5 ms·
Microsoft employees spent years fighting the tech giant's oil ties
- what-the-grump 3y agoThis is so god damned stupid that it hurts. >It’s true that Microsoft is taking numerous steps to address the sustainability of its own operations. But for years, the company has also furnished fossil fuel giants with cloud computing services and specialized software tools powered by machine learning and AI in order to streamline and automate their operations. Let's make the extraction of the life blood of all industry on the planet less efficient, less streamlined, less clean. And do let us all know how you plan to build the next Azure data center without using fossil fuels dug out of the ground and processed plastics.
- gaze 3y agoWhy do you think that cloud computing would lend to the cleanliness or efficiency of their operations in a way that reduces the environmental burden? What stops them from using such services to extract oil more efficiently in the sense that they just produce more externalities faster?
- what-the-grump 3y ago>extract oil more efficiently in the sense that they just produce more externalities faster You need fossil fuels to get off of fossil fuels, you need regulation, the entire planet working on this, etc. Making the process LESS efficient is not going to help at any point. Let's start blowing up the equipment used to dig coal out of the ground so we can go back to doing it by hand like in the early 1900s, and let's start unscrewing the bolts in the machines at the factories, let's all quit at CAT and never build another digger...
- doctorpangloss 3y agoWhen some oil was “$0”, what stopped me from buying it for free, and using grant money to “bury it” (safely store or really dispose of it) and simply never burning it? Every idea in environmental management needs to be explored, because the issue is that serious.
- AlexandrB 3y agoBecause oil is fungible, this has the exact same effect as limiting supply: price will increase. There are plenty of other ways to increase oil price (taxes being the simplest) that don't require creating new waste disposal sites. Burying the oil also has the nasty side effect of increasing demand, so there's a chance that, for example, OPEC will just extract more oil to meet the added demand. And extracting oil isn't "free" from an emissions perspective.
- what-the-grump 3y agoIf oil costs zero its utility is zero because no one wants it. You've solved the problem!
- waveBidder 3y agothey're referring to that time spot prices went negative during the early pandemic when nobody was driving, demand was way down, and storage suddenly became a problem.
- Alupis 3y agoWe need to rub at least two brain cells together to conceive of anything resembling a viable plan. "Buying" some small amount of barrels during a rare market anomaly, then burying them in the ground is supposed to accomplish what exactly? Great, you buried 50,000 barrels of crude - congratulations. Now what are you going to do about the 20,000,000 barrels[1] the US will consume tomorrow? Look, oh no, your buried oil leaked into the water table! [1] https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/pipeline-us-and-global-oil-consumption/#:~:text=Library%20of%20Congress.,barrels%20of%20oil%20a%20day https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/pipelin....
- voisin 3y ago> you need regulation Bingo, except government and industry are so closely related now they resemble a circular human centipede, so we can’t rely on that.
- ng12 3y agoSafety, for one. Technology helps prevent spills.
- torpfactory 3y agoI don't buy that Microsoft's involvement does much to prevent spills. Exxon, for example, cares about spills mostly as a function of 1) regulation, 2)reputation risk and 3) employees who do care about things being done cleanly. I guess Microsoft's software could maybe enable the employees a bit more, but fundamentally the reasons they are safe have to do with incentives, not technology.
- therobots927 3y agoYep. It's genuinely shocking to me that people lack the critical thinking ability to recognize that oil extraction is a function of society as a whole. Oil companies are the ones who get their hands dirty, but society as a whole benefits and encourages the oil extraction. Take factory farming as another example - you can blame the factory farms, but good luck telling the average American they'll have to pay 3x as much for chicken and hamburgers because the animals were treated well.
- letmeinhere 3y agoThese are people in said society operating on another part of the whole. They are not idly "blaming", they are attempting to directly increase the cost function to reduce the extraction. Obviously you disagree with them taking action ("the average American" has to spontaneously demand 3x prices for resistance to be legitimate), but that has nothing to do with a lack of critical thinking ability in your political foes.
