.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/Etruscan... [2] https://www.thoughtco.com/thmb/QytBnfnDoP8aDE-rm3eYGbTYCpk=/1500x0/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/GettyImages-501580205-5c82be0d46e0fb0001a0be42.jpg https://www.thoughtco.com/thmb/QytBnfnDoP8aDE-rm3eYGbTYCpk=/... [3] https://www.ancient-origins.net/sites/default/files/field/image/Frederick-II-Facebook-Preview.jpg https://www.ancient-origins.net/sites/default/files/field/im... [4] https://www.mediastorehouse.com.au/p/731/tsar-boot-antiquities-russian-state-1849-1853-20765720.jpg.webp https://www.mediastorehouse.com.au/p/731/tsar-boot-antiquiti...
- mr_toad 3y agoTo be pedantic the Holy Roman Emperors claimed that title before Constantinople fell to Mehmed, which makes the claim even less legitimate. The Byzantine emperors carried on many Roman traditions, including wearing purple. The imperial birth chambers were decorated in purple (actually a purple stone), giving rise to the term “born in the purple” to describe their legitimate heirs, these days used to describe any old toff. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Born_in_the_purple https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Born_in_the_purple
- mrangle 3y ago>which makes the claim even less legitimate. I'm not sure that follows. Who specifically "inherited" the Right to Rule from Roman Empire was always more of a political claim. The concept of "legitimacy" in this regard is dubious. That said, the original Northwest European territory of the Merovingians-Carolingians had a strong political connection to Roman Imperial Rulership. Not to say that this necessarily translated to "legitimate inheritance", but arguably no territory outside of Byzantium had a stronger historical political claim.
- yard2010 3y agoI just found that video of someone from Tunis, Tunisia making this after years of trial and error: https://youtu.be/IVXqisH6VeM https://youtu.be/IVXqisH6VeM Found in the comments of the other post about this linked here
- unfocused 3y agoThis makes sense, because one of the more famous colonies that the Phoenicians established was Carthage, which is modern day Tunis. Since they had already invented creating purple back in Phoenicia (modern day Lebanon), they simply brought over their traditions/skills along. I have a DVD from 2004 about them, as I did the National Genographic Project DNA test way back before it was popular, but I must admit, the DVD is so-so. I think afterwards, they got more and more data, and were able to track where they travelled to based on artifacts and DNA. Lots of websites about them, but hard to say what is what. I would trust information by Dr. Pierre Zalloua as he uses DNA analysis for his research into the Phoenicians.
- hilbert42 3y agoWhat amazes me is that an organic dye of this nature is still viable and recognizable after ~2000 years in the ground. Seems to me this ought to spur on further research into the chemical. (Given its nature and the way I've seen it prepared these days (on video, not in person) that it would have been much less stable (many organic dyes are very unstable). This stability also suggests it must have been rather stable in use (togas dyed with it, etc.). Its stability would have made it even more valuable than otherwise.
- wil421 3y agoLots of things are stable if you bury them underground away from oxygen and sunlight.
- hilbert42 3y agoNo doubt, at some point, the chemistry of the surrounding soil will be researched in depth and we'll know.
- _xerces_ 3y agoMaybe the beeswax helped preserve it as intended.
- hilbert42 3y agoLikely so. Even so, I'm more curious than ever to know more about its chemistry.
- yawpitch 3y agoInteresting, but I just have to giggle at the fact that my reading of the headline at first had me absolutely boggled by the notion of the Romans dyeing snails Tyrian purple.
- RobotToaster 3y ago> The chunk of Tyrian purple, roughly the size of a ping pong ball That stuff was worth more than it's weight in gold, someone must have been pissed at losing that much of it.
- corinroyal 3y agoThere's some guy on Facebook crushing up snails for this color. Don't do this. You just poke them with a stick and they spit dye onto your skein at the beach. Then you put them back.
- FredPret 3y agoFinally we can break Tyre's stranglehold on the colour purple
- amne 3y agoAnyone else read the title as "Roman Tyrian, exotic luxury house brand of dyes known for making dyes out of unusual extracts, maker of purple dye out of snail juices somehow, is finally selling his stuff in UK either because some ban on mistreating snails was waived or his beef with the king is over" ?? Just me? Thought so