7 ms·
How rich is too rich? Limitarianism: The Case Against Extreme Wealth
- throwitaway222 3y ago[flagged]
- chrispeel 3y agoAs a marketing term I like "Limitarianism"
- psychlops 3y ago"Among a representative sample of Dutch people, for example, Robeyns and her team found that nine out of ten respondents agreed that having wealth exceeding €4 million for a family of four — in terms of ownership of certain assets, such as a mansion, a second home, luxury vehicles and a specific amount of savings — qualifies as being super-rich. In low-income countries, that threshold could be much lower." Interesting to learn that limitarianism is an ideology that respects national borders.
- zamadatix 3y agoIt wouldn't work well if the Dutch inequality was measured by life in Kyrgyzstan.
- psychlops 3y agoIt would for those in Kyrgyzstan. Are they not equal to the Dutch?
- zamadatix 3y agoThey can be whatever they want. The point is the Dutch don't control Kyrgyzstan not that the Dutch should wait for Kyrgyzstan to agree to how the Dutch want to live/regulate themselves or that the populations themselves have different importance.
- psychlops 3y agoThe point is that they are trying to address inequality and immoral use of wealth and the article treats us to biblical and historical examples. Then the idea is applied "equally" only within political and regional constraints. Is limitarianism a philosophy or political stance?
- zamadatix 3y agoWhy does whether the entire world is ready to and can feasibly adopt the idea at the same time play into what the idea is? Why can't it be both a philosophical stance and a political stance at the same time? They desire wealth equality and consider it morally sound. That doesn't mean they also have an answer to every problem external to them or expect a global kumbaya about it overnight. This does not preclude the idea being anything in the same way one wanting safety regulations in their country isn't precluded by solving every other safety regulation problem around the world first, at the same time, and via the exact same steps. I don't even particularly agree with the idea, this line of "gotcha" just doesn't follow.
- psychlops 3y agoNot sure what you are calling a "gotcha". You seem to be misunderstanding or misrepresenting my statements, I never called for them to solve world problems. I don't necessarily disagree with the premise, I simply ask for consistency of the idea. Implementation of it is another discussion.
- zamadatix 3y agoThe "gotcha" is the surface level claim it's inconsistent because it follows borders (indirectly initally stated for diminutive effect). That's not inherently inconsistent in itself, I've attempted to explain why, and you've given no defense as to why it should always be inconsistent and how that explanation applies to other philosophies considered consistent. Disagreeing with an ideology comes down to more than parading a surface level claim to declare the entire idea misaligned. You have to dissect that idea, try to find ways to defend it, then cleanly counter those ideas. Throwing up a facetious one liner is the exact opposite of inspecting a philosophy and it's easy to misunderstand any set of morals that way. As another example of why it's poor form of logic: "He thinks it's okay to kill some people but not others, that must be unethical and misaligned - why does it matter who it is it should always apply equally! The morality is therefore inherently flawed unless this is corrected." when the actual moral was that there are only certain cases it makes moral sense to kill someone (with some justifications if you dive into it) like compassion for terminal illness. Instead of the surface level "gotcha" denial you would dive into what these reasons might be and why you disagree with them, not just blurt the surface disagreement. This tends to be a lot more discussive of the idea instead of immediately dismissive, even when you ultimately disagree with it.
- formerly_proven 3y agoThere’s certainly some strange effects on the edges, for example founders/early investors never realizing their gains and instead just taking loans collateralized with their assets (that’s how hyperrich avoid income taxes: just don’t have any taxable income)
- joshspankit 3y agoWe’re so deep in the “finding loopholes” game that it would be almost impossible to fix the system without starting from scratch.
- Bostonian 3y ago'Robeyns, who has studied how people perceive wealth, opens with a provocative proposal — governments should set a wealth limit on the order of 10 million euros or US dollars per person.' So people with wealth close to $10mil should keep all their money in cash and avoid higher-return investments, since the the excess above $10mil would be confiscated? Besides being morally wrong, that would discourage investment.
