5 ms·
Dear Tim Cook: Be a Decent Human Being and Delete This Revolting Apple Ad
- skyzyx 3y agoI play instruments, read books, and have an iPad. It reminded me of the old magazine clipping of a guy holding a camcorder over his shoulder and pointing to a table full of technology. "All of this fits in your pocket now." Same thing. Chill out. You're free to not like something and have it continue to exist despite your dislike of it. FFS
- lcnmrn 3y agoThe iPad Pro ad, fixed. https://twitter.com/rezawrecktion/status/1788211832936861950 https://twitter.com/rezawrecktion/status/1788211832936861950
- jrhey 3y agoWouldn't this blog fall into the category of running revolting ads as well?
- CoolGuySteve 3y agoThis article is so histrionic that it's a parody of itself. >and most disturbingly (because they suggest destructive violence against children's toys, and against the child in all of us) a ceramic Angry Birds figure and a stack of rubber emoji ball. Are you fucking serious man? It's just an ad
- aredox 3y agoIt seems Japanese are histrionic Or maybe they just care about craft, you know? Like the author of this article https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40313733 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40313733
- 4544h6j7 3y agoTim Cook is a decent human being regardless. Nobody forces you to buy the ipad if you think it's robbing you of so many experiences.
- redserk 3y ago...I can't be alone in thinking the criticism of this ad is on the side of unnecessarily excessive overanalysis ...right? My interpretation of the ad is limited to "this tablet does a lot in a small form factor". I really don't see a higher meaning here.
- taylodl 3y agoYou don't think creatives aren't going to get upset watching all the tools they've been using for all their lives and have a love and appreciation for, tools humanity has been using for quite some time to produce beautiful works of art and have a beautiful aesthetic of their own, being destroyed by an industrial press to only be replaced by a mass-produced iPad isn't a form of higher meaning? If so, then don't go into advertising! They're literally depicted the crushing of the human spirit, to be replaced by a machine. That's the higher meaning here. Yeah, I "get it" - when the mess was over, I understood the message they intended to convey, but boy did Apple screw the pooch on this one!
- redserk 3y agoI fail to see why this is controversial because digital expression in the arts has been mainstream and widely accepted for multiple decades now.
- taylodl 3y agoLike I said, don't go into advertising. The most problematic aspect of this for Apple is it shows they don't understand those who heretofore were considered a core part of their user base. This is a blunder of epic proportions.
- redserk 3y agoFair enough, marketing is not my strong suit, especially to creatives. Perhaps I'm biased because I go out of my way to spend as little energy as I can on an ad when one comes up.
- 3y ago
- blackhaj7 3y ago> This is a disturbing, shocking ad, not just because of what it shows but because of its seeming obliviousness to the subtext that it turns into text, as well as the message it sends to every artist alive: the tech industry will crush you, destroy you; suddenly, violently, all at once. It surprises me how upset people get about stuff these days
- 4544h6j7 3y ago[flagged]
- brevitea 3y agoYou made a new account, to say the word snowflake. Who is the snowflake again?
- DennisAleynikov 3y agoyour account is only 62 days old... also what does that even mean lmao
- brevitea 3y agoyou are confirming I didn't make this account today. thanks. what does what mean?
- xoxxala 3y agoSadly, I'm no longer surprised by these kind of overreactions. We truly live in the Age of Being Offended.
- aredox 3y agoWould you still say the same now? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40313733 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40313733
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- internet101010 3y agoIt ain't that deep bro
- Trufa 3y agoMaybe it’s me that’s numb, but holy crap people are jumpy and making such a big deal, reading into an ad as if the whole of society’s problems could be decomposed from it. Shitty ad? Probably? Move on.
- quasse 3y agoThis ad *really* reminds me of the absurdly tone deaf ads Meta ran during the Super Bowl (great breakdown by David Roth here https://defector.com/facebook-meta-asks-wouldnt-it-be-nice-to-die https://defector.com/facebook-meta-asks-wouldnt-it-be-nice-t.... To me, the message is clearly "the world we are creating is going to destroy you, you relic, you outmodded worthless luddite. You will be allowed to consume through our content square." but apparently someone with severe west coast tech brain thought these two ads were somehow conveying something positive?
