6 ms·
FDA recalls defective iOS app that injured over 200 insulin pump users
- Almondsetat 3y agoApple already has tons of custom rules for different types of applications. Does anyone know which restrictions they impose on medical apps? especially ones that control medical grade devices?
- nullindividual 3y agoThe software is regulated under FDA regs which is more thorough than any Apple review.
- infecto 3y ago+1, and I imagine Apple does not care to regulate the interactions of an app with a physical device.
- WA 3y agoYou can safely replace this with: Apple does not care to regulate apps at all. Their App Store rules are arbitrary and do not resemble local laws. There aren't that many regulations for software anyways, except for a) medical devices and b) privacy stuff, which all apps have to adhere to in most jurisdictions, but under different laws. You can argue that it is simply not Apple's responsibility to check compliance with local laws for apps. Developers are responsible for local conmpliance, but Apple must remove law-breaking apps from countries in which these break local laws, upon request by authorities.
- bdcravens 3y agoPerhaps but Apple has always lagged behind Google on approving diabetes device apps (or severely limit the functionality). I know the Android version of the app for the Tandem had the ability to deliver bolus well before the iPhone version, and the iPhone version of the Omnipod controller app has FDA approval but still isn't approved by Apple https://www.omnipod.com/innovation/iphone https://www.omnipod.com/innovation/iphone
- nullindividual 3y agoApple has had long review times for all sorts of reasons with all types of apps, from games to this app. This isn't unusual for them.
- greggsy 3y agoIt’s probably covered under ‘Medical apps’ and ‘Drug dosage calculators’ under the physical harm section [1], where they defer to the FDA. [1] https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#physical-harm https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#phy...
- WA 3y ago> Does anyone know which restrictions they impose on medical apps? especially ones that control medical grade devices? Zero. It's not Apple's responsibility. Google Play Store just asked developers to provide more information on apps in the categories "Health" and "Medical" [1], which is more than Apple did so far. [1]: https://support.google.com/googleplay/android-developer/answer/14738291?hl=en https://support.google.com/googleplay/android-developer/answ...
- peteradio 3y ago[flagged]
- lenerdenator 3y agoSmartphones provide a very easy and reliable way to have people interface with such devices. It can be done right, but you have to be careful. I'd rather that medical device manufacturers use well-known frameworks and technologies with almost two decades of engineering and UX improvements behind them than the alternative, which is them using some sort of slapdash in-house solution that will almost certainly be worse.
- thejohnconway 3y agoYeah, seriously, the in-house solution would just be an old android phone with a 500% markup rate anyway,
- bdcravens 3y agoThat's what Omnipod does. Their app is only approved for limited Androids, not yet for iOS, so many users depend on the device they provide which is pretty much what you're describing. Not sure what the hardware is, but it even has a camera that isn't used.
- kotaKat 3y agoThat's what it currently is. Omnipod used to/still provides some kind of rebadged Android device. Zoll was shipping various Android handsets with the bootloader unlocked and a custom APK built to take over the device to act as a 'hotspot' for their defibrillator vests to provide remote telemetry. https://www.maxx.ca/Event/LotDetails/412535278/ZOLL-LIFE-VEST-4000-WEARABLE-DEFIBRILLATOR https://www.maxx.ca/Event/LotDetails/412535278/ZOLL-LIFE-VES... (photo's buried in the listing -- that's a Moto G4 Play. If anyone's curious, the APK was called... com.lifevest.zuul. I was amused.)
- peteradio 3y ago> slapdash in-house solution that will almost certainly be worse. Truly libelous shilling for the app store.
- lenerdenator 3y agoKind of surprises me that something this easy to replicate and this pervasive (200+ instances is a lot of instances when you consider the size of the user pool) got through the testing. Would be interested to see what the FDA makes them do as corrective action and a breakdown of how this got into production code.
- thejohnconway 3y agoI use apps for CGMs and I've gotta say, I'm not sure they are tested on anyone before they are release. They are absolute garbage.
- icegreentea2 3y agoThe corrective action is the software fix (it's already out as 2.7.1). It's the preventative action that would be interesting, but we probably won't see that. The specific recall action in the FDA database is here: https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfRES/res.cfm?id=206914 https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfRES/res... It simply says "Software Design Change" as FDA determined root cause... so super vague. EDIT: Although the root cause might be software, it's possible that they did detect the crashing during testing, but did not characterize it fully, and/or missed a step in their risk assessment analysis to determine that it may impact battery life and therefore have risk of harm to life.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoits not 200, I think it is closer to 20,000 for battery issues. for context, there are about 200,000 formally reported events per year for pumps with alternate controllers in the US.[1] https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfTPLC/tplc.cfm?id=QFG&min_report_year=2023 https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfTPLC/tp...