- jajko 3y agoIts an interesting thought experiment but falls apart very quickly when meeting reality of human nature. And just not very logical altogether, unenforceable globally. The current global legal maze that allows all those money hiding places is exactly due to similar efforts in the past, they are half-assed at best. But it keeps wealth management companies busy, so at least somebody benefits at the end.
- blablabla123 3y agoBut not that far fetched in 2024, Bitcoin limits the total amount of coins. I'd think at a certain amount of money, probably a significant part is likely idleling (and not adding to economy) or not in full control of the owner.
- throwaway11460 3y agoThe sole purpose of limiting coins was to create an asset with increasing value.
- blablabla123 3y agoNo, to stop inflation
- throwaway11460 3y agoYes, by creating a limited amount of assets with increasing value, thus resulting in deflation. That's what I said.
- indigoabstract 3y ago> As radical as they might seem, calls for limits on wealth are as old as civilization itself. Well, knowing that, one could reasonably wonder why they never succeed. Could it be something about human nature that prevents utopias and good intentions from working as planned?
- moritzwarhier 3y agoWell, historically they all succeeded, at some point
- jrm4 3y agoIt's weird to say they never succeed? By the numbers, you could reasonably argue they've never been tried because it's never been this extreme.
- throwaway11460 3y agoYeah, no people ever sat on thrones from literal solid gold and never owned dozens of giant castles and hundreds of people serving them there...
- dTal 3y agoLet me just run this through the trusty ol' DeSnarkifier 8000... clunk hum DING aha, here we are: "There was severe wealth inequality in the past". Hm! Very true! But it doesn't really advance the discussion from "it's never been this extreme", does it? And to address that point, "dozens of castles" begins to look unimpressive next to the wealth of e.g. Jeff Bezos, whose personal fortune exceeds the entire world GDP until approximately the time of William the Conqueror.
- throwaway11460 3y agoBezos doesn't own entire states, and he can't use his wealth in the full on-paper value. Literally owning country-sized plots of land, all its natural resources, its people and everything they create including their children, having the privilege to tax all trade going through and assign trade monopolies is incomparable to anything Bezos might own even if he becomes a centi-trillionaire. It was much, much more extreme for most of human history. So much more that I can't actually blame you for this mistake because it's that hard to comprehend how incredible the difference is.
- debacle 3y agoYou cannot functionally limit wealth. Does 10 million include assets? What about company ownership? If a piece of art is worth more than 10 million, does it need to be owned by more than one person? Does it need to be cut in two? If something you own appreciates and your wealth increases as a result, how quickly before you have to divest that asset? What about non profit organizations? What about IP? What about software? When Minecraft was sold by a single owner, it was worth 10 million many, many times over. When exactly would it have been necessary for him to sell his company, and who would he have been obligated to sell it to?
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoThe fact that you can come up with ridiculous scenarios does not automatically mean that the idea is either ridiculous or inherently flawed.
- gipp 3y agoHow are those "ridiculous scenarios?" Any attempt to base laws around the net worth of an individual is going to run into a hundred thousand such scenarios instantly. A person's "wealth" is simply not well defined. Neither ownership nor valuation of any kind of asset, other than cash itself, is nearly straightforward enough.
- wtfwhateven 3y agothis is true, I asked the IRS agent to define wealth and they couldn't do it, therefore meaning I no longer have to pay taxes
- gipp 3y agoIncome -- being funneled through the unifying medium of US dollars usually, and having some other counterparty to the transaction available to verify things -- is a lot simpler to account for than wealth, and look how complex that still is, and how readily it is already circumvented. And that's with a hundred years of refining and reforming the tax code to stop it, which a wealth-based taxation scheme would not benefit from.
- dalmo3 3y agoDo they mention how would they build walls and fund military power to prevent people from fleeing their utopia?
- postepowanieadm 3y agoCommunists did one smart thing: they limited maximum earnings of party members(in theory). You want to have political power? Limit your incomes, share with the state.
- Detrytus 3y agoWhich is why communism turned out to be such a great success, globally. /s
- nox101 3y agoWas that sarcasm?
