5 ms·
Computer models suggest modern plate tectonics due to blobs left by collision
- Aerroon 3y agoThis could be pretty bad news for finding complex life in space. The stability of Earth's carbon cycle is thought to be (partly) a result of plate tectonics. Carbon gets trapped in rocks and volcanoes emit carbon again. Venus doesn't seem to have plate tectonics. One consequence of this is thought to be that volcanoes are much more common on Venus. It's also thought that 300-700 million years ago Venus went through a resurfacing event where basically the surface of the planet was replaced (the floor is lava). If the above is true and plate tectonics is a result of a planetary collision then life like ours should be even more rare than we thought.
- Pet_Ant 3y agoWhat was the surface of Venus like before that?
- Aerroon 3y agoI don't know. I'm unsure whether scientists do either. Chances are that it wasn't really any different than it is now. The resurfacing means that the surface is new - many fewer impact craters.
- rbanffy 3y agoVenus' rotation is quite weird, could it be the result of an impact?
- duluca 3y agoThat's the fascinating thing about lava/magma's power to simply erase what was there before. Plate tectonics does a similar thing when continents scrape each other clean. For all we know, Earth had an advanced civilization on it way before us and we'd have zero ways of knowing about it.
- Evidlo 3y agoSome bits of landmass have been around for a few billion years. From this we have atmospheric records that rule out a large industrial civilization.
- tifik 3y agoWouldn't large body collisions be a fairly common occurrence in young planetary systems though? Of course any additional condition makes life rarer, I'm just thinking this one might not make it rarer by as many orders of magnitude as it might look like at first glance.
- jvanderbot 3y agoAnd yet - where's all the plate techtonics in our solar system? Only 1 of four inner rocky planets seems to experience it.
- jajko 3y agoOut of what, 500-1000 billions of planets just in milky way? I dont think folks do realize how big those numbers are. And there is no reason to ignore rest of the universe if we talk about probabilities and statistics
- dartos 3y agoTbh even if the number of life sustaining planets in the galaxy goes from 400B to 350B, that’s still rarer than we thought.
- jvanderbot 3y agoIt's just another fraction to multiply in the drake equation. Start with planets, cut down to rocky ones, only in habitable zone, only rotating a certain way, only with plate techtonics, etc etc. Or using your numbers, 1/4 factor eliminates 750 million possible candidates. That's not a happy thought.
- eep_social 3y agoYeah but 25% of a few hundred billion (planets in the milky way) is still a fair lot of opportunities. “Space is big. You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly big it is.”
- 3y ago
- jemmyw 3y agoExtra conditions like this mean that the path we took would be rarer but doesn't necessarily make life any more rare. There could be plenty of other pathways to a stable carbon cycle. Or it might not even be a prerequisite, you could imagine a scenario where life gets a foothold then instigates the cycle itself. We just won't know until we've found something. And for us talking now we probably just won't know.
- jvanderbot 3y agoEspecially because they may all just be indicators of something else. I've heard magnetic fields, moons, and plate techtonics are all important, but that really could just be "the right kind of planetary collision not too long ago"
- Aerroon 3y agoSure, but then add the evolutionary path on top of that. We had hundreds of millions of years of dinosaurs and no evidence of intelligent life. Then you've got to consider that Earth is basically approaching its twilight years. The planet is 4.5 billion years old, macroscopic multicellular life is 600 million to a billion years old. Humans have been around for 100,000 years. In 500 million to a billion years Earth will become uninhabitable again. Oh and our sun is unusually stable. Throw all of this together with an added "right type of huge planetary collision" and I feel like you're writing a lot more zeros into that probability. Of course it's possible that life could take a different path, but there was a lot of opportunity on Earth and it took a long time to get there.
- jvanderbot 3y agoAll that comes after the planet is suitable for emergence, which is the focus of the conversation. We can reinvent the drake equation all day if we want, but yeah, definitely, those are more factors to consider.
- felsokning 3y ago> There could be plenty of other pathways to a stable carbon cycle. To be fair, carbon is the only base that we have (first-hand) experience with. There _could_ be other bases.
- api 3y agoThat big thing that whacked us and created the Moon may be responsible for our being here. Amazing. The simplest and most likely explanation for the Fermi paradox that does not rely on fanciful future great filters or even more fanciful galactic zoo hypotheses is that complex highly intelligent life capable of space flight is extraordinarily rare in space and time. When we go out there we might end up finding some bacteria-like organisms and simple fossils but nothing close to ourselves. But ultimately we don't know until we go see.
- dehrmann 3y agoThe sample size is very low, but it's quite the coincidence that the only rocky planet in our solar system with life is the only one with an oversized moon.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- adriand 3y ago> complex highly intelligent life capable of space flight is extraordinarily rare in space and time That feels right to me especially given the timescales we are dealing with when we consider things even just in a galactic context. Heck, even the timescales on this planet alone are such that there could be multiple complex intelligent life forms on earth separated by sufficient time that they are never known to one another! Not to mention the fact that there are intelligent life forms on earth right now that we barely understand. For all these reasons It seems to me that we are far more likely to come across an alien artifact than an alien, and we haven’t started looking for these.
- AlexAndScripts 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silurian_hypothesis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silurian_hypothesis Would we know if they went to space? How long would a geostationary satellite remain? It's both haunting and brilliant to think about the idea of entire other intelligent species and civilisations having lived on this planet without us ever knowing. Fire and iron and cities and empires and "great people", cultures and religions and stories and families... Civilisations and species rising and falling throughout the eons. It feels a little reminiscent of Sagan's "Pale Blue Dot", but on the scale of time, not space. I wonder if they might have considered this too.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mnky9800n 3y agoIt's also possible that a reasonably homogenous atmospheric pressure does not promote sustained plate tectonics over geologic time scales. Since Venus has no oceans this could be why it has no plate tectonics currently.
- kingkongjaffa 3y agoAs the earths core cools, does that mean the tectonic movement will slow down and our carbon cycle will become busted?
- jajko 3y agoBy that time we will have completely different issues, like enlarged sun burning everything down
- icehawk 3y agoThe sun will become more luminous to a point it will stop plate tectonics by evaporating the oceans far sooner (about a billion years from now) than it will take the earth's core to cool.
- idunnoman1222 3y agoThe answer to fermi paradox isn’t about how rare complex life is, it’s that it’s impossible to create self replicating probes that can travel interstellar distances
- michaelmrose 3y agoAre we basing that on the tens of thousands of years between stars required for chemical propulsion instead of the tens of years feasible with other options?
- lazide 3y agoIt’s all based on energy and economy. The amount of energy required (even for a relatively slow chemical rocket!) is so astronomical, it’s apparently not worthwhile to do at scale. Or there are no actual aliens, except us. For whatever reason.
- dboreham 3y agoOr it is possible but we don't know what they look like.
- digging 3y ago> it’s that it’s impossible to create self replicating probes that can travel interstellar distance What makes you say that? I wouldn't actually think that's as difficult as many other problems in space exploration. An uncrewed probe is free from a lot of really challenging constraints.
- lazide 3y agoBecause we haven’t seen any - near as we can tell - ever. If they were possible, we should be having to constantly look up to avoid having one land on us.
- nilsherzig 3y agoWhy would the cutoff be at building self replicating probes and not before that?