- thejohnconway 3y agoI use a Dexcom Continuous Blood Glucose Monitor that pairs with this pump (I don't use the pump). And honestly, this is not surprising. The software quality in this space seems really low. I don't understand why some single-developer Mastodon client app can absolutely reliably get notifications to my watch but Dexcom can't. Even on the phone, the app cannot get alerts right at all, sometimes stacking them over an hour or more, but getting the current value for the alert, so you can get like five in a row (ALERT YOUR BLOOD SUGAR IS IN RANGE). It's kinda terrifying to be honest.
- bdcravens 3y agoMy alerts have pretty much always been on time (Dexcom 6 and iPhone 14 Pro Max)
- thejohnconway 3y agoDon't move to the 7. The software has regressed tremendously. It's clearly some sort of cross-platform abomination.
- bdcravens 3y agoI know that paired pumps have been slow to move to the 7 (only the Tandem has AFAIK; I'm currently on the Omnipod) and I can understand why from what you're describing.
- gmaster1440 3y agoSoftware aside, how do the accuracy/precision of the readings on the g7 compare to the g6? Not having to replace/order a transmitter every 3 months, and a 30-minute warmup, seem like significant improvements over the g6.
- thejohnconway 3y agoRegarding accuracy, I don't know, because I never compare it to anything. Seems pretty similar based on how I feel vs readings when I'm low. The hardware experience is indeed better. Bundling the transmitter with the patch and the 30 minute warmup are great, and part of the reason why I haven't got the energy to switch back.
- bdcravens 3y agoTalk about good timing: I switched from the Tandem to the Omnipod before this recall, but after Omnipod's own software recall had been resolved https://www.fda.gov/medical-devices/medical-device-recalls/insulet-corporation-recalls-omnipod-5-android-app-due-software-error https://www.fda.gov/medical-devices/medical-device-recalls/i... At least the Tandem doesn't require using the phone app; it's not an option with the Omnipod, which has no other way of communicating with the device. (you either use an app on a small handful of approved Android phones, or use a stripped down Android device they provide you; iOS approval is in the works, but not here yet)
- wcedmisten 3y agoI recently did a writeup [1] on the 510(k) FDA clearance process (which cleared this device for market). Basically this device was cleared through a DAG of other devices that were "substantially equivalent". I made a website to visualize these relationships, and any recalls that occurred in the parent devices. If anyone is curious about this particular device, see here [2] [1] https://wcedmisten.fyi/post/medical-device-analysis/ https://wcedmisten.fyi/post/medical-device-analysis/ [2] https://www.510k.fyi/devices/?id=K232380 https://www.510k.fyi/devices/?id=K232380 (click on "Predicate ancestry graph")
- peteradio 3y ago> DAG of other devices Its well known you can infer the safety of a specification by assessing a small subset of its features. Quod erat demonstrandum. /s But seriously, this is how backdoors are trivially integrated.
- hedora 3y agoThe “substantially equivalent” approval loophole is a textbook example of regulatory capture: - approvals for version N + 1 are basically skipped, as is safety testing - manufacturers get a liability shield - for many classes of devices, ladder pulling implies that no one will ever get another v1 approved. (The current rules for that are impossible to meet, but the incumbent company is grandfathered in under the old rules).
- bravo22 3y agoThe testing is NOT skipped. This is a misunderstanding of 510(k). The device still has to go through testing, validation and verification. It is a very detailed process and follows IEC spec. The device also needs IEC 60601 testing by a third party lab. In this case at least 60601-2-24. The 510(k) means it is not doing something new therapeutically therefore it doesn't need to go through PMA process which so much longer and more complex. In this instance they're saying a pump that uses electronics to monitor and deliver glucose already exists. Our device does the same thing therapeutically but we do it differently and here is all out docs showing the device is safe. If they came up with a magical patch that used quantum chemtrail energy to align the shakras and thereby affect the patient's insulin levels, then they would need to go through PMA and show the therapy is safe and works in small clinical trials followed by larger trials before they can make a device that can be marketed.
- Dove 3y agoWell, yeah. Controlling things with an app may seem like a sensible and efficient design given that the user already has a phone, but it seems outrageous to pull a whole phone's worth of complexity into the problem from a safety or security engineering standpoint. I'm genuinely surprised they're allowed to do things this way. Next you'll tell me the autopilot on a 737 runs as an app on the pilot's personal phone. The entire prospect seems to me approximately that crazy.
