5 ms·
Fusion of 2 sisters into a single woman suggests human identity not in our DNA
- andrewclunn 3y ago[flagged]
- polski-g 3y agoPar for the course: "A child is born with 3 legs. Therefore, humans do not have 2 legs."
- _aavaa_ 3y agoPlease read the article, not just the headline. There's nothing "ideological" here. A 0.00001% exception is a counterexample which proves that a model is not complete. The fact that it's rare is irrelevant to the fact that it invalidates a model. As for the article, it's a discussion of how DNA on it's own isn't enough to explain why living being develop the way they do (including an example of literal cloning with big differences in the resulting animal vs the original).
- justin_oaks 3y ago"All models are wrong, but some are useful" -George E. P. Box The exception DOES indicate that the model could be more accurate to cover cases, but the most important thing is whether the model is useful. Newtonian physics may be superceded by what we know about quantum physics and relativity, but it still is very useful. Of course, we should continue to learn and refine our models.
- _aavaa_ 3y agoIt may be useful, but the point is that while the difference between Newtonian physics is good enough for explaining day to day life experiences we wouldn't be able to have GPS without relativity.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 3y agoI didn't know anyone thought that. I would certainly be someone else if I were born with the same DNA but in another family or country or decade
- thatguy0900 3y agoEugenics has a really long history and was very popular not too long ago. Even Elon musk believes in it https://jill.substack.com/p/musk-the-father https://jill.substack.com/p/musk-the-father
- octopoc 3y agoWould you also be someone else if you were born in the same family, country, and decade but with different DNA? Or would you be the same person?
- bayouborne 3y agonon-paywalled - https://archive.ph/R7s7J https://archive.ph/R7s7J
- Gormo 3y agoWhat specifically does "human identity" mean?
- dyauspitr 3y agoWhat is identity? What difference does it make if she is a chimera or two or five people, she’s an aggregate of whatever proteins that get expressed for whatever part of her body.
- jokethrowaway 3y agoHow come these altruistic cells end up reproducing and favoring their offspring? I still see Dawkins's point as valid. Genes are responsible for some behaviours, they are certainly not EVERYTHING there is to human identity. Saying there is nothing in the DNA which gives us 5 fingers is incorrect. >Researchers in Chicago, Dr. Neil Shubin and his team, demonstrated that two genes -- hoxa13 and hoxd13 -- are responsible for the formation of fin rays and our fingers [...] >Yacine Kherdjemil demonstrated that by reproducing the fish-type regulation for the hoxa11 gene, mice develop up to seven digits per paw, i.e., a return to ancestral status. http://thescienceexplorer.com/nature/researchers-explain-how-evolution-has-equipped-our-hands-five-fingers http://thescienceexplorer.com/nature/researchers-explain-how...
- dekhn 3y agoTitle does not match article, article does not match the research, and the scientist making the claim is saying something that, if true, would require absolutely rewriting everything about evo-devo biology. I believe the article was really written to publicize the scientist's book, "The Master Builder", https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/15/books/review/the-good-virus-tom-ireland-the-master-builder-alfonso-martinez-arias.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/15/books/review/the-good-vir... The only counterexample to the mainstream position that I can think of is not chimeric individuals (which are remarkable, but mainly a case for how accomodating of variation the existing biological systems are) but maternal factors- components in the egg cell that are not DNA, but contribute greatly to the phenotype of the embryo and resulting individual. Really the complaint is about the gene-centric view put forward by many- see The Selfish Gene for the best argument for the gene-centric (rahter than "genome-centric") view.