- voisin 3y ago> Oil companies are the ones who get their hands dirty, but society as a whole benefits and encourages the oil extraction. Take factory farming as another example - you can blame the factory farms, but good luck telling the average American they'll have to pay 3x as much for chicken and hamburgers because the animals were treated well. The argument “we’re just doing the dirty work to give you what you want” is horse shit. They actively hid information about climate change for decades, they work to ensure continued subsidies to avoid actual competition, they work to add regulations to competing technologies and run disinformation campaigns. They work to entrench themselves so that “giving you what you want” is really “you’ll take what we give since we’ve undermined the alternatives”. Same with factory farming. The only reason people think chicken and burgers should be 1/3 the true cost is because the four big ag companies have worked the government into subsidizing things and reducing labour laws, etc etc etc. Honestly, when your argument starts with being an apologist for big corporations with a profit rather than social motive, I think you should check what first principles you are working with. Our society is a hunger games hellscape and it is because of whatever first principles you are using.
- kayodelycaon 3y agoIt's a clear case of all-or-nothing thinking. Calling a CEO's statement "gaslighting" because it implied something does not do anything help their credibility.
- UtopiaPunk 3y agoWhen the costs of something go up, people and businesses are more eager to explore alternatives. Driving down the costs of fossil fuels hinders the adoption of alternatives.
- francisofascii 3y agoThat is not a good faith argument. People who support sustainability want less extraction, not no extraction. Sustainability means extracting less so it is doable over a long period of time.
- oceanplexian 3y agoSo then, the oil companies around the world will be able to trivially use Chinese services like Alibaba, further strengthening the Chinese economy at the expense of our own? China will make the process as efficient as it wants. Remember, we live in a global economy with other players who don’t play by our rules, sanctions or not. And I assure you developing countries are onboard with the idea of oil extraction.
- Dalewyn 3y agoI wonder sometimes to what extent progressives (aka the left, "liberals", leftists, woke, etc.) and their agenda are just paid Chinese operatives and operations or the results of such. A lot of progressive agendas have ultimately been to China's benefit at the cost of everyone else and especially Pax Americana.
- irrational 3y agoI think most liberals are more anti-conservative values (misogamy, racism, xenophobia, anti-science, anti-education, homophobia, etc.) than pro-progressive policies.
- Dalewyn 3y agoLiterally none of what you mentioned has anything to do with conservatism. Hell, speaking as a Japanese-American (aka a racial minority), conservative people by far have treated me the fairest because they truly don't care about someone's race. I mean actual conservatism, of course. Not "conservatism" often thrown around in these conversations to label out groups.
- oceanplexian 3y agoSo we’re having an economic argument, what does racism or xenophobia have to do with that?
- Spivak 3y agoThose dirty liberals, not having blind nationalism and not wanting our government to fuck over another country with 1 billion living human beings just because we don't like their government. Like good Lord, we're not at war with China. they're one of our biggest trading partners. The idea that we should be doing everything in our power to economically fuck them over isn't the argument you think it is. "Oh no, we have to supply services to oil companies because if not, a business in China might make a sale?"
- gosub100 3y agoMicrosoft should respond by closing their parking lots to all but EVs. I'm SURE that none of the green activist would ever drive an ICE vehicle while protesting big oil...riiight?
- wizzwizz4 3y agohttps://thenib.com/mister-gotcha/ https://thenib.com/mister-gotcha/
- Spivak 3y agoThis has big, "you want to criticize capitalism while you buy things with money" energy. Consumers are by in large product takers who have to choose between the products that are on offer. There's no market segment for "same product but without fossil fuels." I try to avoid buying plastic. Does that mean I don't buy anything made with plastic? No, of course not. That's ridiculous I couldn't buy 90% of products from the grocery store. But when given the opportunity will I pay for an option that doesn't use plastic, yes. It's not the 1800s you don't have to be pure of heart to want to affect positive change.