- blackhawkC17 3y agoA good example is one of the Chinese Communist Party's top dogs, who $14.5 billion was recovered from (and his family) in a corruption probe [1]. Or Xi Jinping himself, whose family has amassed $1 billion+ [2] despite his modest $22,000 salary. 1- https://www.reuters.com/article/idUSBREA2T02S/ https://www.reuters.com/article/idUSBREA2T02S/ 2- https://www.smh.com.au/world/chinese-leaders-family-worth-a-billion-20120629-218qi.html https://www.smh.com.au/world/chinese-leaders-family-worth-a-...
- _lvbh 3y agoChina is only communist in name. It’s like a state calling themselves paradise. Call it what it is, a dictatorship. Personal opinion: Communism is impossible (in the foreseeable future)
- hui-zheng 3y agogive me an example that it actually works in reality
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoNobody needs more than a billion dollars. Nobody even needs more than 10 million dollars. But that isn't really the question(s). The real questions are: 1. Can you morally take what others have, just because they have more than enough? By what standard of morality? And, given that "don't take other peoples' stuff" has worked out pretty well as a standard of morality, what justification is there for choosing a different one? 2. More broadly, there will be collateral damage from any approach to take wealth from the wealthy. Will that collateral damage leave society better or worse off than the status quo? Probably the most minimalistic way to do it would be a progressive tax on wealth above 10 million dollars. But even that would lead to massive attempts to hide assets (or get them out of the country), and more and more invasive attempts to detect such things. And the invasiveness itself is damaging to society.
- nox101 3y agoWhy do you think nobody needs more than billion dollars? I know if I had a billion dollars there are lots of things I'd fund. Why should I not be allowed to do that? If I had a trillion I also have things I'd fund that I couldn't at a billion
- giraffe_lady 3y agoThe only way to have a billion dollars in the first place is to take it from the workers who created the wealth. No individual's labor or creative output can anywhere near reach that value. We already allow taking from others, from whom and what justification used is simply a matter of ideology. The current system is what we're used to and so it seems necessary and inevitable to us, anything else an abhorrent deviation.
- georgebarnett 3y agoTake it from the workers? Are you suggesting that workers do not have employment contracts where they agreed to trade labour for wages at a fixed price? Workers always have the choice to take the risk of starting their own company for higher potential earnings.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoFrom what I hear, wealth above $50M-$100M is really only useful for status or power. Once you've hit that level you're able to buy pretty much anything material that makes life nicer: a second house, a yacht, servants, a private jet, et cetera. People have identified the private jet as the most expensive thing a person can buy that substantially improves your life. Beyond that point it's more of a status game than real improvement. Yes, a 200ft yacht is nicer than a 50ft yacht, but the difference is marginal. The 7th house isn't adding much.
- dzhiurgis 3y ago> 200ft yacht is nicer than a 50ft yacht, but the difference is marginal Boats scale in ^3 - you'll get a lot more space (volume) in 200ft yacht. 50ft sailing yacht is near minimum for comfortable world cruising. At this size you'd still be crewing and fixing shit yourself.
- delichon 3y agoMusk cares about colonizing Mars a lot more than houses, and that's a goal that requires much more than $50M-$100M. I agree that it's a critical goal and believe that it would be much delayed if removed from private decision makers by a wealth ceiling.
- zamadatix 3y agoIn some ways it's the other way around. Musk (currently holding assets of ~195B) is able to spend billions by selling his ownership in SpaceX (currently valued at $180B) and Tesla (currently valued at ~$550B). Musk doesn't need to sell billions for SpaceX to go to Mars or Tesla to make a new car if he never cashes out in the first place. That's why the hard part is (usually, outside of ideological effort) "then why would they bother to keep doing all the work if they don't get anything out of it?". It's also a reason wealth is a hard thing to really track when you want to limit it. Is that corporate jet 1/5th the CEO's because he is 1 of 5 that uses it or is it not part of the CEO's wealth at all? There's not really a clean way to cut this sort of thing that I've seen that doesn't either lop off things that aren't personal wealth by accident or allow squirreling away personal wealth in ways it doesn't get counted. That's the hardest part of this kind of thing IMO.
