4 ms·
I don't know about "terrifying". "Uncomfortable", or, probably more accurately, "supremely irritating", sure. Zeynep Tufekci has been writing for a couple weeks
by tptacek 3y ago
I don't know about "terrifying". "Uncomfortable", or, probably more accurately, "supremely irritating", sure. Zeynep Tufekci has been writing for a couple weeks --- I don't agree with everything she's saying, but I take anything she says seriously --- about how physically small and limited the protests have been.
If there were white power protests happening on campus at the University of Chicago, we'd all be up in arms; we are not when SJP, an organization that formally endorses the Al-Qassam Brigades, protests instead. There's for sure a blind spot. I see why people are pissed. It is not at all clear to me that anyone's safety was threatened at Columbia, though.
- kasey_junk 3y agoThe comment you are replying to is ridiculous. Frankly by engaging I perpetuate ridiculousness and I should know better. That said, to some reasonable approximation even the most militant pro Palestinian campus protests didn’t threaten any ones safety. In nearly every case the danger came from reactionary protests. Which is completely predictable if you are a campus safety officer!
- tptacek 3y agoI think I agree with all of this, including the ridiculousness. We all have a problem.
- kasey_junk 3y agoWe only have a problem if we agree with the contention that kids protesting genocide are some sort of chaos agent. They aren’t! They’re just college kids. Sleeping rough. Temporarily.
- tptacek 3y agoI don't know what "chaos agent" means, but the problem I'm referring to is us all commenting on this thread. I'm confident we agree more than we disagree about all of this stuff.
- rendall 3y ago> I'm confident we agree more than we disagree about all of this stuff. I do think we all want Palestinians to live peaceful and prosperous lives. Despite what many anti-Zionists believe, Israel would like that for Palestinians too. The fundamental question is, does Israel get to exist as a state? If you believe yes, then congratulations, you are a Zionist! If you believe no, and if you're not struggling intellectually with the practical consequences of the end of the Israeli state to the Israeli people, really walking through it with concern, then you court genocide. There isn't really much leeway, there.
- runarberg 3y agoThis is the second time today I hear this word used, and it is only 07:45 here. The other time was House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries describing Marjory Taylor Greene and “extreme MAGA Republicans” as “Chaos Agents”.
- rendall 3y ago> We only have a problem if we agree with the contention that kids protesting genocide are some sort of chaos agent. Logically, they are, though. They are impervious to logical argument that it is not a genocide. Their only evidence, ultimately, is Hamas' "trust me, bro" and their own presumption that Israel is evil. If people throw the word "genocide" around without second thought out question and cannot accept any mitigating argument, they are not helping. So, yes, chaos agents and no, not just "college students sleeping rough".
- rendall 3y ago> The comment you are replying to is ridiculous. Frankly by engaging I perpetuate ridiculousness and I should know better. This is against the community guidelines. With over 13k karma points, you know better. I hesitate to ask, but pretend for a moment that I am an earnest rationalist who respects logical arguments and lets truth lead to conclusions even if I am not happy with those conclusions. Can you, striving to minimize emotionalism or logical fallacy, walk through in concise points what specifically is "ridiculous"?
- tptacek 3y agoI took zero offense from his comment; its spirit was clear. I agree with him: it is ridiculous that were are frolicking in this rotted carcass of a thread.