- torpfactory 3y agoI mean, I think there is a reasonable argument here: Microsoft has corporate environmental goals and then as a matter of profit takes money from interests working in direct opposition to those goals. It does smack of hypocrisy, no? I'd like to debate a few of your other points: "Let's make the extraction of the life blood of all industry on the planet less efficient, less streamlined, less clean." - People often make this argument and I agree: oil is the _current_ life blood of all industry. The oil companies would like to keep it that way and have for years fought a very effective campaign to avoid responsibility for the externalities of oil production and consumption. They have slowed or blocked progress towards a _future_ where oil is not the lifeblood of industry. That is what we really need to get to as a species, don't you agree? There are no physics-based reason why some other technology couldn't power our lives. There are cost-based reasons why oil is currently the winning solution. This only works because we don't price the externalities, the _future_, yet to be paid cost of oil consumption. Fossil fuel companies have stood in the way of progress on renewables and exterality pricing for decades now.
- froggertoaster 3y agoI upvoted this article, not because of its significance or because I think it's valuable (in truth, I think it contains a fair amount of slant), but because I'd love to hear some critical discourse on its contents. Good on these employees for sticking by their ethos, but I feel in terms of problems in the world right now, there are much bigger fish to fry that Microsoft is in a position to correct. This seems a bit like missing the forest for the trees.
- nequo 3y agoWhat is the bigger fish in your opinion?
- djantje 3y agoThe energy hunger of the people of the world (you and me). Stopping Microsoft supporting oil companies won't fix reducing fossil fuel usage, we have to look at cause and effect. The best course of action to reduce fossil fuel usage is to see which processes on earth use that fossil fuel, and see if that can be transformed to use renewable energy. A combination of scientific research, regulation, awareness, education and trying to change human behaviour is probably the best way forward. Blaming specific companies, for helping solving an energy need, seems not helpfull in that way.
- ClumsyPilot 3y ago> companies won't fix reducing fossil fuel usage, we have to look at cause and effect. Group for responsible solar is a fake charity funded by the oil sector that files planning objection to every solar farm in Britain, including noise complaints and ‘they should be on the roofs’ and then objects to the solar panels being on the roofs too, because they ‘ruin the view’. They’ve made it illegal to build wind turbines on land on UK They objected to an underground electricity cable to France because it would ‘ruin the landscape’ Oil companies are players, they protect their profits and you are getting played
- 3y ago
- qaq 3y agoThis whole thing is a bit of a stretch they would do the same thing in-house even MS did not provide those services.
- therobots927 3y agoEvery, and I mean every aspect of the economy has "ties to oil". Oil companies sell to willing buyers, many of whom turn around and point the finger at the oil company. It's an extreme level of cognitive dissonance that never stops surprising me. I believe in climate change for the record, and do believe we need to switch to sustainable energy, but the attitude of a lot of climate activists really rubs me the wrong way sometimes.
- arp242 3y agoA lot of this seems to be like that Ralph kid from The Simpsons; "I'm helping!" Well-intentioned? Absolutely. Actually helpful? Meh. At one company I worked for someone suggested that we should all stop using metaphors linked to cars and internal combustion engines, to stop normalizing these things and help fight climate change. And look, I don't like this car-centric design; I don't even have a driving license. But how does this stop climate change? "I'm helping!" This was shot down pretty hard by the CEO and pretty much everyone else by the way.
- bluejekyll 3y agoCars and the transportation sector are the primary consumers of oil. I think GP was saying, stop pointing at the oil company while you’re driving around in your car. We should be pointing out the car centric transportation systems we have and work to fix them. We shouldn’t be encouraging things like suburban sprawl that increases car dependence. Reduce car usage, and you will reduce oil consumption.
- bluefirebrand 3y agoYes, that's true But consumer vehicles are a tiny percentage of our actual overall consumption Yes we can and should reduce our usage here, but it needs to be in addition to other much bigger and important changes (which don't get talked about enough)
- jeffbee 3y ago
- evilantnie 3y agoIronically, this article highlights multiple times how successful Microsoft has been at boosting efficiency within the oil and gas industry that it's nearly an advertisement for Microsoft.