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoWhenever I see entropy run in reverse, I get a little disturbed also. The arrow of time if fixed in one direction for good reasons.
- mannyv 3y agoThey should have blended all those objects then poured it into a mold. Or gone for the fetish crowd and had shapely legs (and feet) crushing objects, then taking the dust and molding it into an iPad. Or had a big katamari roll up all that, then transform into an iPad. But really, the reaction to the ad is ridiculous.
- andy_xor_andrew 3y agoam i literally shaking with anger, pacing around my room, crying, cuddling my emotional support dog, because i'm so upset at this advertisement? no. is it a terrible, possibly even insulting ad? yeah, I think so. pretty clearly the original concept was "the new iPad is so thin, let's make an ad that shows all types of art compressed into a small size". And somehow that got lost in translation during production to "let's destroy objects of artistic expression, and show them all obliterated, only to be replaced by our mass-market product". if the goal was to generate controversy, it worked. but if they actually thought this ad would go over well, they're insane, and surely there is someone in the ad meeting who spoke up and said it was terrible, and they got shut down, and right now they must feel so vindicated.
- alberth 3y agoThe video is making people talk about Apple. Seems to me, the ad worked as intended.
- someotherperson 3y agoWhenever I see ads, I ask myself why companies would spend so much money if it barely has any effect (given that ads have essentially no impact on me). And then there's posts like this which remind me that there is a whole group of people out there who are so deeply affected they read entire stories and write entire novels after a few seconds. It's a solid reminder how differently worldviews are shaped.
- stantaylor 3y agoI'm with you. I go out of my way to avoid advertising whenever possible, I'm critical of marketing and advertising, and I pride myself on my rationality, thinking that I'm relatively immune to advertising. But yeah, people like you and me are just one speck in a constellation of human emotion and ration. Disclaimer: I have an iphone, apple watch, ipad, airpods, and personal MacBook. I use a MacBook for work as well. Judge me as you will.
- scubbo 3y ago> given that ads have essentially no impact on me They do. You are just not aware of the impact they have.
- kisonecat 3y agoThat Apple ad feels more like an Advernado ad -- "We can solve any problem that you think up, and find any purchase that you require, the... iPad... is a full solution..." crushing everything.
- linguae 3y agoI was also disappointed by this ad when I first saw it, but I wasn’t shocked. In fact I think it’s symbolic of the direction Apple took since the passing of Steve Jobs. Apple, even during its “beleaguered” mid-1990s era, was a champion of personal computing and was embraced by creative professionals. Heck, the original Macintosh and the LaserWriter helped kickstart the desktop publishing industry, especially once PageMaker and Photoshop were released. But Apple products were complementary to other creative tools, such as musical instruments and cameras. Remember the digital hub strategy Steve Jobs announced in the early 2000s? Unfortunately, this ad, with its destruction of artists’ tools, is completely tone-deaf to the sentiments of the creative professionals who loyally used Apple products. However, I argue that Apple has largely stopped relying on this market once revenues from the iPhone and services started overtaking Mac revenues. Apple used to be a champion of personal computing, not only emphasizing ease-of-use over its competitors, but also investing in technologies that made it easier for regular users to get more out of their computers (e.g., HyperCard, AppleScript). Today Apple is a vendor of luxury-brand electronics. It’s coasting on two things: (1) the goodwill the brand built from the 1980s through the 2000s as “the computer for the rest of us,” and (2) offering a platform that is alternative to Microsoft Windows and all of its shenanigans, as well as some PC clone vendors who load their PCs with preinstalled crapware. Even with point #2, I find pro and education versions of Windows less annoying than their home counterparts, and vendors like Framework and even Microsoft don’t load their PCs with crapware. I hold the opinion that Apple lost its soul in the 2010s when Apple became the iPhone company instead of the Mac company. This commercial would’ve never been produced under the watch of Steve Jobs (“Think different”) or even John Sculley (look up “The Power to Be Your Best.”).
- skyzyx 3y ago> In fact I think it’s symbolic of the direction Apple took since the passing of Steve Jobs. …aaaaaand I've tuned-out.