- zrn900 3y agoExtremely logical - after a certain point, wealth is just meaningless numbers in financial computers, only expressed as the control of major organizations like corporations. Its literal unbounded power. We limited the power of kings and dukes. But we are allowing the same kind of power to those who hoard imaginary wealth that cannot be spent on actual things - it cannot be spent on actual things, because it is estimated that the amount of wealth stored in Swiss banks (leave aside derivatives etc) have already surpassed multiple times of the value of everything on the planet. So there is wealth on the planet that can buy the entire planet dozens of times over. And yet hoarding continues at great cost to the society.
- alecco 3y agoBut money is meaningless. Your "money" in the bank is just a number their systems says you have in their virtual game. And in turn, the same for them and the Fed. It's easily changed in a second.
- brnt 3y agoMoney is a measure of value, and value is conferred, not intrinsic. Therefore, money is what we believe it is, and all things considered, it looks like we think it's worth something.
- blackhawkC17 3y agoSwiss banks hold 8.8 trillion CHF ($9.7 trillion) in deposits [1], not enough to buy everything in Africa, not to mention the world. I'm not defending inequality, but some stats don't just make sense when I read them online and I see a need to correct. 1- https://publications.swissbanking.ch/banking-barometer-2022/assets-under-management https://publications.swissbanking.ch/banking-barometer-2022/...
- zrn900 3y ago> Swiss banks hold 8.8 trillion CHF ($9.7 trillion) in deposits [1], not enough to buy everything in Africa, not to mention the world That's what they tell us. In any case, you could just take derivatives if you would like a more definitive estimate. Or futures. The latter is crazy as it monetizes the literal future of the planet.
- hui-zheng 3y agoI love the conversation going here. A bunch of socialist and communist nerds fantasize that they could build something better than what existing socialism and communism countries have done. Try harder.
- zamadatix 3y agoThis isn't the place for that kind of comment.
- snapplebobapple 3y agoThey make the mistake of thinking the government will do a better job than individuals. When the government is often stacked with the most useless, theiving sacks of lazy crap in society and should be atleast as big a concern as any rich person. they also confuse the negative effects of market power abuse caused wealth accumulation and wealth accumulation from improving the production possibilities frontier. we have laws called antitrust to stop the former we just need to use them a lot more like we used to post ww2 and pre 1970s. Damping the latter wealth accumulation is a really dumb idea and should be avoided. theirideas on ingeritance tax is honestly just naive. They will capture a bunch of the upper middle class guys and the really wealthy will avoid it, as they always do. What that type of inheritance tax will do is fossilize the ultra wealthy and everhbody else
- em-bee 3y agoThey make the mistake of thinking the government will do a better job than individuals. maybe they do, maybe they don't. but by preference, it is easier to demand transparency from the government than to demand it from individuals. because transparency from individuals implies removal of privacy. so i'd rather give billions to a government and have it clearly documented how they spend the money instead of demanding the same from individuals.
- snapplebobapple 3y agoYour statement about government is very narrowly potentially true about only a very tiny slice of western democratic governments (and some of their vassals/former vassals) in the last 200 or so years and is nearly universally untrue about every other government in both time and space. Also you seem to be a bit confused about the flow of funds. You aren't giving anything to anyone. This article is all about taking from some people with an arbitrarily chosen amount of earned and unspent income. if you are referring to all the transactions you willingly (if begrudgingly) participated in trading your money for goods and services you wanted from these people, only the times you had to pay a higher price because of market power abuse should be of any concern to anyone and the solution to that problem already exists in law via antitrust law, we just have to enforce it better, there is no requirement or benefit to arbitrarily confiscating these people's assets in solving that specific and actual problem.
- RhysU 3y agoMoney and power are fungible (caveat heavy transaction costs). If you eliminate the ability to build colossal wealth you leave open only the option to pursue significant power. Doing so will... not turn out well.
- alecco 3y agoI don't mind wealth disparities. I don't like idiots who just tricked the system in some way. We should not reward antisocial behavior. This is how countries and empires fall. From Rome to China.