- fallingsquirrel 3y ago> But for years, the company has also furnished fossil fuel giants with cloud computing services and specialized software tools powered by machine learning and AI in order to streamline and automate their operations. In other words, some low-level engineer at BP signed up for Azure and provisioned a few VMs with GPUs. Let's say MS did ban an entire industry from using their products... wouldn't that engineer just switch to AWS and use EC2 instances instead? Or is the argument that every cloud company should independently decide not to serve this particular industry? If that's true, why are we pressuring private companies at all? Wouldn't it be more effective for the government to sanction these forbidden companies, instead of relying on so many independent profit-motivated companies to voluntarily lower their profits?
- voisin 3y ago> Or is the argument that every cloud company should independently decide not to serve this particular industry? If that's true, why are we pressuring private companies at all? Wouldn't it be more effective for the government to sanction these forbidden companies, instead of relying on so many independent profit-motivated companies to voluntarily lower their profits? Yes, it would be more effective but in the absence of any adults in the rooms of government, I don’t blame regular folk from using whatever little power they might have to try to effect change, albeit however futilely. Our world is a dumpster fire and the ruling class seems fine with fanning the flames, so it is incumbent upon everyone else to fight in whatever ways available to them.
- ryandrake 3y agoAmericans have a very weird individualistic idea of what's acceptable when it comes to reining in Companies Behaving Badly: - Individual action is acceptable (vote with your wallet) - Government action is totally unacceptable (interference with the holy free market!) - But, coordinated, collective individual action is also unacceptable (unions bad! organized boycotts bad!) Consequently, the only way to punish companies that's acceptable to Americans is totally spontaneous, unorganized, grassroots actions by individuals. You can imagine how often that's successful. The only time it actually has a chance of working is when it's secretly organized (astroturfing). So, we Americans continue to run around individually complaining about bad corporate behavior, but are powerless to do anything about it because we've made all the effective mitigations taboo!
- mc32 3y agoYou know what I want? I want Google employees to fight the dark side of the ad business. You know what’s not going to happen? Them being successful in cutting off their own legs.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- analyte123 3y agoI can't think of a better argument to have on-premises software than this article.
- dukeofdoom 3y agoMillions of people on the middle east rely on the oil to fund their countries basics like grain purchases... They don't really have anything else to sell. They live in a desert. Why do Microsoft employees feel good about a cause that will cause misery and poverty to Millions If they want to make the world a better place, make windows crush less.
- jeffbee 3y agoOil and gas computational techniques are going to be critical for future geothermal power. Modern geothermal is only possible because of oil/gas technology. And geothermal is the only practical future "base load" source, since fission is such a clown show. If you are against climate change, the effective policy to pursue is a carbon tax. Trying to shadowban computational geology is counterproductive.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- farceSpherule 3y ago[flagged]
- dehrmann 3y agoIf oil beats out renewables because they're using the cloud rather than several colocated racks, renewables have bigger viability problems. Not saying they do, but the cloud won't be what changes energy policy. This also gets at the issue of whether or not cloud providers are common carriers. Or even Spotify and Joe Rogan. As a business, I don't want to be in the game of policing which customers or vendors I want on ideological grounds because it opens the floodgates to more complaints like this. The bar for not doing business with someone acting legally needs to be very high.
- phkahler 3y ago>> “My resignation was driven in part by the realization that the tech industry, including Microsoft, is increasing the profitability and competitiveness of these fossil fuel giants..." Giants? MSFT is at 3 trillion dollars while XOM is at 529 billion. And we already have alternatives to Microsoft...
- wakawaka28 3y agoYet another reason not to use Microsuck products. We all desperately need oil for decades to come, and expensive oil hurts poor people around the world the most. Your moralizing snobbery will not actually stop oil extraction because we need it. You're just shooting your software LOB in the foot. Where are the Microsoft employees protesting ties to authoritarian regimes, invasions of privacy, censorship, and other actually worthwhile causes? Nowhere to be fucking seen. This "protest" of fossil fuels is not a protest but a psyop pushed from the top by the authoritarians in the West who want to destroy it and set up a world government. I'm not buying it.