- taylodl 3y agoCreatives, a core Apple market, are reacting negatively to this ad. As I said in another comment on the matter, Apple should have shown some kind of "Apple Beam" or something similar shrink the items down to fit into an iPad. Then a voiceover could announce all that creative power is now in your hands. I make my money by creating software, but I'm a musician and photographer outside of the office. Even I was wondering why Apple was showing all these things being destroyed. It looked like the crushing of the human spirit - which is not what you want to be selling. Yeah, I "got it" at the end, but why start the ad with such viscerally negative destruction? Those viewers are going to associate that disgust with Apple.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TechRemarker 3y agoI can only speak for myself, but my guess is the vast majority didn't think twice about the ad. Beyond, it's mimicking a very popular trend on FB/TikTok/Instagram, of things getting crushed, that so many of us can't seem to get enough of since constantly shows in our feeds. And that it's implying all of these wonderful (physically large) tools and experiences are available on a very small portable device I can take with my anywhere. There are countless different ways they could have shown that, and imagine most all would have caused backlash by small vocal few. Is Technology (especially AI), etc destroying the arts and humanity, who knows, maybe? But I certainly don't think this video showcases that.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rqtwteye 3y agoI think best would be if people stopped watching ads. It's not like you learn anything useful there.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoSome more discussion yesterday: A dystopian iPad commercial has X ripping Apple for crushing instruments and art https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40304547 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40304547
- ndstephens 3y agoSeems a lot of comments here are basically saying "calm down, it's just an ad." If these are "just" ads (meaning they aren't a big deal) then why are millions spent on them? Why are Super Bowls ads an event all their own? Maybe read up on some early figures in effective propaganda and advertising such as Edward Bernays. Watch The Century of the Self. Put your ego aside and accept that advertising might have a significant influence on a person's perception, reasoning, and judgment...and accomplish it in subtle ways you may not be fully cognizant of. That can also lead to more vast cultural conditioning. The boiling frog... It's not "just" an ad and thankfully some people are applying critical thought and criticism against it. Why that bothers so many here might also be telling. Why are you being triggered?
- DennisAleynikov 3y agojust an ad means this was an artistic expression inof itself theres nothing inherently wrong with destruction as an artform
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- voisin 3y ago> Why that bothers so many here might also be telling. Why are you being triggered? Maybe because we are exhausted by this woke bullshit telling us that everything is meant to offend and we should be offended by everything. Maybe because the level of outrage at an ad seems to dwarf the outrage we (don’t) see at things that actually deserve outrage. That our little snowflake society should turn its attention to bigger, real issues rather than let its ego get offended by everything that crosses its path.
- D13Fd 3y agoI agree with your point about outrage culture these days. But your language indicates you think it’s a political issue for the left (“woke,” “snowflake”). The fact is that both ends of the political spectrum get way too outraged over things these days (they crushed art! He didn’t wear a flag pin!). It’s not a political issue, it’s a problem with our culture right now, probably driven in part by social media algorithms and systems (upvotes) that reward outrage.
- from-nibly 3y agoMan this is some tea leaf reading nonsense I'll tell you hwhat.
- fidla 3y agoMaybe I'm old school, but I didn't see anything questionable about the ad
- JSDevOps 3y agoTerrible ad absolutely agree. But just don’t buy the iPad. Apple doesn’t ow e you anything and you don’t owe Apple anything. Get over it.
- voisin 3y agoThis is such horse shit. It’s like the university classroom has taken over the world and now everyone gets upset for the sake of getting upset. There’s nothing offensive about this ad at all, and anyone claiming outrage needs to take a hard look at their own fragile egos.
- fractallyte 3y agoBoth submissions (this and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40304547 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40304547) flagged, and no longer up for discussion. Says a lot about the HN crowd, and I have to say, I'm disappointed. The backlash against Apple is growing: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cld0rxlqgggo https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cld0rxlqgggo ...in my opinion, for good reason. I haven't seen mentioned in any of the comments the fact that Apple controls their ecosystem, and takes away our freedom to use our devices. That's the antithesis of "creativity", and I'm disgusted that this seems to be OK with HN voters.