- jnsie 3y agoI think you're greatly overestimating the problem. The only action a user can take in the app is to give a bolus. This is a relatively (1-2 years?) new feature that I believe necessitated FDA approval. Everything else is surfacing information (blood sugar levels and notifications) to the end user. Edit to add: Utilizing a telephone is a significant quality of life upgrade from my (and many other) end-user experience. I'm guessing you are not Type 1 Diabetic (apologies if I am incorrect) in which case you have no idea the number of times in a day that one checks their blood sugar, boluses, etc. Frankly, it's exhausting. Being able to dial in a bolus or view my blood sugars from my phone, versus pulling out my insulin pump, has a significant impact and provides significant benefit.
- WA 3y agoSoftware has different risk classes. Controlling a 737 has vastly more requirements of the operating system / runtime environment than an app that controls a small thing for a single person. What might be ok for one risk class is not ok for other risk classes.
- Dove 3y agoThat's exactly what I'm trying to say! By virtue of its being able to seriously injure you, software controlling an insulin pump is safety-critical software. This should make it more like an airliner's fly-by-wire system than like a toy rc car's. Not in terms of complexity or resource usage, but in terms of development philosophy and rigor. Safety critical software wants to be simple and self-contained. I don't work on medical devices, but I have worked with safety-critical software before. While I know compromises are always made in practice, I would naively expect an insulin pump's remote control to be a few hundred lines of very-intensely-vetted C running on the bare metal of a microcontroller. I don't understand what a general purpose OS (!) connected to the internet (!!) is doing in a tech stack that someone notionally had to prove was safe under a wide range of circumstances. It may be paranoia arising from my particular background. I just find it very surprising that the sheer number of layers in an app is considered responsible and appropriate engineering for the use case.
- tristor 3y agoJust another piece of critical infrastructure or technology that’s suffering enshittification. Bureaucratic capture ensures that any technology produced in a regulated environment requires a large organization to produce it, ensuring the extension of the bureaucracy into that organization as well and killing off any contribution from people who care. Institutionalized apathy is slowly destroying our world.
- csh0 3y agoI wonder to what extent formal verification methods are being employed in the development of these kinds of things.
- cypherpunks01 3y agoFrom the look of these bugs, like this one but especially the other race condition bug that suggested 10x the user's input dosage, I'm gonna go out on a limb and say formal verification appears to be used little or none..
- londons_explore 3y ago"Battery low", "blood sugar too low" and "blood sugar too high" all sound like warnings that should be acknowledged by the user within 5 minutes, and if not the device automatically calls an emergency contact or emergency services... Is that not the case?
- baseballdork 3y agoGood lord no. If that were the case, my emergency contacts would be getting called at least once a week on my drive to work. However, seems reasonable to have that as an option. Unfortunately, like many people have already mentioned, the software coming out for these things is usually trash and who knows how well an autocall feature would even work. I actually ran into this exact bug and wound up disabling the phone connection to preserve the battery.
- cshokie 3y agoI was personally affected by this, but it did not harm me. The battery drain was obnoxiously high (having to charge 2x a day instead of once every 2-3 days). I am always near a power plug so I was never in much danger of shutdown. However, I can easily imagine how others would be. I ended up realizing something was odd with the app and tried uninstalling/reinstalling the app to fix it. Which did in fact fix it (at least temporarily).
- petepete 3y agoI reported a bug with LibreLink to Abbott about 18 months ago and they still haven't fixed it. The app doesn't respect Android's Do Not Disturb override list which essentially means I can't use DND on my phone. It's been the same on two phones, there are loads of reports on the Play Store reviews and on Reddit, so it's definitely a bug and not just me. They haven't even acknowledged it's a bug, every time I'm directed to reinstall the app, clear the cache, factory reset the phone etc.
- jimbobthrowawy 3y agoIs the override set in the system, or does the app somehow know about it? I can imagine some developer misinterpreting how DND detection works and not sending a notification if it's enabled, though I can also imagine android's implementation being bugged in some specific way.
- petepete 3y agoYeah the override is set in Android settings and it works fine for other apps like my house alarm and security camera system. Enabling DND makes LibreLink instantly flash up a warning saying "Alarms aren't available."
- nothasan 3y agoThe tech is really hit or miss sometimes. I have a pump that used to panic error out on a misused bluetooth connection, forcing you to set it up again. Eventually the app developers fixed it but, for something that’s supposed to run 24/7/365 without fail it really rubbed me the wrong way. On a slightly tangential note, I am interested in working on something better although not hardware inclined, so please reach out to me at my username @tutamail.com if you are interested.